Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[PunchyTheCat]

I thought this was his first game?

Oath be quiet this is like my sixth game.

 

[Locket]

I thought this was his first game?

It's not.

 

[FireNinja1]

Oath be quiet this is like my sixth game.

I don't think he was being sarcastic.

 

[Kamzitty]

So far what I'm getting from the past few pages is that nobody REALLY sees FN or Punchy as scum, they're both just sorta playing randomly/badly and need to step up their game. They're p distracting. ;/ Maybe we should move on from these two and focus on other lynch candidates?

 

[Ghostkid]

So far what I'm getting from the past few pages is that nobody REALLY sees FN or Punchy as scum, they're both just sorta playing randomly/badly and need to step up their game. They're p distracting. ;/ Maybe we should move on from these two and focus on other lynch candidates?

Yea i think that ll be best

 

[toadsworthy]

So far what I'm getting from the past few pages is that nobody REALLY sees FN or Punchy as scum, they're both just sorta playing randomly/badly and need to step up their game. They're p distracting. ;/ Maybe we should move on from these two and focus on other lynch candidates?

Who do you propos

 

[FireNinja1]

So far what I'm getting from the past few pages is that nobody REALLY sees FN or Punchy as scum, they're both just sorta playing randomly/badly and need to step up their game. They're p distracting. ;/ Maybe we should move on from these two and focus on other lynch candidates?

Nah, pretty sure FN's scum.

 

[Locket]

So far what I'm getting from the past few pages is that nobody REALLY sees FN or Punchy as scum, they're both just sorta playing randomly/badly and need to step up their game. They're p distracting. ;/ Maybe we should move on from these two and focus on other lynch candidates?

Let's move on for now, but keep them both in mind.

 

[Kamzitty]

Who do you propos

It's hard for me to say because I'm still learning and there haven't been a lot of tale tell signs as of yet. I would prefer to hear more from unactive people such as panda, dad, kate, giglabesh, etc before anything, but my main point was that focusing on these two is fruitless since no one seems keen on lynching them.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Nah, pretty sure FN's scum.

Ffs why did you join this game if you weren't gonna take anything seriously

 

[toadsworthy]

It's hard for me to say because I'm still learning and there haven't been a lot of tale tell signs as of yet. I would prefer to hear more from unactive people such as panda, dad, kate, giglabesh, etc before anything, but my main point was that focusing on these two is fruitless since no one seems keen on lynching them.

- - - Post Merge - - -




Ffs why did you join this game if you weren't gonna take anything seriously

If you had to control the whole lynch right this second, who would you lynch

 

[FireNinja1]

Ffs why did you join this game if you weren't gonna take anything seriously

Ok, ok, I'll stop.

 

[Kamzitty]

If you had to control the whole lynch right this second, who would you lynch

lmao right this second??? I would say FireNinja, not because I'm confident he's scum, but because he's not taking anything seriously and has just been a distraction so far.
Nobody (including myself) really sees FN as for sure scum, but I don't really have anything else to go off of. I just don't wanna avoid your question so I'm answering honestly even though I'm aware it's a horrible idea lol. I still think we should move on from FN and Punchy, we just need to hear more input from members who haven't posted as much.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If you had to control the whole lynch right this second, who would you lynch

ALSO i would like to hear other people's answers to this question as well, as my input didn't help much :^)

 

[toadsworthy]

Agreed, picking a mafia would be hard right now.... I would go for a jacob, dad, Ryumia lynch. Posting minimally and me having no inclination of what they said, playing mediator. Completely under the radar, yet still there.

 

[Ghostkid]

So far my read list hasnt changed much...but im putting FN twords a possible mafia

 

[glow]

Ok, admittedly I haven?t read the thread fully and will not be able to read or address anybody for another three hours (Ness in particular), but why are me and Antonio not teamed in any world?

This just caught my eye

post it note for me to answer later

 

[FireNinja1]

Agreed, picking a mafia would be hard right now.... I would go for a jacob, dad, Ryumia lynch. Posting minimally and me having no inclination of what they said, playing mediator. Completely under the radar, yet still there.

I'm most inclined toward Ryumia personally. I'll explain in a bit.

So far my read list hasnt changed much...but im putting FN twords a possible mafia

Any reason besides incessant trolling?

 

[Kamzitty]

Agreed, picking a mafia would be hard right now.... I would go for a jacob, dad, Ryumia lynch. Posting minimally and me having no inclination of what they said, playing mediator. Completely under the radar, yet still there.

Just skimmed some of their posts. Dad has posted the least out of the 3. His "reads" list was long but didn't add much to the game? Other than that he hasn't contributed, so I would like to see more from him.
Ryumia's reason for defending FN was really odd to me?? Idk what to think of her lol. I do agree that she seems to be playing mediator tho, other than taking a different stance on FN's situation.
As for Jacob, I skimmed his posts but there was some good content from what I saw.. Nothing really stood out to me as sus but I'll re-read them as well as ryumia's to see if I can find anything.

 

[Ghostkid]

Any reason besides incessant trolling?

Theres that and the not disclose thing on ur RQS...uve been acting ssuspicious ?.?

 

[glow]

Dolby math skills are on point (mafia ratio is 1:5 i think and 5:25 is 20%). Anyways, It's late and I will rather wait till after school tomorrow before coming up with a logical mafia reads (I usually go into detail about who I think is mafia instead of everyone which I say is either null, lean, or town) like I did last time about everyone.

I also don't think Punchy is mafia. The whole ness thing was obviously a joke plus last game he was acting super suspicious last game and the majority voted him off. He was town during that game! These are probably crappy claims since I don't have much to work with so I'm going to wait tommorow sometime after school, like I said. (Punchy is null)

I'm going to go pretty myself up and go to bed.

oh there it is

mafia doesn't confirm their partners assessment of the mafia/town ratio

 

[Jacob]

Agreed, picking a mafia would be hard right now.... I would go for a jacob, dad, Ryumia lynch. Posting minimally and me having no inclination of what they said, playing mediator. Completely under the radar, yet still there.

Saying we are going under the radar as your basis for a lynch candidate this early in the game is a heavy claim and I?m interested in seeing what other evidence you have. Dad?s reads? Those went under your radar? More accurately, you were preoccupied, and are just throwing out names of posts you didn't read.

lmao right this second??? I would say FireNinja, not because I'm confident he's scum, but because he's not taking anything seriously and has just been a distraction so far.
Nobody (including myself) really sees FN as for sure scum, but I don't really have anything else to go off of. I just don't wanna avoid your question so I'm answering honestly even though I'm aware it's a horrible idea lol. I still think we should move on from FN and Punchy, we just need to hear more input from members who haven't posted as much.

This is one of the more interesting posts in the game currently in my opinion. Rather than bringing up a scummy candidate, Kammm suggested a priority type lynch like iLoveYou did, and argued for, like the majority of this day.
I tried looking back through Kammms posts, but I?m kind of lost because I skimmed most of the debate. Was Kammm one of the players who criticized ILY for her lynch thoughts? For the people who DID criticize ILY for them, what are your thoughts on Kammms suggestion of FN for being distracting rather than scummy?