Mafia Paper Mario Thousand Year Door Mafia - Mafia Win!!

[Tensu]

Whomever is mafia must be loving this, the people that are pushing me right now should be monitored thoroughly throughout this game. It's also cute how many people have jumped on the "Omg, Zendel is differently this time" train, you little cutie wooties, lmao. It's the perfect opportunity to get someone out, I think at least one or two mafia people are in the midst, so I think I will be paying attention to them.

I have noticed this to be frank. I was the one who brought up your change in behavior but I made sure to be clear that I did not consider that to be indicative of scum. I had agreed with Seroja that I am not entirely convinced that your change in behavior meant scum lean. I'll be looking back through the thread to see who bandwagoned my post about your change and keep it in mind.

 

[moonford]

Oh lord Zendel, you're always so quick to claim omg. Only claim when you are set to be lynched! Otherwise just keep defending yourself. If you're town you have nothing to hide. Anyway, claiming so early will only make it easier for mafia to narrow down power roles. Please keep this in mind in future games.

I know how the game works, a bunch of people will jump on me and vote me because most of them are sheep, lol. I was a sheep in the first game, you could see that from a mile away.

So I think a claim is necessary because pursuing me is a waste of time for us. But you are more experienced so I'll take your advice into consideration for the future. Sorry if this hurts the game's fun, I'm such a silly goose sometimes and I'm still trying to figure out how I should defend myself when people try to pressure me.

The only thing I can do is keep calm and respond with rationality as well as sincerity as I always do.

 

[f11]

That was really lame no offense.

 

[moonford]

Omg, I just realized why being a target for scum is useful. I'm so sorry guys we could have gotten a lot of pointers for who to be cautious for.

 

[f11]

Claiming isn't keeping calm

- - - Post Merge - - -

Like no one even voted for you

 

[moonford]

That was really lame no offense.

None taken, it was lame and I should have waited a bit longer. Sorryyy!

 

[f11]

At anyone who's played paper Mario, is there enough players in the game for mafia to have fake claims?

 

[moonford]

Claiming isn't keeping calm

- - - Post Merge - - -

Like no one even voted for you

I claimed because it would be a dead end for town, I thought it was the right thing to do for us but looking back on it now, I really should have waited until we had more information.

It was dumb of me, so I apologize.

- - - Post Merge - - -

At anyone who's played paper Mario, is there enough players in the game for mafia to have fake claims?

I've never played Paper Mario before, so I don't know any of the characters so I can't fake claim.

 

[Seroja]

I claimed because it would be a dead end for town, I thought it was the right thing to do for us but looking back on it now, I really should have waited until we had more information.

It was dumb of me, so I apologize.

Don't beat yourself up about it. What's done is done, let's move the discussion to something else.

Regarding the bandwagon, the person who stands out to me the most is definitely Nightmares. I like how she's keeping such a low profile in this game. Normally as town she posts whenever and whatever she likes. But she's definitely being more careful in this game. She's definitely on my sus list right now, and I'd really like to hear more from her.

Prima is also very quiet this game, aside from that one post sussing f11 for 'obvious reasons'. I feel like it's possible that the ones who have posted actively so far are mostly town while scums stand at the side.

 

[moonford]

Don't beat yourself up about it. What's done is done, let's move the discussion to something else.

Regarding the bandwagon, the person who stands out to me the most is definitely Nightmares. I like how she's keeping such a low profile in this game. Normally as town she posts whenever and whatever she likes. But she's definitely being more careful in this game. She's definitely on my sus list right now, and I'd really like to hear more from her.

Prima is also very quiet this game, aside from that one post sussing f11 for 'obvious reasons'. I feel like it's possible that the ones who have posted actively so far are mostly town while scums stand at the side.

I said I wouldn't be using meta this game because people change things up, Jacob used meta on Heyden in Dolby's game I believe, and he was proven wrong.

Nightmares is usually more carefree when she is town, in fact she made a careless joke which moved the intention onto her and created a lot of nonsense.

Nightmares is usually more careful when she is mafia, she posts shorter content and bandwagons of the popular opinion. She literally popped in here said her suspicions on me and left, it's weird but I don't know if she should be pursued because meta isn't always right.

I don't know if we should hold Prima's inactivity against him, he is always like that. If he responds to this be on the look out for how he defends himself, he can be aggressive and he could be put under pressure until he makes a slip up or something very revealing possibly.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Intention = attention. =/

 

[Nightmares]

I mean, if no one counterclaims, then I guess Zendel is town
Your style is weird this game, but I'm also feeling ill and acting different...so.......idk
I'm not writing huge paragraphs about it, but w/e
Guess I'll drop it for now lmao
Your last post made a lot of sense?
........idfk kms

I'm not sure about anyone else atm, but I'll put in more effort tomorrow, sorry

 

[Seroja]

It's a bit late so I have to go to bed. I'll be back in a couple of hours.

For now my reads look something like this:

Inactives: Cleb and eun
Where are youuuuu?

Null, possible town: Tensu, Jacob
After much consideration, I decided to put Jacob here. His reads are sensible, but I'd like to hear more from him. I think Tensu is town because I find his posts sincere. However, there's not enough content to be sure.

Null: f11, Heyden, mog, Dan, Corrie
f11 and Heyden could be town but they're mostly null for now. I need more from mog, Corrie and Dan.

Town lean: Trundle and Zendel

Trundle so far has showed the most effort in pushing people and creating discussions. Nothing jumps out to me as scummy so far.
As for Zendel, I was leaning town on him anyway.

Sus - slight scum lean: Nightmares, Prima, Panda

Panda was reading town for me earlier in the game, but right now my gut is saying something isn't right. She appeared to be contributing to the game, but there's a sense of distance in her posts, like she's putting up a front. I can't really explain it well, but I don't feel right with town reading her anymore. Can't even put her on null, cos I'm certainly suspicious of her.

Also I'm not saying that we should definitely vote Nightmares or Prima. Hopefully by addressing them we can finally get more content from them which we can then use to make more informed reads. That's my goal.

- - - Post Merge - - -

sorry if my format is confusing, I'm too sleepy to make it prettier. see you guys in a bit!

 

[moonford]

So the players who I feel need to be looked into:

Nightmares, meta can be a lie but I still think we should look, her post on me was the first in a while and she left after it.

f11, uncooperative. Yes the question could be considered "dumb" but you could've at least answered it.

Corrie, very evasive when asked questions and retaliated with pointing scum at Trundle. Trundle's excuse could be BS but it is rational, so I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt this time.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm not confident in f11, Nightmare or Corrie right now though. I'm sticking to my vote on f11 for now, we have plenty of time to decide on a lynch.

 

[mogyay]

did nightmares just try and justify her own slightly quiet behaviour as the same as zendal's? honestly i think when someone is having a bad day it's best to just believe them but it's odd

also sorry zendal, i believe your claim, i thought maybe your change in play style was just a cover for being scum

honestly i'm a little confused right now as to who to vote, i still think it's probably people in the shadows but there's no point in just randomly voting for one of them, i hope more people speak up tonight (should someone message tae? they aren't v active on tbt)

 

[moonford]

did nightmares just try and justify her own slightly quiet behaviour as the same as zendal's? honestly i think when someone is having a bad day it's best to just believe them but it's odd

also sorry zendal, i believe your claim, i thought maybe your change in play style was just a cover for being scum

honestly i'm a little confused right now as to who to vote, i still think it's probably people in the shadows but there's no point in just randomly voting for one of them, i hope more people speak up tonight (should someone message tae? they aren't v active on tbt)

It's fine honestly, don't worry about it. I would do the same thing.

I really want some posts from Eun and Cleb too, Cleb can be very useful for town whereas I'm not sure what Eun is capable of and I really want to see. Please get here soon you two.

 

[toadsworthy]

Replacement found for eun, move along

 

[PandaDarling]

Heyden think he's been genuinely helpful so far.
Apple2013 comes across as scum hunting.
mogyayl sincere sweet little Mogy <3
Seroja seems to be trying to find scum.
Tensu cant get a decent read.
xCleb not enough input.
Damniel please come back from prom already.
Jacob unsure where to place him.
Primarina need more to get a read.
f11 who knows ha.
Zendel just cause you claimed VT, which is very unhelpful to town if that is your alignment, doesn't mean i believe it, its a very 'safe claim' and you still rub me the wrong way.
Nightmares seriously you're gonna come back tomorrow, after Day1 ? with 'more effort' ?
Corrie i think they are avoiding the thread and any questions pointed towards them.
eun most likely will get replaced or modkilled.

i know these are really short, just first thoughts about each person off the top of my head. i know some of you are more use to me being more active but I've never seen such a quiet Day 1 and with a new job i have less hours to post, i have been keeping up on the thread during my lunch breaks and all but its heard to get any reads when half the plays are hardly responding to one another.

Nighmares i hope that you decide to make an effort TODAY, cause tomorrow will do us NO GOOD. if not you may be my vote.

Corrie i need you to come back and answer the question that were asked of you.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Nightmares no mafia is stupid enough to counterclaim townies, wtf are you on? What mafia would claim a random townie name if they weren't given it fake name anyway?

Anyway I have huge town vibes from Tensu. However I have very scummy vibes from Panda. More on this shortly, I am in the middle of a few things irl. I have a lot to reply to.

 

[PandaDarling]

I mean, if no one counterclaims, then I guess Zendel is town
Your style is weird this game, but I'm also feeling ill and acting different...so.......idk
I'm not writing huge paragraphs about it, but w/e
Guess I'll drop it for now lmao
Your last post made a lot of sense?
........idfk kms

I'm not sure about anyone else atm, but I'll put in more effort tomorrow, sorry

Nighmares i see you lurking the thread you better come back in here and put "more effort" before end of day.

 

[Nightmares]

Nightmares no mafia is stupid enough to counterclaim townies, wtf are you on? What mafia would claim a random townie name if they weren't given it fake name anyway?

Anyway I have huge town vibes from Tensu. However I have very scummy vibes from Panda. More on this shortly, I am in the middle of a few things irl. I have a lot to reply to.

I meant that Zendel is mafia, and a townie counterclaims
Wtf are YOU on?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Nighmares i see you lurking the thread you better come back in here and put "more effort" before end of day.

Like I said, I'm feeling ill today so I'm saying that I'll have more motivation than tomorrow
I'm not saying that I'm gonna completely disappear until then
Lmfao