Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
it looks really, really, bad. considering trundle post merged in the same post IIRC. i remember panicking when i read trundle claimed blue, and then when he was like "omg genuine mistake" it was obviously 100% a real mistake. like what mafia would claim blue "accidentally" then change his claim. and what mafia would claim VT in his position anyway lmao
evan i used to townread for a very wrong reason. i actually have a small post of reads that i wanted to post d4 but withheld it because i can't sort two players. i'm thinking there's a strong likelihood that those two players are mafia. this can wait until later, but dw i will say it at some point. but basically i thought evan's response to punchy was within 1-2 minutes. but evan actually replied to punchy before mentioning the thing about the wincon
^^ 03-26-2018, 09:13 AM ^^
^^ 03-26-2018, 09:15 AM ^^
THEN he said
^^ 03-26-2018, 09:20 AM ^^
so yeah, a full 7 minutes between punchy's and evan's post . which is unnaturally long if you're just going to your inbox and checking your own wincon, and more than enough time to check the day posts to see if town has wincons in their PM's.
not to mention his extremely opportunistic FOS on me and then subsequent drop of said FOS when my lynch was gaining 0 traction. he also seemed completely unphased by my blue claim. and when someone you "fos" claims blue, it's really unnatural to not at least prod them, at least he should've mentioned that he didn't believe my claim, or literally ANYTHING besides completely ignoring it.
notice the difference between your push on me vs. evan's push on me, notice your response to my claim and evan's complete lack thereof.
also evan just softed blue. which looks really bad for him considering it's night and there's no reason to do so and i wouldn't be surprised if i knew exactly what his claim will be.
But yeah if Ness/glow/Kayla aren't on scumteam then I'm proud of whoever's scumplay this is, because those bluesnipes were eerily accurate and a lot of them have slid by very well or gotten people to townread them successfully for a long time. Myself included.
tell me what role karen is
tbh I'm afraid because she's full on stupid as a player ever since I returned late 2017, she's like the next Cory tbh
And Evan seems much clearer. Not totally tring Karen but can we focus on these Trundle bandwagoners for Day 5 please?
bluesniping is easy just pretend you're town and whoever seems scummy but isn't on your team is blue
- - - Post Merge - - -
no because karen is BLATANT MAFIA OH MY GOD
- - - Post Merge - - -
WHY WOULDN'T KAREN NL AS TOWN
karen's afraid to show her face in thread because what she did was so goddamn transparent to the point where it's comedic
fypov, isn't there very likely a doctor?
if there isn't a doctor then why didn't bodyguard die?
i have two answers to this but i'm interested in your response first
I TRY THAT WHEN BLUESNIPING IT DOESN'T ALWAYS WORK
But yeah, it's just not as blatant for me. When you look at that ****in' bandwagon. You need to understand why the bandwagon needs to be focused on for Day 5. Or I could just repeat myself: mafia doesn't care about boldly bandwagoning a mislynch when all they need to do to win is get one more mislynch but we have to lynch correctly four times in a row, and the odds of that happening with 15 players still around is difficult.
He had a gif prepared and everything.
Ok but if we no lynched, what’s the probability that Trundle would evaded tomorrows lynch, maybe 50% to Karen, but the day after that I don’t think there was anything Trundle could do to defend himself. Yes this is honestly like 90% my fault for flipping Trundle and Kammm to scumreads but I don’t have anything to say so.
- - - Post Merge - - -
In all honesty isn’t no lynch even better for scum? Like there’s a larger scum pool going further in the game while being able to knock blues off if that makes sense. I townread everyone on the NL wagon except Vanessa tho, so.
- - - Post Merge - - -
In all honesty isn’t no lynch even better for scum? Like there’s a larger scum pool going further in the game while being able to knock blues off if that makes sense. I townread everyone on the NL wagon except Vanessa tho, so.
FireNinja1
inactive: please read "about" tab on profile
I don't think it's good to dwell on the Trundle lynch being an ML.
I know but, the Trundle lynch was inevitable, whether it was today tomorrow or the day after imo
