Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Ghostkid]

i cant sheep anyone if you all keep making good points about other people that they could be mafia ;-; im about to just start a bid so you all can buy my vote. Lets start the bid at 1 tbt lol jk jk

 

[N e s s]

we're gonna lynch amanda today and see what comes from that. i'll feel a bit more comfortable to see what information it yields.

 

[glow]

poor tina having to count 500 votes from 13 players

- - - Post Merge - - -

ILY:
- Ness
- Dad
- Ghostkid

Dad:
- Hayden
- Ghostkid
- Evan
- glow
- ILY

Amanda:
- Hayden
- Evan
- Vampnessa
- Ghostkid
- Ness

- - - Post Merge - - -

we're gonna lynch amanda today and see what comes from that. i'll feel a bit more comfortable to see what information it yields.

what made you scumread amanda?

 

[Ghostkid]

poor tina having to count 500 votes from 13 players

- - - Post Merge - - -

ILY:
- Ness
- Dad
- Ghostkid

Dad:
- Hayden
- Ghostkid
- Evan
- glow
- ILY

Amanda:
- Hayden
- Evan
- Vampnessa
- Ghostkid
- Ness

- - - Post Merge - - -



what made you scumread amanda?

Amanda gonna get lynched

 

[glow]

i don’t feel opposed to an amanda lynch as much as i thought i would but

i just find it funny that dad has the nerve to call me bad town and it’s reminding me of what karen attempted to do

- - - Post Merge - - -

and despite his ?confidence? in his read he still refuses to make the deal

like honestly if he just said yes it would?ve helped me try to reconsider. but he?s trying to preserve himself and that?s his main concern. if i was in position i?d say yes, if i was that confident, but instead he pivots and says ?NO MISS BRIGHT WE LOSE IF I DIE? which isn?t even true lmfao

- - - Post Merge - - -

why did ILY change votes

 

[iLoveYou]

I changed votes because either way we need to get through both of them. I'm not opposed to keeping my vote on Dad though.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also if you guys noticed, Amanda was heavily stalking this thread all morning. She was probably waiting to see whether it would flip onto me and then vote. So ya, as long as we get out one it'll be a lot safer.

 

[glow]

just curious how sure are we that Ryumia isn't scum

See though thats the thing, I just genuinely feel like that has been her entire shield this game. She never developed anything leading up to the Tom lynch, she just sort of started shouting "Lynch Tom!" and has been saying that the entire game to anyone who feels suspicious of her

and Panda was a needed role, she had to survive to Day 3 in order for the ability to work. What are the mafia roles again I forgot

- - - Post Merge - - -

but then again I have a very hard time seeing her develop the Punchy vote first/last plan as mafia....

maybe I'm just overthinking this

- - - Post Merge - - -

tbh I think it is dad but I have very hard time seeing it as him at the same time

- - - Post Merge - - -

if dad flips town i can't wait to say in the endgame "ZOMG I WAS RIGHT ABOUT KAYLA!"

deeply relate

i just really wanna know what brought you to amanda? i have so many thoughts about amanda and none of them really agree. on one hand i'd lynch gig in a heartbeat purely from d1 but on the other... amanda has had good lines?

 

[N e s s]

It's purely a matter of PoE at this point, if not Amanda who else?

>Fireninja's role seems real
>Antonio exchanged genuine lines with Panda and it's unlikely it's him
>Dad and iLoveYou can't be a team at this point

Only feasibly possible person here is Ryumia, and even then, Ryumia is really Town like especially after her last post.

- - - Post Merge - - -

and after the entire Panda thing Heyden pulled there's absolutely no way it can be him. The only person who can be scum here is Amanda.

 

[iLoveYou]

Definitely the Gig situation.

Agreed. Also, if Karen is blue we aren't going to be regretting spaghetti or anything else - we're gonna be down to LYLO.

Her posts like this look so off. When I read this it felt like she was too okay to get down to Lylo.

I'll have my reads up asap start of D4. The window of time I had allocated to getting them written up tonight was accidentally spent on other things, but I will get them done as soon as I'm functional tomorrow.

Promised reads at the start of D4, never delivered. She goes from that quote to this right away:

I'm considering voting for Trundle because of the following :

- quotes in post # 2791.

- his odd little "reaction test" about surrendering as Town (which Ness already pointed out would never have worked if legit anyway) - not very suspicious in-and-of-itself, but it stood out to me at the time.

- a couple of his posts to throw sus on people have struck me as opportunistic af and not really Town-sided - he never explained his thinking behind them, hasn't seemed interested in pursuing anyone he's openly sussed, or really, anyone at all that I can remember.

I'll go back through his posts and confirm the context of the quotes glow posted, along with the posts I was already concerned about. It's still REALLY early in D4 to be trying to lock in votes as far as I'm concerned, but as of rn Trundle is my top SL.

(I'm still working on my reads now I've caught up, I haven't forgotten I need them posted ASAP.)

Looks opportunistic to encourage a Trundle lynch.

Ya I'm not ruling out voting No Lynch still but I think Trundle is absolutely Mafia and I'm really really struggling to see why leaving him alive is better than lynching him. He's been saying this stuff for how long now? It's just gonna be the same next day phase and we'll have enough to work through as it is with Karen's weird af role-claim (whatever that may be) in addition to so much I can't even keep track of it anymore.

If I had any doubt about Trundle NOT flipping scum, I'd switch to No Lynch in a heartbeat. There's no doubt, and unless he somehow provides it, I want him lynched.

She never developed reads in the thread yet she is confident Trundle is mafia and he needs to be lynched ?

Holey ****ing guacamol?, the surprises just never stop with this game.

I've read back, but I'm just gonna keep working on what I was doing (reads for the four players I still owe, reading old iLoveYou/Kayla games, responding to people I said I would) for now before to trying to work through the new stuff and what it means for my reads.

Just over 9hours to go until EoD, no pressure.

- - - Post Merge - - -

EBWOP : *.. before trying to work through..

When was the last time she even gave reads ?
Who were her scum leans this game anyways ?

Reads are always needed (well, not during Night phases unless you know what you're doing lol) right up until the Endgame post is up.

Yet she never gave any ( or much ? ).

- - - Post Merge - - -

How viable is No Lynch today??

Suggested No Lynch when Panda claimed Survivor. Yet not for Trundle ? Lols. Panda was a much safer lynch than Trundle.

 

[N e s s]

Also Amanda just liked one of my posts 5 minutes ago so she's clearly aware of what's happening here : )

 

[Heyden]

I can’t tell if Amanda’s still catching up or gave up.

- - - Post Merge - - -

whatever idc

 

[Ghostkid]

now that i got that shiny bulbasuar i dont know what to do with my life :/

So are we doing an amanda lynch wagon?

 

[glow]

I can’t tell if Amanda’s still catching up or gave up.

- - - Post Merge - - -

whatever idc

mood

 

[amazonevan19]

I think amanda's play here was her trying to not be like her scum self last game, but she's kinda slipped back as the game has gone on tbh. Let her guard down

- - - Post Merge - - -

I see her lurking again :eyes:

 

[amanda1983]

My apologies for my absence here recently. An irl emergency + cascade of events has combined to render my ability to contribute here almost nil. As replacing players in not a possibility this late in the game, and I was technically able to meet the minimum requirements to avoid being mod-killed, I will make sure I vote before EoD. I have finally caught up on things here, a feat which has taken me wayyyy too many hours of reading and re-reading to manage due to my sleep-deprived state, (non-game-related) stress levels, and frequent need to attend to critical irl issues (note : I am safe, my loved ones are safe at this time, and I believe we will remain so, the initial emergency and aftermath has now been sufficiently resolved/contained.. too late for my involvement in this game but I would make the same choices RE priorities each and every time coz as much as I loathe letting people down here in general, that simply cannot ever come before the physical (and emotional) wellbeing of my loved ones.

Gah, I don't think I'll be able to edit this for coherence before I need to post it as I'm in a low mobile reception area already and I need to do some time-critical stuff irl. < DELETE once checked for clarity + removal of extraneous info

 

[amazonevan19]

My apologies for my absence here recently. An irl emergency + cascade of events has combined to render my ability to contribute here almost nil. As replacing players in not a possibility this late in the game, and I was technically able to meet the minimum requirements to avoid being mod-killed, I will make sure I vote before EoD. I have finally caught up on things here, a feat which has taken me wayyyy too many hours of reading and re-reading to manage due to my sleep-deprived state, (non-game-related) stress levels, and frequent need to attend to critical irl issues (note : I am safe, my loved ones are safe at this time, and I believe we will remain so, the initial emergency and aftermath has now been sufficiently resolved/contained.. too late for my involvement in this game but I would make the same choices RE priorities each and every time coz as much as I loathe letting people down here in general, that simply cannot ever come before the physical (and emotional) wellbeing of my loved ones.

Gah, I don't think I'll be able to edit this for coherence before I need to post it as I'm in a low mobile reception area already and I need to do some time-critical stuff irl. < DELETE once checked for clarity + removal of extraneous info

Glad to hear you are doing all right and that the emergency has been contained. Family and irl stuff definitely comes before any mafia game.

What are your opinions of the Dad v. ILY war? Who do you want lynched? And icymi we're all voting for you so yeah

 

[Heyden]

Just vote Dad he’s scum xDD

- - - Post Merge - - -

Guys vote Dad, Amanda has a bomb on her

- - - Post Merge - - -

Guys vote Dad, Amanda has a bomb on her

 

[iLoveYou]

Aww, Amanda. I hope its only good news for you from here on out. I'm happy to hear you & your loved ones are safe. Please do keep us updated on the Discord Mafia server. I really hope we hear from you soon. <3 I agree with Evan, you definitely made the right choice to put this game as a lesser priority to the emergency you're dealing with. You were so sweet to all of us in this game. Please take care <3.

 

[FireNinja1]

Just vote Dad he’s scum xDD

- - - Post Merge - - -

Guys vote Dad, Amanda has a bomb on her

- - - Post Merge - - -

Guys vote Dad, Amanda has a bomb on her

Explain please.

 

[Ghostkid]

Just vote Dad he?s scum xDD

- - - Post Merge - - -

Guys vote Dad, Amanda has a bomb on her

- - - Post Merge - - -

Guys vote Dad, Amanda has a bomb on her

Are u being serious?