Mafia Janitorial 2.0! Day ends June 22nd 2020, 5 PM PST.

[epona]

THEY omg my brain

Post automatically merged: Jun 23, 2020

so then potential nl to buy remy time

and what if doctor is dead and they kill remy tonight

you're acting very SCUMMY for someone who is legit mechancially townlocked

 

[Trent the Paladin]

THEY omg my brain

Post automatically merged: Jun 23, 2020

so then potential nl to buy remy time

so if remy’s results aren’t red, you are opposed to a guava lynch even if she/ace both claim doc today?

 

[Aerious]

and what if doctor is dead and they kill remy tonight

you're acting very SCUMMY for someone who is legit mechancially townlocked

then guava is mafia. this isn’t scummy at all

Post automatically merged: Jun 23, 2020

so if remy’s results aren’t red, you are opposed to a guava lynch even if she/ace both claim doc today?

if both claim doc we see what happens. rn you and epona aren’t clear at all

 

[Trent the Paladin]

then guava is mafia. this isn’t scummy at all

if both claim doc we see what happens. rn you and epona aren’t clear at all

do you think mafia is crazy enough to keep remy alive til endgame tho

i mean outside of you and remy mechanically, none of us are clear

 

[Aerious]

do you think mafia is crazy enough to keep remy alive til endgame tho

i mean outside of you and remy mechanically, none of us are clear

if doc is alive, remy will be here for endgame. if not, guava fakeclaimed

 

[Trent the Paladin]

if doc is alive, remy will be here for endgame. if not, guava fakeclaimed

doesn’t really answer the q though and i gotta be honest I think you might be overthinking it all

 

[Aerious]

doesn’t really answer the q though and i gotta be honest I think you might be overthinking it all

overthinking how? if doc is alive, mafia has no choice whether remy makes it endgame

 

[Trent the Paladin]

overthinking how? if doc is alive, mafia has no choice whether remy makes it endgame

Going from Ace being doc to Guava being doc. Not sure I buy that the glow kill was an elaborate attempt to frame Guava?

 

[Aerious]

Going from Ace being doc to Guava being doc. Not sure I buy that the glow kill was an elaborate attempt to frame Guava?

i mean i have no idea why guava isn’t dead after softclaiming doc. i’m just waiting until remy comes back with results

 

[Trent the Paladin]

i mean i have no idea why guava isn’t dead after softclaiming doc. i’m just waiting until remy comes back with results

Easy mislynch in their eyes? It’s not like any of us were heavily town leaning Guava yesterday

Post automatically merged: Jun 23, 2020

that is if guava is actually doc

 

[epona]

i mean i have no idea why guava isn’t dead after softclaiming doc. i’m just waiting until remy comes back with results

there is literally such a simple explanation though and it's that guava was fakeclaiming as scum so she COULDN'T die, not the mental acrobatics required to come to the conclusion that guava was real claiming but then they didn't kill her and instead killed glow to frame guava. the risk that we would leave guava alive today to protect remy another night (if she's the real doc) is too big for mafia

i'm gonna dip til remy gets here bc i am completely at odds with the line of thinking you're following rn

 

[Aerious]

there is literally such a simple explanation though and it's that guava was fakeclaiming as scum so she COULDN'T die, not the mental acrobatics required to come to the conclusion that guava was real claiming but then they didn't kill her and instead killed glow to frame guava. the risk that we would leave guava alive today to protect remy another night (if she's the real doc) is too big for mafia

i'm gonna dip til remy gets here bc i am completely at odds with the line of thinking you're following rn

this game is entirely mental acrobatics. you can’t blame me for wanting to exhaust every possible outcome bc it doesn’t necessarily align w your train of thought. guava hasn’t even had a chance to speak yet before you’re accusing her of maf fakeclaiming, and ace hasn’t cc’d doc. there is no concrete plan off of exploring possibilities until people begin responding/remy comes with a claim

 

[Heyden]

i think we should sus anyone that claims doc. there is literally no reason for it but pr hunt from maf. correct if i am wrong
maybe not sus but just dont cc if someone claims doc. just leave it

also i thought heyden was memeing at the start lol epic soft claiming

He’s jan and knew who died, idk what to extrapolate from this but I feel like doc is alive?

 

[Aerious]

it’s entirely possible that guava fakeclaimed, but if we eliminate and she turns up doc, we just killed remy. it’s not adding up how one option is riskier than the other

 

[Trent the Paladin]

He’s jan and knew who died, idk what to extrapolate from this but I feel like doc is alive?

you dont think that was an attempt form them to soft?

 

[Aerious]

PepeHands what happened omg


i mean dont you think it was quite weird people were dogpilling on him. idk dude he looks town

also remy didnt really answer why they went for me of all people TvT

shouldnt we look from other perspective and try to lynch most scummy looking instead just trusting what could be a fakeclaim. guava is pretty weird the discrepancy from last game is very noticiable

doesn’t make sense why he defended ace and not guava

 

[epona]

this game is entirely mental acrobatics. you can’t blame me for wanting to exhaust every possible outcome bc it doesn’t necessarily align w your train of thought. guava hasn’t even had a chance to speak yet before you’re accusing her of maf fakeclaiming, and ace hasn’t cc’d doc. there is no concrete plan off of exploring possibilities until people begin responding/remy comes with a claim

i'm not blaming you at all or saying you're wrong to consider other scenarios, i just said i'm at odds with your line of thinking which i am. us going in circles is unproductive and frustrating bc we're clearly not going to agree on this, so i don't see the point of continuing the back and forth until remy shows up

He’s jan and knew who died, idk what to extrapolate from this but I feel like doc is alive?

this is either literal instructions to the scumteam, or it's code to tell them doc is dead. idk how useful it is bc it could be either

it’s entirely possible that guava fakeclaimed, but if we eliminate and she turns up doc, we just killed remy. it’s not adding up how one option is riskier than the other

i don't want to eliminate guava today for that exact reason. depending on remy's cop check my vote is going on ace

 

[Aerious]

nothing, just said I was going to read

-

I can see how to get confused with roles but we had basically almost two days (since the threat got track late today) so idk gotta do the homework. yeah talking ace. buuut I wished we heard more about other people that are inactive bc only an ace wagon smells.
with that I basically said it's my only sus for the day. mayor disappeared what seems coasting but it's a slow day that suddenly got some track, it seems. also fathers day i think? (fathers day here is august) my point we should score inactivity starting tomorrow. aerious seems fair and understand the mechanics better than anyone here so I will say thats enough reason to believe they got the oracle pm for now haha
tom is quite the weird one, he is the only one I never played with so maybe it's a cultural shock so I will just put on null.
honestly talking about mechanics makes it hard to make a read because it's mostly backing and forth about what how things work. also overall seems like a clash of different opinions - I could see everyone online being town bc maf prefers the inactivity and lack of discussion between town. but as I said, sussing inactivity tomorrow

i think i will go back and quote some stuff now. these were general thoughts

and then this?

 

[epona]

doesn’t make sense why he defended ace and not guava

they were the only viable suspects for the day apart from him. i can see why he'd bus one and defend the other, if that is the scumteam

 

[Aerious]

it steers away from ace heavily and i do think guava is doc for now. ace v well could be lawyer here