Mafia Fuchsia Mafia | Signups | Open

[PunchyTheCat]

fair about dad, scum would be revealing themselves if they majjed someone and thats not a good idea from any pov.

 

[Dolby]

fair about dad, scum would be revealing themselves if they majjed someone and thats not a good idea from any pov.

Actually if they lynch one town that’s not flipper it’s GG

 

[PunchyTheCat]

what the f
that's hella scumsided

 

[Dolby]

what the f
that's hella scumsided

So are you down with town unity or not?

Because frankly, we need everyone unified

- - - Post Merge - - -

That actually reads pretty well for tone. If Punchy is scum I don't think that he's considered the balance of the setup

 

[Dolby]

Anyways, I actually really don't like Toads two filler posts right now. Hiding behind filler is within his scum meta as I've said earlier, but he has had a distinct level of non-contribution combined with presence and a very evident lack of caring that frankly he's the only person that I could consider to be a real scumspect at this point.

Toads darned good contributions thus far this game

Dang thisntarted real quick. But hey yall

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yeah we need some sort of list of whose actually In this

Typo corrected in here btw

Squad tbh

In comparison, last game as town, admitidly a noob game, Toads went forward and was probably the second most active participant and tried to keep the game in line when, similar to this game, it was obviously suffering from a lack of activity, including putting forward and RQS, and doing actual analysis

I'm glad the three of you actually are posting. Keep it up, set alarms to remember to post, make a note on your computer.... I don't care just actively participate in this

Notable given his lack of concern thus far for activity in this game

Spoiler

That RQS is literal trash that gives us nothing helpful to go off of except anxiety that there are a bunch of 12 year olds, I suggest this one instead

- username/nicknames you like to go by

- experience with mafia

- strategy for the game/ or perceived strategy of what you think should be done/ what you think a game of mafia works like

- who you think is scum

- - - Post Merge - - -

- toadsworthy, but you can call me Toad/toads

- pretty experienced I've played in a dozen + games here

- analyze people's posts and votes and intentions with tone to see who is scum

- calamity bot is being very over top trying to look townie. That may be fresh enthusiasm, but could be trying to appear townie. I will look at their other game at some point

Spoiler contains RQS but it's notable that Toads 1. started an RQS and 2. Is already starting analysis on players

Sorry but bad answers like that will not be accepted, if you are not a newbie and played in a few games then you should be able to describe your approach and processes to these games to some degree for question 3.

And question 4 is meant to ask that question early. What do you think of calamity so far

Going after Antonio for not analyzing, still on D1. He's already working to solve, wheras this game we have nothing

A bad answer is one that doesn't answer the question... so anyone can judge that not me.

And I don't care if its too early to have a strategy. If everyone played like that then mafia games would be sitting around doing nothing.

I do this all the time, tell people how to play this game because honestly everyone who plays right now is utter poop. I said I was gonna do this in the original post too... so don't know why this is a surprise. Someone has to say something or otherwise you noobs will just fade into oblivion, like every other game

So ****ing ironic considering what he's done so far

Contrast that to his scum behavior in the Russian Roulette, where Toads tried to coast on a spite shot while keeping his options open

##shoot dolby

I thought screw you from last game

- - - Post Merge - - -

And I wanted as big of a rage post as you gave me for my first post last time

- - - Post Merge - - -

Mission accomplished

Masquarading as contributing

by all means shoot back... there was 1/6 chance and I figured Antonio wouldn't let it end that quick

because I joined this game out of pity for you all not starting and if I die then meh

Saying that Toads behavior that game was no solving would be disingenious. Though notably there was little in lieu of town reads besides an early attempted pocket on Dad when he felt the winds shift towards a me/Dad fight. However, Toads reads were initially weak and left as much wiggle room as possible to change, literally saying in his first reads post "However all of these could change, probably will.". That's besides the point however, the point is that early game scum Toads tries to pretend to be contributing, probably because he's uncomfortable creating organic content that he doesn't know how it will be perceived. This stands in contrast to town Toads, who tries to create reads as early as possible, so I'm going to say now that Intent to vote Toads is go in the bid for town unity

Admitidly looking back at my case on him in Resistance I might pretty much the same argument as I do here, but frankly I consider it far more telling that Toads is actively avoiding contribution right now and not encouraging others to contribute

- - - Post Merge - - -

Before Antonio quotes this and says I have to PM it in, I'm only gonna PM a vote in once a good consensus among us is reached

 

[toadsworthy]

I've made two quotes and the others haven't spoken **** off dolby

 

[Dolby]

And let’s see if Toads reacts this time

 

[toadsworthy]

I am traveling this weekend and still have posted more than mostveveryone. So this game is a rip without me or with lynching me

 

[Dolby]

I've made two quotes and the others haven't spoken **** off dolby

This is scum, follows the exact same pattern and mentality that I mentioned earlier. Fairly emotional, but not in a way that feels townlike. My intent is pretty solidified.

 

[Dolby]

I am traveling this weekend and still have posted more than mostveveryone. So this game is a rip without me or with lynching me

That’s pretty oof tbh

- - - Post Merge - - -

I come back for ten seconds and master plan dumbass wants to jump at his first thought... you're an idiot

Alright, even if you’re town I want you dead, this is the exact same thing that you did in Russian Roulette and I’m not letting you get away with emotional spite as an early game contribution this yime

 

[toadsworthy]

This is scum, follows the exact same pattern and mentality that I mentioned earlier. Fairly emotional, but not in a way that feels townlike. My intent is pretty solidified.

well this is gonna turn out just like the last time because I think it's a pretty dumb move to scum vote lock me when I'm like the third person talking. You aren't even going to contemplate other people... I mean I essentially have to believe your scum not out of you suck your scum, but because that's such a dumb play and it looks scummy on you.

It's a dead game, no convo, Dolby says let's unify, then just picks the first and easy target to try to bandwagon votes onto. Like that looks scummy

- - - Post Merge - - -

And also look at the other games I've played in, I'm just as satirical and couldn't give a care less as right now. And it's because of dumb **** like this.

- - - Post Merge - - -

You're scum tunneling me off of literal nothing, you even resorted to scum reading me because I looked at the thread and didn't reply.... like that's some amateur stuff right there you need to chill homie, this game is gonna be a wash because no one is doing anything

 

[Dolby]

well this is gonna turn out just like the last time because I think it's a pretty dumb move to scum vote lock me when I'm like the third person talking. You aren't even going to contemplate other people... I mean I essentially have to believe your scum not out of you suck your scum, but because that's such a dumb play and it looks scummy on you.

It's a dead game, no convo, Dolby says let's unify, then just picks the first and easy target to try to bandwagon votes onto. Like that looks scummy

First of all, I did not have you scumlocked. Im suspicious of you because you’ve been following your scum meta and are continuing to do so. For probably the first time I’ve been on this site I’ve actually felt like I’ve had to report a post and I have. Secondly, saying that I haven’t been looking into or evaluating other people (particularly Dad) is straight up wrong. I’ve spent this game as THE ONLY one actually trying to make reads, until Punchy started to analyze me a few posts ago. Thirdly, that is exactly OMGUS, you’re saying that I’m playing so poorly that I can’t be town

Prove to me that NOT unifying could result in a scum lynch with three town deciding to independly vote the same scum and Ill be damned if mafia can’t find a way to override that. To say you’re an easy target is also bad because I could go after the zero poster to, who you’re so eager to redirect to

Don’t blame me for not having the motivation to play. You were satirical and weren’t insulting, and frnajly I think your most recent post before this crossed a line that you haven’t crossed before

- - - Post Merge - - -

If nobody is doing anything than do something about it, make some reads, analyze people

 

[toadsworthy]

Dolby you just said you were solidly intent on voting me.... if that doesn't say scumlock to vote then choose better wording. If you are actually open minded then show it better, because I posted two quick posts to show I had a pulse and you built a mountain out of it. So I now about to go to sleep look and see you pulling this crap and what am I supposed to do? History shows when you make up your mind and talk like this you see it through and there isn't anything I can do. I'm defeated before I even have a chance to defend myself and that's what sets me off like this. You did this same thing in a more recent game, you jumped on me and I exploded. Wasn't that the game before I as scum voted you off right away? I forget which game, and honestly I don't care enough to look it up, but I know ow as town recently and your did me into the ground for absolute nonsense like this

That's what pisses me off, jump conclusions, no one willing to change and listen in these games, and just piss poor logic. You wanna stroke your ego every time too about the only one playing and being so great, well that's not helping anything. So don't come at me for being rude when you can't even comprehend how fed up I am with this crap.... but for some reason I still join because I feel bad seeing you all beg for more players

- - - Post Merge - - -

Like this is exactly like resistance mafia where I made one post due to being inactive, and you jumped down my throat. You then rode me for the entire game not believing a word I said.

You are too stubborn, you jump to conclusions, and the way you forcefully present them drove away ness that game and is pissing me off more now. Especially because I guarantee you at ejust gonna see this as an attack and keep fighting rather than self evaluate that I might actually have a point.

If you are town if you are scum, this isn't productive for mafia in general

- - - Post Merge - - -

Like I know I'm an ******* recently, but like can you all at least see why by this point? I don't care if you disagree with my presentation of it, I'm willing to accept that, but you need to actually see I have a point. Because not seeing that I have a point and ignoring, is like the whole problem

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Dolby you pulled all of that from two posts

While yes, the activity (or lack thereof) is suprising, I don't think toads should be lynched for it.

I'm not voting anyone until Toads gives his reaction. @Bianca, Vanessa, Dedenne, What do you think of Dolby and myself.

I think Dolby is scummy for going after Toads for very very little evidence, suddenly dropping Dad after I posted his defense of him and him not saying anything about it.

- - - Post Merge - - -

oh I didn't read that

 

[toadsworthy]

Dolby you pulled all of that from two posts

While yes, the activity (or lack thereof) is suprising, I don't think toads should be lynched for it.

I'm not voting anyone until Toads gives his reaction. @Bianca, Vanessa, Dedenne, What do you think of Dolby and myself.

I think Dolby is scummy for going after Toads for very very little evidence, suddenly dropping Dad after I posted his defense of him and him not saying anything about it.

- - - Post Merge - - -

oh I didn't read that

I would be more than happy to read up on those people for you... I must've missed there posts because I came back to this storm of diarrhea

 

[PunchyTheCat]

this honestly seems like AtE from Toads

Dolby/Toads can't be teamed, Dolby wouldn't do that as scum

Toads you are not the easiest person to bandwagon on to, literally at least three people come before you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

They didn't post, I asked them to post

 

[Dolby]

Dolby you just said you were solidly intent on voting me.... if that doesn't say scumlock to vote then choose better wording. If you are actually open minded then show it better, because I posted two quick posts to show I had a pulse and you built a mountain out of it. So I now about to go to sleep look and see you pulling this crap and what am I supposed to do? History shows when you make up your mind and talk like this you see it through and there isn't anything I can do. I'm defeated before I even have a chance to defend myself and that's what sets me off like this. You did this same thing in a more recent game, you jumped on me and I exploded. Wasn't that the game before I as scum voted you off right away? I forget which game, and honestly I don't care enough to look it up, but I know ow as town recently and your did me into the ground for absolute nonsense like this

You personally attacked me, insulted my thinking, and called me ****. It was overly emotional, and frankly, I'd rather not play with you in the future regardless of your alignment this game. Saying that I had solid intent to vote on you was just stating that you had actually done something that truly differentiated you from every other inactive in the game, rather than your inactivity being the least excusable/expected from all the inactives. Anyway, yeah, it was Resistance. I jumped on you because frankly I had more faith in Ness that he wouldn't rage quit as scum. But don't criticize my townplay unless you're gonna do some actual analysis, because even if I get the whole scumteam wrong, if everybody keeps playing the way that they're playing now, I'll have played objectively better than all of them because at least I made reads, while they didn't. My original sus was Dad anyway, and that's pretty clear looking back in the thread

Besides, I jumped on you that game first because you tried to play both sides it seemed at the time, then you OMGUSED me based on my suspicion

That's what pisses me off, jump conclusions, no one willing to change and listen in these games, and just piss poor logic. You wanna stroke your ego every time too about the only one playing and being so great, well that's not helping anything. So don't come at me for being rude when you can't even comprehend how fed up I am with this crap.... but for some reason I still join because I feel bad seeing you all beg for more players

Then quit, you've already proven that you're incapable of playing in a civil and constructive manner. Or actually make reads so that I'm not left alone here.

Like I know I'm an ******* recently, but like can you all at least see why by this point? I don't care if you disagree with my presentation of it, I'm willing to accept that, but you need to actually see I have a point. Because not seeing that I have a point and ignoring, is like the whole problem

Analyze other players, analyze me outside the context of my sus on you, then we can talk

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dolby you pulled all of that from two posts

While yes, the activity (or lack thereof) is suprising, I don't think toads should be lynched for it.

I'm not voting anyone until Toads gives his reaction. @Bianca, Vanessa, Dedenne, What do you think of Dolby and myself.

I think Dolby is scummy for going after Toads for very very little evidence, suddenly dropping Dad after I posted his defense of him and him not saying anything about it.

- - - Post Merge - - -

oh I didn't read that

Toads has been somebody on my mind for a bit, starting here

Also, upon reflection, I don't like Toads filler. Hiding behind non-analysis I would consider to be part of his scum meta

Punchy also was viewing the thread multiple times without saying anything

Why am I the only one

Before Dad complains about me complaining this time there is actually literally no posts of any solving value besides my own

- - - Post Merge - - -

Note that Toads is reading the thread rn and apparently does not care about what I've said about him

- - - Post Merge - - -

At that point it stemmed from my theory that scum were intentionally vegging and I could only pinpoint Dad being online at one point thus far

 

[toadsworthy]

Omg I just wrote a lot and it got deleted.... ugh lemme retype real quick

 

[Dolby]

I think Dolby is scummy for going after Toads for very very little evidence, suddenly dropping Dad after I posted his defense of him and him not saying anything about it.

If I was scum I could easily veg at let town not unify and have me and my teammate vote some rando. I'm trying to solve the game here from almost nothing. And again, I was shifting from Dad before you posted in defense of him

 

[toadsworthy]

1. Dolby brought up unity really early. I don't think he would have this as his first thought as scum because he knows a disorganized town is easier to win with than a unified town. Also he then publicly figures out its LYLO when if he was scum could've pmed Antonio and kept that to himself, then pulled off a win really easy. He is an idiot, stubborn, and ignorant, but I'm able to look past his bad play and "meta-analysis" that conveniently fits what he wants to think and do. You are also so hypocritical and blind right now, but so brazen I can't even right now, that's all I will say to your last post.

2. One of dad and Vanessa has to be scum. Dad's post are actual filler and no analysis, and Vanessa's could be classified as appearing to be helpful when she is not when you see the questions she asked didn't really help anything

3. Punchy seems to be the voice of reason, and he could've easily went with Dolby just now rather than defend me. It would be the easier route as scum, but punchy has proven not to follow these types of logic trains in the past so....

4.bianca is a wild card and I want her to post more. I can read her pretty well, so I'm not worried about that

5. Dedenne hasn't said anything

- - - Post Merge - - -

If I was scum I could easily veg at let town not unify and have me and my teammate vote some rando. I'm trying to solve the game here from almost nothing. And again, I was shifting from Dad before you posted in defense of him

Just because this is a "valiant" intention, doesn't mean you are going about it right. You did say I wanted Toad dead before I even started losing my mind, so my argument about how you are defeating me before I can defend myself stands. And it's hard to want to play with someone who 1. Makes up there mind way too quickly 2. Threatens to vote based off of such little or poor evidence 3. Openly convinces and validates themselves off shaky meta 4. And has a history of sticking to this logic and not budging or being open to changing your mind.

You have done that to me multiple times and have gotten just as emotional and rude. My point is based on your flaws you don't actively want to admit or deal with, your gripe with me is that I'm rude, blunt, and vocal, but you fail to admit or take credit for anything I actually say.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And you wanna say I've been rude, you were criticizing my meta in your first long analysis and using your own curse words, calling me a hypocrite (your exact words were in response to something I said ina different game, and saying how "effing" ironic it was considering what I had done this game so far) before I even had a chance to defend myself.

Don't try to put everything on me buddy boy, like I said... take some credit for the pot you are stirring and don't be surprised when it splashes back on you