I still have a feeling that Rhino is mafia so I am voting toads for this rounds. I am also looking at Ghostkid and Antonio for not voting the cycle. They could be hiding as mafia. Dad is suspicious because he is very active at sussing when he is mafia. Punchy seems his townie self.
So far the only townie is me.
I'M NOT ACTIVE AT SUSPECTING PEOPLE AS TOWN? THAT'S WHY YOU SAY I AM SUSPICIOUS?
- - - Post Merge - - -
This is my tier list, pretty simple because this is such an insubstantial game but
Bianca - bizzare opening, then said she is suspicious of Dad and Punchy but 'voting Rhino just in case he is newbie mafia' which is super lazy and ridiculous because your level of skill has nothing to do with whether you rand mafia or not, Dolby clarified he's purely randomizing this game. And then there's her last post which she just...did nothing with. She found some arbitrary reason to suspect everyone and say she only sees herself as townie which shows no effort to solve the game which as town she slowly but eventually does as people become clear, at least when we had larger games.
Antonio - Something just isn't sitting right with the way it felt like he was avoiding conflict with me, I think that's the only reason he wasn't also casting doubt on me or questioning me. His answer to the power role question seemed kinda odd. He repeats the theme of 'disliking inactivity' in the answer to the next question in my RQS too. He then ends the RQS answering that he agrees that not much is coming from them and then proceeds to say 'should I supply more questions?' which on the surface seems helpful but contradicts the point about RQS not working in this gamestate. If he flips mafia I'll consider this as an example of RQS answers having the potential for being AI.
Ghostkid - Hasn't provided much. As I've mentioned before I didn't find his doubleposting moment to be super AI but if I was forced to find AI in it I would at least say it shows a lack of self-monitoring and caution that mafia might have and he's played on the forum enough times to know it can be funky. Not a ton of commitment but that's also NAI, so it's pretty frustrating. He doesn't seem to be trying to kill off townie though so I don't want to throw the word coasting at him, because scummy coasting is when somebody doesn't do much but still votes and tries to reduce town's numbers while not dying themselves.
Toads/Rhino - hard to really know what I want from this slot atm, Rhino gave me little to go off as usual but it was at least considerate that he was like 'you might want to replace JT' which seems like a concern for numbers from a town perspective and he wouldn't need to ask that in thread if JT was his partner so I'm not seeing the JT/Rhino equity here. I think Toads is demanding activity from people in a way that reminds me of him as town but it's not impossible for him to do this as scum at all. I may look back at his past scum games for sanity if Bianca is lynched correctly and we're at F3 but I feel kinda decent about this slot atm.
So I'm at Bianca/Antonio team.
