Mafia Love Letter TBT Redux Micromafia (6 Player Mafia)

[Geoni]

LMAO

Are you seriously gonna try to suggest that I kill the guy who left last night with this, reasonable strong and confident in his suspicion of you, and was unconfirmed




No, I, under no circumstances, would kill Runeraider. He was unconfirmed, sussed you, and gave me the only townlean I'd had all game. In fact, if I was scum I would have killed Antonio. He sussed you, but was wavering in his sus on you, making him dangerous to me, and was pretty much confirmed, moreover, I could have hid behind the kill, pointing his convictions towards you while quietly sneaking away behind Rune's townread of me, giving me the two votes I would have needed for the final ML

You're quite clearly panicking with the CAPS line of your thought to be easy win slipping away from you

Also, reference for Rune being more sus of Dad than Antonio was: Antonio's last post


- - - Post Merge - - -



Punchy is comfirmed.

But again, in what world as mafia do I kill the single person who's townleaning me? Dad's pretty clearly scared of me and Rune getting out our two votes faster than him and whoever would be left if he DIDNT kill him

- - - Post Merge - - -



Dad, the only point you have against me is that I was wrong, and you were happy to follow me in my wrongness

If you're going to persist in stating that F3 is better for scum than F4 (which it isn't, regardless of NL, pure math, even accounting for handmaid, has F4 better for scum I'm pretty sure) and that I would risk a 50% chance of death to get it, fine

#1) You killed Rune because they were the only person who had something to say about what is admittedly the only suspect thing I've done this game and you had that quote ready for use in a bull**** case you're trying to storm up here.

#2) Long-winded explanation of what you 'would have done' is something scum do to create doubt and try and reinforce meta that they're aware of but in doing so they make it more obvious that they killed the person they just killed for a reason, and your whole post here is a round-about justification for the idea that I would kill the person who had the best reason to sus me, which is not a smart thing to do because it brings attention to that person's posts towards me.

#3) You actually think I'm panicking in all-caps? As if I'm afraid to face off with you Dolby? I guess you learned nothing from Call Ships to Port and how I went at it with Kayla.

But again, in what world as mafia do I kill the single person who's townleaning me? Dad's pretty clearly scared of me and Rune getting out our two votes faster than him and whoever would be left if he DIDNT kill him

But here's the real screw-up you just made in this post: with three people left, why are you trying to reference that speed is the reason I killed someone when if two people plurality vote me, even if I beat them to the chase, would it matter when it's 1 v 2? No. If this moment doesn't clarify it for Antonio idk what can.

'I have only one point against you' ...lmao, just read my ISO Antonio, I've made plenty, especially before I got swayed into voting Vanessa because this isn't the town meta I've known from her (lurking/pocketing). The baity question #3, the way that whole RQS was written, Dolby's building of a massive case on Vanessa in order to take attention off him because she gave him that opportunity, the fact that he got a mislynch out of it, the fact that he's trying to get me lynched over a nightkill he's trying to spin as one I would make and one he would never make.

- - - Post Merge - - -

"Dad is clearly scared of me."

...

 

[Dolby]

Everything about that is clear BS

1. ?You killed Rune because they were the only one to sus me?
...
If I was scum, I could have very easily killed Antonio or Punchy and persuaded Rune to vote with me against you. Moreover, me killing somebody because they pointed out something against a town member just plain doesn?t make sense. There is no reason for me to try to convert Antonio to my side as mafia when I already had Rune

This comes VERY close to being a straight up confession, and frankly, I think you voted Rune because you were scared that me and him would both vote against you, as I already said

2. Alright then, if I killed Rune for a reason, what?s my ****ing reason. Yours is clear: he?s not in the bottom two and is the one person in the game who is confident in his sus on you. In addition, he CLEARED me, meaning he?d probably vote for you in you vs me. Can?t go about leaving that person alive in F4

3. Wtf is your point here

First of all there are FOUR people alive, not three. A 1v2 isn?t even a possibility here, and the scum chat in Korean War makes it clear that you are very concerned about being the first to vote, and me and Rune would know it two, being here earlier than at least Punchy. Besides, with Antonio and Lunchy alive without Rune here, you have a much better shot at winning SINCE HE WAS GOING TO VOTE YOU

Again, why the **** would I kill Rune? You?re trying to make this look like a big grand conspiracy: Dolby killed the one guy who both townleaned him (cleared even) and had Dad as his top sus for the sole purpose of framing me. Clearly Rune has no value to him left alive, so he allowed Antonio and Punchy continuing to side with Dad (Antonio?s stance was ambiguous, but Punchy def sussed me), thus leaving all three other INDICATED votes against him. A master strategist. Well, sorry to break it to your attacked little heart, but you had all the reason to kill the guy who would most likely vote you at the start of day AND LITERALLY CLEARED THE GUY YOU WERE TRYING TO LYNCH

- - - Post Merge - - -

Again, that kill should be making it blatantly obvious

 

[Geoni]

...I forgot punchy was in this game lmao

- - - Post Merge - - -

Does this look like concern to vote first?

 

[Dolby]

...I forgot punchy was in this game lmao

- - - Post Merge - - -

Does this look like concern to vote first?

Yrah, I get that you forgot and I’m not gonna hold it against you. Point stands though that line of attack is invalid

I don’t remember if you were camping the thread at 7, should have made a note of it

 

[Geoni]

This comes VERY close to being a straight up confession, and frankly, I think you voted Rune because you were scared that me and him would both vote against you, as I already said

lol how does that come close to being a confession that's such a reach

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yrah, I get that you forgot and I’m not gonna hold it against you. Point stands though that line of attack is invalid

I don’t remember if you were camping the thread at 7, should have made a note of it

You always under-react when I catch you on your bull****.

 

[Dolby]

lol how does that come close to being a confession that's such a reach

THats pretty much the exact reason why I’m sure you killed him

 

[Geoni]

"You killed Rune because they were the only one to sus me."

You trying to spin this statement into being 'VERY close to being a confession' is laughably reachy and I can't wait for even RUNE to voteswitch to your ass because that's clearly you trying very hard to make it seem like I slipped somehow because you need to drive this wagon home. What I was saying with that statement is this: it wasn't my main reason for suspecting you, but I was asserting at the time that Bianca gave you the baron card because she was balancing with the cards and it wasn't random, and that is indeed my most un-townlike moment in this game because it seems really pushy, and Rune was the one to point it out. I needed to point out how you were locked and loaded with the quotes regarding this moment as soon as Rune died, which does suggest you are making the mistake of trying to utilize a framing kill on me which tbh is pretty sad, but I also realize that Rune, after Vanessa died, was only suspected by me and just for a moment. Nobody else really found him anything but townlike and that puts him in the same category as Antonio and Punchy, which you are asserting that you would kill instead for that reason.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I should also point out that Antonio said at the end of the last game that he wasn't going to trust me again so I know you remember that and you have been holding onto how he doesn't trust me as town even after reading my meta in Call Ships to Port.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh and speaking of Punchy, looking back, he said he wasn't going to be able to post again until later in day 2 so I vote for the extension to 48 hours.

 

[Dolby]

"You killed Rune because they were the only one to sus me."

You trying to spin this statement into being 'VERY close to being a confession' is laughably reachy and I can't wait for even RUNE to voteswitch to your ass because that's clearly you trying very hard to make it seem like I slipped somehow because you need to drive this wagon home. What I was saying with that statement is this: it wasn't my main reason for suspecting you, but I was asserting at the time that Bianca gave you the baron card because she was balancing with the cards and it wasn't random, and that is indeed my most un-townlike moment in this game because it seems really pushy, and Rune was the one to point it out. I needed to point out how you were locked and loaded with the quotes regarding this moment as soon as Rune died, which does suggest you are making the mistake of trying to utilize a framing kill on me which tbh is pretty sad, but I also realize that Rune, after Vanessa died, was only suspected by me and just for a moment. Nobody else really found him anything but townlike and that puts him in the same category as Antonio and Punchy, which you are asserting that you would kill instead for that reason.

First of all, Rune is dead

Second of all, yeah, that’s definitely your most sus portion of the game so far, with the exeception of just accepting the Vanessa wagon

Thirdly, Rune wasn’t really talked about, but he occupied a place distinct from Lunchy and Antonio (the two locks). You sussed, I listed him as one of my two suspects, Vanessa listed him as one of her two suspects. He wasn’t going to be lynched today I don’t think, but unlike Antonio and Lunchy, he was an option. There is no way that he is functionally there equivalent

Fourth of all I DID NOT COME IN LOCKED AND LOADED WITH QUOTES. My post (#139) was not a case made AGAINST you, but made IN RESPONSE TO YOUR ASSERTOKNS AND ACCUSATIONS, specifically those made in #137. Thus, the post ad a whole LITERALLY COULDNT have been pre-prepared as it relied partially on your post (#137) (specifically that I’d leave Antonio with hammer). Said assertion is patently false. Also, if I had those quotes in hand before, which is probably what your are planning on saying next, why would I wait so long to post them, and why did they go so well against #137. They were organic posts dude

 

[Geoni]

I meant Antonio not Rune*

- - - Post Merge - - -

First of all, Rune is dead

Second of all, yeah, that’s definitely your most sus portion of the game so far, with the exeception of just accepting the Vanessa wagon

Thirdly, Rune wasn’t really talked about, but he occupied a place distinct from Lunchy and Antonio (the two locks). You sussed, I listed him as one of my two suspects, Vanessa listed him as one of her two suspects. He wasn’t going to be lynched today I don’t think, but unlike Antonio and Lunchy, he was an option. There is no way that he is functionally there equivalent

Fourth of all I DID NOT COME IN LOCKED AND LOADED WITH QUOTES. My post (#139) was not a case made AGAINST you, but made IN RESPONSE TO YOUR ASSERTOKNS AND ACCUSATIONS, specifically those made in #137. Thus, the post ad a whole LITERALLY COULDNT have been pre-prepared as it relied partially on your post (#137) (specifically that I’d leave Antonio with hammer). Said assertion is patently false. Also, if I had those quotes in hand before, which is probably what your are planning on saying next, why would I wait so long to post them, and why did they go so well against #137. They were organic posts dude

"They were organic posts" ...like, my god, you're trying really hard to seem town here that you have to assert that you are sounding townlike instead of just waiting for others to read them as such.

 

[Dolby]

Also, if you had cared to read #139 in full rather than just skim it, you might perchance to glance upon that Antonio was warming up to you in his last post before what should have been EoN. Rune was clearly far more against you, and Antonio seemed to be letting his prejudice go

 

[Geoni]

Thirdly, Rune wasn’t really talked about, but he occupied a place distinct from Lunchy and Antonio (the two locks). You sussed, I listed him as one of my two suspects, Vanessa listed him as one of her two suspects. He wasn’t going to be lynched today I don’t think, but unlike Antonio and Lunchy, he was an option. There is no way that he is functionally there equivalent

But by the end of the day did you really find Rune all that sus? You're really trying hard to assert that you kill people who are townread when you're maf when in reality you are a good enough player to kill differently depending on the scenario and you clearly evaluated that a frame kill could work here if all you had to convince were Antonio and Punchy.

 

[Dolby]

I meant Antonio not Rune*

- - - Post Merge - - -



"They were organic posts" ...like, my god, you're trying really hard to seem town here that you have to assert that you are sounding townlike instead of just waiting for others to read them as such.

Ok, so you are going down the path that I kept those posts in my back pocket (or I just hadn’t finished my collecting) and waited for you to respond before integrating your own post into my case

Say the words back to me and smile for the recording please

 

[Geoni]

Also I have read that post in full and Antonio states 'but I may be thinking that's wrong' so how was that a clear 'warming up to me'?

 

[Dolby]

But by the end of the day did you really find Rune all that sus? You're really trying hard to assert that you kill people who are townread when you're maf when in reality you are a good enough player to kill differently depending on the scenario and you clearly evaluated that a frame kill could work here if all you had to convince were Antonio and Punchy.

No, I didn’t find Rune all that sus, however I was of the opinion that if he was scum trying to turn us all against you he would kill either Punchy or myself, which is why I posted #130. He was def less sus than you, but he wasn’t clear

Again, why would or should I kill a guy that townleans me in the hope of convincing somebody else who sussed me that I’m town

 

[Geoni]

Ok, so you are going down the path that I kept those posts in my back pocket (or I just hadn’t finished my collecting) and waited for you to respond before integrating your own post into my case

I'm fully on the path. I'm so on that path I'd put an information plaque up about it behind the rails.

 

[Dolby]

Also I have read that post in full and Antonio states 'but I may be thinking that's wrong' so how was that a clear 'warming up to me'?

He was acknowledging a townie aspect of your play

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm fully on the path. I'm so on that path I'd put an information plaque up about it behind the rails.

Ok good

 

[Geoni]

No, I didn’t find Rune all that sus, however I was of the opinion that if he was scum trying to turn us all against you he would kill either Punchy or myself, which is why I posted #130. He was def less sus than you, but he wasn’t clear

Again, why would or should I kill a guy that townleans me in the hope of convincing somebody else who sussed me that I’m town

But with Punchy being autoclear after not being on and there being a kill, that leaves Antonio, and according to you Antonio was 'warming up to me.' Meaning if not me or Punchy, he'd come around to sussing you. But again, I repeat, you don't kill the same way every time you're mafia.

 

[Dolby]

But with Punchy being autoclear after not being on and there being a kill, that leaves Antonio, and according to you Antonio was 'warming up to me.' Meaning if not me or Punchy, he'd come around to sussing you. But again, I repeat, you don't kill the same way every time you're mafia.

Oh hell yeah I don’t, but Rune is such a patently bad kill for me. Almost as bad as killing you

Also, yeah, Antonio was going to end up sussing me, it was obvious and that’s the whole point of why killing Rune and leaving Antonio and Punchy alive would be a bad idea for scum me

Maybe I’m misinterpreting you here

 

[Geoni]

Ok, so you are going down the path that I kept those posts in my back pocket (or I just hadn’t finished my collecting) and waited for you to respond before integrating your own post into my case

Say the words back to me and smile for the recording please

I mean...there's nothing unfeasible about this at all. How you're confident enough to get all smart about it with a cute little one-liner like that is beyond me. That's exactly how it plays into a framekill.

 

[Dolby]

Or are you trying to turn it around saying that Antonio is the guy who townleans me. that’s Rune and only Rune