Mafia Improbable Role Mafia 2 - Endgame

[Geoni]

I think this is an all SK game/killing TP game and there isn't a mafia team. Role PM win condition is that all hostile threats to town have been eliminated.

 

[Farobi]

I think this is an all SK game/killing TP game and there isn't a mafia team. Role PM win condition is that all hostile threats to town have been eliminated.

but the 2 yellows are dead and non-hostile, and if there are more yellows it'd be unfair for town. i think there is 2 mafia that aren't the conventional goon/gf/rber, but thats how i'd assume it considering the funky roles this game seems to have.

- - - Post Merge - - -

im not discounting the fact that there could be a hostile tp, i think there is one but only just one

 

[Byngo]

hmm

it’s possible but the last improbable maf had scum and a couple tps

 

[Geoni]

Well whether it's mafia or TP, there's something out here that's still hostile to town, probably two at least given the day 3 deadline. I'm more concerned with the scumhunt than the 'what are we up against' hunt, which doesn't lead to much success.

Tina, Farobi, Dedenne, and Chick, I need reads from all yall. The stances yall have taken so far have been lackluster. Not going through another game of Tina coasting on drunk.

 

[Farobi]

ATM I'm only TLing Punchy, Heyden, and Dad. I think they're pretty towny and some reads I have are aligned with them.

As for the rest of the people, theyre all scummy imo so I can't really nitpick who's scummier than the other.
So Chele, Byngo, Dedenne, Tina, and Chick. Scum is likely among these 5

 

[Chele]

I find Chick's one post weird still and she hasn't answered my question. But I don't like the way she goes after Bianca there either and defends Chele similarly to how Byngo defends her and also seems somewhat fillery.

Was this bolded part referring to Chick? Because she never went after Bianca, nor did she even talk about Bianca yet. Of Chick?s 3 posts, I?ve seen them all and there?s nothing about Bianca. Is this just an memory error or something? Here is Chick?s most recent post:

So busy rn

- - - Post Merge - - -

Anyways Chele is in with the big ass posts already (this is normal behaviour tbh,) and hmm this game is gonna be hard. I?m not even sure if this game could last up to D2 lol.

Also guys ya?know Waffles is my daughter and it makes me so proud to see that she?s confirmed already and she?s growing up a lot and I get so emotional ?cause I still remember when she was a small kid and when I was helping her to walk and when I was helping her to actually eat food the right way and etc...

So...? She only talks about Waffles and me.

Well whether it's mafia or TP, there's something out here that's still hostile to town, probably two at least given the day 3 deadline. I'm more concerned with the scumhunt than the 'what are we up against' hunt, which doesn't lead to much success.

I feel that there?s a/some Mafia still out there, maybe it?s just a Mafia but with a special killing ability. I don?t think that Ness would use a specific role twice, so there probably can?t be a TP (referring to Serial Killer) again. The only other TP killing role that I can think of off the top of my head is an Arsonist, maybe they?re off to douse somebody now (it?s night rn, isn?t it?). If nobody gets doused, then I?m not sure of what TP to think of, and therefore would probably prove my statement of the only hostile being Mafia.

Not going through another game of Tina coasting on drunk.

Amazing theory: Tina got angry and drunk because she found out that she was scum

Also, @Punchy where?d you get this ?Chele?s special ability? from? And what made you think that I was a role designed to lynch you? Why me of all people in the first place? Just because your role is plain, that doesn?t really mean that there?s something hidden away from you. Look at Waffles? role. She basically had no action. Even though she was an unaware person who would die from any actions, her role is very small.

 

[Chick]

Hi guys, I am legit extremely busy with work. The only thing I can think about with Waffles’ death was probably a vig action or something? Who knows, anything crazy could happen. There could be a day vigilante but Mafia aligned. Despite looking at all the weird roles, this could be a possibility. Something among those lines.

So, Dad. I literally just commented on Chele’s posts being really big and informative, and I said she was in with the big posts and I added that it is normal behaviour just in case any of you would misunderstand and think that I was being sarcastic or talking about when she was scum and used big posts so then you’d think I was scumleaning her

 

[Chris]

Tina, Farobi, Dedenne, and Chick, I need reads from all yall. The stances yall have taken so far have been lackluster. Not going through another game of Tina coasting on drunk.

I'll have a re-read of the thread later, but I'll be honest for now: I've no strong feelings on anyone. The only two people I felt had any good idea on are dead so I'm back at square one. D1 felt really lacking and I just skimmed everything I missed overnight.

Amazing theory: Tina got angry and drunk because she found out that she was scum

I signed up drunk. That's why I didn't realise it was a PM game until someone said.

I also don't like PM games so kind of kicking myself here but hey. My mistake.

 

[Geoni]

@Chele: yeah no that was a memory fizzle, but I recall multiple people going after Bianca, tbt mafia's go to sacrificial lamb. I'm still more concerned with the nature of how Chick defended you than anything.

Speaking of which

@Chick: that's a lot of concern over how you think people are reading into what you're saying, you saw it as normal behavior and felt the need to bring that up, period. You specifically selected this player to townread aside from the announced townie (ityw), and so it seems like some really rushed and basic read to come off as active with, which is why I asked what I asked.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'll have a re-read of the thread later, but I'll be honest for now: I've no strong feelings on anyone. The only two people I felt had any good idea on are dead so I'm back at square one. D1 felt really lacking and I just skimmed everything I missed overnight.



I signed up drunk. That's why I didn't realise it was a PM game until someone said.

I also don't like PM games so kind of kicking myself here but hey. My mistake.

This is a really fast and easy re-read compared to other games. It's about 15 pages total since day 1 began.

 

[Heyden]

Also just ftr I'm townreading Byngo based on contributions and Punchy bc their behaviour seems legit, scumleans are Dedenne (inactivity I guess lul) and Tina bc her posts feel fillery in a way idk honestly I'm just skimming at this point

 

[Geoni]

I feel like it's safe to say that Tina not having a single strong opinion or even slight opinion on anyone after at least two contributing posts from all the players still alive isn't reflective of an experienced mafia player playing as town. Her posts so far, especially during the first day, has been full of helpful observation or guiding one-liners. Which is classic town-try filler. I'll be curious as to what her reads are atm. Blaming dissonance over not liking PM games and accidentally joining one isn't going to cut it for me either.

 

[N e s s]

Guys I know who scum is

 

[toadsworthy]

Btw I'm out of the game now because I won.... no poems for you

 

[cornimer]

Btw I'm out of the game now because I won.... no poems for you

 

[dedenne]

Eek sorry for inactivity I'm still dying

I don't have any strong reads but I will try to contribute a bit more

After doing all homework due in tomorrow :///

 

[unravel]

Guys I know who scum is

Shush dude HAHAHAHA

 

[N e s s]

Intermission 2​

heyden has died. They were a Town Shapeshifter.

Town Shapeshifter

You have a tendency to change your shape from time to time; some days you're a circle others a square, jeez you have like no consistency.

For each passing phase, your role will change. At the current moment, you are nothing but a Vanilla Townie.

You win once all threats to town have been eliminated.

Its a miracle! Biancasbotique has been revived and brought back into the game! (Toadsworthy still wins though)

You have 2 hours and 30 minutes left to send in actions.

 

[toadsworthy]

Intermission 2​

heyden has died. They were a Town Shapeshifter.





Its a miracle! Biancasbotique has been revived and brought back into the game! (Toadsworthy still wins though)

You have 2 hours and 30 minutes left to send in actions.

I was about to be real pissed

 

[Farobi]

Roleclaim to bianca and forward it to me i got this

 

[Biancasbotique]

what is going on? who revived me?

am i just a stump ? what the hell