Mafia Monster Mash Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
- Thread starter Damniel
- Start date
BetsySundrop
🧙♀️ 🧹
This might take me a while....but I'll get right on it.....
i think an explaination would still be pretty cool of you to give
i know i questioned the follow up of "town" to random's post earlier, and now we have the reverse as well. What's going on there?
Sheep Villager
Feel free to call me Sheep
Serotonin list part 1.
Betsy- Putting on my meta hat because I can't stop myself from doing this. Betsy has been notably un-aggressive for how she usually is. I expected way more pot stirring in the first 24 hours than what ended up happening...The problem with this whole thing is Betsy has almost always been cursed to wolf in past games so I'm suspecting she might be town here. It'd kinda make sense for her to just not aggress in the name of not getting the boot d1 as town. Early on I also noted Betsy took a moment to reinforce the merits of no-vote to Sidney who is new. Just a minor interaction that felt more town-y.
Shawo- Kinda touched on Shawo earlier but yeah, he's been the one to do the most poking and rattling peoples brains. The 24 hour drought was also ended by him. I'm not seeing chaotic-force-of-nature Shawo this game which feels indicative of making an effort to solve given the cast we have in this game. Agreeing with a lot of his posts in general.
Tae- Kind of feels like Shawo: Lite and I'm not sure if that's because of the matching icons tricking my brain or not. I'm getting mild town from the fact they seem to dumpster out thoughts when prompted (and sometimes without even being prompted) so like... either really good at making stuff up on the spot or genuinely just not afraid of what comes out of their mouth. The same cannot really be said for everyone this game I feel. That sorta crashing around recklessly like an elephant is p rare for mafia.
Trent- I genuinely still don't get the early plays from Trent tbh. Hating d1 is one thing but what was with the early insistence on putting us on route to a d1 sequel for d2. Like if you hate d1 just.... why do that? I already pointed out the one post I specifically didn't like early and I'm too lazy to go dig it up again. Going in to the last 12 hours I am seeing more questions from Trent at least but it just doesn't feel natural when you compare the zzzz start. I'd also like some takes on who he's planning on voting?
Starlit- I'm still a bit confused about the very last post they left, however I will note that I did see the point raised that they might've voted no vote due to knowing they won't be at EoD and I actually kinda get that. When I signed up for this game and there was a possibility of 4-6AM EoD I remember agonizing over how the heck I was going to vote. I do kinda wish if this was the case they'd actually said it themselves... Looking at Starlits other activity I will note there wasn't really much prying done in to anything either, which is kind of a weird thing to do if you already showed up late with limited time. If you're town on that position wouldn't you want to make the most of the time you do have...?
Tessa, Sidney and Random will be in the next post since those people posted while I was ISOing this batch of people and I want to give them my full attention.
Betsy- Putting on my meta hat because I can't stop myself from doing this. Betsy has been notably un-aggressive for how she usually is. I expected way more pot stirring in the first 24 hours than what ended up happening...The problem with this whole thing is Betsy has almost always been cursed to wolf in past games so I'm suspecting she might be town here. It'd kinda make sense for her to just not aggress in the name of not getting the boot d1 as town. Early on I also noted Betsy took a moment to reinforce the merits of no-vote to Sidney who is new. Just a minor interaction that felt more town-y.
Shawo- Kinda touched on Shawo earlier but yeah, he's been the one to do the most poking and rattling peoples brains. The 24 hour drought was also ended by him. I'm not seeing chaotic-force-of-nature Shawo this game which feels indicative of making an effort to solve given the cast we have in this game. Agreeing with a lot of his posts in general.
Tae- Kind of feels like Shawo: Lite and I'm not sure if that's because of the matching icons tricking my brain or not. I'm getting mild town from the fact they seem to dumpster out thoughts when prompted (and sometimes without even being prompted) so like... either really good at making stuff up on the spot or genuinely just not afraid of what comes out of their mouth. The same cannot really be said for everyone this game I feel. That sorta crashing around recklessly like an elephant is p rare for mafia.
Trent- I genuinely still don't get the early plays from Trent tbh. Hating d1 is one thing but what was with the early insistence on putting us on route to a d1 sequel for d2. Like if you hate d1 just.... why do that? I already pointed out the one post I specifically didn't like early and I'm too lazy to go dig it up again. Going in to the last 12 hours I am seeing more questions from Trent at least but it just doesn't feel natural when you compare the zzzz start. I'd also like some takes on who he's planning on voting?
Starlit- I'm still a bit confused about the very last post they left, however I will note that I did see the point raised that they might've voted no vote due to knowing they won't be at EoD and I actually kinda get that. When I signed up for this game and there was a possibility of 4-6AM EoD I remember agonizing over how the heck I was going to vote. I do kinda wish if this was the case they'd actually said it themselves... Looking at Starlits other activity I will note there wasn't really much prying done in to anything either, which is kind of a weird thing to do if you already showed up late with limited time. If you're town on that position wouldn't you want to make the most of the time you do have...?
Tessa, Sidney and Random will be in the next post since those people posted while I was ISOing this batch of people and I want to give them my full attention.
tessa grace
yeehaw
Okay i'm starting to figure out the betsy chat thing and it's making sense kind of, I think it's a ploy haha. Also @Damniel are roles revealed upon death?
anyways i have some things i need to do now, I'll be less active but trying to follow along and more active in a few hours.
anyways i have some things i need to do now, I'll be less active but trying to follow along and more active in a few hours.
Sheep Villager
Feel free to call me Sheep
@Damniel If No Vote ties with a vote on someone will it randomize between no-one dying and someone dying or will one overwrite the other?
Sheep Villager
Feel free to call me Sheep
Before anyone asks that question was due to me noticing Random popping a no-vote.
BetsySundrop
🧙♀️ 🧹
I got 3 reads left, but taking time out to explain more fully.
I could not understand the "got it" post. What was it in response to?
Side trip- in the tbt fair, i typed in an answer to the fair quiz in my team pm thread, but did not hit reply. But- went back to the quiz thread in main forum to check something. When I finally hit reply, I had accidentally posted my quiz answer in the main forum thread. (Yes, embarrassing).
So...when i saw the "got it" and no explanation was obvious or forthcoming, I wondered if maf was using pms, and if it could possibly be an accidental post to the game thread.
That's it. Not complicated. I dismissed this idea, but posted it here in my randomYT read because I like to include everything even if it's crazy.
like. 2.3 ish hours i think.
I think this is an honest possibility
the latest post could also be one that was a guided response to the earlier question of what random was thinking
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
Punchy.. cursed...
It's either super oblivious town or the more active mafioso asking the other to please for the love of god check the chat.
We have two hours and like 24 minutes if my math is right
granted if this is something both of you think is possible-
of the two posters under fire in the interaction, random & shawo, who would you vote for today?
because betsy in previous posts you said you townlean!shawo... so this is a little weird to me.
this is me stating i am going to play ffxiv with an amigo and therefore be checking thread less
i will be checking but like not responding right away
i will be checking but like not responding right away
I would say random over shawo today, since shawo has been generating discussion at least. I’m still weird on that interaction, but I also m weird bout the interaction with betsy.
Random seems way more suspicious to me; seems maybe guided?
I think the chat thingy from betsy brings her up on my list, too, so i’d say my list of sus rn is random/shawo/betsy. Unsure whether i rank shawo or betsy higher.
Also the internet on my computer decided to quit agin, nd my phone is being weirr, so ignore my finger typing mistake and ill iso people to make sure im not missing thing if i cn get it back up
But why Random? Wasn't Shawo/Betsy your maf leans?
BetsySundrop
🧙♀️ 🧹
My last reads are Sheep, Tae, and Trent...
And I just have no idea. I did iso and reread the whole game thread. I'm gonna include as much of my thoughts as possible and try not to be confusing.
At first, I had trent high on my sus list (no offense) because of the immediate no elim vote and the intro post pointing to a lazy d1. Most of the more experienced players seem to really go for the d1 elim, which is the only way for town to strike maf.
(I understand the numbers of 2 no elims in a row being potentially beneficial in gathering more info via the nk or the det, but have never seen the proposed seriously becausecof the drawbacks).
Also seemed to want to keep the early game relaxed and remove d1 posting/elim pressure, which I'm not a fan of as it's not helpful for town. I understand the explanations, but don't necessarily agree with the playstyle. Reminds me of geoni a bit, in that it seems really hard to tell what he's thinking, but you know he's paying attention. But to what purpose? Identify wolf or exploit town weakness? I haven't seen any sus teaming, tunneling, wagon pushing...? I wish i had a better read, but I just don't.
Yeah that's why I dismissed it. It is frustrating though. But out of shawo or random that's easy, random (no offense random). It doesn't seem like random will be more helpful as time goes on.
And as far as the possibility of random being the det and misyeeted... I understand the whole lay low and don't be sus, but there is a certain responsibility on the det to at least show some town.
It's very frustrating...
And I just have no idea. I did iso and reread the whole game thread. I'm gonna include as much of my thoughts as possible and try not to be confusing.
At first, I had trent high on my sus list (no offense) because of the immediate no elim vote and the intro post pointing to a lazy d1. Most of the more experienced players seem to really go for the d1 elim, which is the only way for town to strike maf.
(I understand the numbers of 2 no elims in a row being potentially beneficial in gathering more info via the nk or the det, but have never seen the proposed seriously becausecof the drawbacks).
Also seemed to want to keep the early game relaxed and remove d1 posting/elim pressure, which I'm not a fan of as it's not helpful for town. I understand the explanations, but don't necessarily agree with the playstyle. Reminds me of geoni a bit, in that it seems really hard to tell what he's thinking, but you know he's paying attention. But to what purpose? Identify wolf or exploit town weakness? I haven't seen any sus teaming, tunneling, wagon pushing...? I wish i had a better read, but I just don't.
Yeah that's why I dismissed it. It is frustrating though. But out of shawo or random that's easy, random (no offense random). It doesn't seem like random will be more helpful as time goes on.
And as far as the possibility of random being the det and misyeeted... I understand the whole lay low and don't be sus, but there is a certain responsibility on the det to at least show some town.
It's very frustrating...
It was, previously. I questioned random as well and was waiting for more engagement from them. I just don’t understand why the next post was about the thread being quiet when there was multiple pages added since + immediately voting no elim
Shawo explained their reasoning earlier, which doesn’t clear them for me entirely but does give them more credibility + did contribute things of substance/tht i thought were helpful
betsy has been fine aside from the one interaction with shawo, and now the maf chat thing, both of which confuse me and only become more confusing with the additional random sus post
Honestly at the moment my gut says it’s two of those three, though i’d like to review everyone if i can just get my computer internet workimg again (it works fine for a couple of hours and then dies again) and my gut feels strongest about random
this could all change in the a few hours we have though, we’ll see
