Mafia Monster Mash Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)

[Trent the Paladin]

Then push me back? The only reason I'm voting you is because of the fact that your day isn't shifting at all. I'd be happy if you proved me wrong.

What's there to shift? I have made plainly clear my plan today, I have answered all questions thrown at my honestly and y'all suddenly expect me to change what I've been set on all Day One now? When the majority of players are focused on "Got it" and elim vs no elim?

 

[shawo]

oh ok that makes sense.
still not sold on trent tho... :/

But you're not actively defending them either? Do you, for any reason think Trent is town?

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

What's there to shift? I have made plainly clear my plan today, I have answered all questions thrown at my honestly and y'all suddenly expect me to change what I've been set on all Day One now? When the majority of players are focused on "Got it" and elim vs no elim?

If you don't change anything I will keep pushing you. I do have some expectation that you'd change the way you played to keep yourself alive, since that's a reaction that both town and mafia would make. What doesn't make sense is you not doing anything at all, even after you said my posts were bad, and even after you're the majority vote. Like, if you're town, letting yourself die is the worst possible move you can make?

 

[Sheep Villager]

What's there to shift? I have made plainly clear my plan today, I have answered all questions thrown at my honestly and y'all suddenly expect me to change what I've been set on all Day One now? When the majority of players are focused on "Got it" and elim vs no elim?

Were you not just on my case earlier for not going big enough with my old thoughts on voting Starlit and thinking about Random? Yet you sit on the option that gives even less info than those two.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

"Who is Trent going to vote today?"
I'm not, I am not interested.

I am playing self centered and purposely not aligning with anyone. Arguing with Shawo is a fruitless endeavor in my mind because it's either town v town generating nothing or it's town v mad, where I don't feel confident enough to push Shawo D1 right now.

 

[tae]

Trent the Paladin - gives food for thot. contributes. questions. still ****-posts and thats also pretty meta. only half null due to not being super obvious about potentials but also trent's pushed for no-elim since the very start so i can partly understand why he's not really deep diving anyone for a d1 vote. cdurious to see what he says d2.

i don't think hes being the best town he has been, but he's definitely been straight shot on what he thinks and why he's doing it. never waivered. our D1 hasnt been the most eventful in history and we're battling some inactivities and what not so like, i don't don't know what to do lol.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Were you not just on my case earlier for not going big enough with my old thoughts on voting Starlit and thinking about Random? Yet you sit on the option that gives even less info than those two.

Yes, because if you're going to vote a person out on Day 1 instead of No Elimination go big or don't bother voting

 

[tae]

sorry my quote was in response to @shawo

 

[shawo]

Tae, I scumread trent for the same reason you townread them. It's unnatural to be so committed to a single plan like that. What's the point?

 

[BetsySundrop]

like betsy's thought on it is a tinfoil hat theory?

That confused me too

 

[tae]

@BetsySundrop @Sidney @tessa grace where do you all stand on this no elim vs trent.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Tae, I scumread trent for the same reason you townread them. It's unnatural to be so committed to a single plan like that. What's the point?

Is it truly that strange to find someone committed to a singular plan? Would it not be stranger if I stayed my intention was to No Elim and then flip flop repeatedly afterwards?

 

[shawo]

tbh @BetsySundrop @tae we should just vote trent here to stop a forced no elim. I'm not entirely sure why you guys were on eachothers case still, but the alternative of getting a no elim here is the worst option I think. Trent doesn't seem super interested in keeping themselves alive in the last 30 minutes either.

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

Is it truly that strange to find someone committed to a singular plan? Would it not be stranger if I stayed my intention was to No Elim and then flip flop repeatedly afterwards?

That's... exactly normal behavior, actually. Especially since you haven't given a logical reason as to why you wanted the no elim, and instead just. Declared it.

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

Every other person in this game who wanted a no elim. Barring Random. Has put more thought into it with the posts than you have. The more Trent posts the more sure I am they're maf tbh. Which means it might not be worth responding to.

 

[BetsySundrop]

@BetsySundrop @Sidney @tessa grace where do you all stand on this no elim vs trent.

I dont like no elim.
I prefer random or yourself (sorry) over trent.
I have issues with trents absence of substance but still posting go ahead and vote him.

 

[shawo]

We're coming into 20 minutes till end of day. Let's get votes down so we don't force a rand on No Elim. We're basically splitting votes on Trent/No Elim here. And I'm pretty certain Trent!Town doesn't play like this.

 

[tae]

tbh @BetsySundrop @tae we should just vote trent here to stop a forced no elim. I'm not entirely sure why you guys were on eachothers case still, but the alternative of getting a no elim here is the worst option I think. Trent doesn't seem super interested in keeping themselves alive in the last 30 minutes either.

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

i'll revisit trent d2, but i don't have enough of a gut feeling on him to bandwagon here.

 

[tessa grace]

That leaves me with my official list of who will I be open to voting today and who I won't. List is slightly subject to change.

Will not vote today: Shawo, Betsy, Tessa, Tae

If something spicy happens by them I may vote: Sidney

Will vote one of these unless EOD reveals something magical: Trent, Starlit

Null zone: Random. Only voting if for whatever reason we dip back in to a no-vote dominant world.

Right now my process of elimination is in favor of Trent more than Starlit. I just have not had the chance to talk with Starlit at all and I have so many questions I'd like to ask if I make it to d2.

Why starlit? Voting ia is a no go for me.

 

[shawo]

i'll revisit trent d2, but i don't have enough of a gut feeling on him to bandwagon here.

ok but you also don't have enough time to not bandwagon. Forcing no elim is anti town. No one else offered an alternative up to end of day, and there's no counter bw.

 

[Sidney]

@BetsySundrop @Sidney @tessa grace where do you all stand on this no elim vs trent.

I have no idea my dude. Trent is hard for me to get a read on still

I just got internet restored back to my computer, so let me try to figure this out when i can get them off the phone finally

 

[shawo]

Tessa please, are you pro no elim?

 

[tae]

I dont like no elim.
I prefer random or yourself (sorry) over trent.
I have issues with trents absence of substance but still posting go ahead and vote him.

voting me wont do jack today. revisit me d2.

the options we have with 20 mins left is basically no-elim or trent.