Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]

OMGUS maybe, but I think its clear I have my doubts about shawo... and if he can throw out votes so can I

hopefully you wake up and see your faults, un vote, and apologize. so i'll wait

but i probably won't take my vote off
 
oh nice we're sussing people

unfortunately i've lost my WIM

who's the scummiest scum scum in all the land
Post automatically merged:

i agree with whoever said it's 3 mafia

4 mafia with 1 KP is better for balance imo

3 mafia with 2 KP is more viable for TBT
 
some people may town clear ness for not reading the OP and not knowing the KP, but i honestly wouldn’t clear him since I can see either alignment doing this (shawo in ness’s game did the same as maf) so no clears for you. his interaction with epona doesn't seem staged tough

punchy is wanting to solve but hasn’t been trying yet is not a good look

shawo popped in to talk about the setup and put some early votes. i don’t find talking about the setup that particularly helpful so i’m curious to know what his thoughts on the current interactions so far is. talking about the setup is an easy way to post without giving much substance, so when you take that away he’s only posted the votes and that he’s not sorry for it. shawo is a tough one to figure out so i’m gonna sit on this more but I'm not liking it

aerious seems to be confused on lingo and gives off inexperienced vibes which confuses me since she's played in the past. I'm also curious on her current thoughts on players so far since she's only talked about role claiming and filler, which I would expect an inexperienced player to talk about but she's not inexperienced. not liking this so far

after the ness and epona conversation I think Epona's replies made sense and doesn't seem to be giving off TMI yet. I think epona came out looking better than Ness did

Current thoughts from that. Everyone else I need to see more from, but these things stood out to me in particular. No hard reads yet
 
WIP but this will be the board this game

sAPvvNb.png
 
Damniel said:
aerious seems to be confused on lingo and gives off inexperienced vibes which confuses me since she's played in the past. I'm also curious on her current thoughts on players so far since she's only talked about role claiming and filler, which I would expect an inexperienced player to talk about but she's not inexperienced. not liking this so far
Click to expand...
i haven't played in 3-4 years, and even more recently (3 years MIN) was town of salem. i've never seen these words in tos, so i'm having to use the forum dictionary to keep up. i AM inexperienced after 6 years of not playing forum mafia. you have a pretty high standard of what to expect from me compared to the patience you've shown to other people. even epona faced a similar scenario last game after years and can understand where i'm coming from. she even mentioned that we used to rc early and 1 town would take lead. you can not like this all you want, playing 6 years ago isn't sufficient to me being an experienced player. it's a complete logical fallacy

if you want my thoughts so far, i think ness and epona are inno. both brought up valid points. ness thought 2kp, but it was prior to radical6 changing the rules. this rules out ness as maf imo

right now what i'm keeping track of is mafia numbers. we have no idea how many there are rn/what roles. shawo seems concerned with the same thing. i don't think he's maf, i just think he's busy and trying to contribute as much as possible, while still being a troll. as much as people are trying to negate the importance of setup, it changes the entire game based on what town and maf both have.

i don't know what to think of toad/punchy. they could be guilty, they could be inno. there's also people who haven't really contributed thus far. it's hard for me to rule things out when i'm trying to gauge reactions

keep in mind that there's 3-4 maf based on numbers and the swap to 2kp
 
Aerious said:
i haven't played in 3-4 years, and even more recently (3 years MIN) was town of salem. i've never seen these words in tos, so i'm having to use the forum dictionary to keep up. i AM inexperienced after 6 years of not playing forum mafia. you have a pretty high standard of what to expect from me compared to the patience you've shown to other people. even epona faced a similar scenario last game after years and can understand where i'm coming from. she even mentioned that we used to rc early and 1 town would take lead. you can not like this all you want, playing 6 years ago isn't sufficient to me being an experienced player. it's a complete logical fallacy

if you want my thoughts so far, i think ness and epona are inno. both brought up valid points. ness thought 2kp, but it was prior to radical6 changing the rules. this rules out ness as maf imo

right now what i'm keeping track of is mafia numbers. we have no idea how many there are rn/what roles. shawo seems concerned with the same thing. i don't think he's maf, i just think he's busy and trying to contribute as much as possible, while still being a troll. as much as people are trying to negate the importance of setup, it changes the entire game based on what town and maf both have.

i don't know what to think of toad/punchy. they could be guilty, they could be inno. there's also people who haven't really contributed thus far. it's hard for me to rule things out when i'm trying to gauge reactions

keep in mind that there's 3-4 maf based on numbers and the swap to 2kp
Click to expand...

It's okay, I'm noob supreme, ask anything related to terms and someone will help. :)
 
I mean I’m flattered you think I’m town for the KP thing but I agree with what Dan said in that you shouldn’t clear me off that alone lol. You’re def bloating my ego @Aerious but is that really the only reason you’re townleaning me?

Also I stand by my comments about Daniel, unless he’s seriously evolved from being a big time champ I think he’s coming from a. Town mindset. I also concede I like Epona’s responses, I respect the clap back at me there, it shows some guts👏

To be honest nobody is really pinging me as suspicious right now but that’s also in part that I’m typing things out in mobile and I’m passing out, Shawo is purposefully being a heel for some reason and I don’t see the motive behind it?

anyway that’s all from me I’m going zzzz
 
I don't see Shawo as mafia, but that vote for me was uncalled for, I would like to know their reasoning, and I'll work from that.
Epona is giving me town vibes, which is scary, since she is so good at blending.
Bianca is always town lock for me, unless proven guilty.
Toads, Ness and Punchy are safe from elimination, so is Mayor Leaf, but might be a little bias.
 
N e s s said:
I mean I’m flattered you think I’m town for the KP thing but I agree with what Dan said in that you shouldn’t clear me off that alone lol. You’re def bloating my ego @Aerious but is that really the only reason you’re townleaning me?

Also I stand by my comments about Daniel, unless he’s seriously evolved from being a big time champ I think he’s coming from a. Town mindset. I also concede I like Epona’s responses, I respect the clap back at me there, it shows some guts👏
Click to expand...
i'm not clearing you based on that alone. it's my opinion as of current, that's prone to change. you mistaking the rules prior to radical6 changing them means that you more than likely had no knowledge of it. that's the sole reason why in my mind, you're currently inno

it's really hard for me to say what i think definitively. too many people haven't responded.

also not fully understanding why dan is directly coming for me because i didn't understand that something was a joke (epona was right, it rly didn't seem that way) and bc i haven't played forum mafia in 6 years. either he's town and gauging reactions to take lead later in the game, or looking to plant seeds of doubt as mafia. i'm leaning town, but as i've said, i have no clue. i think it's too early to make a definitive assumption on anything besides ness due to people not posting
Post automatically merged:

and by this i mean that i believe daniel to either be blue or to be mafia
 
Aerious said:
ness thought 2kp, but it was prior to radical6 changing the rules. this rules out ness as maf imo
Click to expand...

I wouldn't be so quick to clear anyone this early tbh

Aerious said:
you have a pretty high standard of what to expect from me compared to the patience you've shown to other people
Click to expand...

true I do have high standards for towniness, but I will let you settle in more since you're sinking your teeth into players now. Not sure what patience you think Ive shown to others tho

Ace Marvel said:
Punchy are safe from elimination, so is Mayor Leaf, but might be a little bias
Click to expand...

What has punchy done? and explain your bias on mayor more please
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

ILoveAnimalCrossing123
Bell Tree Forums Profile Inventory Item + TBT Bell Giveaway Contest Game (kinda but it is also kinda a game)
Replies
4
Views
215
-Blue-
-Blue-
C
Review the Video Game Above You!
Replies
11
Views
287
Midoriya
Midoriya
N e s s
Mafia TBT Mafia - Darkest Dungeon (Cancelled)
Replies
15
Views
950
N e s s
N e s s
C
Write Me a Short Story About...
Replies
1
Views
120
CoolJhon
CoolJhon
X
Fantasy Life 2: The Girl Who Steals Time question
Replies
7
Views
639
stitchmaker
S
Back
Top