Mafia [GAME THREAD] Karen Mafia (Endgame - Mafia Wins)

1) Arstotzkan 30
2) voltairenism 24
3) Ace Marvel 32
4) Tensu 10
5) dedenne 27
6) Ronishy 13
7) Antonio 32
8) Endless 11
9) glow 6
10) Aerious 31
11) guav@ 21
12) Amazonevan19 0
13) MyLifeIsCake 7
14) epona 31
15) mogyay 4
 
@epona What do you think of nobody coming to the Ronishy’s defense? I feel like that could be AI for them. (Asking bc you voted them)

it's been noted, and my reluctance to vote them in the first place was how many people were considering them
i'm not confident with my vote and will happily switch to a better wagon if there is one but rn i need to vote and i am also not ruling out the possibility of bussing
 
In total agreement w/ Endless here: NLing/voting an inactive is a horrid idea. Day is short and not contributing Day 1 doesn't mean they won't contribute in the future. We get way more intel based on any kind of interaction right now than the no interaction of the others. The inactivity system is in place for a reason - let it do the work it's meant to do.
They are going to be mod killed/replaced anyways,why would they still be around past day 1?
 
eh you dont know they're not maf tho so,....,.,.,.
Which is entirely the point. If they're maf and they die to modkill that is straight beneficial to us, and we get to use our lynch to have another shot at hitting mafia.

As for who I'd vote for? I'm stuck between Antonio and Ace.
I know the general concensus with Ace is that his behaviour is off because of the situation around the game, I don't necessarily follow that. Inconsistency meets faux joviality - or real joviality, other people in this game know him better than me.
Regardless, I dunno, don't like much of his content so far.
As for Antonio, despite my earlier townread of him, his latest content is.. weird, and, ironically, considering my original reason for townreading him, I can't really put my feet in his shoes and understand where he's coming from.

I would be happy with either of those lynches.

As for ronishy, I don't have a good defense for them, but I don't particularly agree with the reasoning for voting them. I found their 1 unique push a little genuine, which makes up for the somewhat hivemind-y behaviour.
 
Mog hasn't posted much and gets defended.
I will not vote for mog or amazon as I think being maf they are in the minority and will be more active to steer the game.
 
i dont agree with voting evan. its not that hes posted little, hes posted nothing. he mightve even forgotten about the game idfk. but as far as lynching inactives goes, id prefer a mog lynch over evan
 
Mog hasn't posted much and gets defended.
I will not vote for mog or amazon as I think being maf they are in the minority and will be more active to steer the game.
exactly. mog has a total of 4 posts and people have come to her defense
the same thing with dedenne
NO ONE defended you

i absolutely WILL NOT vote evan because he’ll more than likely be replaced
 
Honestly I'm leaning Aerious right now, just because I feel like it's opportunistic to say let's lynch an inactive. They seem like a good player who should know better.
 
i also feel like the ronishy wagon is just as weak as voting evan .-.
Post automatically merged:

i absolutely WILL NOT vote evan because he’ll more than likely be replaced
wait but.. weren't you just.. saying u would??????????
 
Honestly I'm leaning Aerious right now, just because I feel like it's opportunistic to say let's lynch an inactive. They seem like a good player who should know better.
i’m offering a solution instead of allowing people to twiddle their thumbs and say they don’t know
i’d rather we gather some sort of intel than blatantly allowing maf to hide. this point makes 0 sense — YOU offer an alternative then
 
Ace Marvel 32
Antonio 32
Aerious 31
epona 31
Arstotzkan 30
dedenne 27
voltairenism 24
guav@ 21
Ronishy 13
Endless 11
Tensu 10
MyLifeIsCake 7
glow 6
mogyay 4
Amazonevan19 0

sorted ace's numbers
thank you for your contribution
 
man im a bit late with this but i also disagree with a ronishy lynch. nothing in their posts has rly stuck out as ai but i might need to look through them again
 
i’m offering a solution instead of allowing people to twiddle their thumbs and say they don’t know
i’d rather we gather some sort of intel than blatantly allowing maf to hide. this point makes 0 sense — YOU offer an alternative then
Besides you? Dedenne. They've talked with others so there's content to comb through, but they aren't being super helpful so it isn't a huge loss, and I think they'd give a ton of intel on Epona.
 
There's too many negatives for an inactive Lynch but what I'm concerned about is how modkills could impact are numbers.

@Geoni, what happens to the people who don't fit the 5 post requirements? Would they be mod killed or replace?
 
i’m offering a solution instead of allowing people to twiddle their thumbs and say they don’t know
i’d rather we gather some sort of intel than blatantly allowing maf to hide. this point makes 0 sense — YOU offer an alternative then
Town already have a solution: A Ronishy lynch.
I am fully aware that you townread Ronishy.
If so, what's your reads on Ace an Antonio? I am very happy to vote either.
 
Unless someone want's to replace one of the inactive slots, we will lose 2 players today, one by vote and one mod killed, because we only have one replacement.
 
Back
Top