if you could only have one animal species on your island, which would you pick?

[VulpineVengeance]

Wolves for sure. They all have cute designs and matching color palettes, with there being none that I really dislike. I'd say the same for cats, though, because I love them all, even Tabby

 

[themysterybidder]

This is so difficult to choose, but since I couldn't give up my beloved Buck, it would be horses! I also really like several other horses (so it wouldn't be too bad!): Roscoe, Elmer, Ed, Victoria and Julian.

 

[VulpineVengeance]

This is so difficult to choose, but since I couldn't give up my beloved Buck, it would be horses! I also really like several other horses (so it wouldn't be too bad!): Roscoe, Elmer, Ed, Victoria and Julian.

Oooh, I love Buck! He was my jock on my first island, along with Mira (sisterly)

 

[river]

frogs all the way

lots of variety in their vibes -- from Wart Jr. to Gigi to Jambette, Ribbot, Drift -- and they're all little and cute

 

[Firesquids]

Back in New Leaf at one point I had an all wolf town, it was fun for a while, but it gets kind of boring to only have one villager species so I probably wouldn't do it again.

 

[You got mail!]

Easy peasy for me! Rabbits for sure, huge fan of them my entire life.

 

[Coach]

I started doing it with penguins in NL, so potentially them. They're just so very cute and I like the majority of them so it's not too hard to fill a roster up.

 

[-Blue-]

I wouldn't really like that and it'd probably dampen the mood of the game, but I'd probably go with cats. There's so many cat villagers that I could always just move some out and still have plenty of different cat villagers with different personalities to choose from.

Also because of this.

 

[angelcat621]

I've had three all cat islands at this point. My forever island is all cats and that's how it will stay.

 

[VernalLapin]

Probably bunnies. My dreamie list is pretty much just brightly-colored villagers, but I like a lot of the bunnies and they are one of if not my favorite villager species.

 

[Mallika]

This is a tough choice because I love so many species, and I really enjoy having a variety on my island. But if I had to choose, I'd go with either wolves or ducks, since I have so many villagers I like in both species.

 

[DaCoSim]

Squirrels or bunnies for sure!!!!!

My list of each

Squirrels
Filbert, Ione, Static, Peanut, marshal, mint, nibbles, poppy, sylvana, and of course Uni-wow Hazel

Vs.

Bunnies
Francine, Chrissy, Bunnie, Sasha, Gaston, Coco, Hopkins, Ruby, Toby, & o’hare

 

[Chere.]

I'm probably gonna be giving a basic answers but definitely the wolves, I love so many of them and their models have always been one of my favourites! A second strong contender though would have to be the eagles, as I feel similar about them the way I do with the wolves. ^^

 

[BiscuitsAndTriscuits]

Oooh that’s a hard choice between ducks, squirrels and cats all three I like the vast majority of the designs with squirrels and cats have 2 of my favorite designs overall hmm

 

[Rainy.Nights]

Definitely cats, there are so many I like. But my island now is the opposite, I planned to have 1 each of all different species so I had to pick a favorite.

 

[Wolfsbane]

Tough choice, but I'd say dogs. I love them just as much as cats and there's a bunch of them I've never had yet. (❁´◡`❁)
Heeey, that could be a nice goal for my second island. o:

 

[speardovich]

I'm not sure... I'd have to say rabbits or deer. Rabbits are my favourite animal IRL and my fav villager is Bonbon, but I think on average the deer have cuter designs... idk

 

[PugLovex]

my top 3 runners would have to be either cats, wolves, or deer. my island is already primarily made up of these 3 anyways (3 cats, 2 wolves, 2 deer). i think they're all such adorable species and truly not a bad one in any!

 

[annex]

I always loved squirrels, still do, but I recently discovered that I really like small birds. I moved in Midge and Jitters, and noticed how cute Robin, and Twiggy are too. I know there are other cute ones, but can't remember their names. I doubt that there are 10 small birds, so I would have to mix them with the bigger birds too.