If you could date one islander, who would it be - and why?

Love that this thread got revivied-

Uh, I would never date any of my villagers, that's a little odd. BUT, I definitely had a crush on Kyle as a kid. Now I like to be his good friend.

I'm honestly shocked other people also said Kyle :)
 
Haha, I love it. Poncho because he reminds me of the guys I like irl. I may have poor taste but I feel like he's funny, friendly, kind of carefree and oblivious sometimes, but a good guy. Not a fan of him naming his abs but I don't date guys who do that, don't worry lol.

That or one of the intellectuals. I'm a nature lover and a huge passion of mine is rock climbing so I enjoy things like that and snowboarding, any creative type sport or alternative sport (rather than football…I hate football). So guys that are into alternative sports are great. But also intellectual. I like a little nerdy. I am a little nerdy.
 
Nah, I don't do that. I just see them as friends that I could have a laugh and hang around with. That would be Queenie and Sterling!
 
Hmmm katt from NH or Sky form acnl.... Would have said coco. But she way into Chief. So no chance there in my NL game
 
look when i was a tween and played NL i joked that wolfgang was my NL boyfriend cos he always visited and gave me gifts. it was cute. as an adult tho, gotta go for my main man Brewster. I will be sipping hot chochies every day of the week and helping him look after his gyroid collection.
This is very much a joke, i love Brewster but only as a friend. ignore the fact i have his plushie.
 
While obviously in real life, I wouldn’t want to date an animal—even an anthro one—my character grew up in a world with sapient animals. So it wouldn’t be weird at all to her? Anyway, she’s dating Stella.
(I would date a human version of her tbh. I drew a gijinka of her when I met her in pocket camp, and chubby? Rosy cheeks? Curly hair? Bookworm? Dateable and relatable.)
(Obviously, I mean this in a wholesome way!!)
 
I've never had a crush on an animal because that's very strange (the fox from zootopia doesn't count, i was like 10 and literally everyone liked him at one point lmao) but lets be real.

I would date tom nook. I don't have any romantic connection to these characters but Tom Nook is rich so I mean... I'd do it for the money 😅
Post automatically merged:

Also tbh some of you guys kinda weird on this thread, some of these replies are actually serious and its both hilarious and uncomfortable...
 
Last edited:
thetessagrace said:
I've never had a crush on an animal because that's very strange (the fox from zootopia doesn't count, i was like 10 and literally everyone liked him at one point lmao) but lets be real.

I would date tom nook. I don't have any romantic connection to these characters but Tom Nook is rich so I mean... I'd do it for the money 😅
Post automatically merged:

Also tbh some of you guys kinda weird on this thread, some of these replies are actually serious and its both hilarious and uncomfortable...
Click to expand...
Welcommen to peoples weird fantasy and fanfiction! well plz dont go into the fanfiction sections .... its dark and scary in there :eek:
I think it a bit fun to read what villager, that ppl like. sometime there may be a story behind from the older games. hade a story from acnl. where Skye for little more then week keep pinging me or seem to follow me.... and there also that, she standing out my home almost every day...... she was living across the town.
but that what i like about the old Ac games. that there are small storys, where you as player could fill in the blank spot with what you want. where Acnh is alittle more bland in that area. BUT HEY none have said Octavian yet :p
 
Tex. ❤
He was my Wild World bestie. I actually sent him a Valentine’s letter a few years ago. I just need him on my island in ACNH now. :rolleyes:
 
I would say (friend) date Merengue. Just cause she was my first villager i connected with in new leaf and been with me ever since. (Most people say no homo but in my case I would have to say no straight 😅)
 
I wouldn't date anyone as it's pretty weird and I'm not into animals in that kind of way (to each their own though).

On the other hand I would totally be best friends with Kiki. She's so nice and down to earth. I love when she relaxes with a good book I totally relate to her that way.
 
this thread is so extra, i can't with the replies 😂

i adore villagers like wolf link, katt, judy, raymond, maple etc
but i personally wouldn't date them lol
 
Olivia, because she's the snootiest cat in town. My smug personality would be perfectly complementary as we laugh at the poor villagers who are forever stuck in one bedroom homes while we enjoy our 3 story house with basement, 3 bedrooms and an upstairs.
 
I- what? How about no ❤️
but if I absolutely HAD to... I have to admit I’d pick... none of them ✨
Post automatically merged:

Mello said:
This makes me uncomfortable, and I didn't know you guys all had these feelings towards your animals...
Click to expand...
Thank you! they’re god damn animals
 
Last edited:
Actually, I never imagine this possibility, I always wanted to be friends of the islanders, I never thought about dating one of them. I think that none of the villagers. I only think about being friends with them 😂
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

. Rarity .
If you had an Island of only one personality, what would it be?
Replies
16
Views
371
Tsukuri_Yukimura
T
DaCoSim
If you could have one of the crossover villagers
2
Replies
33
Views
1K
Croconaw
Croconaw
. Rarity .
Would you date someone who is completly different from you?
2
Replies
31
Views
1K
mogyay
mogyay
Cetoddle769
9 Scorpions in one night
Replies
7
Views
236
Tsukuri_Yukimura
T
. Rarity .
If you could remove a character from a video game, who would it be?
Replies
16
Views
566
Psydye
Psydye
Back
Top