Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Geoni]

Lols that's so funny because I was contemplating getting modkilled to prove they were mafia.

Lmfao no you weren't. Keep on writing that self-sacrificial narrative.

I'm trying not to back and forth with her. I really am.

 

[glow]

because i don't see ILY getting lynched over u rn

 

[Geoni]

was that a no? what happened to your confidence

if you're town take the offer

Town loses if I'm lynched, Miss Bright.

- - - Post Merge - - -

because i don't see ILY getting lynched over u rn

But yeah we could get there if you're able to shake off that I've sussed the wrong people and tunneled you and then actually read back on the points I've brought up against Kayla as well as some of the things Ness has pointed out but then again I don't have much faith in you.

 

[glow]

Town loses if I'm lynched, Miss Bright.

- - - Post Merge - - -



But yeah we could get there if you're able to shake off that I've sussed the wrong people and tunneled you and then actually read back on the points I've brought up against Kayla as well as some of the things Ness has pointed out but then again I don't have much faith in you.

i don’t scumread you because you’ve made wrong reads

 

[N e s s]

this entire game in a nutshell:

 

[amazonevan19]

I'm unvoting

Really not confident in a dad vote rn

Decently confident in an Amanda vote tbh

 

[glow]

all dads done so far is AtE and i dunno why it’s working

- - - Post Merge - - -

AtE and the one thing i asked him to not do (focus on kayla)*

 

[Ghostkid]

Ok everyone depression just came and hit me like a brick. So if anyone has any questions or amything to tell me like...idk something to change my vote or something go ahead and tell me cuz i might not be on tomorrow...

 

[Ghostkid]

Ok everyone ill leave off tonight woth something for youvall to think about...geres what i think about Ily vs dad
Either they are misreading each other and its Town vs Town
Or its mafia vs town...one of them coukd be a mafia

 

[Geoni]

and the one thing i asked him to not do (focus on kayla)*

How can I not? Have you actually read her glow?

- - - Post Merge - - -

this entire game in a nutshell:

It ranks high:

 

[N e s s]

@glow but if Dad were mafia, why would he:

1. Beg you to put the game at No Lynch on Day 3
2. Plead Kammm to vote someone to prevent the modkill from happening

- - - Post Merge - - -

and just saying if Mafia had decided that they were going to straight up drop Karen, why would Dad go through the trouble of defending Karen that he didn't fully think that she was obviously mafia? Why not just say "Yeah I'm near certain that she is scum" and get the towncred after she flips scum the phase?

- - - Post Merge - - -

god i'm definitely going to hate myself if one or the other is scum but I really just cannot tell, both of them have played a good scum game should either be mafia but I genuinely am having a hard time deciding here

 

[Heyden]

@glow but if Dad were mafia, why would he:

1. Beg you to put the game at No Lynch on Day 3
2. Plead Kammm to vote someone to prevent the modkill from happening

Eh, these two points are easily town and mafia behaviours though. The lynch was Kermit, Trundle or No Lynch, voting Trundle would've brought a lot of attention onto him and no lynch seemed the most protown choice, and wouldn't really affect mafia, bc lets be honest, Trundle probably would've been lynched anyway.
Also he was probably pleading her to vote so we could mislynch her.
Ofc these points only apply if he's scum and I've been townreading him all game, and same with iLoveYou, so I'm very very lost. If neither is scum I'll probably cry at endgame.

 

[glow]

1. because it was either karen or trundle and dad couldn’t vote trundle (his ~tr~) so he would ofc advocate for NL lmao what was he supposed to do

2. why is that a towntell exactly? mafia would want kamm to live since she wasn’t clear and her towniness was tapering off. more dead town is a smaller pool to hide in

- - - Post Merge - - -

tbh all dads done so far in response to me is insult me / AtE

not once did i ever insult him all game when i was being tunneled? lmao

if i didn’t scumread him already i’d be down 2 ego lynch him

- - - Post Merge - - -

for the record idc about insults, it?s more that when you?re town and in a bad position you shouldn?t feel so hostile. when he was pressuring me it never bothered me because i knew i was playing in a non-town like manner

though he?s definitely played the part of being town he should know that due some of his actions this game would make others SR him.... he should know he isn?t owed any TRs but still feels entitled to them. i think another sub component of this is him reducing my doubt as just ?you only scumread me because my reads were wrong? when bruv i?ve made plenty of wrong reads and honestly more often than not mafias reads are ?better? than towns

it?s the manner in which he approached those reads

- - - Post Merge - - -

not proofread at all woopsies

- - - Post Merge - - -

Town loses if I'm lynched, Miss Bright

there is no B in my last name

 

[amazonevan19]

there is no B in my last name

 

[Geoni]

1. because it was either karen or trundle and dad couldn’t vote trundle (his ~tr~) so he would ofc advocate for NL lmao what was he supposed to do

2. why is that a towntell exactly? mafia would want kamm to live since she wasn’t clear and her towniness was tapering off. more dead town is a smaller pool to hide in

- - - Post Merge - - -

tbh all dads done so far in response to me is insult me / AtE

not once did i ever insult him all game when i was being tunneled? lmao

if i didn’t scumread him already i’d be down 2 ego lynch him

- - - Post Merge - - -

for the record idc about insults, it’s more that when you’re town and in a bad position you shouldn’t feel so hostile. when he was pressuring me it never bothered me because i knew i was playing in a non-town like manner

though he’s definitely played the part of being town he should know that due some of his actions this game would make others SR him.... he should know he isn’t owed any TRs but still feels entitled to them. i think another sub component of this is him reducing my doubt as just “you only scumread me because my reads were wrong” when bruv i’ve made plenty of wrong reads and honestly more often than not mafias reads are “better” than towns

it’s the manner in which he approached those reads

- - - Post Merge - - -

not proofread at all woopsies

- - - Post Merge - - -

there is no B in my last name

I'm making whatever appeals I can at this point because not only are you dead ****ing wrong but a number of people in town are, and you're clearly not reading Kayla and stubbornly cling to whatever read you think is right like you always do. Honestly if you do end up leading town the wrong way with your vote and voice then your cute little retort here at the end? ...I rest my case lmao. And yes I'm insulting to you because you're brash af, don't deny it. It's fair that you're turning around to do what I did to you all game though so whatever. I'm just going to have to rely on good town to actually pull through with the votes here.

 

[iLoveYou]

When we were placing votes on KermitsTea, Dad went out of his way to split the votes on Glow. He has been doing that for the majority of the game, I know. But during a mislynch phase, can you really argue that its still the best move to be making ? He knew he wouldn't get support and he was staying consistent with his attack on Glow during the worst times to be doing that.

After successfully getting his first mislynch out of two ( Trundle ) do you really think he would be worried about saying " Karen might be blue " and then killing her off at night to flip red when he could easily do damage control on that ? All he had to do was get through one last mislynch the next day. Why would he allow us to lynch Karen and have two extra days of discussion over potentially losing some Town cred ? Plus if anything KermitsTea voted on me so that could have been used against me too if he needed it.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dad was all over the place that day when our lynch candidates were KermitsTea vs. Trundle.

 

[cornimer]

She's distancing herself from you in case one of you get lynched. Or trying to make it seem like we're both on the same team pushing for your lynch so people turn on me and mislynch me. There are two mafia left so little things like that can be a form of manipulation.

Or, y'know, she knows I'm town and wants me mislynched. Pretty simple. Either way she didn't add you to her PoE mafia suspects until she absolutely had to if we're all in agreement that Heyden/Antonio/Ryumia are town. Instead she kept you in the middle. But me? She was prepared to see me lynched sooner.

Idk if this has been addressed yet but last game (Woodpines) in which Amanda was scum and it was LYLO, she went for the mislynch. She didn't bus her partners (she like lightly sussed them but not to the point of voting iirc)

- - - Post Merge - - -

So I think its more likely that shes partnered with Kayla since she put Kayla farther down on her sus list

 

[iLoveYou]

Has she voted yet though ? Why isn't she placing her vote on Dad yet ? She was online and didn't do anything. She didn't post or vote. Saying she would vote for someone is such an easy set-up to get people to stack votes on the opposite player and then earn the mislynch that way.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Vanessa, when there's only one mislynch left do you really believe two mafia players would come off as that obvious ? Literally if the last two get caught in ANY way, they lose the game.

 

[cornimer]

Vanessa, when there's only one mislynch left do you really believe two mafia players would come off as that obvious ? Literally if the last two get caught in ANY way, they lose the game.

But it worked for her last game, so idk why she wouldn't do it again, especially considering that not that many ppl in this game were in the last game

 

[iLoveYou]

But it worked for her last game, so idk why she wouldn't do it again, especially considering that not that many ppl in this game were in the last game

I'm sure she knew people would look back into her old games if they wanted to compare the likelihood of her being mafia this game. That's what these mafia games run on too, right ? Looking into past trends of players.