Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]

i don’t really agree. it could be as town yea but it can also just be maf throwing in some random reads. being unable to explain them doesn’t convince me of an alignment. i think you’re being to quick to townread them

I'm just trying to narrow who I would conceivably vote for today and what I look for in scum day 1. Loth give me no red flags and I don't think its fair to hold her to the same expectations as like heyden, epona, etc.
 
i want to park my vote on someone before i go to bed but there's genuinely so many people i would be content to chop today that i really just don't know who to go for
park your vote? we still have like 24 hours left

i really don’t want to play with emotions so i hope ace can come back when he’s more collected. still not convinced of the glow push though but he is seeming like the easiest player to beat on now so i’m gonna get off of him for now
 
btw, i love kallie's pm role message. it was so detailed haha

im much more interested in your current thoughts of everyone so far

I'm just trying to narrow who I would conceivably vote for today and what I look for in scum day 1. Loth give me no red flags and I don't think its fair to hold her to the same expectations as like heyden, epona, etc.

okay fair enough
 
Day ends in 12 hours, so you'll have time to vote in the morning Epona. I'm not sure it matters who you vote right now.
Post automatically merged:

I may have rounded a little bit, 10 hours and 17 minutes.

i think we have like 24 hours

park your vote? we still have like 24 hours left

i really don’t want to play with emotions so i hope ace can come back when he’s more collected. still not convinced of the glow push though but he is seeming like the easiest player to beat on now so i’m gonna get off of him for now

by park i mean like temporarily park with the hazard lights on
 
serious has explained her reads, ace hasnt. i’m really trying to get out the reasoning as to why teddy is voting for you but I don’t see it. I thought it was a reaction test but he’s still sticking with it

TMI is too much information. like does she know too much and that’s why there was the backing off
you make a lot of bold assumptions about my playstyle when you've never seen me play. why?

From what I can tell Aerious has made a lot of solid posts... with one caveat. They tend to 'Exaggerate' for lack of a better word when describing things. This comes off as a bit abrasive but I still think Aerious has made a lot of good reads (even if they were only about posts) and is following the game well, so I'm going to go ahead and say that they're probably a top town-lean for me.
i have a flair for the dramatique. i'll try to be more concise about what i mean from now on

found it, now I know you have experience and I find it really weird that all your scum leans are on "Easy targets" I feel like you aren't trying to work towards resolving which one to eliminate rather than, you felt compelled to do this as kind of like a defensive to appear town... and all your content is all over the place. nothing seems town helpful imo
i've chosen the targets i've leaned on from reactions and been consistent. go through past posts -- i was the first to mention sensei. my posts have entirely been town-helpful and trying to encourage discussion. easy targets? i'm not rushing to conclusions to appease you. my content isn't all over the place -- i've consistently said that i want to hear more from individuals and i want to gauge reactions. it feels like a lot of time was wasted on filler

on this note, why were you defensive when i mentioned wanting to hear more interaction between you and shawo?

btw, i love kallie's pm role message. it was so detailed haha
why are your posts primarily joking vs substance? what are your thoughts on everyone?
 
would anyone else vote for bianca? the last post i quoted from her is making me nervous lol... and she's playing the same as last game...
yes, i've been bugging her about reads bc i wanted to see if she'd trip over herself like last time and she did (not to mention her reads were inconclusive and she refused to actually out anybody as a scumlean lol)
 
what’s your answer on this. you know shawo off site right?

yes, we know each other off site

i don't follow ness' logic at all and i took issue with the way he was phrasing his reasoning to sus shawo because his terms didn't fit contextually and it seemed constructed. i like ness' pivot onto a townread of shawo but i need to think about it a bit more, ness is doing well under the pressure he got imo. but it could be that he thinks his only "out" from the statements he was making is to retreat entirely.

as for shawo, it will take more for me to say anything about his alignment. it surprised me that he seemed to put a LOT of effort into trying to lynch ness though i think some of his commentary is sticky despite the reasoning being ok, it was definitely unforgiving. at first i thought it was scummy how adamant he is with his convictions but it does seem like him to snap-read based off inconsistencies as either alignment.

if you asked me like a page ago or whatever i would not have remotely even seen it as TvT though so that should speak to how i think ness' recent posts changed for the better. my read on shawo can be summarised by that he's very clearly trying to preserve himself ("i sure as hell am not getting lynched"), also he's playing how he would as either alignment (1. mechanics 2. looking for holes in logic 3. strong tone)

can we talk about @SensaiGallade what were your thoughts on me based on exactly?
 
@toadsworthy i also want to point out that two people can say that my posts have been quality. you've openly admitted to not keeping up by not knowing my list. why focus on me for trying to get discussion going?
 
you make a lot of bold assumptions about my playstyle when you've never seen me play. why?

what assumptions do you think I've made? If you're talking about your standard like yea I expect you to be aware of how to play to some degree. I get its been years but its not like you're completely clueless on mafia

yes, i've been bugging her about reads bc i wanted to see if she'd trip over herself like last time and she did (not to mention her reads were inconclusive and she refused to actually out anybody as a scumlean lol)

you said before you were very aware of her scum play last game and that she was town to you. what changed and is this new behavior consistent with her play last game?
Post automatically merged:

this is true though..:) and I would take that as a genuine sincere and not coming from another place
can you give your updated reads
 
Why do you need my reads? it is meta that if I dont give my reads, I am scum?

This is my mantra all the time: You are all scum until proven innocent.
Post automatically merged:

do you means all (well Daniel and epona)
 
Back
Top