I adore Raymond's design and he is my favorite, however I got Sherb in my island and have since come to love his quirky personality! So I've voted for my baby Sherb <3
I like Audie the most. I think it has to do with the fact that they named her after that elderly woman who had thousands of hours racked up playing New Leaf. That was really sweet of Nintendo to do.
The rest seem... so plain to me. Or in Judy's case too creepy.
I don't like any of them. Actually I like Raymond because he's becoming really popular. I love having some of the most sought after Villagers in my town, then I like to read posts from other people who are desperate for that Villager, it's just so satisfying knowing I have what others want.
I especially hate Audie because I played more hours New Leaf than that old woman and I didn't get a Villager named after me.
Dom. He's too cute. I think he's my new fave villager in a general sense. Though, I feel the way he looks would suit the smug or lazy personality better, it's nice to have an adorable jock character.