Post interspersed with actual defense and fluff. Enjoy.
Fireninja leaves this. I'm going to say this right now before rereading through the rest of the thread: I don't like either of them as of right now. FN is being far quieter than I last remember him as town (MM), while Punchy has been kinda weird, even considering that it is him we're talking about. However, Fire leaves absolutely zero reason for his vote other than "he voted first" when Punchy literally retracted it in the same post and it was well established as a joke
1. The "he voted first" reasoning was a response to Mog about why I'm not trying to get an easy townclear from this, not why I voted him.
2. I don't think using Mystic Messenger is a good standard. My opening to that game was ridiculously controversial.
Honestly, my theory is that FN is a hostile TP. This is quite possibly a new role that no one else has created. If this is true, and something happens, then town will be doomed.
This theory is false.
other than that noonces done anything obviously scummy yet, just a few weird things like toms kinda memey posts and fireninjas weird omgus in defense of ness thing, but idk their meta yet so that could be normal. gotta look over old games when im free, theres so many new people and vets i havent played with b4
I haven't mentioned Ness once this game.
FireNinja
-Voted for Punchy over one simple thing, and I don?t think he has played with Punchy before either. I agree that what Punchy said was weird and out of place but I am also considering that if Punchy is inexperienced town acting wacky and he isn't mafia, this can very much be looked back upon as jumping on easy prey. I don't see how this is so. The vote against Punchy was exactly that: a vote against Punchy.
-Also if you are going to answer RQS with a bunch of ?not saying? then just ignore the RQS Why?
Ok, still don?t have time to talk in depth rn, but I?ve read the thread and would like to remind you that FN is still a option, and I kinda feel like you all forgot that he existed
Yeah, this FN guy is pretty shady, let's lynch him.
- I get why fireninja would vote punchy, seeing as FN hasn?t played with punchy before, but the fact he kept his vote long after it was established punchy was trolling is mildly concerning
I sort of just kept it there and was going to change it later lol. This should answer your question from earlier.
I just went through his posts and he hasn't really posted anything substantial, and his punchy vote seems really random? FN seems v fishy but I also feel like that's too obvious as mafia, would he really vote somebody right away without explanation if he was trying to lay low?
- - - Post Merge - - -
The whole "we aren't a team" was random to me as well, I don't see why FN would feel the need to say that as nobody had even considered the fact that they were a team. I agree with punchy, FN is either playing bad town or bad scum lol. Not quite sure who a jester is tho?
It's not me, I am not the jester this game. Also, if you had to pick between the two which one is it?
@Ryu If I have somebody who I think should be, itd FN. but I don?t think he?s getting nearly enough scrutiny
I'm not opposed to more scrutiny.
@Dolby Fireninja's never played with Punchy and what punchy did could have been seen as scummy by someone unfamiliar with Punchy's ****posting. But at this point it's an untenable position to hold
I didn't know of Punchy's meta going into this game, just to be clear.
I can't tell if this is a beary509 town or a mafia and yarr it's drivin' me nuts
- - - Post Merge - - -
post glitch ripperoni
Throwback to 2015 oh my god.
don't know who or what beary509 is, but if I'm reading Trundle right, I gotta say I agree that Ryumia's post doesn't make much sense here. If FN is scum I wouldn't be surprised if Ryumia is as well cuz of Ryumia seemingly protecting FN here. But it's way too early to make a definitive call on that. Just a situation to keep tabs on for sure
Beary was a former mafia player. I'll talk about other players in a bit.
Ok. So. I can think of a few reasons why FN would vote me.
1. We're scum bussing each other, which we aren't.
2. He's a Jester who is intentionally doing something that would seem not obvious to do as Jester, as in like reverse psychology.
3. He's being a really stupid townie.
4. He's scum doing a form of reverse psychology. He probably knows that he would be sussed for it, and then people would realize it is a stupid idea to do as scum, because it would be too obvious that he would be sussed for it.
It's actually all four at the same time.
sounds good. I await your post(s). And thanks - but were you going to anyway, or did you do so only because I prompted you to?
See above--I was going to change it at some point, but you asked so I did it anyway.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Ahh these RQ's are really bad imo. If he's played 15-20 games, then I'm defo more confident that he's scum. Also the number of Not disclosing? Really? You're kidding me. He only really answered 3 and 8.
That was on purpose.
