Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

[Arstotzkan]

I'm really quiet, even I know that. I'm really not too confident in any reads I gathered earlier. Whenever I had an attempt typed out, I'd refresh the page in another tab to see if someone beat me to it. Someone always does. Didn't wanna make it seem like I was just hopping onto someone else's opinion. That's why when Tardis mentioned the new members, I knew only me or the other two would reply.

Any reads, even if rehashed, are better than none. Mind sharing what you're thinking rn?

 

[tae]

how i feel towards alexi

- so far, she's been active as usual in games.
- her meta seems to be similar to the games i've played with her, the only difference i see right away is she's more aggressive and quick to accuse this time around. she's tunneled but she keeps bouncing back and forth between "aron cannot be trusted" and "yes i agree aron might actually be dumb townie."

i'm uncertain honestly, she;s been flip floppy and a little back an forth on the tunnel of aron and the "maybe he's actually town" but i can't honestly say i feel like she's legit scum. i feel like she's a bit all over the place but i don't think she's scum for not settling with aron's claim. i myself don't even feel right with arons role claim, but i'm not as experienced as most players here and i don't know the benefits of waiting and seeing how the game plays out after night 1.

so i guess in the end, yeah her flip flopping around is alarming but this game has proven to be a bit chaotic so far and i think the way alexi reads is similar to the way toad reads. a little all over the place, but they usually try to read with good intentions. if that makes sense.

i'm not saying there isn't a chance she could be scum, because she might be. but from games i've played with her in the past i can say i don't think she's acting all that differently than games before hand. but meta isn't hard to change i don't think. maybe for some but not all.

2. How do you react under pressure? Pretty well I guess? I'm not really under pressure a lot.
3. Do you prefer to play as town or mafia? So far I'm always town ): so I can't say which one I'd prefer.
4. What are you going to be known to do this game? Get better at my reads hopefully. Be active, as usual.

the only thing that makes me curious is this. because i mean, i know that feeling bc i've only been scum once and it was in an unofficial game but at the same time i feel like sometimes the simple answering style of "idk bc i've always been town." makes me anxious. i know a few others answered this ?'ve only ever been town." as well which makes me always question whether or not it would be true for this game.

 

[Arstotzkan]

how i feel towards alexi

- so far, she's been active as usual in games.
- her meta seems to be similar to the games i've played with her, the only difference i see right away is she's more aggressive and quick to accuse this time around. she's tunneled but she keeps bouncing back and forth between "aron cannot be trusted" and "yes i agree aron might actually be dumb townie."

i'm uncertain honestly, she;s been flip floppy and a little back an forth on the tunnel of aron and the "maybe he's actually town" but i can't honestly say i feel like she's legit scum. i feel like she's a bit all over the place but i don't think she's scum for not settling with aron's claim. i myself don't even feel right with arons role claim, but i'm not as experienced as most players here and i don't know the benefits of waiting and seeing how the game plays out after night 1.

so i guess in the end, yeah her flip flopping around is alarming but this game has proven to be a bit chaotic so far and i think the way alexi reads is similar to the way toad reads. a little all over the place, but they usually try to read with good intentions. if that makes sense.

i'm not saying there isn't a chance she could be scum, because she might be. but from games i've played with her in the past i can say i don't think she's acting all that differently than games before hand. but meta isn't hard to change i don't think. maybe for some but not all.



the only thing that makes me curious is this. because i mean, i know that feeling bc i've only been scum once and it was in an unofficial game but at the same time i feel like sometimes the simple answering style of "idk bc i've always been town." makes me anxious. i know a few others answered this ?'ve only ever been town." as well which makes me always question whether or not it would be true for this game.

I get the general feeling from this that you don't want to lynch Alexi, right? Who would you lynch instead?

 

[PandaDarling]

Any reads, even if rehashed, are better than none. Mind sharing what you're thinking rn?

I strongly agree to this and this goes for EVERYONE (mainly new/ inexperienced players) its definitely ok to do post your reads even if they just go with someone else's, posting them even if they match other players opinions helps us know where you stand and so we can make progress in weeding out who seems scummy and who doesn't, especially later when we can match up what someone is saying at this point and how it correlates with the information that we'll get from lynches and night kills. i know at times it may seem daunting to say it over and over but as long as you put it in your own words and explain why you agree or disagree then its going to help us very much, but if you stay silent cause you think you don't have to post it cause someone already has then you just stay a big question mark to the rest of us and we don't know how to move on and who to question or go after.

also wanted to add to Aron and New Peeps. It's ok to be wrong, i don't know if anyone else feels like this but when i began i was kinda scared to post/ make reads cause i didnt want to be wrong.... we are all going to be wrong at some point, this is a guessing game in a lot of ways so of course we aren't going to get it right 100% of the time, as long as you use your mind and make educated guesses and play to the best of your ability then your gonna help us win, and if we get it wrong every once in awhile then it still helps us in the long run.

 

[tae]

I get the general feeling from this that you don't want to lynch Alexi, right? Who would you lynch instead?

i don't think alexi is a good lynch candidate as of right now, no.
i also don't think aron is a good lynch candidate either because it's too much of a risk.

as far as heavy scum reads i don't have much to go off of.

i feel iffy about m3ow, mostly because she was so aggressive about anyone questioning aron and claiming if we set out eyes on him she'll be aiming her crosshairs at us. i mean, i can see why lynching a potential doctor is a really bad idea, but even so that was overly aggressive and not really needed. yes please come tunnel me, i don't mind if thats what you want to do. it wont help town though, but anyway.

i think cory was acting strangely yesterday, but i don't know his usual game play and i don't have much to go off of except his aggression. so i guess thats null until further notice.

crys has me confused bc the only game ive ever played with them they were SO ALL OVER THE THREAD we couldn't escape them, but here in this game they're barely here and we're just hanging on for their reads. i know crys is a good player and is usually a wild card of a personality so their incredibly lack of posting for once really makes me unsettled. but this is just an observation rather than a potential sr.

aron rubs me wrong and everyone already knows why so i don't need to waste words discussing it more.

as your you sarasa, you intrigue me because i can see why you use your questioning to scum read, but i don't know whether i should town read you so easily. you kinda come off as townie to me, but it's more so because i like seeing you pick apart at others and allow everyone else to see questions answered and gauge them ourselves. if that makes sense.

shiida rubs me a little wrong, mostly because of their bold ass comments towards unofficial roles.
i know it can be party innocent but it rubs me wrong why you would push so much for roles. not to mention even with all the replies i don't know how to make heads or tails of it all because, well most people seem to have living roles. which freaks me out because mine is not living..in tarot it was really simple to realize who was an obvious power role vs who was not based on the tarot card claims against arcanas, but here, i don't think there is anything as obvious as the tarot cards were.. with so many living roles and so far, what two not living have been "claimed" i feel like the push towards role claims isn't a very pro town thing. even if it's just to try to see what the roles are based off of. and the asking about ted cruz thing just seems.. sketchy?

there's so much inactivity i'm sad and i don't know how to make heads or tails of a lot of it.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Shiida, why the vote on Cadbberry?

 

[tae]

I get the general feeling from this that you don't want to lynch Alexi, right? Who would you lynch instead?

i don't think alexi is a good lynch candidate as of right now, no.
i also don't think aron is a good lynch candidate either because it's too much of a risk.

as far as heavy scum reads i don't have much to go off of.

i feel iffy about m3ow, mostly because she was so aggressive about anyone questioning aron and claiming if we set out eyes on him she'll be aiming her crosshairs at us. i mean, i can see why lynching a potential doctor is a really bad idea, but even so that was overly aggressive and not really needed. yes please come tunnel me, i don't mind if thats what you want to do. it wont help town though, but anyway.

i think cory was acting strangely yesterday, but i don't know his usual game play and i don't have much to go off of except his aggression. so i guess thats null until further notice.

crys has me confused bc the only game ive ever played with them they were SO ALL OVER THE THREAD we couldn't escape them, but here in this game they're barely here and we're just hanging on for their reads. i know crys is a good player and is usually a wild card of a personality so their incredibly lack of posting for once really makes me unsettled. but this is just an observation rather than a potential sr.

aron rubs me wrong and everyone already knows why so i don't need to waste words discussing it more.

as your you sarasa, you intrigue me because i can see why you use your questioning to scum read, but i don't know whether i should town read you so easily. you kinda come off as townie to me, but it's more so because i like seeing you pick apart at others and allow everyone else to see questions answered and gauge them ourselves. if that makes sense.

shiida rubs me a little wrong, mostly because of their bold ass comments towards unofficial roles.
i know it can be party innocent but it rubs me wrong why you would push so much for roles. not to mention even with all the replies i don't know how to make heads or tails of it all because, well most people seem to have living roles. which freaks me out because mine is not living..in tarot it was really simple to realize who was an obvious power role vs who was not based on the tarot card claims against arcanas, but here, i don't think there is anything as obvious as the tarot cards were.. with so many living roles and so far, what two not living have been "claimed" i feel like the push towards role claims isn't a very pro town thing. even if it's just to try to see what the roles are based off of. and the asking about ted cruz thing just seems.. sketchy?

there's so much inactivity i'm sad and i don't know how to make heads or tails of a lot of it.

 

[Cadbberry]

I strongly agree to this and this goes for EVERYONE (mainly new/ inexperienced players) its definitely ok to do post your reads even if they just go with someone else's, posting them even if they match other players opinions helps us know where you stand and so we can make progress in weeding out who seems scummy and who doesn't, especially later when we can match up what someone is saying at this point and how it correlates with the information that we'll get from lynches and night kills. i know at times it may seem daunting to say it over and over but as long as you put it in your own words and explain why you agree or disagree then its going to help us very much, but if you stay silent cause you think you don't have to post it cause someone already has then you just stay a big question mark to the rest of us and we don't know how to move on and who to question or go after.

also wanted to add to Aron and New Peeps. It's ok to be wrong, i don't know if anyone else feels like this but when i began i was kinda scared to post/ make reads cause i didnt want to be wrong.... we are all going to be wrong at some point, this is a guessing game in a lot of ways so of course we aren't going to get it right 100% of the time, as long as you use your mind and make educated guesses and play to the best of your ability then your gonna help us win, and if we get it wrong every once in awhile then it still helps us in the long run.

This really describes how I am feeling, this is all very stressful because I would hate to be incorrect and say leads that are totally incorrect. I am going to attempt doing a read on players but I am a bit nervous at how it will come across, everything makes me nervous, I have a feeling this may be my only mafia game I play XD

 

[tae]

sorry post glitch.

 

[Cadbberry]

Shiida, why the vote on Cadbberry?

Did someone vote on me, welp I missed something rather important then. I would love an explanation as well

- - - Post Merge - - -

I just found the voting thread, man do I feel dumb

 

[PandaDarling]

My Internet just went down !! FML I have to call the iqnternet company and yell at them, brb.

 

[tae]

Shiida, why the vote on Cadbberry?

i also want to know why you voted cad.

 

[PandaDarling]

my internet just went down and i had to call and yell at the internet company and i told the lady on the phone "but you don't understand im playing Donald Trump forum mafia!" and she was just like "ooooook... well it should be back up shortly." haha i was cracking up. all fixed now.

 

[piichinu]

shiida rubs me a little wrong, mostly because of their bold ass comments towards unofficial roles.
i know it can be party innocent but it rubs me wrong why you would push so much for roles. not to mention even with all the replies i don't know how to make heads or tails of it all because, well most people seem to have living roles. which freaks me out because mine is not living..in tarot it was really simple to realize who was an obvious power role vs who was not based on the tarot card claims against arcanas, but here, i don't think there is anything as obvious as the tarot cards were.. with so many living roles and so far, what two not living have been "claimed" i feel like the push towards role claims isn't a very pro town thing. even if it's just to try to see what the roles are based off of. and the asking about ted cruz thing just seems.. sketchy?

there's so much inactivity i'm sad and i don't know how to make heads or tails of a lot of it.

well, i wouldnt really count asking if people had living roles to try and verify whether aron was lying or not bold. also im not entirely sure how trying to find out if theres a serial killer is anti-town, but ok.

--

also, i voted cad bc i was a little sus of her and i know she wont get plurality lynched (currently) so shes sort of just a filler vote. was hoping she'd react somehow so i could get a better read.

 

[N e s s]

Good lord, over 60 pages i need to read.

 

[tae]

well, i wouldnt really count asking if people had living roles to try and verify whether aron was lying or not bold. also im not entirely sure how trying to find out if theres a serial killer is anti-town, but ok.

--

also, i voted cad bc i was a little sus of her and i know she wont get plurality lynched (currently) so shes sort of just a filler vote. was hoping she'd react somehow so i could get a better read.

i don't think saying "is someone ted cruz bc everyone knows his zodiac killer meme" is a good way to get someone to claim a role.

 

[Cadbberry]

well, i wouldnt really count asking if people had living roles to try and verify whether aron was lying or not bold. also im not entirely sure how trying to find out if theres a serial killer is anti-town, but ok.

--

also, i voted cad bc i was a little sus of her and i know she wont get plurality lynched (currently) so shes sort of just a filler vote. was hoping she'd react somehow so i could get a better read.

My reaction was more just confusion currently, I guess I have made a few sus posts but seems most people are sus of me. I can not stop people from having those reactions immediately but I hope as the games go on I will be more trustworthy

 

[PandaDarling]

my internet just went down and i had to call and yell at the internet company and i told the lady on the phone "but you don't understand im playing Donald Trump forum mafia!" and she was just like "ooooook... well it should be back up shortly." haha i was cracking up. all fixed now.

uh. sorry for saying it twice haha i thought the first one didn't post cause i was using my phone and the internet was being dumb. any ways....

@Ness i know you have a lot to read and its gonna take you awhile to get back to us with anything but can you please address the things we were suspicious of you for i know it was awhile go but i don't really feel like its been cleared and we have kinda just moved on cause we didnt have a response from you, but i don't want it to just be ignored. thanks. and gl catching up.

 

[piichinu]

i don't think saying "is someone ted cruz bc everyone knows his zodiac killer meme" is a good way to get someone to claim a role.

at first i only asked if someone got ted cruz, but then i thought that they wouldnt admit to it, so i answered someones question after realizing that.

 

[N e s s]

Wait, from what i've read someone has claimed Doctor. Who is this???