Mafia Monster Mash Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)

[Sidney]

What's your preferred kill EoD if not Trent?

Probably betsy rn

Maybe you but I feel more inclined to trust you

random…idk whats going on there

trent will at least give info at this point, I think, and i doubt i’d get a good read on him later either (as i said, i’m inclined to believe he’d be good at hiding wolf. that and he’s been agreeing with me a lot which worries me for separate reasons) and I’m pressed for time now so

this is fine, i suppose

 

[shawo]

Tae, if you think Trent is town - is mafia leading the vote on them?

I'm pretty sure this is a natural bw that formed. So do you think this was manufactured by maf to kill Trent?

 

[tae]

Mafia being chill is actually a really strong tool to make town hesitate. In the one wolf game I had my partner literally got away with doing this exact thing.... and then I ruined it for the both of us the following day.

but theres not much sway here, and he's literally just rolling over and giving up.
thats legitimately against win-con as maf and id assume thats grounds for griefing don't you think?

Why did you vote no elim? There's no way you're 100% sure Trent's town here, so you're saving someone you THINK might be town (and in the process, still wasting our elim?)
It's not like we share the Meta you have, I've only ever seen Trent play in one other game, and you're not making a compelling argument for the No Elim either.

my only reasoning is gut instinct and past meta. was a town lean and null bc noelim from him is new but like, he's still his normal d1 trent self. and maybe that makes me bias but i'd bet money he doesn't flip maf. it's hard to play based off meta but this isn't maf!trent and you're burning an innocent witch at the stake.

 

[BetsySundrop]

If it’s not trent i say we do need to look into shawo/betsy as i sussed them earlier too

but also wonder if trent is only saying that to get us off of him, too

voting is always hard

It aint me. But if i get nk, yall know who to look at.
Tae and random lolol...

 

[tae]

Tae, if you think Trent is town - is mafia leading the vote on them?

I'm pretty sure this is a natural bw that formed. So do you think this was manufactured by maf to kill Trent?

thats a possibility yeah, and maybe it was just a hunch to stir the pot and enact EOD chaos to get people in the thread and actually contributing.

 

[BetsySundrop]

but theres not much sway here, and he's literally just rolling over and giving up.
thats legitimately against win-con as maf and id assume thats grounds for griefing don't you think?



my only reasoning is gut instinct and past meta. was a town lean and null bc noelim from him is new but like, he's still his normal d1 trent self. and maybe that makes me bias but i'd bet money he doesn't flip maf. it's hard to play based off meta but this isn't maf!trent and you're burning an innocent witch at the stake.

Then he should've fought for it. Why just say ok, np.

 

[Sheep Villager]

but theres not much sway here, and he's literally just rolling over and giving up.
thats legitimately against win-con as maf and id assume thats grounds for griefing don't you think?

Nope. Not against the win con if it gets town to hesitate. At that point it's an actual play to save yourself.

 

[BetsySundrop]

Tae, if you think Trent is town - is mafia leading the vote on them?

I'm pretty sure this is a natural bw that formed. So do you think this was manufactured by maf to kill Trent?

That would be you leading the vote....hmmm

 

[shawo]

but theres not much sway here, and he's literally just rolling over and giving up.
thats legitimately against win-con as maf and id assume thats grounds for griefing don't you think?



my only reasoning is gut instinct and past meta. was a town lean and null bc noelim from him is new but like, he's still his normal d1 trent self. and maybe that makes me bias but i'd bet money he doesn't flip maf. it's hard to play based off meta but this isn't maf!trent and you're burning an innocent witch at the stake.

Ok but I'm saying it's still optimal to kill Trent even if you DO tr them over no elim. Why are you actively playing into the no elim when it's just like. Mathematically bad.

 

[tae]

Then he should've fought for it. Why just say ok, np.

i mean i agree he needs to fight harder but ****, like i believe we're smart enough to push through the mechanics of a no-elim d1.

 

[shawo]

That would be you leading the vote....hmmm

I mean, if Tae's willing to commit to a sr an bw on me that'd be cool, but I'm curious as to how his reads are affected by the the Trent TR.

 

[shawo]

i mean i agree he needs to fight harder but ****, like i believe we're smart enough to push through the mechanics of a no-elim d1.

So you're playing for a mafia aligned game because... you townread Trent? Knowing no one else here does enough to let them die over no elim?

What's your end game?

If you force a no elim I will tunnel you. Again.

 

[tae]

So you're playing for a mafia aligned game because... you townread Trent? Knowing no one else here does enough to let them die over no elim?

What's your end game?

If you force a no elim I will tunnel you. Again.

im shocked you didnt d1 tbh.
you and betsy can beat me up together in the back alley if that helps you sleep at night.

my meta gut feeling on trent isnt wrong and i will eat my own socks if im wrong.

 

[BetsySundrop]

trent's apathy in dying isn't a scum tell at all. i don';t believe it.
i don't think ive ever seen maf!trent just lie over and take a beating.

I'm wondering if this strong towntrent read is because tae has inside information. So protesting so strongly = tae cleared of sus d2.

I'm still super sus of it and my order is the same: tae then random

 

[tessa grace]

Okay I'm here VERY last minute lol to give you all a quick who I'm voting and stuff

Who I WILL vote:
Sidney: I'm not backing down from this one even though some of her stuff has been explained I feel weirdly about the ins and outs of changing positions and ideas that's been happening, but I can see why she might be confused town. Idk it's still kind of scummy to me. I also didn't love the bandwagon onto trent after pushing so strongly a no elim.
Trent: He's gonna be my vote today because I am very against no elim for so many reasons, and I don't think we should split d1. He's also not given many great points that haven't already been said (ex: asking sidney a question I had literally just asked right before lol). I can get behind this for the sake of information for d2, he could be maf or couldn't be but I'm leaning more towards maf.
Tae: I will vote tae cause angry person haha (please dont come after me this is a joke)
Random: Literally no information from him but it's been very suspicious with the no elim and last minute opinions that have no actual value. But this would be my last option.
Who I WON'T vote (for now):
Shawo: Solid points, seems very town to me and has lead a lot of good discussion. From previous games I've seen he seems pretty standard town behavior. Maybe he's just really good, idk.
Starlit: STOP BEING SUSPICIOUS OF IA, LOL, they'll get replaced
Betsy: I think she has more to offer d2. That's really all I gotta post this before it locks.

 

[BetsySundrop]

Yep...its too strong trent town reading

Either its a team, or tae is looking to place early sus d2.

 

[shawo]

I'm wondering if this strong towntrent read is because tae has inside information. So protesting so strongly = tae cleared of sus d2.

I'm still super sus of it and my order is the same: tae then random

This is an interesting take, if trent flips town. Tae!maf could be possible on a no elim split. The one thing I'm wary of is that if Tae!maf Trent!town with another!maf in those voting Trent, reasonably one of them could vote no elim here and force

 

[tae]

I'm wondering if this strong towntrent read is because tae has inside information. So protesting so strongly = tae cleared of sus d2.

I'm still super sus of it and my order is the same: tae then random

i townread trent off meta and sisnt think shawo's push would cause a whole ass bandwagon. idk how me supporting my original townread on trent is sus now bc i worry yall ran into a riot on a whim.

 

[tessa grace]

Tae wouldn't team so quickly with someone being voted off if it was a tae/trent duo. That would draw too much suspicion d1 and be an easy town win.

 

[BetsySundrop]

You have inside info...sus

Post automatically merged: Oct 16, 2022

Tae wouldn't team so quickly with someone being voted off if it was a tae/trent duo. That would draw too much suspicion d1 and be an easy town win.

I think tae is maf def