Mafia Monster Mash Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)

[Sidney]

but if it was me tessa sidney, sidney would be the easy kill in f3.

tessa already had sus of sidney along w/ me. logistically speaking chancing it on you two would have a go at it would be foolish. absolutely and utterly foolish. the possibility that you'd tunnel me would be too high. and i think that was taken into account as to why we're left where we're at. it's sidney man. i don't have enough game experience as mafia to put my eggs into a basket like that and chance a f3 like this. i've been mafia like once and i got caught EARLY.

it would have been so much easier today if you had been the nk for maf!tae.

Post automatically merged: Oct 25, 2022

i mean somewhat yeah thats possible. but knowing im town, and seeing where todays landed, idk what to think anymore?

nothing i do or say can convince you it's sidney, and you're dead set on killing town today so what do i do here? what options do i have? do i still vote sidney and die town and lose? or do i push in hopes that maybe, just maybe, you're actually a wolf who's pushing the eod f3 kill on townie?

Killing betsy would mean that I would be pretty darn sure it’s you. I feel like tessa would’ve doublechecked and made sure, no? I’m not convinced tessa would’ve just auto voted me either

 

[tae]

Killing betsy would mean that I would be pretty darn sure it’s you. I feel like tessa would’ve doublechecked and made sure, no? I’m not convinced tessa would’ve just auto voted me either

probably not auto voted but the push to continue to convince her would have been easier. esp with the argument that could be made by your standpoint of "why would i kill my biggest sus and leave the two people who sussed me alone with me on f3".

 

[Sidney]

man, thats unfortunate. but i assumed you'd eventually "oh well i guess it's tae after all" you know, keep the townie appearance up when you know you're killing a tonwie here atfer sheeping your "most sussed player"

if you are town then i’m sorry to all of town

I suspected you as well since early

If it’s betsy, betsy is 1000 iq genius and I will eat plastic and send picture proof if you want

It’s also not an appearance? I genuinely am just town

 

[tae]

if you are town then i’m sorry to all of town

thank you. i am the clownie townie. you are not forgiven.

 

[Sidney]

probably not auto voted but the push to continue to convince her would have been easier. esp with the argument that could be made by your standpoint of "why would i kill my biggest sus and leave the two people who sussed me alone with me on f3".

Maybe, but I think tessa would’ve took a step back to evaluate a lot too

This set up seems like the ideal for maf!any of us to me, and maybe that is just me not getting this far last game/having little experience in general

 

[tae]

I suspected you as well since early

If it’s betsy, betsy is 1000 iq genius and I will eat plastic and send picture proof if you want

so why not push? why just claim you lean betsy more in f3 and then have the final "ahhh yeah i guess it is tae" stance?

Post automatically merged: Oct 25, 2022

Maybe, but I think tessa would’ve took a step back to evaluate a lot too

This set up seems like the ideal for maf!any of us to me, and maybe that is just me not getting this far last game/having little experience in general

i too have never been in f3, and have like, one game as mafia under my belt and i subbed into the game as mafia already under fire. so i feel you there. still sucks to see town lose.

 

[Sidney]

so why not push? why just claim you lean betsy more in f3 and then have the final "ahhh yeah i guess it is tae" stance?

I wish i had access to a computer so I could give you a better run through

I can give you another mobile mess of how I got here if you want

 

[tae]

I wish i had access to a computer so I could give you a better run through

I can give you another mobile mess of how I got here if you want

i leave for work in like, 20 mins. its gg with your vote on me.

 

[BetsySundrop]

but if it was me tessa sidney, sidney would be the easy kill in f3.

tessa already had sus of sidney along w/ me. logistically speaking chancing it on you two would have a go at it would be foolish. absolutely and utterly foolish. the possibility that you'd tunnel me would be too high. and i think that was taken into account as to why we're left where we're at. it's sidney man. i don't have enough game experience as mafia to put my eggs into a basket like that and chance a f3 like this. i've been mafia like once and i got caught EARLY.

it would have been so much easier today if you had been the nk for maf!tae.

I've played with tessa, and there's no way that sidney would have been an easy kill. Tessa was already questioning her sidney stance, and she indicated in eod posts that she was mainly going by your case against sidney and wasn't sure.

If today was sidney/tessa/tae, sidney would have had proof of me being town, and maybe looked to the person who tried to elim her. Also, tessa would have gone back and questioned the sidney push I believe.

I think it's very possible maf!tae thought that by killing tessa, it would have made sidney look sus, as tessa joined in voting her. So sidney would vote me, I would vote sidney, and town would lose.

If at eod it turns out to be sidney, then the best I can do is apologize, and double apologize to tessa, lol.

But the stronger case is that it's maf!tae.

 

[tae]

if ignoring your gut makes you feel more confident in your vote by all means, do it.
at the end of the day, caving and voting your biggest susser seems like the logical standpoint most people would do.
plus its a nice "heck you tae" for all the push ive given you. hope it's cathartic. well played mafia, well played.

 

[Sidney]

fingers crossed on this one

 

[BetsySundrop]

If it’s betsy, betsy is 1000 iq genius and I will eat plastic and send picture proof if you want

It's not. I would've voted you yesterday and targeted random today. No plastic needs to be eaten, lol.

 

[tae]

I've played with tessa, and there's no way that sidney would have been an easy kill. Tessa was already questioning her sidney stance, and she indicated in eod posts that she was mainly going by your case against sidney and wasn't sure.

If today was sidney/tessa/tae, sidney would have had proof of me being town, and maybe looked to the person who tried to elim her. Also, tessa would have gone back and questioned the sidney push I believe.

I think it's very possible maf!tae thought that by killing tessa, it would have made sidney look sus, as tessa joined in voting her. So sidney would vote me, I would vote sidney, and town would lose.

don't you think killing me, the biggest sus of her would have been the better route?
and then continuing to push onto you as a set up would have been better? esp if tessa was on the fence per se as you see it?

But the stronger case is that it's maf!tae.

If at eod it turns out to be sidney, then the best I can do is apologize, and double apologize to tessa, lol.

i'd like your apology in 14pt font, double spaced please.

Post automatically merged: Oct 25, 2022

gg mafia, you played well.

 

[Sidney]

I've played with tessa, and there's no way that sidney would have been an easy kill. Tessa was already questioning her sidney stance, and she indicated in eod posts that she was mainly going by your case against sidney and wasn't sure.

If today was sidney/tessa/tae, sidney would have had proof of me being town, and maybe looked to the person who tried to elim her. Also, tessa would have gone back and questioned the sidney push I believe.

I think it's very possible maf!tae thought that by killing tessa, it would have made sidney look sus, as tessa joined in voting her. So sidney would vote me, I would vote sidney, and town would lose.

I think so too; esp since yesterday i said i thought it would be tessa in the case that all of us were still townreading her more than anyone and she wasn’t mafia

esp since tae started first thing with talking about the nk when I’m struggling to comphrend it being anymore than just. giving us nothing. and leaving us with three people that all thought it was each of the others at some point in time

If at eod it turns out to be sidney, then the best I can do is apologize, and double apologize to tessa, lol.

But the stronger case is that it's maf!tae.

well i can guarantee it’s not that at least

 

[BetsySundrop]

don't you think killing me, the biggest sus of her would have been the better route?
and then continuing to push onto you as a set up would have been better? esp if tessa was on the fence per se as you see it?

If sidney was maf, yeah. You being alive kind of defeats that argument, no?

 

[tae]

I think it's very possible maf!tae thought that by killing tessa, it would have made sidney look sus, as tessa joined in voting her. So sidney would vote me, I would vote sidney, and town would lose.

well town just lost anyway

Post automatically merged: Oct 25, 2022

If sidney was maf, yeah. You being alive kind of defeats that argument, no?

im just saying that killing her sussers is a valid way to go.
i think im alive bc killing me might be TOO obvious, but killing tessa was the best route to go. and look it worked! you flipped and mafia wins.

 

[BetsySundrop]

i'd like your apology in 14pt font, double spaced please.

If I need to apologize, I'll make it a good one.

 

[Sidney]

well town just lost anyway

Post automatically merged: Oct 25, 2022

im just saying that killing her sussers is a valid way to go.
i think im alive bc killing me might be TOO obvious, but killing tessa was the best route to go. and look it worked! you flipped and mafia wins.

The game isn’t….over yet?

If you have a good argument or anything you think was said wrong we still have some time to discuss

Post automatically merged: Oct 25, 2022

I’

If I need to apologize, I'll make it a good one.

I’ll eat plastic if I’m somehow wrong

or any other apology

 

[BetsySundrop]

well town just lost anyway

Yeah, I don't think so...

you flipped and mafia wins.

What did I flip from? Thinking you were wolfy eod and now thinking you're...oh wait, still wolfy. What flip?

 

[tae]

If I need to apologize, I'll make it a good one.

you fell directly into the ploy. or you're a 1000 iq mafia mastermind.
given your flip was followed by a tunnel, theres a higher chance its you. idunno.

The game isn’t….over yet?

If you have a good argument or anything you think was said wrong we still have some time to discuss

i got like 10 minutes, but just sit and think about betsy while im away i guess. you were more leaning towards betsy at the start of today and now that i'm not super pushing you w/ a vote, betsy saw an opportunity to actually flip it all onto me instead and pile drive it home up until i need to leave for the day. you gut read her, but her "logic" has you flipped completely. once i voted on her for pressure she pile dived me. hunkered down when pressure was added to her case. me pushing for my innocence is too "spiky" but once pressure was added onto her at eod she gets intense and spiky too? i mean, that didn't ping your gut a little?

you sussed her the hardest all day and the second she pushed on me it all became super "clear" that im mafia.
if you are town, i wouldn't trust betsy in this case. and maybe it's bc i know im town and know a vote onto me = town loss. but if you're convinced in your own feelings and opinions on it, thats it.

Post automatically merged: Oct 25, 2022

What did I flip from? Thinking you were wolfy eod and now thinking you're...oh wait, still wolfy. What flip?

being more passive about it all until one final moment of NAH GET EM. its fine. you played a beautiful maf!betsy game and i envy you here. give me tips and tricks after this is all over i want to learn.

Post automatically merged: Oct 25, 2022

betsy knew if she voted me id HAVE to omgus and vote her back for self preservation.
she knew i'd have to do the logical town thing and keep myself alive and fight it even if i suss you.