Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Jacob]

Panda: 2 posts, tied for lowest post count I think. However, she did drop her thoughts which means she at least a little invested and reading, so not inactive.

1. What is your timezone?
PST.
2. How active will you be this game?
Hopefully more than last game.
3. Preferred pronoun?
She/Her/Your Majesty.
4. Do you prefer being town or being mafia?
Town.
5. How do you handle pressure?
Decently.
6. Which player(s) in this game can you read the best?
Probably Toad or Mog.
7. Which player(s) in this game can best read you?
Definitely not Mog.
8. How many games have you played?
Too many.
9. Who would you fearkill N1?
Glow or Tom Darling.
10. Will Ness answer this RQS?
Nope.

Ness vs Toad seems town vs town to me.... Toad usually does this thing were he pushes a couple players D1 to get a reaction out of them, and Ness being so emotional reminds me of his old play style as town.

Ness i hope you decide to stay in the game, i know it gets emotional at times, but you don't have anything to be embarrassed about, sometimes our emotions get the better of us, but we fam here, no worries little Pineapple Head.

Dolby & ILoveYou you guys are too smart for me you post make my head go in circles and after a long day of work, i just can't.

Tom i dont like the whole "im not gonna open my role pm" i think you lied and said this once before as scum, and if you are town... you could be an important PR and if you don't know, how is that helping us ?

FireNinja & Punchy i dont even know what to say, you guys are clogging the thread with nonsense and its very annoying to read page after page of it.

?2. How active will you be this game?
Hopefully more than last game.?
Ok so I learned that being quiet isn?t a new thing. The activity shouldn?t be a huge red flag if this is a common thing for Panda, but there?s still content to be looked into so I?ll just keep going.

? 6. Which player(s) in this game can you read the best?
Probably Toad or Mog.?
Question 4 Panda: When you read this, what are your thoughts on toad and Mog if theyve changed or updated?

?Tom i dont like the whole "im not gonna open my role pm" i think you lied and said this once before as scum, and if you are town... you could be an important PR and if you don't know, how is that helping us ? ?
Although i believe that Tom?s post was just a joke I do like how you?re thinking with it.

@Dad Whats wrong with me trying to comfort a friend, i wasn't PLEADING for him to stay in the game Ness and i have a lot of history in these games especially when it comes to getting into heated arguments, so i know how he is feeling about it and i dont want him to feel bad. also when i was saying that the back and forth between Dolby and ILoveYou (Kayla) was making my head spin i didn't literally mean that i was incapable of understanding what they were saying, but serious all their post doesn't seem like scum hunting to me just long winded post about how the game of mafia works, which is fine and dandy for the newer players to understand the game but its not getting us closer to finding scum. Finally i wasn't saying i couldn't comprehend the conflict between Fireninja and Punchy what i was saying is the way they are going about it is annoying to read through. it seems to me that Fireninja may be doing it on purpose for some reason.

Now im gonna try to catch up on the 15-20 pages i have missed while at work. and i am off tomorrow so i will be able to be here EoD thank god, cause I'm sure its gonna be our usual ***** show.

I lied there isn?t a lot more to analyse, this was just a defense thing that reiterated her first post. No red (Or green?) flags in this post for me.

But also thought about this:
? 5. How do you handle pressure?
Decently.?

This was a pretty long winded and at the beginning a little emotional defense, and I?m having a hard time believing that?s a decent way to handle a little pressure.

BUT the reason I went over panda?s posts was to look to see if she?s coasting. And as Post 1 #2 suggests, by meta she?s not coasting. As far as content goes, nothing current is being debated or anything. Is she at work or just not posting?? IDK, but I?m not prepared to vote her D1, so I?ll be crossing her off my lynch candidate list. Hopefully you start posting a little more Panda...
Reading mog?s posts now

 

[glow]

God damnit

Fine I'll stay in but I'm still done with mafia after this game. Ill post whatever later tonight, I think Antonio/Mog are suspicious but that is based off of practically skimming

- - - Post Merge - - -



hey we said Mog at the same time we're #confirmedscumteam

no tilt pls just take a break or someth

 

[Kamzitty]

Kammm-Slight townlean. I know that I said earlier that she is "probably town" and she has said some stuff in reflection that looks good for her. She does seem to be genuinely entrapped in Ness's ATE if he is scum, but I don't like that all of her scumreads are relatively inactive(though I do agree that two in particular (Antonio and Dedenne) deserve to be there at this point). I'm not really sure if I read her posts on FN coming from town or mafia though because they are really hesisitant.

For reference to her being hesistant. The tones really clash here, from calling him out on his bull****, to backing off. However, I really don't see her as scum making this if teamed with FN (not saying FN is really sus). I'm really not sure how to read this. Still, I also don't think she'd be posting so much as new scum. TL

I understand my posts on FN were all over the place and I do realize I kinda backpedaled when calling him out. I apologize for being so hesitant, it's D1 and I'm nervous I'll be honest. FN's attitude just really threw me off. Thank you for pointing that out tho, in my future posts I'll try not to be as hesitant when calling someone out.
Also I see what you're saying about how all my scum reads are generally inactives. But for now it's really difficult for me to point out scummy behavior (since I have no clue how scum usually play), esp this early in the game. so I'm not changing my stance on them and if nothing else arises I'll be all for a discussion of lynching one of them. (preferably antonio, he's the most sus to me and most people seem to agree)

 

[glow]

So has Tom but you straight up exclude him if that's your reason. Again, Oath is an easy target and your response here makes me feel more certain about that. Why you don't suspect Tom for the same reason is curious.

tom's input and tone are completely different to oath's. oath's tone is hesitant and careful, he's all "idk guys i might be crazy here don't mind me!!" while tom just genuinely does not care about towntelling. i feel like you're comparing them because they're low activity posters but i actually don't read into that as much as i do tone.

Wasn't talking about frequency, but people who said it and still apply. Panda and Locket.

i disagree, frequency is really important. literally everyone has a life outside this game and it's fine to be like 'hey guys i'm gonna go do X i'll post reads later bye'. that's not scummy, even if they fail to do so

...wat

my point was: the more that town outs awkward ~forced~ reads on the whole playerlist solely because they feel like they have to, the harder it is to see the ACTUALLY forced reads that mafia makes on each other.

i feel like that sentence is still convoluted and idk how to fix it

Ness situation put to the side for a moment, I'd like to see a Ryumia or glow lynch at this point out of my scumpool. I'm placing my vote on glow because unlike Ryumia she has responded to what I've had to say about her/ask of her and I don't like it. Confirms that out of all the content on the board she's targeting convenient targets, although myself being arguable. If Ryumia has a terrible defense that looks more than struggling inexperienced player I may switch to her.

Anyways, actually getting some sleep now. Not much. :/

do u know how bad it looks fmpov that you now sus me because i'm "going after easy targets" when you were clearly going after the emotionally heated ness and only changed your target after i continually pushed you.

look at your argument. who do you want me to push on d1? who do you consider "not easy targets" if you somehow considered yourself as an easy target? lmao. the only person i feel like would be quote hard unquote to lynch is dolby/you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

hey guys, anyone feel free to answer for dad. try to help him make sense please, for the sake of my sanity. who is a "non convenient target" excluding dad himself?

 

[PandaDarling]

~snip~
“ 6. Which player(s) in this game can you read the best?
Probably Toad or Mog.”
Question 4 Panda: When you read this, what are your thoughts on toad and Mog if theyve changed or updated?
~snip~

Toad feels town to me, with his reaction testing and pushing of a few players, he usually does that D1 to get reads but we can't be completely sure of his alignment until he has a complete mental breakdown... and if and when he does best believe there will be rose pedals and poems everywhere. <3

Mog I'm unsure about, she is a lot busier irl now a days, which has changed her play style and i can understand that cause im in the same boat, i use to be super active but now im forced to make fewer post with more content, which is harder imo... every single game Mog scum reads me for some reason so i want to see more from her so i can get a feel for where she's at.

 

[Dolby]

Ok, in Dad/Glow I honestly trust Dad more. His meta as scum is typically to make more small posts, less more on-the-spot analysis, if anything. This does still represent a change in playstyle, but he did wallpost a bit D0 in APM as well.

Antonio seems different from last game tonally. He seems to be less positive and silly.

Dedenne-also different tonally. Honestly, I feel like she's been less helpful than recent games. And honestly that frustration seems kinda fake. If anybody could point me towards a game that Dedenne's been scum in, that would be immensely helpful

Ryumia-Again, I don't trust her. They've made 8 posts, 7 which have practically no pertinence to scumhunting

Mhm... I see. I'm assuming this has to do with FireNinja's vote on Punchy.



The above was his supposed reasoning on why they voted on Punchy for a lynch. Only thing I like about is that it seems like FireNinja isn't easily swayed by other people based on how they responded about their vote on Punchy. That's the only reason I would want to have them around is because of that.


It's a potential possibility is all I have to say.

This is kinda what I said earlier about Kammm, but the middle section honestly just seems to be reaching not to draw an unfavorable conclusion (damn, all you noobs are scummy af rn). It's like "I sus him, but here's a reason to keep him around so I don't look bad for pushing a townie"

Why did Panda join if she's just gonna keep staying inactive and every single game she joins. Regardless, that she at leasts posts thoughts (in comparison to last game) does bode well to here being town I feel still

When the **** has Mog been scum? I'm really reaching for anything here. Her tone feels forced, like she's trying to get as much emotional credit for the "hello" in each of her posts

coming up with a good candidate is gonna be pretty hard today

 

[Dolby]

Ppl viewing, at this point in time who would you vote?

 

[amazonevan19]

Ppl viewing, at this point in time who would you vote?

I’m fine with lynching any of my scumleans, but I’d really like to see Antonio or Ryumia voted off

 

[Ghostkid]

Ppl viewing, at this point in time who would you vote?

I dont know rn...id say tom...but punchy or FN could also be canidates

 

[illunie]

Ppl viewing, at this point in time who would you vote?

dont bully me u >: (

still reading through and processing the whole glow vs dad thing, so that might take a bit, but if i were to vote right this second and not take the likelyhood of other voters into account id probably vote for antonio bc hes my strongest sr at the moment. however im gonna try and process the glow vs dad thing in a bit so its subject to change

- - - Post Merge - - -

the only problem i have with an antonio lynch is that we dont get much info from an antonio lynch, as least compared to killing ness or fireninja.

 

[Kamzitty]

EoD is in less than 3hrs correct? If so we need to make a decision quick lol. I'm leaning towards Antonio for lynch, he's on almost everyone's scum list. If anyone is against this or has a better candidate in mind now would be a good time to voice it because I'll likely vote Antonio otherwise.

 

[mogyay]

ok so blah blah sorry for being away, busy schedule, did mention before the game started but can't blame anyone for criticising me, ANYWAY

the last game i played w fireninja was mystic messenger AND OH BOY, he basically just created so much confusion for town so ye, sure, i know it's def in his town meta to stir crap but i'm worried he's acting so cryptic bc we can chalk it up to 'oh that's just fn for you', voting punchy was confusing as hell, and i know someone said i sounded forced but i still stand by the fact that scum is going to hide behind voting first bc it usually is a move used by town, he still doesn't even bother explaining himself, his post responding to all his accusations done nothing to explain his behaviour. i don't really mind his post on ryu, but it does feel a little weak just focusing solely on one player who aside from being a little vague isn't all that scummy to me. where are your opinions on other players? you tell ryu to formulate their own opinions but then end your post telling people to give you names who you should focus on.. i dunno, i'm getting weird as hell vibes from fireninja, kinda like he's trying to recreate a meta but backs away from this when he's getting sus.

antonio, kinda similar to what people have said but generating useless content, promises thoughts that never came. i don't mind people being inactive bc that would be called being a hypocrite but promising content that doesn't come is slightly worrying.

locket, isn't she usually a little more active than this? content feels a little forced 'let's move on', advising punchy not to derail the game, i agree with both comments but obviously interjecting your own opinion on these situations would be helpful.

^^^^ same can be said for oath, i don't think i've ever played with him before but doesn't he have some stronger content out by now (ALSO GOD I KNOW I'M SUCH A HYPOCRITE BUT to be fair at least i'm always inactive)

null on kate but i am a little disappointed, i thought she might be one of the more active players, started off being jokey which did feel a little forced but can't really blame her since mafia is a weird environment but now that we haven't heard from her again it feels even worse

ok that's my initial thoughts from skimming, now time to actually read the thread with a little bit more depth, don't think i'm gonna promise full reads tbh bc the player list is really big and i'm not used to these kind of numbers but i really wanna look into ness, honestly feel bad even saying that but still find his general reaction to things just really weird. also tom bc strange as hell defence

dolby, hayden and jacob are town to me rn

- - - Post Merge - - -

i'd be fine with antionio lynch unless he actually comes through with his promised thoughts (as long as they don't seem forced) but ye until then i'd prob be fine with voting him

 

[iLoveYou]

I'm going to make my post towards 6:15 pm est. I know it's just 45 minutes before the day ends but I don't have a choice because I'm at work. I will be extra active during the last 45 minutes to help as much as I can.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Quick note now I don't know if it's a good thing or a bad thing that Antonio is coming up so much. I tend to question thing s as bandwagons occur

- - - Post Merge - - -

Coming up as final lynch votes I mean

 

[FireNinja1]

Hi, I'm here. Currently looking at Ryu for lynch.

 

[Heyden]

Antonio’s definitely avoiding the thread at this point. If he’s town I’ll be very disappointed in him.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I wish people would turn off invisible so we don’t have to make possibly false assumptions but whatever.

When’s EoD?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Antonio if see this and you’re town, pla say ANYTHING

 

[Dolby]

Antonio’s definitely avoiding the thread at this point. If he’s town I’ll be very disappointed in him.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I wish people would turn off invisible so we don’t have to make possibly false assumptions but whatever.

When’s EoD?

He hasn’t posted since yesterday morning and is on invisible?

That being said, I do think that there’s been a change in tone from Antonio, but the large amount of people willing to vote him honestly makes me uncomfortable (especially as many of those I haven’t really established as town). I’m also looking at Locket and Ryu right now as well. Oath and Tom I feel will make themselves obvious in due time. Neither have provided much of anything concrete, and both of their behaviors have been borderline egregious honestly

 

[illunie]

When’s EoD?

eod is in 2 and a half hrs i think

 

[Dolby]

Also, EoD in 2 hours

 

[EpicGamer12]

I won't be able to be on for EOD, I'm just gonna place my vote now and explain it.

Honestly I know the argument was said and done, but I'm on Kayla's side for this. Lynching lurkers D1 might be the only way to avoid killing off a good player. The mafia are more than likely mostly AFK. Since Heyden has mentioned it already, I'm going to vote for Antonio. Sorry 2 h8ers who will sus me for this.

 

[dedenne]

ugh I'm still doing my reads but I had to help my brother with his stupid project and I never want to see devon again>.>
I don't know who to vote, I don't feel 100% on voting Antonio but I'm not 100% caught up so I'm just going to vote myself.

toads don't kill me ples I swear