Okay so apparently the cat has got your tongue on the very thing you're basing all of this on? If I had more time on my hands I could go and hunt it down for you but okay, this is you processing the game for yourself, more or less. At least that's what I can tell about it. While I think you can find it helpful in gauging how willing people are to discuss their mafia theory with you I'm not sure how it's going to result in a 'gotcha' moment, just...how well someone wants to work together with you when you're being mostly townread from what I can tell. Daniel's treatment of the question seemed the most stubborn for no reason but I'm not going to +1 it being outright wolfy, weird as it was. I don't see what's funky about Epona using glow as an example. Speaking of which I do think glow actually has meta and I'm not seeing it here yet but it's probably because she hasn't seen my posts yet for her obligatory case/tunnel of me. Dedenne's response is kinda funky tbh, feels like a very roundabout way to say she was uncertain about it.
And why give guava the pass to D2? Same goes for Cake and Shawo who said they want to reach the night before they have anything to go off, although from what I can tell Shawo has had a few thoughts more than the rest in the grouping.
Didn't like the timing of this after Dan said he was still willing to vote for him (sorry for an earlier misgender btw!) and I think someone else was casting some doubt on Hikari as well. Keeping my eye on that wagon because as much as I want more from Hikari than response, he could be needing that extra nudge as someone who hasn't played in a while and that's why we don't see more wide-view solving.
Same applies to the above. Potentially opportunistic in calling someone an opportunist.
Okay it was Alek that also said it. I don't think he was referring to me in saying 'they're' because that would make no sense even for mafia to throw out there.
You have to find townies to solve the game via PoE though, it's the best way to get a successful elim on day 1. What don't you understand about the exchanges between Dan and Alek being towny? Is there something about that you disagree with specifically? I mean my read on Dan in particular more or less does equate to him amounting to seeming towny enough through the nuances.
Conesnsus town from these seven people (half the game): Arcadia, Dino, and shawo, and volt is almost there. I'm not sure I agree with shawo being consensus town because he hadn't done enough up to the point of the game to merit it at for me and it feels like an easy pass is being given by some of these folks. Ace needs more than two townreads, that feels pretty narrow, and he's been having some sort of world view that I haven't seen him give a good convincing explanation for in regards to Dan x Alek.
Dan I'd like to see you explain why your folks work well together as a team if you can.
Hikari's Alek read is ??? I find epona and Alek to be very towny so far.
I feel like I'm pretty in line with a lot of Arcadia's choices.
I'm curious as to why so many people had glow as town with a gun to their head, haven't found much memorable from her yet and will probably need to ISO when all is said and done.
This is kinda silly, he has to stick his neck out regardless as mafia because it's more or less expected of him among this playerlist.
If anything it's good for pushing people to take a stance when there is so little of that going on and driving further discussion to figure out who is willing to work together and who some elimination candidates are. I do expect Dan to dig into it more later because it's one of those things that you refer back to as the game goes on for the sake of tracking progress. I would hope he understands that's what's useful about it.
What do you make of that from Volt?
