Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[PandaDarling]

Since when is everyone ok with voting for inactives/ dead weight ? i use to get told off for wanting to "trim the fat" and lynch people that will eventually get modkilled, cause i also believe its an easy way for the mafia to hide and also close the game towards the end, but now everyones ok with it ?

 

[FireNinja1]

Since when is everyone ok with voting for inactives/ dead weight ? i use to get told off for wanting to "trim the fat" and lynch people that will eventually get modkilled, cause i also believe its an easy way for the mafia to hide and also close the game towards the end, but now everyones ok with it ?

I'm largely opposed to it, but there was at least one post that made me wary of Antonio.

 

[illunie]

Since when is everyone ok with voting for inactives/ dead weight ? i use to get told off for wanting to "trim the fat" and lynch people that will eventually get modkilled, cause i also believe its an easy way for the mafia to hide and also close the game towards the end, but now everyones ok with it ?

idk if ur not paying close attention or smth (youve been away for a bit so idk) but the reason i and most other people sus antonio is bc of his repeated posts about promising to post content, but never doing it, as well as his big shift in behaviour from just posting his thoughts last game to holding them back this game, rather than him just being away for a bit.

 

[glow]

Ok, in Dad/Glow I honestly trust Dad more. His meta as scum is typically to make more small posts, less more on-the-spot analysis, if anything. This does still represent a change in playstyle, but he did wallpost a bit D0 in APM as well.

you really need to stop basing all your reads off meta specifically when it comes to experienced players

 

[Dolby]

Ok, I’m going to vote Locket. I was considering voting Ryu, but I given that this will be my last chance to vote today, I prefer leaving more options open than running up the vote count or causing a two-way race

Peace

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I'm fine with the Antonio lynch, I'm going to vote him bc FN's lynch isn't going to pick up any steam. I kind of overlooked him at first, but he's definitely scummy.

 

[glow]

ugh I'm still doing my reads but I had to help my brother with his stupid project and I never want to see devon again>.>
I don't know who to vote, I don't feel 100% on voting Antonio but I'm not 100% caught up so I'm just going to vote myself.

toads don't kill me ples I swear

why even do this as town i want to vote u so bad now

- - - Post Merge - - -

ppl 2 scared to lynch scum daddy sad ;(

 

[illunie]

ok punchys voting antonio now im def switching lmao the bw has come in full force

 

[glow]

so can we vote dedenne since they softclaimed VT or mafia

- - - Post Merge - - -

or jester

 

[illunie]

i might not be able to vote later and im still not sure, but after looking over ryu and fireninjas posts im probably gonna shift to her

- - - Post Merge - - -

yep locked in

 

[PandaDarling]

idk if ur not paying close attention or smth (youve been away for a bit so idk) but the reason i and most other people sus antonio is bc of his repeated posts about promising to post content, but never doing it, as well as his big shift in behaviour from just posting his thoughts last game to holding them back this game, rather than him just being away for a bit.

i get the Antonio thing, but why Locket and if people are considering inactives for lynch then why isn't anyone mentioning Giglabesh ?

 

[PandaDarling]

idk if ur not paying close attention or smth (youve been away for a bit so idk) but the reason i and most other people sus antonio is bc of his repeated posts about promising to post content, but never doing it, as well as his big shift in behaviour from just posting his thoughts last game to holding them back this game, rather than him just being away for a bit.

i get the Antonio thing, but why Locket and if people are considering inactives for lynch then why isn't anyone mentioning Giglabesh ?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Wait is Antonio a Jester

 

[iLoveYou]

I was going to vote for Antonio because he is definitely keeping up aith the thread ( he correctly called out inactives) but not posting enough. I'm a little worried to place a vote on him now because it seems that several people in a row decided that he would make a good lynch candidate. We're Day One and I didn't think this many people in a row would agree directly on him out of their general scum pool ( consisting of several names suspected per person ). I thought there would be more fight between players and not just "I'm down for an Antonio lynch". The more vocal players have unfortunately carved a path for the rest of the players to blend into and we're seeing the start of a bandwagon already. If we all have several suspicions then how come we are all suddenly fine with Antonio ?

Inactives: Antonio, Kate, Lovket, Gigablush .. am I missing anyone ? Of those 4, I think Gigablush will just end up getting modkilled so a lynch there would be a waste. I'm not going to vote Antonio due to the bandwagoners. I find it too risky now. I am now more likely to vote Kate due to one of her sole posts being a mafia accusation without participating in the thread or providing her own reasoning.

Ryu / mog - both bandwagoned onto me when convo shifted ( Toad too but just a bit compared to them ). I see that mog is posting a lot more so I feel like we have a chance to read into her, as we would Tom. and Ryu has not posted nearly as much content as mog and I feel she may be lurking on purpose now. How does she not have any opinions after everything ? Is she going to vote ?

Ryu, Kate and Locket = I think those three names are ideal for the lynch. I am leaning towards Ryu so badly right now due to her filler posts which "blend" in. I don't have the best feeling on her.

Dedenne voting herself is not okay either. She is staying active but neutral in the vote. Glow I agree with you I am almost tempted to vote her for doig that but it is too impulsive.

I feel like I need to vote Kate or Ryu here.

- - - Post Merge - - -

i get the Antonio thing, but why Locket and if people are considering inactives for lynch then why isn't anyone mentioning Giglabesh ?

I feel like Giglabesh is the most likely to get modkilled so a lunch would be a waste on them

 

[Heyden]

If you’re scum reading Ryumia based on meta if you look at her first game all her poste were fillery too which is why I lowkey townlean her.
Dedenne/Locket/Antonio are all fine, preferably the latter

 

[FireNinja1]

If you’re scum reading Ryumia based on meta if you look at her first game all her poste were fillery too which is why I lowkey townlean her.
Dedenne/Locket/Antonio are all fine, preferably the latter

My SR is not based on meta.

 

[mogyay]

yep i'm also not ok with a ryu lynch, seems typical for them judged on past games (albeit i've only played with like once or something), i think i might go for dedenne i guess. in regard to their team mate defending them.. they may as well just join in tbh, defending any of them at this point would be kinda weird. it's not nice lynching inactives but what more can we really do

 

[illunie]

i get the Antonio thing, but why Locket and if people are considering inactives for lynch then why isn't anyone mentioning Giglabesh ?

people (not me) were sussing locket for changing her behaviour from last game, as well as being inactive and fading into the background. noone wants to vote giglabesh bc they literally havent posted anything other than the rqs, its impossible to get a read off that

 

[Kamzitty]

I haven't voted Antonio yet because I'm still looking at everyone's opinions. I'm starting to consider Locket/Ryumia after the last few pages, but I need to read up on their posts before deciding.

 

[mogyay]

My SR is not based on meta.

i don't think it's strong enough for a lynch though, at least she's providing some thought... plus maybe you should consider it since it is kinda typical of them...