Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

[PandaDarling]

Dolby do we have wait until D1 ends to get the replacements for those two roles?
I'm hoping not, cause their opinions/ interaction in the thread could be pretty use full rn. i feel like a player with a fresh perspective could get us out of this rut we're in.

 

[Cadbberry]

Tbh I would have imagined mafia would have talked about the Doc claim at length by now, so I'm derp clearing him anti-mafia at least.

That was a clever thought, I will have to say I agree with that idea. Good catch SarasaKat!

 

[Arstotzkan]

what about you though? can i ask you what your current sr / tr are?

Well I scumread Alexi. I understand she's kind of wishy-washy, but to go wishy washy on the outted doctor seems a bit odd. She seems to be pretty opportunistic with peoples' suspicions, and her tone in those first few posts of hers still raises red flags. I also agree with meow's read.

I've got a slight scum read on Kevinn and Cad, but not nearly enough to want to lynch them. Mainly for being too self-focused and not trying to question people and figure them out.

Champ is bleeding neutral/slight scum territory for being a hypocrite about scumhunting and not scumhunting unless asked.

Town reads on Toads, Curry, and Aron. See http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?363810-Make-Mafia-Grate-Again!-Day-One/page26

Ness derp cleared anti-mafia

Townreading Panda for taking a step up to the plate a lot and contributing more.

I really like this interaction with you, so I have a townlean on you currently.

 

[N e s s]

Expect something big from me in a few hours, but I have a suspicion about SarasaKat about the whole Aronthaer claim.

In other words, my character is still alive irl.

 

[PandaDarling]

Wait, from what i've read someone has claimed Doctor. Who is this???

@Ness what ? how the heck do you know the doctor claimed but you don't know who ? where did you get that info but not the players name ? if it was in this thread wouldn't you have seen who claimed Doctor ?

 

[N e s s]

Expect something big from me in a few hours, but I have a suspicion about SarasaKat about the whole Aronthaer claim.

In other words, my character is still alive irl.

 

[xine]

Meow has a point with Alexi but I still am uncomfortable with Inkling, quite frankly. I am giving Ness time to post more.

At least Alexi contributes but inkling is coasting still. Last game when I'm pretty sure they were town they were one of the top posters. And now almost silence, like they know that if they post too much they will attract suspicion.

I feel similarly about Crys, but at least they are saying they will post reads.

okay, this is making me sus of aron. I'm beginning to question his true intentions.

Tunneling on the doc claim

Sorry, I'm a bit confused. I'm not offended? Where did the stupid part come from?

By this time I've read the thread and I understand nobody wants to lynch aron bc he claimed doctor. I understand that.

As to the rest of whatever you said, I'm honestly just not interested and like I said you're grasping for straws here. I especially have nothing to say since you completely ignored and did not directly respond to my explanation.

It came from how you said you weren't stupid or oblivious

2nd paragraph: But then what is the point of mentioning that he's scummy- it's basically just filler at this point. There is no point to waste time talking about someone that we are not lynching today.

3rd- I did not ignore any of it. You're not interested in responding to me? Well, that's quite the change from when you were being pressured in the previous game.

at this point there isn't much to go off of but here are my current thoughts in a nutshell:

i think tae is being unusually quiet. i think this important to make note of and I'd like to hear an explanation.

heyden is following his typical meta so is probs town.

n e s s, its hard to say. i think he did get frustrated and quit. maybe he's giving himself breathing room? in the last game he was scum and acted defensive but was a bit more calm and collected. this game he kinda just exploded so i think he might really be town.

cad, seems like she's trying to be helpful to town and didnt post previously bc she was unsure or whatever.

xine is trying to be helpful to town but i don't feel she asks enough questions.

panda is being less aggressive this game

there's definitely something off about aron. i know m3ow and xine are defending him. but maybe he read the last game and saw the doctor was killed d1 and wanted to start a guilt trip? i don't want to lynch him of course but something's not right here.

- - - Post Merge - - -

oh and tardis is very confused as usual

Tae- But Taesaek is talking and contributing more than you are.

Ness- It's interesting that you read him as town at this point. Your reason also doesn't make sense so I feel like you are trying to pocket him here. He never actually exploded but he did express frustration about being suspected. I would hardly call that exploding at all.

All inklings reads consisted of townreads with a light suspicion of Panda for not being aggressive enough (I disagree with that by the way) and possibly me. The read on me is ironic because they have not been questioning anyone all game besides me.

If you know we are not lynching the doc claim then why on Earth do you keep mentioning it as if it's relevant? He will likely die if he's doc and he won't die if he's scum so we will see. I am not defending him, it's merely that either 1. He is real and will die or 2. He is not real and will not die.

I have a lot going on in real life so I'm fully aware I'm tunneling but I will be looking at others more in depth as I reread the thread.

 

[Chrystina]

sorry, I left for a bit cause my niece is here. i reeally didn't think i'd miss much but it looks like some think m3ow's read has good points, considering i have 2 votes.


but i see ness is back, so thats good.
question, ness -
you return with a post saying omg so many pages etc, then post a few mins later with this:

Wait, from what i've read someone has claimed Doctor. Who is this???

it just seems very odd that you read "someone claimed doctor" but didn't bother to keep reading the thread to find out who. if you have so many pages to read, then why waste time to keep continuing posting instead of catching up.

 

[N e s s]

@Ness what ? how the heck do you know the doctor claimed but you don't know who ? where did you get that info but not the players name ? if it was in this thread wouldn't you have seen who claimed Doctor ?

I saw something about a Doctor claim in one of taesaeks posts or some recent one, but I didn't see who.

 

[Cadbberry]

I saw something about a Doctor claim in one of taesaeks posts or some recent one, but I didn't see who.

I would suggest reading from the start instead of first or else opinions may muddle the real posts and change your opinions in a different way, I made that mistake and it confused me for a while

 

[Arstotzkan]

Expect something big from me in a few hours, but I have a suspicion about SarasaKat about the whole Aronthaer claim.

In other words, my character is still alive irl.

Good. I made a change in opinion that I was looking for someone to pick up, and it looks like Ness caught it.

 

[glow]

I forgot to mention, my role is alive as well

 

[N e s s]

Agreed.

- - - Post Merge - - -



I believe that people had good intentions to go after me. The way I see it, role claimin would be something only noob scum or a noob doctor would do, and so of course it was logical for them to get suspicious.

As for the "search thread" thing, no, I didn't know about that. That's immensely helpful, thank you.

Ah hah, it was this post. I didn't know who, because I read this.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Good. I made a change in opinion that I was looking for someone to pick up, and it looks like Ness caught it.

Why would you wait for someone to pick up on something when you try to say that Aronthaer isn't cleared, since you expect Doctor to be a fakeclaim?

Your post looks incredibly fake.

 

[tae]

Well I scumread Alexi. I understand she's kind of wishy-washy, but to go wishy washy on the outted doctor seems a bit odd. She seems to be pretty opportunistic with peoples' suspicions, and her tone in those first few posts of hers still raises red flags. I also agree with meow's read.

I've got a slight scum read on Kevinn and Cad, but not nearly enough to want to lynch them. Mainly for being too self-focused and not trying to question people and figure them out.

Champ is bleeding neutral/slight scum territory for being a hypocrite about scumhunting and not scumhunting unless asked.

Town reads on Toads, Curry, and Aron. See http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?363810-Make-Mafia-Grate-Again!-Day-One/page26

Ness derp cleared anti-mafia

Townreading Panda for taking a step up to the plate a lot and contributing more.

I really like this interaction with you, so I have a townlean on you currently.

i really like your viewpoints so far. i need to look back over m3ow_s read on alexi though.
you're calm and collected and i'm glad at least one of us are. it makes things easier to gauge.

your read on kevin / cadbberry makes good sense, i do find it odd that they're more pointed towards each other / themselves than sticking their heads out. i know my first game i was a bit all over the place with my opinions, but i can't compare my personality to theirs because i'm pretty head strong around the forums out of games. but the lack of posting / contributing because of the fear of being called out really is a poor excuse to not contribute to the cause, like cad claimed earlier.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Why would you wait for someone to pick up on something when you try to say that Aronthaer isn't cleared, since you expect Doctor to be a fakeclaim?

Your post looks incredibly fake.

Back then, me posting what I did was genuine. But after reanalyzing, I realized that my shift in opinion once he claimed was kind of out of the blue and could be perceived as suspicious. And hell, I was. But after reevaluating, I'm not anymore.

 

[tae]

also, thank you xine i'm glad im not the only one who's noticed the change in inkling's behavior from previous games.

 

[Aronthaer]

Wait, did Shiida ever explain why she was voting for Caddberry? If so, I missed it.

 

[Cadbberry]

Wait, did Shiida ever explain why she was voting for Caddberry? If so, I missed it.

It was just a place holder vote for the moment, they have removed said vote at this point though

 

[Aronthaer]

It was just a place holder vote for the moment, they have removed said vote at this point though

Ah, kk.

Alexi's in the lead with votes with 3 atm.

 

[PandaDarling]

as of right now, I'd be ok with a Ness/ Inkling/ Mother lynch.

Ness unless he comes back with some decent intel and response to the suspicion on him, which seems to me he is just trying to brush under the rug.

@Ness why are you going to go to hours (the last few hours of D1) to go make a long (boring) post about Sarasakat when she is one of our (or at least mine) strongest town reads ? i think what you really need to do is go back and respond to us about our suspicious on you cause we have been patiently waiting and i think we deserve it. if not then i will be voting for you.

Inkling because of their random in and out of thread and the emotional outburst (i know they were quite emotional last game) but with the inactivity it looks more sus atm.

Mother cause im really done with them signing up for these games and then going mia. its pointless and i know thats not a good reason to lynch someone but if we had no where else to go with our D1 lynch i really wouldn't mind this option tbh. sorry.

as far as Alexi goes im kinda on the fence... i think her meta isn't too far off from last game but i do feel like she's not being as sure footed as she was before, but im kinda just given her the benefit of the doubt cause i think the really quick accusation from Sarasakat in the very beginning kinda discouraged her.