Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]

[Biancasbotique]

that is the game when I said that

Bianca while you're here, can you explain why in one your earlier posts you townread Shawo, then a few minutes later post merged and asked if Shawo vs Toads was scum vs scum distancing themselves?

Seems a bit contradictory if you really thought he was town, no? Wouldn't a scum vs town situation make more sense. I just don't understand how you achieved that conclusion so fast.

I just remember Shawo being passionate last time he was in game which is reminiscent of what he is doing now so townread..

then there's that whole Shawo vs. Toads discussion. I am always sus of players seeming to have arguments and OMGSUSIng each other as distancing strategy.

Of course, it will be contradictory as time goes on, opinions change.

 

[Damniel]

Sorry I’ve been inactive! For some reason I stopped getting notifications around page 18 so I just assumed everyone was being silent for whatever reason...

The game is always active in some capacity unless its night phase. it never ends lol

I think to reiterate, there's a pretty good mathematical reason as to why there are 4 mafia, any other assumptions about mafia roles is impossible to make though.

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

Daniel how many ML's does town have with 3 mafia w/ 2 kp.

Just do the numbers yourself.

It's not a whole discussion there's literally only 1 reasonable mafia number, and I trust radical6 as a mafia host.

I don't really care to talk about numbers right now. I think its 3 and you think its 4 but its not helpful until we start worldbuilding/knock out a scum to see what the KP is after that

 

[toadsworthy]

I also think it’s four mafia, from a host perspective I always look at best care and worst case scenario. In worst case scenario, mafia lynched day 1 with 3 mafia, this game is dreadful

 

[Aerious]

I think to reiterate, there's a pretty good mathematical reason as to why there are 4 mafia, any other assumptions about mafia roles is impossible to make though.

mathematical reasoning aside, claiming a ninja and roleblocker definitively is pretty bold

 

[Biancasbotique]

4 Mafia is too scumsided!

 

[Ace Marvel]

Yo ace, you know that I made a whole separate post where I talked about your reads, and then a second post where I talked about peoples reactions to your reads. Which are both valid things to analyze. Are you just ignoring the first post I made where I talked about your reads?

And I said, ask away! who do you want me to expand?

 

[shawo]

You're picking a weird hill to die on, you're making a conclusion that has no sound basis and telling me that it doesn't matter right now?

This IS important?? Why is it not to you?

The difference between 4 and 3 mafia shifts when mylo/lylo is, which changes the urgency of different days, determining the number ASAP matters.

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

Why do you think mafia doesn't read the game?

 

[Ace Marvel]

mathematical reasoning aside, claiming a ninja and roleblocker definitively is pretty bold

I understood that possible roles meant those plus others, that's were my comment came from.

 

[shawo]

4 Mafia is too scumsided!

Proof?

 

[Heyden]

that is the game when I said that


I just remember Shawo being passionate last time he was in game which is reminiscent of what he is doing now so townread..

then there's that whole Shawo vs. Toads discussion. I am always sus of players seeming to have arguments and OMGSUSIng each other as distancing strategy.

Of course, it will be contradictory as time goes on, opinions change.

Well duh, but it was literally in the same post. So you read through the whole Toads vs Shawo interaction, settled on a townread, then switched up within a few minutes. Did you actually read the thread or are you formulating thoughts based on others?

 

[Biancasbotique]

Well duh, but it was literally in the same post. So you read through the whole Toads vs Shawo interaction, settled on a townread, then switched up within a few minutes. Did you actually read the thread or are you formulating thoughts based on others?

 

[Damniel]

You're picking a weird hill to die on, you're making a conclusion that has no sound basis and telling me that it doesn't matter right now?

This IS important?? Why is it not to you?

The difference between 4 and 3 mafia shifts when mylo/lylo is, which changes the urgency of different days, determining the number ASAP matters.

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

Why do you think mafia doesn't read the game?

sure lets say its 4 why not. I value each day with importance so I think we just have different philosophies on the importance of it and that's fine. Doesn't matter to much for me until there's a flip so yea sorry

 

[toadsworthy]

You're picking a weird hill to die on, you're making a conclusion that has no sound basis and telling me that it doesn't matter right now?

This IS important?? Why is it not to you?

The difference between 4 and 3 mafia shifts when mylo/lylo is, which changes the urgency of different days, determining the number ASAP matters.

Post automatically merged: Jun 17, 2020

Why do you think mafia doesn't read the game?

who are you to determine what is important to each person? I think it’s most important to really hone in on possible lynched, but here you are trying to start a flame war about numbers. If it’s not a matter of deciding if mylo/LYLO is today then I think it’s not really important I think you are distracting again

 

[shawo]

sure lets say its 4 why not. I value each day with importance so I think we just have different philosophies on the importance of it and that's fine. Doesn't matter to much for me until there's a flip so yea sorry

This is a very different attitude than what you took on the last game.

If we lynched a town today, would you care tomorrow? What about the day after that? Were you just going to accept being surprised if mafia suddenly won because there were more than you thought?

I would say that it's characteristically unlike you to just, ignore such an important piece of information, especially one you could figure out by yourself.

 

[Ace Marvel]

Again I started a whole conversation by not understanding the basics of the English language.

 

[Biancasbotique]

Proof?

Maybe not? Would Day 4 MYLO a scumsided affair with 17 players?

 

[Damniel]

I just remember Shawo being passionate last time he was in game which is reminiscent of what he is doing now so townread..

which game are you referring to cuz Ness's game he was scum in

 

[Biancasbotique]

which game are you referring to cuz Ness's game he was scum in

okay you're right..i was wrong

 

[toadsworthy]

This is a very different attitude than what you took on the last game.

If we lynched a town today, would you care tomorrow? What about the day after that? Were you just going to accept being surprised if mafia suddenly won because there were more than you thought?

I would say that it's characteristically unlike you to just, ignore such an important piece of information, especially one you could figure out by yourself.

Or he was just annoyed that you are trying to start this conversation again when I also don’t think it’s that important to establish right now

 

[shawo]

who are you to determine what is important to each person? I think it’s most important to really hone in on possible lynched, but here you are trying to start a flame war about numbers. If it’s not a matter of deciding if mylo/LYLO is today then I think it’s not really important I think you are distracting again

We're playing a goal oriented game, so yes, I am able to make a sweeping generalization as to the things that are important to each player. I think your post was absolutely ridiculous, nothing I have said is taking away from our ability to decide on who's being lynched, nor does it distract from it. If I were to die no one else would bother worrying about the numbers, so it's incredibly important that people decide in advance what the numbers are?

If people were arguing about there being 3 vs 4 mafia in 4 mafia lylo what would you think?