Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

[tae]

Maybe because I have literally never played this before and have 0 idea how I'm supposed to do this

you 180'd.

first you claim you're not a noob and you know what you're doing.

now you claim you've no idea what you're doing because you are a noob.

 

[Aronthaer]

would u mind linking us to some of the other games you've played. i think that qualifies as publicly available text evidence.

I haven't played any other games...? what are you asking?

- - - Post Merge - - -

you 180'd.

first you claim you're not a noob and you know what you're doing.

now you claim you've no idea what you're doing because you are a noob.

Because, once again, I thought party mafia and this were practically the same. I claimed to be experienced because I thought it was the gmae I've played literally hundreds of times. now I know it's not, and I realize: I am a noob at this. a total noob.

 

[Chrystina]

okay.. so @aron, flip flopping with being pro and being noob at this.
said you're playing as "50% mafia" like what?
APPEAL TO EMOTION LIKE CRAZY. i think this tops ness actually.
idk. i really don't know what to think. crazy 3rd party most likely.

 

[Aronthaer]

okay.. so @aron, flip flopping with being pro and being noob at this.
said you're playing as "50% mafia" like what?
APPEAL TO EMOTION LIKE CRAZY. i think this tops ness actually.
idk. i really don't know what to think. crazy 3rd party most likely.

OMG.

"playing like part mafia" was a tyo haha. I meant to say I'm "Playing like party mafia." as in, I thought this and 20-minute mafia were nearly the same and then I realized "LOL nope I'm a noob."

 

[tae]

i need to shower, to get ready to head to the airport.

but as stated above.

if aron's claim for doctor is not correct and someone out there is the real doctor.

do. not. counter. claim. him. do. not. out. yourself.

 

[Aronthaer]

i need to shower, to get ready to head to the airport.

but as stated above.

if aron's claim for doctor is not correct and someone out there is the real doctor.

do. not. counter. claim. him. do. not. out. yourself.

aye. let me die, I can take it.

 

[toadsworthy]

okay.. so @aron, flip flopping with being pro and being noob at this.
said you're playing as "50% mafia" like what?
APPEAL TO EMOTION LIKE CRAZY. i think this tops ness actually.
idk. i really don't know what to think. crazy 3rd party most likely.

idk, he has been back and forth on mafia and on town, never said anything about 3rd parties really, even when we started bringing it up. Part of me wants to believe everything he is saying and then I laugh at the dumb ploys at making us try to think he was "toying with our minds", but I mean doesn't make a difference because the mafia is just gonna shoot him down now anyways smh

 

[Aronthaer]

or you could protect me since there's a 100% chance maf's gonna kill me

- - - Post Merge - - -

on the bright side, I doubt the Mafia's gonna kill anybody this round. We all know they'll kill me and whoever the doctor is will protect me (or should because who else is the Maf gonna gun down?)

 

[Cory]

I might yell.

 

[Arstotzkan]

or you could protect me since there's a 100% chance maf's gonna kill me

- - - Post Merge - - -

on the bright side, I doubt the Mafia's gonna kill anybody this round. We all know they'll kill me and whoever the doctor is will protect me (or should because who else is the Maf gonna gun down?)

But:

A. Couldn't you protect yourself
B. You realize the mafia would have to be moronic to shoot someone that's 99% chance protected, right? Why would they shoot you?

- - - Post Merge - - -

On a side note: I've been in the wrong class for the past 30 minutes and Im sad now

 

[Cory]

Why are you assuming there is more than 1 Doctor

 

[Aronthaer]

But:

A. Couldn't you protect yourself? Not everyone believes I'm the doctor. I'm saying in the case that I'm not, the real doctor would protect me.
B. You realize the mafia would have to be moronic to shoot someone that's 99% chance protected, right? Why would they shoot you? Fair point. unless they think the doctor won't protect me for whatever reason (Maybe they followed your logic as well and figured they didn't have to protect me? then Maf figures, "Hey, he probably won't be protected, let's shoot him."

. .

 

[Kirbystarship]

Going to ask why you voted for no lynch

##Vote Heyden

- - - Post Merge - - -

##Unvote

##Vote: No lynch

Why did you vote for Nl? If we do no lynch then we can't find out who the scums are. Of course if we do No lynch then we don't do a miss lynch. And we are giving the Mafia a chance to kill one of are townies with out lynching. I think we should do a Rl because you could be a scum for afew reasons.
-you say that you know how mafia games works then you say that you don't know how it works and you are a noob at it.
-You want to lynch a inactive player who knows one of them could be a townie or they are in different timezones.

 

[Chrystina]

oh my god. @aron - you claimed.
yeah, you ****ed up. but now you're just looking scummy as hell for trying to take it back and mess with our heads.
I HIGHLY doubt there is 2 doctors, has that ever even happened? so what are you trying to do here.

 

[Cory]

Next person that emotionally appeals I'm voting for

 

[Aronthaer]

Going to ask why you voted for no lynch



Why did you vote for Nl? If we do no lynch then we can't find out who the scums are. Of course if we do No lynch then we don't do a miss lynch. And we are giving the Mafia a chance to kill one of are townies with out lynching. I think we should do a Rl because you could be a scum for afew reasons.
-you say that you know how mafia games works then you say that you don't know how it works and you are a noob at it.
-You want to lynch a inactive player who knows one of them could be a townie or they are in different timezones.

I changed my mind on lynching Heyden, he seems okay. I don't want to lynch anyone without evidence so I voted for no lynch until I can get some evidence that someone's the mafia, at which point I'll ##unvote.

 

[Arstotzkan]

I wish. sadly, no.

You said here you couldn't protect yourself though, right? What gives?

 

[Aronthaer]

oh my god. @aron - you claimed.
yeah, you ****ed up. but now you're just looking scummy as hell for trying to take it back and mess with our heads.
I HIGHLY doubt there is 2 doctors, has that ever even happened? so what are you trying to do here.

Never claimed there were two doctors. that sounds insane. I said that it's POSSIBLE that I'm not the doctor.

I don't want to mess with any townies but unfortunately if I want to throw off and confuse the maf you guys are collateral damage.

- - - Post Merge - - -

You said here you couldn't protect yourself though, right? What gives?

I said I couldn't protect myself two nights in a row.

 

[Kirbystarship]

oh my god. @aron - you claimed.
yeah, you ****ed up. but now you're just looking scummy as hell for trying to take it back and mess with our heads.
I HIGHLY doubt there is 2 doctors, has that ever even happened? so what are you trying to do here.

Yes some games can have 2 doctors. The first TBT mafia game had 2 doctors want me to link it to you?

 

[Curry]

Catching up on a phone is hard. I read one page and two new ones appear.

As for an update, I went to bed right before when Daniel asked me to speak so I figured I'd respond now. As far as leads to go on, I don't know the "meta" of TBT, so this is based purely off of what I've seen in this thread alone. I'll just respond to claims.

No one really seems scummy to me to be honest, Kat seems aggressive but knowing Kat outsidd mafia I know she can be kind of aggressive. Ness seems to be always lynched d1 at TBT but he was trying to get information too I think.

I'm still catching up so I've got several pages to read still but I'll respond to more once I get back from class for the day.