like i said, ill explain all my thoughts in greater detail later on. im at school rn so its kinda hard to add a bunch of quotes at once
Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
like i said, ill explain all my thoughts in greater detail later on. im at school rn so its kinda hard to add a bunch of quotes at once
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
Quit AtEing, we lost one townie and there’s 24 players left. Coulda been a lot worse
oath2order
#Porygon2024
what does AtE mean
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
I don’t think Antonio or Ryumia voted, though I’ve seen Ryumia lurking when thread closed
Also, Giga refuses to say anything still smh
- - - Post Merge - - -
Appeal to emotion
Also, Giga refuses to say anything still smh
- - - Post Merge - - -
Appeal to emotion
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
kate isn't posting or didn't vote either iirc
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
So Antonio, Kate, and Giga...do we seriously think the scumteam are all noobs who would risk getting modkilled to not stand for anything??
1/3 or 2/3 of the above may be dumb town now that I think of it, ugh
1/3 or 2/3 of the above may be dumb town now that I think of it, ugh
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
I did too.
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
I think she was lurking after the thread closed
Antonio and Katezilla are risking getting a warning and then modkilled ( if I understood correctly ). If that's the case, then they can't be mafia. There aren't enough replacements so that would **** up a mafia team.
If Gigalabesh is new, then what are the chances they knew when to come by and vote ? This person had 1 post when they signed up. I feel like someone may be helping them.
If Gigalabesh is new, then what are the chances they knew when to come by and vote ? This person had 1 post when they signed up. I feel like someone may be helping them.
im pretty sure that panda is friends with gig (im just gonna say gig from now on) outside of the game so she probably told them to vote
- - - Post Merge - - -
also that argument about the fact that theyre getting a warning mean sthat they cant be maf kinda sucks, just bc theyre maf doesnt mean that its impossible for them to be modkilled. besides, theres a bunch of people in obs who would probably sub in if they were forced to
Oh, fudge. I completely forgot that Observers can be replacements. But isn't that the case only until Day Two ?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Nevermind their deadline is Day Three. Just found it in the main post.
im not sure, i guess it depends on how much discussion goes on in the obs chat and how important a replacement is. its probably up to tinas discretion. reading way into if nthey get replaced or modkilled is probably more a distraction than a scumtell tho
- - - Post Merge - - -
for all i know antonio or kate could have a mega important town role that wed insta lose without
I feel like if they were mafia, they would have voted.
So you think they're Town too ?
Call me suspicious of whatever, but I didn't even know that Dedenne was the lynch until like 2 minutes at EoD. I spent the last hour of EoD looking at players I thought should/shouldn't be lynched by reading META and post filters and drafting it up in a google doc, the only part that I had coherently put together was the part about Ryumia and that was what I decided to post. People can say I'm using ATE for the 50000th time after I said this but I felt depressed and didn't feel like making any big posts/didn't care at all and was too busy with school to try and create some huge last second reads list, which I attempted to do in the last hour. Dedenne was a player I was townreading not based off of her content but the fact that she had the same bubbly tone behind her posts that I was used to and (no offense Dedenne) hasn't particularly ever had a lot of coherency to her posts ever since she started playing mafia.
Dedenne did promise a lot of content that was never delivered, I had at minimum read town from her tone. Antonio doesn't have that and hasn't had it from the start. Dedenne at minimum had said "I'm working on it soz" and was atleast in the thread providing SOMETHING in her posts while Antonio was purposefully saying either useless things like "good night" or "i'll post it later when there is more content". He has done literally nothing while Dedenne did at least something.
At the very least when I had seen the Dedenne lynch was happening I had said "why are we lynching Dedenne she is literally voting herself". It reminded me of last game where Punchy would just randomly vote himself without reasoning as a "placeholder" and coming from Dedenne I saw that as something only she would do as Town. If it was someone like Dolby putting his vote on himself, then I would be a lot more skeptic but with Dedenne it feels different. Indecisiveness has always been her thing and I've never seen her play different than that.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Side note, my computer crashed when I was typing that post the first time so content was lost. Wanted to add onto the first paragraph that I fully thought that it was Ryumia being lynched at first.
hey scum while you're at it can you kill me too i want to die
I thought this was supposed to be postponed when I checked real quick at 6. >:[
This is bull**** and I'm annoyed that nobody wanted to listen to what I had to say about glow before I went to bed and I implore people to read back into that now that the flip has occurred. Ness can rest easy tbh because glow is my top scumread at this point, unless I catch up and certain people scumtell. Either way she is a lock into my scumpool.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also Ness see what I mean when I say nobody listens to me.
Anyways be back in about two hours.
This is bull**** and I'm annoyed that nobody wanted to listen to what I had to say about glow before I went to bed and I implore people to read back into that now that the flip has occurred. Ness can rest easy tbh because glow is my top scumread at this point, unless I catch up and certain people scumtell. Either way she is a lock into my scumpool.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also Ness see what I mean when I say nobody listens to me.
Anyways be back in about two hours.
Ness jester confirmed
Heyden unjester confirmed
