Mafia Sunleth Waterscape Mafia (Game Over/Mafia Win)

[radical6]

Instead of having temper tantrums, calm down and think about town's strategy logically. If mew is telling the truth about being vig and Prin is telling the truth about being doc, then we can at least tell them who they should protect. In my opinion, Prin needs to protect mew so that mew can shoot potential scum and perhaps reduce the KP. Yes, it wasn't smart of them to out blue roles on day one but what is done is done. I don't think either of these players deserve to be lost either. I don't think they're BSing because like somebody else said I think mew had no other way to defend herself and just panicked and outed herself. Same with Prin.

Fireninja, Jellofish, Nikki, Ashtot, SP, Minties, and Tom...it could be any of these people imo. For me, I've gathered two blue claims and two townie claims, so they aren't included in this list. Again, you'll probably get snappy at me for not including Ryan but I don't think Ryan is mafia tbh. And out of all the people I listed at the beginning of the paragraph I think Ashtot seems the most townish due to his tantrums and lashing out. So I think it's one of these folk:

Fireninja1
JellofishXD
Superpenguin
Tom
NikkiNikki
Minties

When it comes to Tom and Superpenguin though, I want more information on the whole twin thing.

I agree with this list. I personally believe you're town as well because you could've denied the miniflan claim and lynched me. Also as mafia you wouldn't have known if all townie names are unique or not sooo. That and you're trying to get us back on track during this mess, when as mafia you could've let this chaos continue.

As for the twin claim, I don't buy it. Even if this was another twin case like in Frozen, Tom would've at least known about it right?
I'm going with Jellofish though. It's really hard to get a read on JellofishXD anyway.

##UNVOTE
##VOTE: JellofishXD

 

[toastia]

Oh thanks for reminding me tsundere.

Ty dad. We'd probably be still going insane right now.

 

[Geoni]

If I'm remembering correctly Jellofish is in a different timezone than many of us? She was really quiet in newbie on the run and she ended up being blue, but I wasn't a part of mean girls and I know she flipped scum in that game. I think it's quite possible that she's mafia in this game though, because school should be over for her by now and she should have posted by now. Also is Jellofish a male or a female? :|

FireNinja1 seems to have lurked up until now and from what I've read into the posts he has made he seems a little less scummy than others, at least on an emotional tone in his post against mew, but at the same time I think it's a really silly vote because it's easy to tell that mew outed out of panic.

Tom and SP...I just don't know lol. Unless Tom comes forward with information about his PM and monster than I'm not sure I'm willing to buy SP's claim as twin. They would definitely need to be the same monster and I don't think they'd also be miniflan.

NikkiNikki is a little harder to read into as she always is. And because she has only made one post, Minties is a little difficult to read into as well.

- - - Post Merge - - -

For now I'll be voting for JellofishXD due to them not coming forward after saying they would. I'll change if somebody seems scummier and they have an excuse as to why they didn't come forward.

- - - Post Merge - - -

So...

#Vote: JellofishXD

Almost thought there was another voting thread for a sec lol.

 

[Minties]

Okay so I've woken up early because day ends when I'm at work (5am here).

And at the twin thing, Minties, they don't always know each other's identities. They didn't in Frozen when there was good elsa and evil elsa. At least I don't think they did? They just knew the other one existed from what I remember. I won't disregard the idea that SP could be throwing a curve ball of a role claim at us, he's done it a number of times before.

I hadn't kept up with frozen mafia at all, so I thought they knew they were a twin, which is why I asked. I agree with Tsundere though, not buying the twin claim because it's SP.

Instead of having temper tantrums, calm down and think about town's strategy logically. If mew is telling the truth about being vig and Prin is telling the truth about being doc, then we can at least tell them who they should protect. In my opinion, Prin needs to protect mew so that mew can shoot potential scum and perhaps reduce the KP. Yes, it wasn't smart of them to out blue roles on day one but what is done is done. I don't think either of these players deserve to be lost either. I don't think they're BSing because like somebody else said I think mew had no other way to defend herself and just panicked and outed herself. Same with Prin.

Fireninja, Jellofish, Nikki, Ashtot, SP, Minties, and Tom...it could be any of these people imo. For me, I've gathered two blue claims and two townie claims, so they aren't included in this list. Again, you'll probably get snappy at me for not including Ryan but I don't think Ryan is mafia tbh. And out of all the people I listed at the beginning of the paragraph I think Ashtot seems the most townish due to his tantrums and lashing out. So I think it's one of these folk:

Fireninja1
JellofishXD
Superpenguin
Tom
NikkiNikki
Minties

When it comes to Tom and Superpenguin though, I want more information on the whole twin thing.

So let me get this straight - because most of that list didn't publicly roleclaim on day one, they're all suspicious? The majority of people on there have played 10+ games and are NOT stupid enough to throw out their roles, green or blue day one. You know what that does? That gives the mafia a perfect little sniping list to mass murder all of our god damn blues. The fact that 5 people out of 12 have claimed on day one is ridiculous. Bloody Tsundere claimed 11 POSTS after the day post and Ryan88 did it directly after her on the same page. There was literally no reason to. I understand Mewx3 rush claiming because she was going to die, but Prin did NOT have to reveal her role when she wasn't even close to majority. :/ Could have even hinted at a PR without telling us which one. I'm more inclined to believe that Ashtot, Prin and Tsundere are town over any other claimers (even though Ash didn't claim) at this point.

I could just be cynical, but I don't buy the whole "I'm a stupid newb, so ignore me if I look scummy" excuse that you do. I never do. It's one of the best excuses when newer players start to screw up and make themselves sus. If they can't handle suspicion being cast on them, then they have NO place in a normal mafia game and should stick to newbie mafias until they're ready.

I am completely willing to vote for Jello because it doesn't look like they're even going to come in and defend themselves (I have no idea what timezone they're in). Pretty annoying to just post once if they flip town, but great if they're mafia.

And because she has only made one post, Minties is a little difficult to read into as well.

That is the unfortunate part of living in Australia. I catch up on the thread whenever I can and try to lump all my thoughts in one post because you guys are active when I'm asleep or working. (Sadly it's only Tuesday)

- - - Post Merge - - -

them***

****, sorry Tsundere

x_x

 

[radical6]

Ah Minties, it's okay. No biggie.
I wasn't really thinking of claiming until we started talking about the townie name. I guess it kinda went through my head when I replied to SP about the townie name. Sorry.

I could just be cynical, but I don't buy the whole "I'm a stupid newb, so ignore me if I look scummy" excuse that you do. I never do. It's one of the best excuses when newer players start to screw up and make themselves sus. If they can't handle suspicion being cast on them, then they have NO place in a normal mafia game and should stick to newbie mafias until they're ready.

though im a bit confused to who you're talking to here

 

[Minties]

Ah Minties, it's okay. No biggie.
I wasn't really thinking of claiming until we started talking about the townie name. I guess it kinda went through my head when I replied to SP about the townie name. Sorry.



though im a bit confused to who you're talking to here

Sorry, I was referring to how Dad keeps clearing Ryan88 just because he's new x_x making posts as soon as you wake up makes them goofy sometimes haha.

I have to go to work now, but I will check before voting ends to vote because I want to see if Jello plans on posting at the last minute.

 

[Geoni]

No, I'm not sure about SP's claim either.

So let me get this straight - because most of that list didn't publicly roleclaim on day one, they're all suspicious? The majority of people on there have played 10+ games and are NOT stupid enough to throw out their roles, green or blue day one. You know what that does? That gives the mafia a perfect little sniping list to mass murder all of our god damn blues. The fact that 5 people out of 12 have claimed on day one is ridiculous.

No, I definitely didn't think that we would get five claims by the end of the day and I was only hoping to get one townie claim so that it would clarify that townies all got the same monster (miniflan). But now things have been narrowed down significantly for mafia, yes. And y'know what Minties? Yes, I stand by the statement that the people on my list are potential scum not just because they have no claims, but because I've read into the claims that have been made and have decided that they all seem legitimate for a number of reasons (monster provided, what led them to the claim, emotional tone in their posts). There is still a lot of uncertainty about the people on the list and I'm not going to deny that. However, we need to narrow it down anyways since mafia already have things narrowed down themselves.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Hi, catching up on the thread but I know you guys probably want to know this tidbit the most.

As for the twin claim, I don't buy it. Even if this was another twin case like in Frozen, Tom would've at least known about it right?

Correct! I'm not going to claim, though at this point with so many claims what does it even matter, but I would at least be aware of this. I actually asked Tina about it last night because it was beginning to bug me, she told me I would be notified of such a thing.

 

[Chris]

Vote Count. It takes 7 votes to lynch.

Mewmewmewm - 1 - Superpenguin, FireNinja1, Superpenguin, Ashtot
Prin - 0 - Superpenguin, Ashtot, Ashtot, Superpenguin
NikkiNikki - 1 Ashtot, tsundere
JellofishXD - 6 - Superpenguin, Prin, Ashtot, NikkiNikki, tsundere, Dad

JellofishXD is set to be lynched.
There are two hours and fifty-one minutes left.

 

[radical6]

Vote Count. It takes 7 votes to lynch.

Mewmewmewm - 1 - Superpenguin, FireNinja1, Superpenguin, Ashtot
Prin - 0 - Superpenguin, Ashtot, Ashtot, Superpenguin
NikkiNikki - 1 Ashtot, tsundere
JellofishXD - 6 - Superpenguin, Prin, Ashtot, NikkiNikki, tsundere, Dad

JellofishXD is set to be lynched.
There are two hours and fifty-one minutes left.

i unvoted for nikki

 

[Ashtot]

Hi, catching up on the thread but I know you guys probably want to know this tidbit the most.



Correct! I'm not going to claim, though at this point with so many claims what does it even matter, but I would at least be aware of this. I actually asked Tina about it last night because it was beginning to bug me, she told me I would be notified of such a thing.

So Nick was lying (again). I don't see how this could have been helpful to us at all. Superpenguin you're on mah list.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

So Nick was lying (again). I don't see how this could have been helpful to us at all. Superpenguin you're on mah list.

Not big surprise. So if I've read everything right so far, we hopped from Mew to Prin to Nikki to Jello? Jello on the basis of lack of contribution?

 

[Chris]

i unvoted for nikki

Sorry for not catching that. Ta.


Vote Count. It takes 7 votes to lynch.

Mewmewmewm - 1 - Superpenguin, FireNinja1, Superpenguin, Ashtot
Prin - 0 - Superpenguin, Ashtot, Ashtot, Superpenguin
NikkiNikki - 0 - Ashtot, tsundere
JellofishXD - 6 - Superpenguin, Prin, Ashtot, NikkiNikki, tsundere, Dad

JellofishXD is set to be lynched.
There are two hours and forty-five minutes left.

 

[Ashtot]

Not big surprise. So if I've read everything right so far, we hopped from Mew to Prin to Nikki to Jello? Jello on the basis of lack of contribution?

That's pretty much it. Mew and Prin claimed and Nikki posted so we're just lynching an inactive.

 

[JellofishXD]

I'm catching up now I was asleep from the time zone difference!

 

[Geoni]

I'm catching up now I was asleep from the time zone difference!

Why didn't you post once you got back from school though? That's why I voted for you: because you said you would but you didn't, and just seemed really inactive because of that.

 

[JellofishXD]

I really didn't find anyone suspicious I know some ppl aren't gonna buy it but it's true!!

 

[Geoni]

Okay but you could have said something about that at that moment. It's probably too late to turn the votes around even if you are town and convincing enough to be.

 

[JellofishXD]

Yeah well good luck town I should have posted something damn.....

 

[Superpenguin]

Hi, catching up on the thread but I know you guys probably want to know this tidbit the most.



Correct! I'm not going to claim, though at this point with so many claims what does it even matter, but I would at least be aware of this. I actually asked Tina about it last night because it was beginning to bug me, she told me I would be notified of such a thing.

Wow, okay that's not fair. Yeah, I was lying of course. I figured I would be more important than Tom and I wanted to see mafia kill Tom thinking they would instead be killing me, lol. And how funny would it be to see Tom randomly die mafia because they were trying to kill me? XD Sorry.