• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia Forest Fire Mafia - Town Win- Endgame

Okay so out of everyone I want to point out Trojan.
ok idgaf

- - - Post Merge - - -

wait no **** you daniel

Then proceeds to vote Daniel
dolby is mafia.

i like ****ing pancakes

What even
no **** panda hes just pushing starry cause why not

danny confirmed mafia

cause they're part of your mafia team.

she hasnt lived too long cause I shot her

you guys have to understand, the only good vote right now is danny.

can we please do something about daniel-

im always right

nope thats really all I have

- - - Post Merge - - -

Do you have anyone on your radar
Seems REALLY determined to vote CallMeDaniel, I disagree with the lynch on Starry aswell but please give some justification.

you also include kit who you say is an inactive, but made some good posts as higher than regular inactives

- - - Post Merge - - -



post merge stealer

bro who ever ****ing doused me is dead m8

This is His dousing claim which everyone fully trusted, being doused is a safe af claim because no one can disprove it. People shouldn't just trust and dismiss that easily.

stop being depressed

- - - Post Merge - - -



school is hard m8

daniel is arsonist.

- - - Post Merge - - -

what do you think tom

who is arsonist than danny?

What did you contribute Danny. Oh wait never mind you helped lynch the vigilante on day 1 even though we could've actually tried to find someone suspicious.

Thanks

- - - Post Merge - - -

White claw is also pretty sus because.... Well, not doing anything, like has this person even posted.

Pretty hypocritical asking CMD what he contributed when all he had done was post one liners about Daniel being scum. Inactiveness to me doesn't mean scum, I mean just because your not posting means your mafia???

All I have to say is that I trust you panda. You passed Trojans legendary, Not Mafia List.

This was his reply when Panda called him out on lurking.

Placing my vote for danny, dont care what any of you say.
I've only played two games with him so I have really no right to judge him but based on those two games he was being helpful and scum hunting out of thread.

Next is Mother of all lamas
As bad as it was to lynch the vigilante, its not like she was going to be active in this game or shoot the correct person anyway to be honest.

That's pretty hypocritical considering this was your first post this game. Also how would you know for sure she wouldn't be around, The Hunter is gone why are you so unaffected by it?

Right now I'm thinking Minties, Meow and Tom are almost 100% town in my opinion.
As for Mafia, I'm leaning towards Kit or Trundle. I'll make a more informative post when I'm more awake.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Yeah I saw him lurking a second ago, he better post soon...

Sorry for my inactivity, don't want to make up excuses but I'll definitely try and post more. Anyhow, sort of been typing this up over a long period of time as I've been busy so some parts might be outdated or incorrect.

Tom- He has been acting very weird and suspicious, but I am inclined to believe that Tom is town based on some of his current posts though.
Meow- She seems very content with her posts and cases and they are informative, she seems determined to hunt down scum.
Minties- Claimed to be doused and saved, and doctor didn't reveal themselves to justify that the claim was false, so I am assuming she is telling the truth.
Oath- Not much to say to be honest, I don't know if he's being serious or not with this game.
Ayaya- Seems like she would rather defend herself than make claims about other people just to be safe.
Trundle- Very aggressive towards other players and defensive of himself. His hostility makes it hard to determine if he is town or mafia. I'm leaning towards town as I don't think mafia would be acting that way to get themselves lynched already.
Trojan- Obviously not taking this game seriously, unless he is usually like this. Claimed to be doused, which I believe as I'm pretty sure it was only Trojan and Minties who claimed they were doused. Still has strong bias opinions on Daniel, but I guess I can see that as Daniel lead a lynch on the vigilante.
White Claw- Has appeared to been lurking the thread a lot and not posting. Has also been voting without saying anything. I feel like he is town, because I don't think any mafia would be dumb enough to do so his actions.
Reyy- Most of their posts are slang or sort of off topic to what everyone else had been posting recently. Also blames time zones as her excuse even though its still possible to post during any time of the day.
Dolby- Hasn't been posting much as he used to in other games, so something isn't right.
Panda- Very active and responds to some posts rather quickly. Not sure what to think of her but I'm thinking town
Luca- Hasn't said much, his case he posted seemed legit, don't want to believe
Kit- I don't know why but to me she seems a bit off. Her posts seem a bit forced. I don't really have much evidence on Kit but I feel like I should keep an eye on her.
Daniel- Lead a mislynch on Starry, probably just a bad stuff up as town. I still have my slight suspicions on him
Jellofish- Always full of excuses and usually inactive in games. Hard to determine their actions.

- - - Post Merge - - -

yikes, shouldve organised it more..

Most are just gut feelings, care to explain more in depth and giving examples of the posts of Tom you find "weird" or "suspicious" or the posts that you think Kit "forced"
if my posts are unstructured correctly it's because I don't have a computer and use my phone for everything. So..... They are my two suspicions so far.
 
Second half

Kit
Voted for Starry to avoid CMD getting majority, which is kind of weird. Pretty questionable with her behavior, will need to read through her posts but so far I?m leaning slightly on town​

Minties
Voted for Starry, and their reason for voting her makes more sense than Daniel?s. Bring out good points on her posts. I?m more inclined to believe she was really protected, as faking being protected would be easy to disapprove, as she said. If she was lying and the doc didn?t want to reveal their role yet, I?m sure they?d be pushing her statement more but so far people have been mostly questioning it. Strongest town read.​

m3ow_
Voted for Trundle. Also bring out good points on her posts. Suspicious of Daniel after he bandwagoned for Starry and stay consistently suspicios by bringing good points. I think her posts about Trundle make sense too, she questioned his vote but moved on, then when Trundle became suspicious of her, she replied pretty well. Leaning more on town.​

Tom
Honestly not sure. He was good at being convincing on the last game so I?m not keen on writing him as town yet. If anyone who has played with him as town can tell us how he behaves as town, that?d be helpful. He?s still suspicious to me with these posts, trying to lead town to a lynch. He also voted for himself which I found really weird, like what do you wish to accomplish with this? Along with Trundle I?ll need to read more about his posts, specifically the one against my reading.

Also, I called him out as Arsonist Leader based on my assumption that Daniel was working alone as scum. Other than that, I have no other evidence honestly. That post was more about Daniel looking like scum, and Tom being suspicious in my eyes.​

oath2order
Voted for CMD. He was also going at CMD at night for the mislynch. I honestly can?t read him so far so I?m waiting for more posts from him​

Panda
Voted for CMD. The amount of her replies, what she says in them, and how quick she is to response to them, makes me think she?s more town who have nothing to worry about what she said. I feel bad she?s being suspected for agreeing with my lacking reading though, but personally I?m leaning on town for her.​

Call Me Daniel
I am still suspicious on you as I have already said often enough, and I already posted my reason for suspecting you. Like panda you?re also quick to reply (and posts a lot wtf) which would might make believe you?re town, but I read you as town on the previous game so I?ll still keep an eye on you just to be safe.​

In conclusion:
Minties and m3ow is my strongest town read so far, will need to look more into Trundle, Tom, and possibly Dolby, maybe later on Kit, CMD is still on my red list, the rest are in the middle/need to hear more from them/leaning to town.
 
Replying from mobile is annoying

* It wasn't just quick, you made it based on 1 post that I softly accused Daniel

How was I defensive.... Lol wat did u even read my reply

I mean, quick replies usual mean town. Scum usually waits for the other team mates on what to say so it doesn't look suspicious. Town doesn't really have a reason to wait so long on wait to say, the only reason I could think is that they don't want people reading it the wrong way, but quicker replies are more townsfolk anything.

I still don't get you're case on meow.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Second half

Kit
Voted for Starry to avoid CMD getting majority, which is kind of weird. Pretty questionable with her behavior, will need to read through her posts but so far I’m leaning slightly on town​

Minties
Voted for Starry, and their reason for voting her makes more sense than Daniel’s. Bring out good points on her posts. I’m more inclined to believe she was really protected, as faking being protected would be easy to disapprove, as she said. If she was lying and the doc didn’t want to reveal their role yet, I’m sure they’d be pushing her statement more but so far people have been mostly questioning it. Strongest town read.​

m3ow_
Voted for Trundle. Also bring out good points on her posts. Suspicious of Daniel after he bandwagoned for Starry and stay consistently suspicios by bringing good points. I think her posts about Trundle make sense too, she questioned his vote but moved on, then when Trundle became suspicious of her, she replied pretty well. Leaning more on town.​

Tom
Honestly not sure. He was good at being convincing on the last game so I’m not keen on writing him as town yet. If anyone who has played with him as town can tell us how he behaves as town, that’d be helpful. He’s still suspicious to me with these posts, trying to lead town to a lynch. He also voted for himself which I found really weird, like what do you wish to accomplish with this? Along with Trundle I’ll need to read more about his posts, specifically the one against my reading.

Also, I called him out as Arsonist Leader based on my assumption that Daniel was working alone as scum. Other than that, I have no other evidence honestly. That post was more about Daniel looking like scum, and Tom being suspicious in my eyes.​

oath2order
Voted for CMD. He was also going at CMD at night for the mislynch. I honestly can’t read him so far so I’m waiting for more posts from him​

Panda
Voted for CMD. The amount of her replies, what she says in them, and how quick she is to response to them, makes me think she’s more town who have nothing to worry about what she said. I feel bad she’s being suspected for agreeing with my lacking reading though, but personally I’m leaning on town for her.​

Call Me Daniel
I am still suspicious on you as I have already said often enough, and I already posted my reason for suspecting you. Like panda you’re also quick to reply (and posts a lot wtf) which would might make believe you’re town, but I read you as town on the previous game so I’ll still keep an eye on you just to be safe.​

In conclusion:
Minties and m3ow is my strongest town read so far, will need to look more into Trundle, Tom, and possibly Dolby, maybe later on Kit, CMD is still on my red list, the rest are in the middle/need to hear more from them/leaning to town.

I like how you literally call me, Call me Daniel
 
Okay so out of everyone I want to point out Trojan.
Then proceeds to vote Daniel




What even















Seems REALLY determined to vote CallMeDaniel, I disagree with the lynch on Starry aswell but please give some justification.





This is His dousing claim which everyone fully trusted, being doused is a safe af claim because no one can disprove it. People shouldn't just trust and dismiss that easily.









Pretty hypocritical asking CMD what he contributed when all he had done was post one liners about Daniel being scum. Inactiveness to me doesn't mean scum, I mean just because your not posting means your mafia???



This was his reply when Panda called him out on lurking.
I've only played two games with him so I have really no right to judge him but based on those two games he was being helpful and scum hunting out of thread.

Next is Mother of all lamas
That's pretty hypocritical considering this was your first post this game. Also how would you know for sure she wouldn't be around, The Hunter is gone why are you so unaffected by it?





Most are just gut feelings, care to explain more in depth and giving examples of the posts of Tom you find "weird" or "suspicious" or the posts that you think Kit "forced"
if my posts are unstructured correctly it's because I don't have a computer and use my phone for everything. So..... They are my two suspicions so far.

Dont think you know everything about me and what I do from 2 games. I dont have much time to work on this game and the fact that you are still calling me scum is just...... ********.
 
Okay so out of everyone I want to point out Trojan.
Then proceeds to vote Daniel




What even















Seems REALLY determined to vote CallMeDaniel, I disagree with the lynch on Starry aswell but please give some justification.





This is His dousing claim which everyone fully trusted, being doused is a safe af claim because no one can disprove it. People shouldn't just trust and dismiss that easily.









Pretty hypocritical asking CMD what he contributed when all he had done was post one liners about Daniel being scum. Inactiveness to me doesn't mean scum, I mean just because your not posting means your mafia???



This was his reply when Panda called him out on lurking.
I've only played two games with him so I have really no right to judge him but based on those two games he was being helpful and scum hunting out of thread.

Next is Mother of all lamas
That's pretty hypocritical considering this was your first post this game. Also how would you know for sure she wouldn't be around, The Hunter is gone why are you so unaffected by it?





Most are just gut feelings, care to explain more in depth and giving examples of the posts of Tom you find "weird" or "suspicious" or the posts that you think Kit "forced"
if my posts are unstructured correctly it's because I don't have a computer and use my phone for everything. So..... They are my two suspicions so far.

So you're pointing me out because I'm not sad about Starry dying and the fact that I have thoughts? right.
 
Okay Trundle I find this reply/post weird

It's not dumb stuff. You instantly pointed out Daniel's town behaviour as scum behaviour and I do not believe from his posts that he is mafia. I think the fact that you are completely off putting my post without any reason behind it shows you have something to hide. I can understand the Starry lynch for sure because it creates confusion in every game. I'm not sure why hosts let him into games because they can't even play, it's pretty ridiculous to me.

Regardless, your reaction was very scummy in my opinion, m30w_. If you are lynched today you will surely be struck down eventually for your refusal to reason based on behaviour.

Who are you replying to exactly, m3ow or minties or both? Because minties is the one who called your post "dumb stuff". Did you mix up their posts? Also can you show us where she is "off putting" and "has something to hide"?
 
Breathes heavily
Can someone fill me in on what's happened because I've been busy the past few days with homework and haven't had time to look into the +30 pages of posts that have been made after my departure
 
Breathes heavily
Can someone fill me in on what's happened because I've been busy the past few days with homework and haven't had time to look into the +30 pages of posts that have been made after my departure

Minties and Trojan(mostly minties) have Been proven town for being claiming to be doused by scum and minties being protected by Doctor. No one counter claimed.

You may want to read the rest of the pages because we're all kinda making our cases on who to lynch at his pint.
 
wouldn't confirm Trojan as town just yet, there's still a possibility that mafia didn't douse a 2nd person and told him to claim that he's doused so that we'd trust him.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Okay Trundle I find this reply/post weird



Who are you replying to exactly, m3ow or minties or both? Because minties is the one who called your post "dumb stuff". Did you mix up their posts? Also can you show us where she is "off putting" and "has something to hide"?

he is talking to me. he definitely got our posts confused though, I never referred to his claims as "dumb stuff" I think it's silly to say things like that and interesting how he constantly attacks me, calling my accusations "********" etc. anyway he has also said that I was "defensive" in my reply to his original post where he said he voted me yet I literally didn't even care that he voted me I just simply said "not sure why you're voting me though". I quoted it in the last page I'm pretty sure

- - - Post Merge - - -

I mean, quick replies usual mean town. Scum usually waits for the other team mates on what to say so it doesn't look suspicious. Town doesn't really have a reason to wait so long on wait to say, the only reason I could think is that they don't want people reading it the wrong way, but quicker replies are more townsfolk anything.

I still don't get you're case on meow.

- - - Post Merge - - -



I like how you literally call me, Call me Daniel

sure I get how quick replies can indicate that but I disagree that quick votes mean that. Quick votes based on one reply that isn't even very serious, is suspicious to me. As town you want to lynch the most threatening or harmful person to town. He did not do that, even though he'll never admit that ofc

He has no case on me, that's what I pointed out. He realized he can't push me anymore so I am now a new role called "******** town"
 
sorry men for not posting at long time but here r my insights:

- Daniel - Daniel is scum becaus he keeps a using people but not evident in the way he traces through the wind.

- M3ow_ - Town in my opinion because she is very nice

- Kaydee Krunk - very cute

- Lucanosa - Scum tracing back to old posts he did not mention he is town I need to go further on this but for now I will vote him as scum

- Minties - nice username probably a fairy.

- Mother of all llamas - Looking back at his older posts, he accused people of scum and Lucanosa so I love him he is probably town

- Trundle - I have not read back on his posts yet but I think he is mafia, will elaborate more later
 
Last edited:
wouldn't confirm Trojan as town just yet, there's still a possibility that mafia didn't douse a 2nd person and told him to claim that he's doused so that we'd trust him.

- - - Post Merge - - -



he is talking to me. he definitely got our posts confused though, I never referred to his claims as "dumb stuff" I think it's silly to say things like that and interesting how he constantly attacks me, calling my accusations "********" etc. anyway he has also said that I was "defensive" in my reply to his original post where he said he voted me yet I literally didn't even care that he voted me I just simply said "not sure why you're voting me though". I quoted it in the last page I'm pretty sure

- - - Post Merge - - -



sure I get how quick replies can indicate that but I disagree that quick votes mean that. Quick votes based on one reply that isn't even very serious, is suspicious to me. As town you want to lynch the most threatening or harmful person to town. He did not do that, even though he'll never admit that ofc

He has no case on me, that's what I pointed out. He realized he can't push me anymore so I am now a new role called "******** town"
Ignore the stupid troll above. I already reported.

I thought trundle was just testing you at first but now that he's just dragging on the case when there's much more solid things to go on. It's pretty obvious trundles scum he's not doing anything but attacking the people most susipicious of him and you who is the strongest town read in my eyes.
 
Are you kidding me right now, i was almost done writing my reads and the page refreshes and loses everything

UUGGGGGHHH
 
My conclusion is... Few people in this game know how to do reads.
Okay look, if you're going to make a reads post back it up with actual quotes from the said person you're reading.
Not just "mmmm.. Seems odd lol"
Otherwise people aren't going to take it seriously. You have to justify WHY you feel that way.
Just something that was ticking me off and seems to be a trend in this game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, please recall that Kit accidently confirmed Trojan as vig
I can confirm my accidental vig confirmation.
Dumbest moment ever.
Ever.
I'm sorry Trojan :(

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also can oath maybe contribute sometime yeah that would be great
 
I was going to write a read for everyone, but my laptop is just ******** and crashed again so I'm just going to write my scum reads and why because this is just frustrating
 
Can we see your reads then, Kit? And these reads might not be helpful now because personally I haven't seen much to point out (like this behavior is weird but is it scum behaviour? is what going through my mind when I read them) BUT these reads would be helpful somewhat figuring out alignments when someone flips later, at least.
 
Can we see your reads then, Kit? And these reads might not be helpful now because personally I haven't seen much to point out (like this behavior is weird but is it scum behaviour? is what going through my mind when I read them) BUT these reads would be helpful somewhat figuring out alignments when someone flips later, at least.
I'm crap at reads but if I find some time to get on my computer today then sure.
 
Here
Dolby- Who i want to lynch tonight.
Reasons stated here
I'm going to do my reads whenever I get on my computer, but I think we should lynch Dolby tonight.
Reasons being:
1. Posted very little, only sht posting until N1 or was just silent
2. Was there before/after the starry lynch but said nothing on the subject until people questioned his unusual silence.
3. His only worth reading post


All of this stuff was already said, none of this adds anything and is more just to wasting the suspions on him for silence.
This is his only serious post and it was made at a weird time and does nothing.
4. Like I said before, he was most likely blue snipping for kill candidates and compared Trojans Blue meta to his town meta, like he did in reindeer Mafia, and thought Trojan may be a blue role and went for him.
5. Went back to silent and hasn't said a word since.

I have other people suspicious on my mind, which I will get to with my reads, but Dolby is the only one who's behavior isn't town or excuable at all. I think he's the best candidate for today.

Also I think the doctor is a veteran for protecting minties correctly out of meta since there was no reason to protect her otherwise, and the Mafia who tried to douse her is probably a veteran too since she didn't put suspions on anyone at that time expect trundle. Just keep this in mind, but I'm voting Dolby as of now.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Satisfy the suspions*

Also minties could out also been targeted for fear of her catching on to the veteran scum.
He defending himself by saying this.
Why the hell would anybody douse you?


Also, please recall that Kit accidently confirmed Trojan as vig


Because I thought I had more time to post and my parents had movie tickets that I thought we had to leave an hour later for, oops on my part


So had literally 50% of the playerlist



You were on my scum team last game and you should know this. I was against killing Trojan night one, even though he was a confirmed vig by Kit, and more inclined to kill Blu Rose because I knew that Trojan would do little in the thread to harm us and was shooting town. As mafia, I am more inclined to kill players who are actual threats.



I have a life outside of mafia and haven't been able to come online until now(I went downhill skiing today, it was awesome).

After reading through past games, I feel more inclined to think that Trundle is town as compared to scum, I will post why in a bit.

Okay you went to the movies right before the starry lynch. But the game has been going on for 2 days and the starry case for like 1 day, unless it was a really long movie, you should have said something. Epssecially from you, it's not like you to just be quiet a whole day cycle and not comment on anything.

Yes a few people haven't contributed at that point, but we're talking about dolby. He's a good town player, so good that he has been killed early out of fear from scum, him not contributing or commenting in the game is extremely off don't you think? Not expected from town Dolby.

I'm comparing Trundle's behavior between this game, as mafia, and as town in recent games
Game: Kissing to be Clever Role: Townie

In response to Forek voting for pillow bunny day one in that game

This game

In response to being voted for by m3ow

KTBC Role: Townie

This game

Game: Smash mafia Role: Mafia Roleblocker



Trundle seems to insult and write off people's posts as garbage as mafia. As town, he'll tend to explain why he thinks that people are town/mafia and why people shouldn't think that way

On why suspects are mafia
KTBC as townie

This game



Smash as mafia

And no points earlier on why Tom was scum

To sum it up, Trundle acts differently between being mafia and town. The thing that made people suspicious of him was his response to m3ow, which he handled similarly to how he normally does stuff as town.

And for Tom

Oath2order-Town
Kit-Null
reyy-Null
Panda-Leaning red (Response to Ayaya's "case")
Jello-PR
Trojan- How should I know, pancake king
Call me Daniel- (Slightly) Leaning Red
Tom-Leaning Town
Ayaya- weak town vibes
Lucanosa-Leaning Red (50/50 Minties suspicion. WTF)
Minties-Town
m3ow-Prob Town
Trundle- Leaning Town
White Claw-???
Llama-Leaning Town

- - - Post Merge - - -

I don't mind being lynched if it clears up my alignment, but why the **** would anybody douse Trojan? Even if they thought they were blue? Hunter's dead, there's no cop, and he doesn't scumhunt at all.

Defends trundle, but doesn't say why he thinks people are scum. Like if you have so much time to go read trunde's past games and take quotes to compare them, but why don't you say anything on why you think people are scum which is really more important for town. It just looks like you're trying to look like you're contributing when you really aren't to town.

Soft claiming townie/unlynchable and is willing to waste a precious lynch to prove that he is innocent. With people no longer being told they were doused, lynches are the only way we can get scum. If we purposly mislynch to just prove a townie innocent, it's giving more time for arsons to douse and ignite without being lynched.

And the only logical reason trojan was doused was because he was blue snipped. yes a vig is dead, but who's there to say there's only one vig? Or with dousing and igniting as many people as possible, the doctor is a very threatening role in reducing the number of people killed and would take more time to douse and ignite again. You managed to slip away from suspicions until now so the only threats you had at the time were blue roles.

I think Dolby's lack of being useful and silence is very strange for him, and that's who i think we should lynch.

Another very good lynch candidate is
Trundle- Like stated by many, he sucks at being scum and it's pretty obvious he is here.

He started out by voting for M3ow for questioning my alignment. I thought this was just a test on a newbie to see if they'd crack but since it's still dragging on now, i don't get it.

1. M3ow is new, no that doesn't make them automatically town, but that means she(I'm assuming) doesn't know how i play as town so being suspicious of me seems like a newbie just trying to scum read me.
2.
I'm not sure quite what you expected from me in Day 1. You guys are playing as if the amount I post plus or minus 5 determines whether or not I'm scum. What did you want me to do? I didn't find scum and guess who didn't either? YOU. What the heck did you do other than accuse me? What did I do other than accuse m30w_ as an attempt to get the game to steer from lynching an inactive.



I find it funny that you hop on me being "fishy" even though you haven't even commented on anything I've said yet. What makes me fishy? You saw me as scum last game I played and you know how I play.



RUSSIAN RED MAFIA YOU SCUMMY PIECE OF TRASH (AND COUNTLESS OTHERS)
And yes, I did forget that because I HAVE SO MUCH SCHOOL WORK TO DO but I'm actually trying my best. I haven't avoided pointing suspicions at anyone. That's how you know I'm not scum. My scum play is terrible and it just avoids pointing fingers for as long as possible because I know when I die those people are cleared as town. I'm aggressive and accusatory as town, and you know that. You're just pushing me like this because a) you lied about being doused (btw if there is a doctor that can confirm they DIDN'T protect Minties, that's a confirmed scum kill) or b) you're just salty Monroe. I'm not being quiet.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Lists like that are exactly what mafia players do to try to prove they are helping town. You suck at mafia and I'm going to get you lynched.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Yes, sorry I don't post crap once every 5 minutes but actually take the effort to put together a drawn out post


His defense to his suspicions are very salty. He says he was trying to steer the lynch to M3ow instead of an inactive, but his weak case on a newbie isn't help at all. It more to me looks like "I wont go for starry because i know shes town so i'll go on someone else so i can say i tried to stop it".

He also constantly says he's busy with university and that's why he's silent. So? You're not the only busy person in the world, you don't need to constantly make excuses. You're busy, that's all you need to say. Would like to point out though that when you were scum in smash mafia you were quiet until questions, so their suspicions are valid.

He's really only just calling the people who question him(Tom, Minties, and M3ow) ********, he's not helping town at all. He's just pinning suspicions on those who question him, does a really had job going against the suspicions, and isn't acknowledging anyone else for scum. Weak scum.

I think Dolby,Trundle, a newbie/inactive, and someone else who i can't pin down to who that is. As a team. Both would be the best players to lynch right now, so I'm keeping my vote on Dolby.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Anyone else is either townie or middle.
 
Here
Dolby- Who i want to lynch tonight.
Reasons stated here

He defending himself by saying this.


Okay you went to the movies right before the starry lynch. But the game has been going on for 2 days and the starry case for like 1 day, unless it was a really long movie, you should have said something. Epssecially from you, it's not like you to just be quiet a whole day cycle and not comment on anything.

Yes a few people haven't contributed at that point, but we're talking about dolby. He's a good town player, so good that he has been killed early out of fear from scum, him not contributing or commenting in the game is extremely off don't you think? Not expected from town Dolby.



Defends trundle, but doesn't say why he thinks people are scum. Like if you have so much time to go read trunde's past games and take quotes to compare them, but why don't you say anything on why you think people are scum which is really more important for town. It just looks like you're trying to look like you're contributing when you really aren't to town.

Soft claiming townie/unlynchable and is willing to waste a precious lynch to prove that he is innocent. With people no longer being told they were doused, lynches are the only way we can get scum. If we purposly mislynch to just prove a townie innocent, it's giving more time for arsons to douse and ignite without being lynched.

And the only logical reason trojan was doused was because he was blue snipped. yes a vig is dead, but who's there to say there's only one vig? Or with dousing and igniting as many people as possible, the doctor is a very threatening role in reducing the number of people killed and would take more time to douse and ignite again. You managed to slip away from suspicions until now so the only threats you had at the time were blue roles.

I think Dolby's lack of being useful and silence is very strange for him, and that's who i think we should lynch.

Another very good lynch candidate is
Trundle- Like stated by many, he sucks at being scum and it's pretty obvious he is here.

He started out by voting for M3ow for questioning my alignment. I thought this was just a test on a newbie to see if they'd crack but since it's still dragging on now, i don't get it.

1. M3ow is new, no that doesn't make them automatically town, but that means she(I'm assuming) doesn't know how i play as town so being suspicious of me seems like a newbie just trying to scum read me.
2.


His defense to his suspicions are very salty. He says he was trying to steer the lynch to M3ow instead of an inactive, but his weak case on a newbie isn't help at all. It more to me looks like "I wont go for starry because i know shes town so i'll go on someone else so i can say i tried to stop it".

He also constantly says he's busy with university and that's why he's silent. So? You're not the only busy person in the world, you don't need to constantly make excuses. You're busy, that's all you need to say. Would like to point out though that when you were scum in smash mafia you were quiet until questions, so their suspicions are valid.

He's really only just calling the people who question him(Tom, Minties, and M3ow) ********, he's not helping town at all. He's just pinning suspicions on those who question him, does a really had job going against the suspicions, and isn't acknowledging anyone else for scum. Weak scum.

I think Dolby,Trundle, a newbie/inactive, and someone else who i can't pin down to who that is. As a team. Both would be the best players to lynch right now, so I'm keeping my vote on Dolby.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Anyone else is either townie or middle.
I'm voting for trundle muncle because of Tom & MINTIES cases ^_^
Good post Danny boi
 
My conclusion is... Few people in this game know how to do reads.
Okay look, if you're going to make a reads post back it up with actual quotes from the said person you're reading.
Not just "mmmm.. Seems odd lol"
Otherwise people aren't going to take it seriously. You have to justify WHY you feel that way.
Just something that was ticking me off and seems to be a trend in this game.

- - - Post Merge - - -


I can confirm my accidental vig confirmation.
Dumbest moment ever.
Ever.
I'm sorry Trojan :(

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also can oath maybe contribute sometime yeah that would be great

Sure.

It's Dolby or trundle.

I have a full time job now I can't post as much as I used to.
 
Back
Top