Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[iLoveYou]

Seriously, avoiding my questions, retracting his vote after he actually realizes that it's a bad idea, honestly if he's town I'm going to seriously be annoyed. Why would he do any of that as town?

Something that is bothering me a lot about a potential lynching of FireNinja1 is that he seems to be making carefree moves ( voting Punchy right away and keeping it there while appearing to not give a **** ). Should he be mafia, wouldn't he have to worry about staying alive to represent KP ?

FN seems v fishy but I also feel like that's too obvious as mafia, would he really vote somebody right away without explanation if he was trying to lay low?

This is bothering me too. Why would any mafia player be this obvious and make this horrible move ? On the other hand, it could be reverse psychology but wouldn't that be a huge risk to take this early in the game ?

Seriously, avoiding my questions, retracting his vote after he actually realizes that it's a bad idea, honestly if he's town I'm going to seriously be annoyed. Why would he do any of that as town?

I feel like he is being way too careless to be playing as mafia. You're right, if he is Town aligned though, then why would he do this ? This is already the second time in a day that we are visiting the FireNinja1 vs. Punchy fiasco.

I?d be down for a fireninja lynch, as he?s done the most demonstrably scummy thing so far this game. But I also feel like it?s just way too blatant for scum!ninja to do. The one time I was scum with fireninja, he really was trying to fly under the radar and NOT commit to positions.

So do you think voting early is scummy or not ? You contradicted yourself here. How is it the most demonstrably scummy thing yet way too blatant for scum to do ?

I do agree with you in the sense that it is a little bit too obvious if he were playing on the mafia team. Here we have direct insight from someone who has played with FireNinja1 as mafia and they are telling us that he would fly under the radar. In general, it would make more sense to me that mafia would try to fly under the radar. Not randomly and perhaps carelessly vote within hours of the beginning of the game. Of course we would be talking about a move like that and force it into the spotlight for reads. Just one question though .. what do you mean "not commit to positions" ? I don't understand that ? I'm from 2014 and we never used that lingo.

 

[Ghostkid]

Punchy is acting rly dumb but maybe hes doing that on purpose to make us think hes a bad mafia idk

Wait isnt the point of the game if one is mafia not to act suspicious so they dont get lynched? If so thats a bad move.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

tbh I'm fine with my lynch if it gets FN killed

 

[iLoveYou]

tbh I'm fine with my lynch if it gets FN killed

If you are lynched, why would it get FireNinja1 killed ? I don't think anyone said they wanted to lynch you either unless I missed a post ?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

If you are lynched, why would it get FireNinja1 killed ? I don't think anyone said they wanted to lynch you either unless I missed a post ?

it would because I'm town

- - - Post Merge - - -

Basically I'm willing to risk everything to get FN lynched

 

[toadsworthy]

tbh I'm fine with my lynch if it gets FN killed

God stfu, this isn't how you be a good town, you say this every time and it's just aggravating.

- - - Post Merge - - -

it would because I'm town

- - - Post Merge - - -

Basically I'm willing to risk everything to get FN lynched

You don't have the swaying power to make a claim like that

 

[amazonevan19]

So do you think voting early is scummy or not ? You contradicted yourself here. How is it the most demonstrably scummy thing yet way too blatant for scum to do ?

I do agree with you in the sense that it is a little bit too obvious if he were playing on the mafia team. Here we have direct insight from someone who has played with FireNinja1 as mafia and they are telling us that he would fly under the radar. In general, it would make more sense to me that mafia would try to fly under the radar. Not randomly and perhaps carelessly vote within hours of the beginning of the game. Of course we would be talking about a move like that and force it into the spotlight for reads. Just one question though .. what do you mean "not commit to positions" ? I don't understand that ? I'm from 2014 and we never used that lingo.

It's not voting early that's scummy. It's voting early for very little/poor reason, and that's what FN1 did. That is what I found scummy about his behavior, and it's arguably the most scummy thing done so far this game.

But as I said earlier, FN has never played with Punchy, and I'd get why he'd instavote punchy and be sus of his behavior. Cuz Punchy is always random, unpredictable, and generally scummy at the start of games. And I definitely remember scum!FN being much quieter day one, not wanting to attract much attention. So while I think what he did is itself scummy, his corresponding behavior to be more townlike. Well, not really townlike, but anti-scum FN meta...which by process of elimination means FN might be town. (Or he could be TP)

- - - Post Merge - - -

it would because I'm town

- - - Post Merge - - -

Basically I'm willing to risk everything to get FN lynched

if you're town, I'mma be hella pissed. This is not what good town play looks like.

 

[toadsworthy]

I mean I would understand it as a policy lynch at this point... but FN does this, I've seen it. People don't want to read other games or use meta but it's true

 

[amazonevan19]

Punchy, you got mad at toads for tunneling you? Take a hard look in the mirror m'dude lmao

 

[PunchyTheCat]

tbh I'm just being stupid.

 

[amazonevan19]

Wait isnt the point of the game if one is mafia not to act suspicious so they dont get lynched? If so thats a bad move.

sometimes scum does what's known as WIFOM - Wine in front of me - you can read more about it in the Encyclopedia Maftannica

BTW guys, if you don't know what something means, chances are it's defined and explained in the Maftannica #shamelessplug

 

[toadsworthy]

tbh I'm just being stupid.

We know. Do better.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Punchy, you got mad at toads for tunneling you? Take a hard look in the mirror m'dude lmao

I was annoyed at toads for tunneling me for no reason. Fire is being scummy af rn. Why would town just blatantly not answer questions asked to them?

 

[amazonevan19]

tbh I'm just being stupid.

well then stop being stupid and start being helpful

 

[FireNinja1]

tbh I'm just being stupid.

Then stop being stupid.

(and before I get called out for hypocrisy, I'm posting some stuff later tonight)

- - - Post Merge - - -

well then stop being stupid and start being helpful

danggit

 

[amazonevan19]

Why would town just blatantly not answer questions asked to them?

um please explain why that's scummy???

- - - Post Merge - - -

ok so I missed a page nvm

- - - Post Merge - - -

NO I DID NOT MY QUESTION IS STILL VALID

oh the irony, so delicious

 

[Ghostkid]

sometimes scum does what's known as WIFOM - Wine in front of me - you can read more about it in the Encyclopedia Maftannica

BTW guys, if you don't know what something means, chances are it's defined and explained in the Maftannica #shamelessplug

Thanks ill bookmark it just incase i need it again

 

[Locket]

@Punchy Stop. You did this last game and it got us nowhere. Get on track, stop saying you're being stupid. Don't go for your own lynch.

 

[toadsworthy]

I was annoyed at toads for tunneling me for no reason. Fire is being scummy af rn. Why would town just blatantly not answer questions asked to them?

To tunnel there needs to be someone saying you are scummy... I said you are town

 

[oath2order]

@Punchy Stop. You did this last game and it got us nowhere. Get on track, stop saying you're being stupid. Don't go for your own lynch.

I thought this was his first game?