Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]
- Thread starter radical6
- Start date
Yeah okay that makes more sense. I'm more hung up on the fact that it only makes sense for there to be 2 goons?? I'd expect a framer type role for a 4 man mafia but it's Radical's call I guess
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
having a tracker and a watcher seems redundant so I would guess its only one of those
jail keeper is a fun role, so I'm eager to see how that plays out if its in the game, and having a doctor is kinda broken if KP is set at one. If we have a good doctor, then rip KP and this game goes longer and even more kill me
jail keeper is a fun role, so I'm eager to see how that plays out if its in the game, and having a doctor is kinda broken if KP is set at one. If we have a good doctor, then rip KP and this game goes longer and even more kill me
the latter
i don't want to talk about PRs too much but i think it's very safe to assume that at least one of the town PRs is not in the game for pure balance reasons
I'm just gonna end setup discussion there, at any point more than that we're just going to be arguing over random stuff.
let's just agree that it's...
"more than 3 mafia, can be any amount of prs"
and stop there.
ok bye now
let's just agree that it's...
"more than 3 mafia, can be any amount of prs"
and stop there.
Post automatically merged:
ok bye now
It's not a case in that I could see the value in hypothetical scum!Epona purposefully revealing there is 4 mafia, but it just seemed a bit jarring to state so confidently there's 4 mafia, I was under the assumption that it was a 3 man team with 2 KP, but I concede that since it's only 1 KP for whatever reason it makes more sense that there would be 4.
Lothitine
psst, @frogslimeofficial is funky fresh and cool
I agree, it’d be weird if it was only 3 yknow
Ace Marvel
Merry & Happy
It's happening again OH MY GLOB ahhhhh!
Post automatically merged:
Also the theme will be yearbook
i don't think dan is sus. he's gotten the conversation stated, which is getting us talking. this game could be extremely town-sided if we have both a jailkeeper and a doctor, so it's best to get things out in the open/out of the way. was entirely my bad, epona hit the nail on the head, i didn't take it as a joke
at what point do we rc? this should be a pretty easy game depending on what roles we have in town
having less than 4 would make no sense with the amount of town we have. 3 roles =/= 3 mafia. but as shawo said, it could be up to 5
i wouldn't say using the word 'probably' counts as a confident statement
anyway, between me reading the OP thoroughly and making a rational conclusion about the setup based on numbers, vs you clearly not reading the OP very closely at all and making a completely false assumption based on...nothing (??), i'm gonna go out on a limb and say you look worse here
regardless this conversation is redundant soooo
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
comes in to game
strictly talks about game setup
leaves while saying lets stop talking about set up
am i the only one that really doesn't like that?
Post automatically merged:
by strictly, I mean he only talked about game setup while here
Post automatically merged:
so shawl if you would like to contribute to any other conversation, I would appreciate it
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
no one was role-claiming, no one really insinuated that? did i miss something? no one should role claim, don't do it
i feel like it's something that used to be done a lot more when aerious and i were active in forum mafia (2014ish) but there's been a definite move away from roleclaiming without necessity since then. claiming vs not claiming is honestly comes down to a culture thing in different mafia communities but yeah in this case i would definitely not be advocating for RCing
it's dependent. if we have two protective roles who claim (doctor/jailkeeper), they could protect each other. you're right that it's too early to claim, but at what point do we talk about it?
i was asking at what point do we rc, not that we should rc now, just bc depending on the mixture of town roles, we may have a good chance at an easy game
Post automatically merged:
ya thx. i was asking genuinely, not saying we should all rc now. was also wondering bc of @PunchyTheCat mentioning that someone should rc earlier
I don't think it is redundant, and I don't think I made a false assumption at all actually. I find it odd you're deflecting on something that you claim is redundant (why care at all, then?), when all I asked was what made you think there was 4 mafia specifically.
How am I suddenly "worse" when I'm trying to question what made you think 4 mafia as opposed to there only being 3 roles in the semi-open setup? If your assumption is rational, how is mind not?
Similar threads
