if you could only have one animal species on your island, which would you pick?

[MrBox]

Oh thats hard! I wouldn't be able to pick one ... if I could reset my island every time I wanted a new animal then maybe lol!

Honestly maybe mice? or squirrels? I feel like I'd get so bored of seeing the same shape over and over again

 

[Jacob]

Ooh, tough one. Back in NL I would’ve said Sheep. I think my town had 7 sheep at one point. Then they got a little too skinny for me in New Horizons, so now I’d go with Cats or Deer villagers.

 

[LordSheep78]

Squirrels

 

[VampireSenpaii]

personally I’d have to go with all hamsters - I think they’re so cute!! but all cats would probably be a close second

Cats. Just all cats. Or sheep.

 

[moonford]

Hmmm, it would tough choice between anteaters and ostriches. Although there are only 8 anteaters in NH at the moment! Lulu and Nosegay need to make comebacks.

I'm also a little bit picky with personalities so I'd need a lazy and uchi anteater too. So I'd lean toward ostriches solely because they check all the boxes.

Elephants would be cool too, there just needs to be more of them as well.

 

[Asarena]

This is a tough question, but I'd probably go with cats. Cats are one of my favorite animals in real life, and there are a lot of cat villagers that I like

 

[bestiepango]

I think since having Bluebear in my new leaf town the bear cubs have really grown on me and I def consider having an all bear cub island/town, they are just so so cute to me ^o^

other than that maybe anteaters or dogs bc I like the majority of their designs.

 

[Hyoon]

i think it would be between deers, cats, or squirrels. i feel like a woodsy, naturecore town with all deers would be really cute actually

 

[faerie]

This is painful, but I would go wolves, because I cannot leave Chief my boy behind. I also like a lot of wolves so I’d be in good shape.

 

[CylieDanny]

I'd love to have my gay rabbit island again. I miss it so much. Plus I don't think I could play this game without my mint bunny ♡

 

[Nougat]

Such a tough question! I think I'd go for squirrels. Filbert, Marshall and Ione are definitely moving in.

 

[Kevinnn]

Wolves! mentioned in a other thread earlier but I almost like the entirety of that species

 

[JellyLu]

This is tough because I enjoy so many species. Plus, having a variety on my island is something I enjoy. If I had to pick one though, it would be wolves. Whitney is my only dream character and all towns/islands/villages have to have her. So... wolves by default I wouldn't mind though because I like all the wolf villagers. I don't think I dislike any of them, haha.

 

[skarmoury]

I think I like the diversity of cats the most! But I also do love the sheep and rabbit so I’ll take any of the three species :]

 

[Rio_]

Definitely cats! I had an all-cat town in New Leaf but I think by the time I collected all the villagers, I got so burnt out that I didn't play in it much lol

On my first ACNH island I had three cat villagers, and it took all my strength to resist having any more!

 

[Zerous]

Hmmm I do have all the octopi already, but out of the species with enough members to fill a whole village, maybe frogs? I think a lot of them are really cute!!

 

[Chibi.Hoshi]

That's a tough decision. There are so many species I love, like squirrels and ducks, but to dedicate an island to just one? I would have to go with cats. There’s a lot of variety within that species, and a few of those villagers are my favourite villagers as well.

 

[Sarah3]

An island full of penguins would be amazing! I would choose octopus but there aren't enough of them.

 

[digimon]

hmmm i think i’d go with all frogs, cats or maybe all penguins! i feel like there’s lots of variety there!

 

[IonicKarma]

most likely cats, there are so many cats that I love that I could do a island of just cats. They do seem to be the most popular type of villager so i guess its a bit basic, but I love them nonetheless!