Mafia Resident Evil Mafia - Game Thread [Endgame- Mafia Wins]

[Damniel]

anyway @b100ming, if you find my slot sus solely on the basis of the previous player, you'd have to have a problem with my posts too. if your evidence for my slot relies solely on misty and not me, i can't defend against that and the evidence is a bit outdated imo

 

[b100ming]

anyway @b100ming, if you find my slot sus solely on the basis of the previous player, you'd have to have a problem with my posts too. if your evidence for my slot relies solely on misty and not me, i can't defend against that and the evidence is a bit outdated imo

Ok. I‘ll try not to do that anymore.

 

[Antonio]

BTW, I would like to say I understand @BetsySundrop POE and why she came to me, even though I do not agree with her reasoning for susing me. I still would like to hear your POE @b100ming.

Based on this, I still think my theory has merit as previously stated here:

Regarding the coincidence, usually mafia are the informed minority with a separate chat so they would discuss their opinions during the night phase. Y'all both mentioned the idea of me bussing wolf being suspicious. I have previously stated the idea of that is stupid and obvious. Plus, I also implied the idea was flawed here:
I don't actually believe it was an attempted push, but a slip of having similar ideas. Since I have stated the idea doesn't make sense, it would be weird for two townies to bring the idea up, which doesn't make sense, especially as closely as possible. It makes more plausible sense for two mafia, who has discussed their opinions during the night, to come up with a similar flawed idea together and express those opinions so closely to one another.

Regardless of the theory, I do think Ghost is the most sus due to their lack of reasoning for their behavior. Betsy/Shell have been posting full out opinions so any suspicion I have on them based on the theory is making me doubt it.

@Damniel @b100ming @tessa. @voltairenism can you provide your opinions on the theory?

 

[Ghost2008]

What even are you doing? I thought you found me sus earlier?

Maybe you are on my list

Post automatically merged: Oct 13, 2021

Maybe you are on my list

You are on my list not maybe

 

[Antonio]

Maybe you are on my list

Post automatically merged: Oct 13, 2021

You are on my list not maybe

Game aside, there's an odd threatening aura to this. "You're on my list" like are you trying to kill me.

 

[Ghost2008]

Game aside, there's an odd threatening aura to this. "You're on my list" like are you trying to kill me.

Lol no then I would say hit list

 

[b100ming]

Lol no then I would say hit list

That would give it away

Post automatically merged: Oct 13, 2021

Game aside, there's an odd threatening aura to this. "You're on my list" like are you trying to kill me.

What good would that do? He could vote you off! But he’s also a noob, so….

 

[b100ming]

Ghost, as much as I love you, I’m voting you off because you’re misleading us as town or are actually mafia.

“It’s not personal, it’s just programming”

 

[Antonio]

Ghost, as much as I love you, I’m voting you off because you’re misleading us as town or are actually mafia.

“It’s not personal, it’s just programming”

May I ask why you want to vote off Ghost over your other sus reads like me and dan.

 

[Ghost2008]

Ghost, as much as I love you, I’m voting you off because you’re misleading us as town or are actually mafia.

“It’s not personal, it’s just programming”

Suuuuuuuuuussssssss

 

[Antonio]

Suuuuuuuuuussssssss

but why is it sus, explain your actions.

 

[Damniel]

Regardless of the theory, I do think Ghost is the most sus due to their lack of reasoning for their behavior. Betsy/Shell have been posting full out opinions so any suspicion I have on them based on the theory is making me doubt it.

@Damniel @b100ming @tessa. @voltairenism can you provide your opinions on the theory?

i agree that you bussing ghost is unlikely. not only would it be unnecessary to do that, but its honestly somewhat throwing by pressuring your partner THAT hard. im not sure on ghost's alignment but I think antonios town anyway

on shell and betsy posting similar things at the same time, I think that's coincidental. If they were a team, I would imagine they would have planned their attack more carefully and not carelessly post at the same time. I see strong validity for betsy being maf, but I see shell as town. regardless, I dont think the two would be teamed. its just too careless. yeah i dont agree with the you-bussing-ghost theory, but I dont think them posting at similar times means it was necessarily planned

Post automatically merged: Oct 13, 2021

it can exist as a tinfoil theory i suppose, but I think its unlikely

 

[b100ming]

May I ask why you want to vote off Ghost over your other sus reads like me and dan.

He’s kinda making it impossible to solve this. I mean, he’s been asked for reads hasn’t he? The main reason I didn’t sus him was due to a big sister instinct and that wasn’t good for the game.

 

[Antonio]

on shell and betsy posting similar things at the same time, I think that's coincidental. If they were a team, I would imagine they would have planned their attack more carefully and not carelessly post at the same time. I see strong validity for betsy being maf, but I see shell as town. regardless, I dont think the two would be teamed. its just too careless. yeah i dont agree with the you-bussing-ghost theory, but I dont think them posting at similar times means it was necessarily planned

I'm not implying it was planned, please go reread the theory carefully.

I don't actually believe it was an attempted push, but a slip of having similar ideas. Since I have stated the idea doesn't make sense, it would be weird for two townies to bring the idea up, which doesn't make sense, especially as closely as possible. It makes more plausible sense for two mafia, who has discussed their opinions during the night, to come up with a similar flawed idea together and express those opinions so closely to one another.

Post automatically merged: Oct 13, 2021

He’s kinda making it impossible to solve this. I mean, he’s been asked for reads hasn’t he? The main reason I didn’t sus him was due to a big sister instinct and that wasn’t good for the game.

He was mafia in the last game which you hosted, do you see any differences or similarities?

 

[b100ming]

He was mafia in the last game which you hosted, do you see any differences or similarities?

Last game was unreliable because he spammed himself into a day one elim. But I have seen similar spammy behavior in this game

 

[Antonio]

Last game was unreliable because he spammed himself into a day one elim. But I have seen similar spammy behavior in this game

Could you elaborate on the similarities? Why do you consider it unreliable as well?

 

[Damniel]

I'm not implying it was planned, please go reread the theory carefully.

oh whoops. idk, it feels a bit tinfoily. i dont know how much more likely it would be for partners to coincidently post the same thought than it would be for t/t or t/w to do the same

 

[Antonio]

oh whoops. idk, it feels a bit tinfoily. i dont know how much more likely it would be for partners to coincidently post the same thought than it would be for t/t or t/w to do the same

It's not just about the similar thought though, it's more that both of the same thought happened so closely together. If it was a bit spread out, I wouldn't even be thinking this though.

 

[Damniel]

its a theory to keep in the back of our mind, if one were to flip red at least. b

Post automatically merged: Oct 13, 2021

It's not just about the similar thought though, it's more that both of the same thought happened so closely together. If it was a bit spread out, I wouldn't even be thinking this though.

i think its just more of a coincidence. idk if wolf partners would come up with the same thought so quickly. even if they are teamed it just feels like it happened by chance

 

[Antonio]

its a theory to keep in the back of our mind, if one were to flip red at least. b

I do agree it's a bit tinfoily, though. What do you think about day 2 so far? Has anything stood out to you?