ive been giving my thoughts throughout the same. im going to give tessa time to catch up, but betsy and ghost look the worst for me rn. volt has also fallen off today tbh. i feel like i haven't heard much from volt at all today
ive been giving my thoughts throughout the same. im going to give tessa time to catch up, but betsy and ghost look the worst for me rn. volt has also fallen off today tbh. i feel like i haven't heard much from volt at all today
I have a cold too. So does ghost and everyone in our family
Btw none of my teachers have tissues
Post automatically merged:
You can get a cold year-round, but most people consider the winter months to be common cold season. The viruses that cause colds also spread more easily just after a drop in temperature and humidity. 1 Generally, this means the United States' cold season starts sometime around September and ends sometime around April.Mar 17, 2020
Yup. It's WIFOM that has me overthinking and complicating everything. I like to at least feel sure (ish) if I vote someone, or at least have good reasons.
Thinking of voting the inactive potter as last resort if I cant make up my mind. At least its a known mia that likely wont improve....
i mean jumpy in how at the start of EoD she basically opened herself up to voting antonio, volt, ghost, potter and geoni by stating that she would consider voting them, yet cast some doubt at the end of each statement as if to not commit to any read in lieu of seeing how EoD would develop. a lot of her posts at EoD have something like “i could be wrong here” or “you could be right” which comes off as a little forced and allows her to jump around between different ideas. she was kinda just all over the place and it’s hard to pinpoint her train of thought (because she casts so much self doubt on herself) is what i’m trying to say
Looks like there may be people hopping on my wagon, so I'll do my best to answer everything, give reasons for my decisions etc. I'll be around on and off this evening if anyone wants to ask me anything directly.
i mean jumpy in how at the start of EoD she basically opened herself up to voting antonio, volt, ghost, potter and geoni by stating that she would consider voting them, yet cast some doubt at the end of each statement as if to not commit to any read in lieu of seeing how EoD would develop. a lot of her posts at EoD have something like “i could be wrong here” or “you could be right” which comes off as a little forced and allows her to jump around between different ideas. she was kinda just all over the place and it’s hard to pinpoint her train of thought (because she casts so much self doubt on herself) is what i’m trying to say
For all of those quotes above, there is a consistent "I don't know who to vote" theme. It was d1, having had "never vote no elim d1" drilled into me in last 2 games, I was trying to figure out who to vote for. I had a few people on my town or town lean (misty, shell, b100ming), everybody else was possible vote. Nobody had done anything that I could point to and say aha! It's that one! So I was trying to figure out who I was going to vote.
So you are right- I did have everyone (except my townreads) as possible votes, and you are also right that I was very doubtful that out of the possible 5, I would get it right. D1 seems to always be that way, so I don't believe it is unusual or suspicious. And I did list all my reasons for town/sus.
i mean jumpy in how at the start of EoD she basically opened herself up to voting antonio, volt, ghost, potter and geoni by stating that she would consider voting them, yet cast some doubt at the end of each statement as if to not commit to any read in lieu of seeing how EoD would develop. a lot of her posts at EoD have something like “i could be wrong here” or “you could be right” which comes off as a little forced and allows her to jump around between different ideas. she was kinda just all over the place and it’s hard to pinpoint her train of thought (because she casts so much self doubt on herself) is what i’m trying to say
While I don't think this matches her mafia meta, I do agree that her behavior does allow her to jump between different ideas. I also feel her first post at the beginning of day 2 where she posted her reads but didn't explain them right then in there allowed her time to come up with an actual reason for her read falls under the category of "jumping between ideas".
BTW, I would like to say I understand @BetsySundrop POE and why she came to me, even though I do not agree with her reasoning for susing me. I still would like to hear your POE @b100ming.
Based on this, I still think my theory has merit as previously stated here:
Regardless of the theory, I do think Ghost is the most sus due to their lack of reasoning for their behavior. Betsy/Shell have been posting full out opinions so any suspicion I have on them based on the theory is making me doubt it.
i meant to say "but for now its not the strongest evidence imo"
Post automatically merged:
ive been giving my thoughts throughout the same. im going to give tessa time to catch up, but betsy and ghost look the worst for me rn. volt has also fallen off today tbh. i feel like i haven't heard much from volt at all today
@Damniel I'm on for a while, responding. Ask me anything. Feels like there is a wagon push for me, and I know I'm flipping town, so want to give every opportunity for people to dig in and do my best to explain my actions.
While I don't think this matches her mafia meta, I do agree that her behavior does allow her to jump between different ideas. I also feel her first post at the beginning of day 2 where she posted her reads but didn't explain them right then in there allowed her time to come up with an actual reason for her read falls under the category of "jumping between ideas".
I dont understand what you mean when you say my behavior allows me to jump between different ideas. On d1? Of course I had a larger pool of suspects. I had 5. On d2 I now have 3. This is how it works. At first, everyone is sus. Then I try to spot town/sus and reduce the pool. And I haven't seen anything to change my townreads.
I also addressed my d2 entry post already. I voted, gave my list of town/sus, then said that I was going to answer questions and give my reads. And that's what I did (after a brief mix up because I didn't get the friendly neighbor pm until 5 minutes after b100ming asked me about it, so had no idea what she was talking about). And you have even stated that you do not disagree with my townreads, and you see why I voted for you.
All of my reads in d2 match my first d2 posting. I'm not jumping around, or trying to wait to come up with something, or even trying to convince anyone to vote a particular way. Just putting my reasons out there, and trying to get it right.
I realize I was a day late and a dollar short at d1 eod. That was completely my own fault. I was still unsure who to vote, and was looking for a "last minute clue" that would help me finally decide. When geoni continued his death tunnel, and didn't respond to any of my (I thought reasonable) counters, it reminded me of last game (illogical geoni who won as maf), as it appeared an illogical death tunnel, and so I did decide to vote geoni. By the time I finished typing my vote explanation post and hit reply, there were several new posts. I read those, saw geoni had claimed pr, b100 asked which, he said jailkeeper, and I switched my vote to volt (who was just 1 out of the others on my sus list). Then went back to post that I'd switched off geoni, and then catch up again with the thread, where I saw volt said my other post was dumb. And I can definitely see that from his perspective, as I was behind on things. However, I can't really regret that sequence, as reviewing that is what has put volt in firm town for me, helping to narrow my poe.
Post automatically merged:
Also wanted to mention, geoni calling me out after I disagreed with him about misty did make him more sus to me, as he mentioned I could be protecting misty/dan, but did not have a good response to my logical rebuttal. Could I be wrong about your slot? Pfft, sure. But I have it town, and haven't seen anything to change my mind, so am hoping I'm not wrong, and keeping it town.
(And yes, I can hear geoni from the graveyard, probably objecting, lol)...
at this point in time i’d rather hear volt and tessa have to say since those two are the slots i have yet to sort. Particularly volt, who i feel hasn’t been a point of discussion much
Post automatically merged:
i am also interested in what people have to say on volt cuz i feel the reads on them are either vague or based form early D1
Volt- at eod d1 I really had volt on my sus list (explained in previous post, the light sus/unanswered questions, then sudden long absence, then back in game for last part of d1). I thought geoni/volt could be a possible team (see previous on why geoni was sus), and voted geoni. However- after I saw geoni had claimed jailkeeper (and I switched my vote off of him)...I noticed volts CAPITAL LETTERS of GET YOUR VOTE OFF GEONI to either b100ming or myself. That has cleared volt for me. It appeared to be town completely frustrated with people voting a claimed pr. I think it was genuine frustration, in a situation where mafia would just keep quiet and let it happen, so volt is town.
I haven't noticed anything else that stood out that didn't fit with what seems usual.
