Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

[xine]

I'm not really comfortable with saying whether my role is alive or not, can we explain why this is relevant?

 

[tae]

as of right now, I'd be ok with a Ness/ Inkling/ Mother lynch.

Ness unless he comes back with some decent intel and response to the suspicion on him, which seems to me he is just trying to brush under the rug.

@Ness why are you going to go to hours (the last few hours of D1) to go make a long (boring) post about Sarasakat when she is one of our (or at least mine) strongest town reads ? i think what you really need to do is go back and respond to us about our suspicious on you cause we have been patiently waiting and i think we deserve it. if not then i will be voting for you.

Inkling because of their random in and out of thread and the emotional outburst (i know they were quite emotional last game) but with the inactivity it looks more sus atm.

Mother cause im really done with them signing up for these games and then going mia. its pointless and i know thats not a good reason to lynch someone but if we had no where else to go with our D1 lynch i really wouldn't mind this option tbh. sorry.

as far as Alexi goes im kinda on the fence... i think her meta isn't too far off from last game but i do feel like she's not being as sure footed as she was before, but im kinda just given her the benefit of the doubt cause i think the really quick accusation from Sarasakat in the very beginning kinda discouraged her.

i'm with panda on this, minus the ness thing bc i don't feel that much scum coming from him. but the inkling / mother lynch i wouldn't mind. esp because inkling's change has been so obvious this game i don't know if they're trying to tone **** down for once (or not bc they've been been pretty emotional) or if they're scum trying to stay under the radar.

and about mother i'm petty like that and i hate when ppl sign up and barely play the game. (looks into the camera like on the office & mouths the name"jacob")

 

[N e s s]

Back then, me posting what I did was genuine. But after reanalyzing, I realized that my shift in opinion once he claimed was kind of out of the blue and could be perceived as suspicious. And hell, I was. But after reevaluating, I'm not anymore.

This strikes up more red flags.

I say we don't kill claimed Doc and move onto something else. I know the claim is odd but this is a Doctor we're dealing with here.

I sense mob mentality coming back and I don't like it.

So you expect that since you spend 3 hours tunneling a doctor claim (which, why would mafia claim doctor of all living things, a NEW PLAYER I MIGHT ADD) , you say this and you try to say you were hoping someone would point it out? What gives?

 

[tae]

I'm not really comfortable with saying whether my role is alive or not, can we explain why this is relevant?

bc aron's claim was that his role is reagan. who's deceased irl. so saras and shiida (at different times) asked if anyone else can claim that they have a dead role just to try to rule out the fact that his claim might have been fake or not. it's kinda shady though.

 

[piichinu]

I'm not really comfortable with saying whether my role is alive or not, can we explain why this is relevant?

since the majority of people claimed living people then only someone w a dead role would feel uncomfortable so is that what you have?

i asked because aron claimed a role w a dead person so i wanted to see if anyone else had dead ppl

 

[Cadbberry]

as of right now, I'd be ok with a Ness/ Inkling/ Mother lynch.

Ness unless he comes back with some decent intel and response to the suspicion on him, which seems to me he is just trying to brush under the rug.

@Ness why are you going to go to hours (the last few hours of D1) to go make a long (boring) post about Sarasakat when she is one of our (or at least mine) strongest town reads ? i think what you really need to do is go back and respond to us about our suspicious on you cause we have been patiently waiting and i think we deserve it. if not then i will be voting for you.

Inkling because of their random in and out of thread and the emotional outburst (i know they were quite emotional last game) but with the inactivity it looks more sus atm.

Mother cause im really done with them signing up for these games and then going mia. its pointless and i know thats not a good reason to lynch someone but if we had no where else to go with our D1 lynch i really wouldn't mind this option tbh. sorry.

as far as Alexi goes im kinda on the fence... i think her meta isn't too far off from last game but i do feel like she's not being as sure footed as she was before, but im kinda just given her the benefit of the doubt cause i think the really quick accusation from Sarasakat in the very beginning kinda discouraged her.

As I have not played before this kind of insight from past games really helps. Inkling has been acting a little sus from the tiny amount I know of from watching the littlest bit of the Tarot game and Mother I dont think I have seen and maybe that is due to them not replying. Maybe we should leave mother to mod kill if they dont reply after a few days and look at inkling as a prime target.

 

[N e s s]

as of right now, I'd be ok with a Ness/ Inkling/ Mother lynch.

Ness unless he comes back with some decent intel and response to the suspicion on him, which seems to me he is just trying to brush under the rug.

@Ness why are you going to go to hours (the last few hours of D1) to go make a long (boring) post about Sarasakat when she is one of our (or at least mine) strongest town reads ? i think what you really need to do is go back and respond to us about our suspicious on you cause we have been patiently waiting and i think we deserve it. if not then i will be voting for you.

Inkling because of their random in and out of thread and the emotional outburst (i know they were quite emotional last game) but with the inactivity it looks more sus atm.

Mother cause im really done with them signing up for these games and then going mia. its pointless and i know thats not a good reason to lynch someone but if we had no where else to go with our D1 lynch i really wouldn't mind this option tbh. sorry.

as far as Alexi goes im kinda on the fence... i think her meta isn't too far off from last game but i do feel like she's not being as sure footed as she was before, but im kinda just given her the benefit of the doubt cause i think the really quick accusation from Sarasakat in the very beginning kinda discouraged her.

Panda, I plan to include more things in that post then just a suspicion about Sarasakat, even though I think she's scum right now. I'm trying to collect more alignment tells out of her.

 

[xine]

But Ness why are you targeting Sarasakat for tunneling the doctor but not Inkling or Alexi who has kind of been doing the same thing?

 

[N e s s]

But Ness why are you targeting Sarasakat for tunneling the doctor but not Inkling or Alexi who has kind of been doing the same thing?

They are on suspicious xine, but theres no reason for me to be including them at the moment, since i'm trying to get information about SarasaKat.

And if you look back, Kat has a suspicion about Alexi, but then later drops it and suspects Me, M3ow, and Tardis. Afterwards, M3ow makes a reads post, and Kat drops suspicion about M3ow, then suspects Alexi again.

 

[PandaDarling]

and about mother i'm petty like that and i hate when ppl sign up and barely play the game. (looks into the camera like on the office & mouths the name"jacob")

@Tae omg i love you right now, that last part had me rolling.

since the majority of people claimed living people then only someone w a dead role would feel uncomfortable so is that what you have?

i asked because aron claimed a role w a dead person so i wanted to see if anyone else had dead ppl

@Shiida in hopes of what ? are you seriously PR hunting right now ?

 

[Arstotzkan]

This strikes up more red flags.



So you expect that since you spend 3 hours tunneling a doctor claim (which, why would mafia claim doctor of all living things, a NEW PLAYER I MIGHT ADD) , you say this and you try to say you were hoping someone would point it out? What gives?

Yup. When I changed my opinion on the Doctor thing, I realized I had a lot of inconsistencies while I tunneled. So I was looking to see if anyone would read back and point them out.

 

[N e s s]

Yup. When I changed my opinion on the Doctor thing, I realized I had a lot of inconsistencies while I tunneled. So I was looking to see if anyone would read back and point them out.

So what exactly are you trying to accomplish with me pointing you out then?

 

[Arstotzkan]

So what exactly are you trying to accomplish with me pointing you out then?

Shows you're actively scumhunting. So you basically scored town points.

 

[xine]

since the majority of people claimed living people then only someone w a dead role would feel uncomfortable so is that what you have?

i asked because aron claimed a role w a dead person so i wanted to see if anyone else had dead ppl

I am uncomfortable with it because it seems like it could narrow down PR's- which may or may not be confirmed now. Since Aronthaer claims PR and has a dead role, I do not think I am going to share this information at this time.

 

[piichinu]

@Tae omg i love you right now, that last part had me rolling.



@Shiida in hopes of what ? are you seriously PR hunting right now ?

to see if he was fakeclaiming or not

dead person =/= important role, i just looked back at my posts and i never implied anything of the sort unless i missed it.

 

[PandaDarling]

Shows you're actively scumhunting. So you basically scored town points.

haha :::here Ness heres a cookie:::

How many town points does he have now Sarasakat ?

imo he only had 2 for coming back to the thread but then i gave him a -25 for not responding to our suspicious, and by trying to waste our last few hours of D1 by arguing with someone (usually me) like he always does... "to the town".

 

[N e s s]

Shows you're actively scumhunting. So you basically scored town points.

Ok, I really, REALLY dislike your reasoning for doing this. You literally just admitted that you had inconsistency to tunneling a doctor claim, so you attempt to cover it up, and hope that someone can point it out so you can try to call them town. It sounds hypocritical for me to say this, but why would you automatically call me town right away when scum can do situations like this as well, when you were obviously suspecting me for "lurking", and had me as one of you main prioritys to lynch today?

 

[Arstotzkan]

haha :::here Ness heres a cookie:::

How many town points does he have now Sarasakat ?

imo he only had 2 for coming back to the thread but then i gave him a -25 for not responding to our suspicious, and by trying to waste our last few hours of D1 by arguing with someone (usually me) like he always does... "to the town".

3.141952654

Haha nah but seriously, I think he's getting there. I'm guessing he's still reading back - reading takes a good, long time.

I have to go in a few minutes FYI. Work.

 

[PandaDarling]

since the majority of people claimed living people then only someone w a dead role would feel uncomfortable so is that what you have?

i asked because aron claimed a role w a dead person so i wanted to see if anyone else had dead ppl

to see if he was fakeclaiming or not

dead person =/= important role, i just looked back at my posts and i never implied anything of the sort unless i missed it.

seriously ? you just said it right there( twice), you are trying to find out who the "important roles" (PR) are...

 

[Arstotzkan]

Ok, I really, REALLY dislike your reasoning for doing this. You literally just admitted that you had inconsistency to tunneling a doctor claim, so you attempt to cover it up, and hope that someone can point it out so you can try to call them town. It sounds hypocritical for me to say this, but why would you automatically call me town right away when scum can do situations like this as well, when you were obviously suspecting me for "lurking", and had me as one of you main prioritys to lynch today?

I never had you as one of my main priorities to lynch. I had you as Null, and someone I wanted to keep my eye on.

I didn't suspect you for lurking. I said it was unusual for you to lurk as both town and mafia, so it piqued my interest.

I'm not calling you lock town. I think scumhunting is townie, and you showed you were analyzing posts by pointing that out.