Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]

blah reading, am i right?



ohhh the power i would yield!!! with all my chaos and memes combined i could just rule the mafia world.

@Ace Marvel should i expect to see photoshop make an appearance?


watch out before i accuse you of manipulating me :(

and yes, teddy, please bring back the conspiracy boards i live for those lol
 
with 17 players and only 1 KP i think we are probably dealing with an unholy quartet

I read the OP again to catch up, something about the fact that epona specifically thinks there is 4 mafia when there are only 3 roles listed under the mafia section of the roles is something that is not stirring right in my stomach.
 
I read the OP again to catch up, something about the fact that epona specifically thinks there is 4 mafia when there are only 3 roles listed under the mafia section of the roles is something that is not stirring right in my stomach.
hm.. i can personally see how there would be more than 3 given the amount of people. also is there such a thing as vanilla mafia?

they’re also possible roles so who knows
 
hm.. i can personally see how there would be more than 3 given the amount of people. also is there such a thing as vanilla mafia?

they’re also possible roles so who knows
I mean I think it's kind of obvious that those 3 roles under the mafia section are what we're dealing with, but it's bothering me that epona specifically said 4 mafia rather than 3... like, what basis was there for that.

Am I overthinking this? I can't get this out of my head
Post automatically merged:

btw it's 5 or 4

3 doesnt rly make sense
I dunno, Radical only listed 3 roles so I'm assuming it's 3? 2 goons sounds weird to me.

4 makes sense, but it's definitely not 5.
 
I'm work rn so post quality sux

5 is 3 ml
4 is 4 ml
3 is 5 ml

if u assume town has like, any number of prs. 3 mafia would be like flipping mafia and finding out u have terminal cancer.
why try. just die.

not 2 mention the 3 possible mafia roles super suck.

I mean really I would question why u would see that it was an open setup ,see3 mafia roles and go.

"yes, this is right, there are only these 3 mafia"
 
Actually the more I think about it, I can see how epona would naturally come to the conclusion that there could be 4 given previous games... but it's still kind of in my head.
 
I read the OP again to catch up, something about the fact that epona specifically thinks there is 4 mafia when there are only 3 roles listed under the mafia section of the roles is something that is not stirring right in my stomach.

there's 17 players total, 1 KP, and no surprise death mechanisms or TPs. i think it's likely that the scumteam is larger than 3. 3:14 seems unbalanced

anyway if i were scum (which i'm not, if i need to clarify that) i don't really know what i'd gain from revealing how many people are on the scumteam? surely that would just narrow down the POE for town lol
 
3 to 14 seems really town-sided... and if were gonna go that long, then kill me now tbh
 
Town
Vanilla Townie
Tracker
Watcher
Doctor
Jailkeeper

here r town roles

notice how most of these PRS are investigative/protective mix.unless the scumteam was 3 ninjas team would super suck.

I actually think it's most likely 2 be 5 due to how strong the potential town prs are
 
I would also assume that the roles weren't randomly doled out.

Although that would be how u do some closed games, I assume there was a bit of balance added 2 the mix in setup creation.

IE 12 town, 5 mafia, 8 town is forced to be VT, and the other 4 prs are randomly made.

Not that this really matters, but there's a chance this will b more scumhunting than not.
 
Back
Top