Mafia Monster Mash Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)

[shawo]

I'm gonna be real I feel too dumb for the Betsy Vs Tae thing. I thought the whole Got It thing was an obvious tinfoil...?

It could be a deflection off of Trent. You should vote Trent to make sure they don't succeed.

 

[tae]

Maybe unrelated, but Sheep seems willing to push Trent. I still don't think Sheep mafs with Trent. I'm not sure solving for team dynamics here is going to be super useful though. It's easy to fake posts but it's hard to fake votes.

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

You think Betsy!Maf tries to force an omgus onto someone who isn't really on anyone's elim list? (You)

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

You think Betsy!Maf tries to force an omgus onto someone who isn't really on anyone's elim list? (You)

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

Wanna park votes on trent with me

if im being honest, i think most of sheep's sus of trent is the fear of trent being a geoni-esque veteran. more of a d1 fear kill than actual mafia. but like, i havent played with trent in years and everything i do know about his gameplay is pretty hit or miss.

trent scares me bc i never get a feel for him right away, in the same way that playing with glow or geoni or daniel is always scary at first.



i think betsy is definitely in some level of OMGUS towards me- but like, i don't think theres enough push and everyone is split pretty weirdly today.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

I think you're expecting far too much from me on a Day 1 Shawo, but do feel free to elim me.

 

[shawo]

My sus on random was explained. Low (extremely) activity is not modkilled until later in the game, and more important (to me) is that weird got it post.

Did you read my analysis on the got it post?

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

I think you're expecting far too much from me on a Day 1 Shawo, but do feel free to elim me.

This is my issue - this is exactly the type of post that it looks like lazy town would say... but also.... it doesn't. Further the game. If you know you're down, why are you letting the only person you know is town die?

It just reads like a "haha I'm willing to die so I must not be maf post."

Anyways we have to elim Trent now.

 

[tae]

not just someone hopping on to create a wagon.

i never once said "hey vote betsy! everyone." i literally just posted my d1 reads. lol. it's not a bandwagon.

 

[shawo]

if im being honest, i think most of sheep's sus of trent is the fear of trent being a geoni-esque veteran. more of a d1 fear kill than actual mafia. but like, i havent played with trent in years and everything i do know about his gameplay is pretty hit or miss. hot jabbs and memey-****posts sprinkled in.

What are your thoughts on my read on Trent?

 

[BetsySundrop]

how does your bloodthirst for inactive players not equate to being just as scummy as the potential of you thinking trent is scummy for just noelim?

I've explained it. They were not replaced in previous games and ended up making the game more difficult d3. After dan said they would be replaced i responded that i wouldn't vote the absent players at that time. I also removed my vote from starlit, and both absent players have shown up.

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

Did you read my analysis on the got it post?

Not yet, catching up.

 

[tae]

I'm gonna be real I feel too dumb for the Betsy Vs Tae thing. I thought the whole Got It thing was an obvious tinfoil...?

like betsy's thought on it is a tinfoil hat theory?

 

[shawo]

I've explained it. They were not replaced in previous games and ended up making the game more difficult d3. After dan said they would be replaced i responded that i wouldn't vote the absent players at that time. I also removed my vote from starlit, and both absent players have shown up.

I don't think either player are going to be replaced, for what it's worth. They both may have made enough content to not be replaced starting d2. I wouldn't play expecting either to get replaced, unless we can get some sort of guarantee from Daniel. That unless Random makes X more posts they're getting replaced.

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

Not sure if I'm misunderstanding you though Betsy. You get a little long winded at times and it's a bit hard to keep track of where you are and aren't unless you explicitly say so.

 

[tae]

What are your thoughts on my read on Trent?

i think with less than an hour left its a lot to digest.
the no-elim thing seemed weird, but mechanically speaking, how would a no elim day 1 help mafia? street cred? most people who've ive read as townleans are totally down for blood on d1.

 

[Sheep Villager]

like betsy's thought on it is a tinfoil hat theory?

Yes. It just doesn't feel that deep to me.

 

[shawo]

Hey guys. Funny theory. What if Random was responding to Daniel's mod PM asking for them to be more active in the thread. Doesn't that offer a perfect explanation for the Got It without making them explicitly mafia?

 

[BetsySundrop]

i never once said "hey vote betsy! everyone." i literally just posted my d1 reads. lol. it's not a bandwagon.

Again, misrep. I don't see you as originally sussing anyone, including me. That's kind of the point. Not trying to offend, just see following, not leading.

What do you think about the random got it post?

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

Not sure if I'm misunderstanding you though Betsy. You get a little long winded at times and it's a bit hard to keep track of where you are and aren't unless you explicitly say so.

Sorry. Just trying to be clear, lol.

 

[Sheep Villager]

I am begging people to let the 'got it' post go.

 

[shawo]

I am begging people to let the 'got it' post go.

It's not being let go, hence why I've offered like, THREE theories as to why it isn't a mafia thing. I'm way more comfortable just voting someone who's maftelling.

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

i think with less than an hour left its a lot to digest.
the no-elim thing seemed weird, but mechanically speaking, how would a no elim day 1 help mafia? street cred? most people who've ive read as townleans are totally down for blood on d1.

Was this not explained? Town's losing an elim. That's beneficial to mafia. Think about it like this. Town has 5 votes to find 2 mafia. By voting no one, town gets 4 votes to find 2 mafia. Is that not an added benefit for the mafia?

 

[Trent the Paladin]

This is my issue - this is exactly the type of post that it looks like lazy town would say... but also.... it doesn't. Further the game. If you know you're down, why are you letting the only person you know is town die?

It just reads like a "haha I'm willing to die so I must not be maf post."

Anyways we have to elim Trent now.

"We have to" I'm sure you do Shawo, after all this is the time to push out townie by causing panic voting? Honestly your posts suck this past day

 

[tae]

i literally answered the "got it post" thing you asked me. @BetsySundrop

sorry just saw this while re-reading.
that it was a half-assed attempted at appearing active before voting and leaving.

it doesnt look good by any means.
but i def don't view it as a maf chat miss post. if anything its lazy gameplay.

 

[shawo]

Then push me back? The only reason I'm voting you is because of the fact that your day isn't shifting at all. I'd be happy if you proved me wrong.

 

[BetsySundrop]

Oh and, while Got it being a mafia slip would be really funny. (Imagine. Mafia partner telling Random to post, and Random posts got it in the forum lol.) It really doesn't seem maffy because realistically if someone was coaching Random to post... they'd probably give more guidance. Realistically Random just posted for... X reason.

Hey on the verrrry remote chance it was....ima high five myself

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

i literally answered the "got it post" thing you asked me. @BetsySundrop

Im catching up. Sorry. Will get there.

 

[tae]

It's not being let go, hence why I've offered like, THREE theories as to why it isn't a mafia thing. I'm way more comfortable just voting someone who's maftelling.

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

Was this not explained? Town's losing an elim. That's beneficial to mafia. Think about it like this. Town has 5 votes to find 2 mafia. By voting no one, town gets 4 votes to find 2 mafia. Is that not an added benefit for the mafia?

oh ok that makes sense.
still not sold on trent tho... :/