Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[dedenne]

Honestly that's the most scummy thing anyone's done. Voting you.

um please explain why that's scummy???

- - - Post Merge - - -

ok so I missed a page nvm

- - - Post Merge - - -

NO I DID NOT MY QUESTION IS STILL VALID

 

[oath2order]

oath answer the RQ's and tell everyone who you're sussing
Heyden who do you suspect?

can you link me the RQs

i'm still re-reading; had to leave work early today and i've got a headache so it's probably gonna take awhile.

coincidentally I agree with toad's comment about you.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

*That's* a reason for you to vote him?

Seriously, avoiding my questions, retracting his vote after he actually realizes that it's a bad idea, honestly if he's town I'm going to seriously be annoyed. Why would he do any of that as town?

- - - Post Merge - - -

can you link me the RQs

i'm still re-reading; had to leave work early today and i've got a headache so it's probably gonna take awhile.

coincidentally I agree with toad's comment about you.

it's legitamately on the first or second page lol

 

[toadsworthy]

Fireninja what were you're most recent games? Carnival? People should really go read it

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Fireninja what were you're most recent games? Carnival? People should really go read it

I believe his most recent game is Mystic Messenger.

 

[EpicGamer12]

can you link me the RQs

i'm still re-reading; had to leave work early today and i've got a headache so it's probably gonna take awhile.

coincidentally I agree with toad's comment about you.

take your time man you have over 24 hours

 

[Kamzitty]

FN's awaited response to accusations was honestly a let down and his so called "defenses" were half-a**ed. He brushed off all accusations by saying things like "this is false" or "not true" which don't seem like valid defenses imo. Does anybody else find this odd? I'm unsure if these are an indication of scum tho, because like I said earlier it seems to be WAY too obvious ;/

 

[Locket]

1. What is your timezone? MST/GMT -6

2. How active will you be this game? As active as possible (minus these past couple days, I've been out of town)

3. Preferred pronoun? she/her

4. Do you prefer being town or being mafia? I've only been town so I still have no idea

5. How do you handle pressure? Depends on what pressure. Sometimes I do well and other times I break easily.

6. Which player(s) in this game can you read the best? No one, I'm really bad at reading people still.

7. Which player(s) in this game can best read you? Everyone else honestly.

8. How many games have you played? This is my fourth?

9. Who would you fearkill N1? Whoever I'm most scared of.

I'm still reading the thread so this is just a "hi I'm alive" kind of thing.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

because like I said earlier it seems to be WAY too obvious ;/

Isn't that what he wants us to think?

 

[toadsworthy]

Isn't that what he wants us to think?

There's leading an argument based on scum observation and there is trying to just make someone be scum because you just want them to be.... this falls in the latter

 

[Kamzitty]

Isn't that what he wants us to think?

Are you referring to your idea that he's using reverse psychology to make us think he's not scum? If so, I believe that's a possibility. His excessive sarcasm towards everyone and avoidance of defending himself don't seem to hint towards town lol. so I believe your theory is decent and more people should consider it.

 

[Ghostkid]

Are you referring to your idea that he's using reverse psychology to make us think he's not scum? If so, I believe that's a possibility. His excessive sarcasm towards everyone and avoidance of defending himself don't seem to hint towards town lol. so I believe your theory is decent and more people should consider it.

I think a few people here are using reverse psychology tbh

 

[dedenne]

um please explain why that's scummy???

Seriously, avoiding my questions,

have I missed the answer or????

 

[Heyden]

Quick reads cos I have school today and I wasted last night playing PUBG;

Kammm/iLoveYou/Trundle/mog are all probably town.

Punchy sounds really awkward and I can't tell if he's bad town or bad mafia.

Toads vs Ness fiasco, I found Ness very out of character to crack like that. Toads is aggressive af but I think that's a towntell of his? Need to read up, but I don't really think either of them are scum.

Fireninja is probably just stirring the pot cos he thinks he's funny, could be scum or town haven't really looked into it.
I have to reevaluate later.

Dolby/Antonio/Dad are people I'm gonna look into later bc I lowkey scumread them. I don't really like their posts skimming through them so ya I'll get back to that

Everyone else is null or I haven't noticed them.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Seriously, avoiding my questions, retracting his vote after he actually realizes that it's a bad idea, honestly if he's town I'm going to seriously be annoyed. Why would he do any of that as town?

Ugh, it annoys me that he's so obviously scum. he had absolutely no reason to vote me in the first place..

 

[amazonevan19]

Dedenne: “please explain why fire ninja is scummy, Punchy”

Punchy: “OMG OMG OMG NINJA IS SCUUUUUUUUUUUMMMMMMMMMYYYYY”

:thonking:

 

[Ghostkid]

Ugh, it annoys me that he's so obviously scum. he had absolutely no reason to vote me in the first place..

He seems a little bit sketchy...but im not gonna full on say hes scum

 

[oath2order]

Quick reads cos I have school today and I wasted last night playing PUBG;

Kammm/iLoveYou/Trundle/mog are all probably town.

Punchy sounds really awkward and I can't tell if he's bad town or bad mafia.

Toads vs Ness fiasco, I found Ness very out of character to crack like that. Toads is aggressive af but I think that's a towntell of his? Need to read up, but I don't really think either of them are scum.

Fireninja is probably just stirring the pot cos he thinks he's funny, could be scum or town haven't really looked into it.
I have to reevaluate later.

Dolby/Antonio/Dad are people I'm gonna look into later bc I lowkey scumread them. I don't really like their posts skimming through them so ya I'll get back to that

Everyone else is null or I haven't noticed them.

I wanna say I vaguely remember FireNinja stirring the pot in previous old-school games, but I could be delusional. TBF it is day one and things just being ****posting is expected.

I agree on Toads. whatever that last game was I played when I was maf he was semi-aggro on me.

OH RIGHT isn't this punchy's first game?

Ugh, it annoys me that he's so obviously scum. he had absolutely no reason to vote me in the first place..

day one ****-lynch basically

 

[Locket]

The Ness v Toads thing that happened feels like Town v Town to me. Though, Ness breaking like that is pretty strange.

FN is pretty weird in his posts. He refuses to elaborate a lot. He doesn't have a lot of good contributions so far.

I'll add more later but I've had a long couple of days so I'm gonna rest a bit.

 

[duckykate]

Punchy is acting rly dumb but maybe hes doing that on purpose to make us think hes a bad mafia idk