Mafia [GAME THREAD] New Horizons Mafia - A Classic 9er (ENDGAME)

[glow]

pathetic omgus :0

- - - Post Merge - - -

gimme a sec

 

[N e s s]

pathetic omgus :0

- - - Post Merge - - -

gimme a sec

U know it

 

[Pathetic]

if we have to lynch in ness/antonio i'm going with ness

fwiw i like how daniel used "ness's teammates" rather than teammate. relatively arbitrary town-slip but it caught my eye somewhat

i'm contributing

 

[N e s s]

if we have to lynch in ness/antonio i'm going with ness

fwiw i like how daniel used "ness's teammates" rather than teammate. relatively arbitrary town-slip but it caught my eye somewhat

i'm contributing

1. That wasn’t a townslip, he said who my “teammates” are, singularly, as in who among the roster would be it.
2. Stop editing your posts.
3. Y’all will be sad when you see me flip town but whatever.

I kinda see that I have to be the lynch at this point since I’d rather avoid a week of “Ness said this” or “Ness said that.” Generally I’m against accepting a lynch as town but I’m certain you guys will at least mildly listen to me about Daniel after I flip.

 

[Damniel]

yea ness is right ik there’s only 2 scum but i had multiple potential partners in my head. i don’t see why you’d think that was a slip since i’ve mentioned before ik this is an open setup

 

[Pathetic]

okay then get lynched

 

[Damniel]

okay then get lynched

where’s your vote tho

 

[Heyden]

Antonio lynch isn’t gonna happen lol but I’m indifferent to Ness so yeah cool.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Wait why is waffles even voting me

 

[Geoni]

Random end of day question but do y'all want night to be 24 hours or 12 hours? Keep in mind I lock threads at night.

 

[Heyden]

Random end of day question but do y'all want night to be 24 hours or 12 hours? Keep in mind I lock threads at night.

12 preferably for me, or extension to 24 if someone doesn’t send their action in time imo

 

[glow]

glow: my main sr atm, made incredibly weak posts

m-my posts are weak? sure, ok. wbu tho?

daniel: ur honestly really tricky to read. i'm afraid of townreading you because you'd probably slip under my radar and i could be completely wrong. what really struck out to me is that you mentioned glow which is my main sr while barely anyone else mentioned her beyond a line or two or just flat out townread her. you're my main tr atm but i'm scared of one of the "stronger" or "active" players being mafia. I actually think you and ness have a high potential of being town, but that leaves toads as also town, and I don't know how I feel about that, despite me somewhat townreading them. in your earlier posts, you have a wide range of a lynch pool (antonio, glow, ness) and that's the only thing that really stuck out to me despite you vgetting on glow for that.

strikethrough is commentary, not reads.
italics = reads
bold = downplaying your reads / walking back ur reads

toads: you seem like a really strong player just based off of how you talk along w/ damniel, this is my first game playing with you all so i won't be very good at tone-reading much because i don't have past experiences. i've really liked and agreed with most of your posts so far. your thought process is understandable and you seem frustrated with ness rather than trying to bandwagon onto a quick vote, but i could also be completely wrong and you're just using that as leverage.

nonspecific. what do you agree with? more walking back reads

ness: i don't know if this is what "experienced" is supposed to be but the way you play is incredibly arrogant (at times) and aggressive for really no reason at all. when the heat's finally on you for how you've been playing, you cry for a replacement? because you're being "insulted"? in a game like mafia? you're unreadable to me. i initially townread you but this entire game is revolved around you now so idk i'll have to reread half of your posts because i barely read your push on damniel not gonna lie

3/4s of this is commentary and not reads. bolded outlays a townread which was discarded.

heyden, unravel: idk soz post more unravel you're silly i like you

hayden has more content than shawo but aight

antonio: surprisingly, i actually really like your tone despite people saying otherwise. in a lot of your posts, you come off as genuine to me lol

what feels genuine? what posts do you like?

shawo: nothing much to really see here. i just like their posts. i like their attempt at (albeit weakly) contributing and being recognized through their reads (specifically mentioning to damniel that they just "wanted to let him know) even though their troll posts were kinda awk

non specific. what about shawo's contributions are better than mine? you criticise me for not being srs but shawo's been trolling for the same amount, if not more, of posts

second half of the sentence is nonsensical -- what does ?being recognised through their reads? mean? i have no idea how what you?re saying relates at all to shawo being a townlean for you

1) i think i'm misreading in (ness, toads, daniel), or that's just my paranoia of reading "stronger" or more "condensed" players wrong

1. you never townread ness.
2. you said you agreed with toads posts but walked back on that in the same sentence.
3. even with daniel, your ?main tr? you started your post with ?daniel?s tricky to read?.

2) none of these are concrete townreads and they are liable to change at any time

lol

 

[Geoni]

12 preferably for me, or extension to 24 if someone doesn’t send their action in time imo

I don't do extensions for that reason since it has the potential to narrow down who could have a night action. Which would mean host influence. If it's 12, it's 12.

 

[Pathetic]

why r u nitpicking my post

 

[glow]

also my point is that you're being hypocritical, pathetic; i actually don't care about people having "weak" reads that much on it's own and if anything i'd instead SR you for your overreaction to me saying i'd placeholder vote you (which didn't even happen)

 

[Heyden]

I don't do extensions for that reason since it has the potential to narrow down who could have a night action. Which would mean host influence. If it's 12, it's 12.

Oh true duh
—

Anyway I’m still on deathrow so I might move to Ness if it gets to that point ~~~

 

[Pathetic]

why did u waste ur time making that post then. should i even bother replying since it was to just "prove a point"

you have weak posts because the content in your posts, not solely because of how little you're posting. you know the "placeholder" vote thing is not only you and three other people, like i said lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

also soz forgot about editing i don't use forums anymore

 

[Damniel]

okay pathetics responses are def weird but i’m not sure if that’s blunt town or dismissive maf yet

 

[N e s s]

Rainbow reads list!!

glow: She's going to be a badass in a few phases. Give her some time to shine, I have faith she'll lead town to victory, she always comes through. Her tone in post #68 screams town to me based on tone alone, I don't think she would be that straight forward and she's going to be more in depth sooner or later.

Toadsworthy: Thought it over, don't really think it's him, and if it is I won't be surprised. Nevertheless his splash of emotion earlier feels extremely townish to me, I don't think that he would be this bombastic as mafia and I don't see it from anyone in general. His read on me hurts my ego but I've accepted it.

Shawo and Pathetic: Kinda lumping these two in the same category because they're both equally putting the effort in, but I don't see either as amazing. Shawo weirdly feels more town to me than Pathetic, mostly because I feel like Shawo is just trolling around and voted Heyden for a pretty unstrategic reason if they are Mafia. Pathetic has the spirit of a town player and that's essentially it. They'd both be far more quiet if they were scum, but I've been wrong about newbscum! before so don't discount them.

Antonio: Once again, I like his tone. If I truly am the lynch today, at least promise me that you guys will be mildly easier on Antonio? I really don't think it's him, and his thoughts on Daniel align with my own. Granted he may have pocketed me, but I would rather you guys focus on someone else next phase than tunnel exclusively on him. If Antonio doesn't step it up and acts like the leader I saw him as in Jailbreak mafia, you all have my endorsement to rip into him. Otherwise, I don't think it's him but I'm less certain about him than others. I don't particularly like that he just said "oh you said everything I wanted to say about Daniel" but that's essentially it.

Unravel: I'm thinking it over constantly and I just can't lump her into a category just yet. She truly is a mystery. I'm of the opinion that if Antonio actually is town, then she is a prime candidate for future discussion. But inversely if Antonio is mafia then she truly is just unreadable at that point. I think worst comes to worst then she's probably the last option I see for a future lynch.

Heyden: I don't like his case on Antonio. It feels hashed out and really I disagree with a lot of the points he's said. I don't really know what Toads sees in his case regarding Antonio but it's whatever. Particularly this rustles my Jimmies:

Q2 - dodging the question by masking it under something supposedly humorous to make it look of substance never sits with me well, and Q3 - nor do I like his forced ~train of thought~ trying to appear unaware and confused, as if he's trying to mimic the notion of a lost townie.

Not only do I disagree with this tremendously, it feels like an extremely cherry picked detail that makes Antonio look suspicious for something that really isn't at all what he was intending to do. Antonio... has always been weird. It's hard for me to read him but I don't think that he is at all doing what Heyden has lumped him into doing, it feels like people are just going along with it. Granted, Antonio hasn't done much else since he mentioned his suspicion of Daniel, so in the event Daniel is town then I see a scumpool of Heyden/Antonio/Unravel.

But other than that this case on Antonio is all Heyden has really done. It feels like Heyden is coasting by on this one thing rather than actively promote anything else. I dunno, if I had to say someone is profiting off of the chaos between me/Toads/Daniel/Antonio, it would be Heyden as the missing link.

Damniel: Please refer to my posts on page 12 for all future discussion regarding Damniel, I hope you guys discuss him more when I'm gone: https://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?477747-GAME-THREAD-New-Horizons-Mafia-A-Classic-9er-(Day-1-ends-at-9pm-EST-on-3-10)&p=8472055&highlight=#post8472055

And that's basically it! I wish you guys the best and I'm sorry for causing the chaos I did, I shouldn't have been rude and I genuinely apologize. Scumpool for Day 2 should be Daniel/Heyden/Unravel, and maybe Antonio if the cards fall like I suggested in that he coasts by.

My role is Rowan the Vanilla Townie. He's a big orange tiger guy and he was actually in my New Leaf town.

- - - Post Merge - - -

also my point is that you're being hypocritical, pathetic; i actually don't care about people having "weak" reads that much on it's own and if anything i'd instead SR you for your overreaction to me saying i'd placeholder vote you (which didn't even happen)

I mean, Pathetic is voting me just cuz' so I don't think they're particularly playing 4D chess at the moment.

 

[Pathetic]

did u not read what i said i'm voting you because i'd rather you over antonio

 

[Heyden]

Who wants to bandwagon Antonio