Mafia Official TBT Mafia General Thread - Game Types/Bans/Hosting
- Thread starter Justin
- Start date
- Status
What's going on at the bottom there? Seems reasonable enough, but I'd have the names come first before the offense.
You always could.
That is one idea yeah. Judging from the looks of it that's how it'd be done in Lauren's example form?
I appreciate everyone looking to help by taking initiative towards a system, a list, or a doc. However, whatever ban system we put in place is going to be ran by the staff in alignment with the official game system. Our new mafia playing mods, Tina and Gandalf, will be helping out with this as well and we'll have something put together within a few days hopefully. (which was the plan when I posted looking for discussion on a system earlier this week) I understand some of you might be upset since I heard there were a lot of mod kills today, but really this has been a problem for a while, the sky is not suddenly falling on our heads. Sit tight, we'll figure it out. We'll also be looking at changing parts of how the official games, queue, and host requirements work.
Awesome, well mind and ash' ideas are thrown into that doc.
Ill explain it.
(TBD) - To be discussed. Its a group decisions. We should all discuss, how long bans are for each offence, and how much they escalate for repeat offenders.
I left a space to the end as this indicates we could add more columns such as, the host who awarded the ban and what not
the stuff at the bottom.
general mafia changes and improvements.
Game plans, breaks and what not.
main and mini… newbie… main and mini
Maybe have breaks between games so
play a main and a mini at the same time...
allow a break for main and mini and let newbie mafia commence.
Once finished open a mini and a main
Newbie mafia - what would you class as newbie?
unless stated otherwise, 3 game maximum for newbie maf
Ash brought up certain members taking advantage of newbie mafia, so placing a game maximum for people to play would make this easier. I mean its the host decision if they feel a member needs help.
Suggested age? Not a limit, just a guideline (TBD)
a suggested age, theres a lot of heated arguments in mafia so like 13? discuss.
Hosting requirements, change them?
with people flopping at hosting, maybe it takes more knowledge to host?
Post quality and gifs
THIS! One word sentences, Cent made a post about how post quality still counts here yes, and without punishment. Gifs too, i know they enhance a game, but they're being used willy nilly, if a gif had no relevance to the post or is just spam.
Last edited:
Not exactly wanting to sound ungrateful about you guys stepping in Jubs, but shouldnt that be discussed openly amongst us?
oath2order
#Porygon2024
How are unofficial games going to be affected by this?
Last edited:
Breaks are definitely needed between three to four games (two main, two minis?) but I also think we should enforce breaks on players who haven't taken a break in a while. Despite what some players might think, sometimes you really ought to have some people step and tell you its time for a break.
Newbie games I would class newbies as player who haven't played five mafia games or generally have not improved in anyway or need remedial games.
I don't think age is that big of a problem player wise.
Require co-hosts for players who haven't hosted before and worry is expressed via thread or PM?
I think gifs are fine so long as its not out of control like Kermit was. The post requires a lot of substance with it unless a death post?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh I misread then, my bad. I thought you meant you guys (the staff) was going to handle the whole thing.
If by handle it, yes, we will run it and manage it. I don't believe an open doc to all hosts is a good method. But I do want to include everyone else in the discussion, say, what are reasonable ban lengths for example?
My personal opinion is that either official games need to have more of a benefit, or unofficial games need to be hidden away more, to promote waiting in the queue civilly or else there is no point anymore and we will be back to the line jumping that occurred previously. (which is why we implemented a queue) I can't speak for everyone else though, those are simply my thoughts right now.
Please don't take this personally either Ashtot. It's not against you personally, you're just the first one to actually try posting an unofficial game which HAS always been allowed.
My personal opinion is that either official games need to have more of a benefit, or unofficial games need to be hidden away more, to promote waiting in the queue civilly or else there is no point anymore and we will be back to the line jumping that occurred previously. (which is why we implemented a queue) I can't speak for everyone else though, those are simply my thoughts right now.
Please don't take this personally either Ashtot. It's not against you personally, you're just the first one to actually try posting an unofficial game which HAS always been allowed.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
Thanks for reading my mind 
Ah, I gotcha now. I thought the whole process (like the discussion happening now) you guys were handling.
What kind of benefit could we possibly add to official games though? Badges for playing "X" amount of mafia games?
Probably going to be controversial, but I think perhaps The Cellar should be reserved for the official games, and other games can go in The Basement like the old days. History thread should be reserved for the official games as well, although I believe that's already the case. By badges, do you mean like a collectible?
oath2order
#Porygon2024
I like the Official in cellar, unofficial in basement.
- Status
