Can you tell me why you think she's distracting town?
- - - Post Merge - - -
I don't like it when people tell the PR's what to do.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I don't like it when people tell the PR's what to do.
-
Staff favorites and raffle winners have been announced for TBT's Season of Giving! See the latest announcement thread: TBT's Season of Giving 2024: Closing Ceremony. Thank you to everyone for sharing your creativity and generosity during this event!
Mafia TBT Mafia: Game of Thrones - A Crown for a King - GAME OVER
- Thread starter Minties
- Start date
oath2order
#Porygon2024
Is this a ****ing joke
with her olde thyme english bull****
and her shouting "lynch tom or trojan" nonstop
how is that NOT distracting town
Shh, no need to be all Gung Ho. Thanks for the input <3
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
- - - Post Merge - - -
I'm deciphering all of the posts that are related to Llama in some way. It will be up in an hour or so, writing in google docs
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
Are you even achknowledging his point or are you just joking it off
I am. saving it for later use.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
ah more of the save for later
Yup!
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
When are you going to be
These are all of the posts that have some kind of connection to Llamas.
Thats most of the posts that relate towards Llama?s if I can recall. I may have missed some, heres some general thoughts.
I don?t like this post. It went over my head before but Daniel is calling Llama?s out as scum here for the blandest of reasons. It was too early in the game to make any sort of case either.
I dislike how Oath called me out for being overly defensive here when it wasn?t overly defensive at all.
Trundle is another one of my major town reads because of the way he posts. I really like the way he makes lengthy posts talking about something, obvious town Trundle.
Still don?t know what was going to be said about this.
I don?t like this fence sitting. You never did anything contributional or added to the conversation either.
Still not a fan of the way Kit called Ender out as scum. This post still stands out to me.
Inacurate post.
Thats most of my thoughts right now.
Thats basically that. Heres a bit of a blunted reads list.
Town
Trundle: I like the way he?s posting and progressing discustion further. Its obvious when Trundle is scum, so he?s town.
Sataric: The way they post isn?t scum motivated and they have great points. Its these types of posts that I really like-
Panda As annoying as I think she is, this is her obvious town behavior. Her points on me are bad and just posts one liners but this is obvious town.
Enderwiggin: His points about Llamas and Kit are good, overall town.
KarlaKGB: I feel like their posts are town oriented, mainly the same boat as Sataric.
Tom: Even though he was the one who casted the vote for Llama, its not his fault. Other people had been pushing for a Llamas lynch, he just did what everybody was asking him to do. I also like that he pointed this out-
Null
Kit: She?s been defending me a lot, and I agree with oath on her distracting town with her posts, but I have her down as null because she?s only recently started contributing a bit. During Forest Fire, she did contribute quite a bit but she just sheeped along with everybody and stayed quiet the whole time. Now, she?s mostly been s###posting the entire time. Null for now.
Ashtot: I like the way he?s been posting and he?s been suspicious of little things that go over people?s heads. I also really liked that he went from s###posting to now being much more serious. I have him down as null because of post about Endless however which isn?t much.
Endless: Progressivily pushing the day forward with his posts, but from what others are saying its giving a slight gut feeling, so I just put him down as null. Overall town however.
M3ow_: I don?t know what to think of her, I have mixed feelings about her. While I feel like she got over defensive when it wasn?t a serious suspicion on her, I can?t tell what she is. I?d prefer to hear what other?s judgements of are her before I can say she?s a scum read.
Trojan: Usual behavior, but null.
Middle of the road
Oath2order: I?m still not a fan of the push on he made on me by saying I was overly defensive when I wasn?t. This isn?t after the scum read panda made on me, this is before in this post:
I don?t know what I think about oath.
Ayaya: Came in at the beginning of the game and was a bit weird, and has disappeared since. Don?t know what to think either.
Scum reads
Call me Daniel: Sorry to single this one out, but I dislike the way he?s been posting. He hasn?t been doing anything much of substance and I like stated above dislike this post.
Trundle also called him out for this same reason, but he only replys with-
and theres also this, which I dislike as well for calling one or the other out-
To me he?s seeing these 2 as easy lynches for the day, and the bolded is making me feel weird about it. Daniel is either dumb town or scum, I hope its the 2nd right now.
Can?t read, needs more posts.
Dolby
JellofishXD
Blu Rose
AVidear
Meg-mog
Sorry this took so long. I?ve been putting it off for the majority of the day. Also as a side note, i've been really rude and annoying most of this game. I can be decent at this game, as I won a game as scum the other day on a different website. I'm aware that I can really suck at this, but I can try to start posting things of substance.
475 we have our first This is the first post that relates to a Llamas suspicion from Call me Daniel.
481, Daniel now explains his suspicions on Llamas, I?m not a big fan of some of the things said in this post.
We don?t really discuss much more about Llamas for a while after Daniel?s 2 posts on her.
We get yet another suspicion of Llama?s from Call me Daniel in post 692.
706 A new suspicion from Karla saying that most of Llama?s defense was worthless and didn?t do anything.
709 Endless says he doesn?t get Llama?s posts at all.
776 Ender calls Llama?s out for pocketing.
780 Ender explains more as to why Llamas was pocketing her posts.
840 Tom says he?s considering these 4 people to lynch, one including Llamas.
853 , 854 and 855 all state that they want Llamas to be lynched without providing any feedback as to why. Ender I can understand, but Tom never stated a reason to lynch Llama and Daniel hasn?t brought up lynching Llama since post 692, and I still think that Daniel?s reasoning for this lynch is really weird.
868 Endless says here that Llama?s isn?t the best lynch for today.
872 Panda never mentioned any sort of suspicions towards Llamas up until this point, and sheeps along with everybody on the Llama?s lynch.
918 Tom once again says that Llamas is up for lynch.
940 (its only fair that I put myself on this list) I say here that a Llamas or M3ow lynch is better over myself.
945 Ender says he wanted a Llama?s lynch over me.
949 Panda sheeping along again wanting a Llamas lynch without providing the reasoning.
Posts 952-953 both are sheeping along the Llama?s lynch, 1 being myself.
973 Ender once again saying he wants a Llamas lynch.
From posts 100 to the night post, nothing really happens besides Llama being lynched.
481, Daniel now explains his suspicions on Llamas, I?m not a big fan of some of the things said in this post.
We don?t really discuss much more about Llamas for a while after Daniel?s 2 posts on her.
We get yet another suspicion of Llama?s from Call me Daniel in post 692.
706 A new suspicion from Karla saying that most of Llama?s defense was worthless and didn?t do anything.
709 Endless says he doesn?t get Llama?s posts at all.
776 Ender calls Llama?s out for pocketing.
780 Ender explains more as to why Llamas was pocketing her posts.
840 Tom says he?s considering these 4 people to lynch, one including Llamas.
853 , 854 and 855 all state that they want Llamas to be lynched without providing any feedback as to why. Ender I can understand, but Tom never stated a reason to lynch Llama and Daniel hasn?t brought up lynching Llama since post 692, and I still think that Daniel?s reasoning for this lynch is really weird.
868 Endless says here that Llama?s isn?t the best lynch for today.
872 Panda never mentioned any sort of suspicions towards Llamas up until this point, and sheeps along with everybody on the Llama?s lynch.
918 Tom once again says that Llamas is up for lynch.
940 (its only fair that I put myself on this list) I say here that a Llamas or M3ow lynch is better over myself.
945 Ender says he wanted a Llama?s lynch over me.
949 Panda sheeping along again wanting a Llamas lynch without providing the reasoning.
Posts 952-953 both are sheeping along the Llama?s lynch, 1 being myself.
973 Ender once again saying he wants a Llamas lynch.
From posts 100 to the night post, nothing really happens besides Llama being lynched.
Thats most of the posts that relate towards Llama?s if I can recall. I may have missed some, heres some general thoughts.
I don?t like this post. It went over my head before but Daniel is calling Llama?s out as scum here for the blandest of reasons. It was too early in the game to make any sort of case either.
I dislike how Oath called me out for being overly defensive here when it wasn?t overly defensive at all.
Trundle is another one of my major town reads because of the way he posts. I really like the way he makes lengthy posts talking about something, obvious town Trundle.
Still don?t know what was going to be said about this.
I don?t like this fence sitting. You never did anything contributional or added to the conversation either.
Still not a fan of the way Kit called Ender out as scum. This post still stands out to me.
Inacurate post.
Thats most of my thoughts right now.
Thats basically that. Heres a bit of a blunted reads list.
Town
Trundle: I like the way he?s posting and progressing discustion further. Its obvious when Trundle is scum, so he?s town.
Sataric: The way they post isn?t scum motivated and they have great points. Its these types of posts that I really like-
Panda As annoying as I think she is, this is her obvious town behavior. Her points on me are bad and just posts one liners but this is obvious town.
Enderwiggin: His points about Llamas and Kit are good, overall town.
KarlaKGB: I feel like their posts are town oriented, mainly the same boat as Sataric.
Tom: Even though he was the one who casted the vote for Llama, its not his fault. Other people had been pushing for a Llamas lynch, he just did what everybody was asking him to do. I also like that he pointed this out-
So, Tom is in my main town reads right now.
Null
Kit: She?s been defending me a lot, and I agree with oath on her distracting town with her posts, but I have her down as null because she?s only recently started contributing a bit. During Forest Fire, she did contribute quite a bit but she just sheeped along with everybody and stayed quiet the whole time. Now, she?s mostly been s###posting the entire time. Null for now.
Ashtot: I like the way he?s been posting and he?s been suspicious of little things that go over people?s heads. I also really liked that he went from s###posting to now being much more serious. I have him down as null because of post about Endless however which isn?t much.
Endless: Progressivily pushing the day forward with his posts, but from what others are saying its giving a slight gut feeling, so I just put him down as null. Overall town however.
M3ow_: I don?t know what to think of her, I have mixed feelings about her. While I feel like she got over defensive when it wasn?t a serious suspicion on her, I can?t tell what she is. I?d prefer to hear what other?s judgements of are her before I can say she?s a scum read.
Trojan: Usual behavior, but null.
Middle of the road
Oath2order: I?m still not a fan of the push on he made on me by saying I was overly defensive when I wasn?t. This isn?t after the scum read panda made on me, this is before in this post:
I don?t know what I think about oath.
Ayaya: Came in at the beginning of the game and was a bit weird, and has disappeared since. Don?t know what to think either.
Scum reads
Call me Daniel: Sorry to single this one out, but I dislike the way he?s been posting. He hasn?t been doing anything much of substance and I like stated above dislike this post.
Trundle also called him out for this same reason, but he only replys with-
and theres also this, which I dislike as well for calling one or the other out-
To me he?s seeing these 2 as easy lynches for the day, and the bolded is making me feel weird about it. Daniel is either dumb town or scum, I hope its the 2nd right now.
Can?t read, needs more posts.
Dolby
JellofishXD
Blu Rose
AVidear
Meg-mog
Sorry this took so long. I?ve been putting it off for the majority of the day. Also as a side note, i've been really rude and annoying most of this game. I can be decent at this game, as I won a game as scum the other day on a different website. I'm aware that I can really suck at this, but I can try to start posting things of substance.
These people are on my leaning on town list:
Ashtot
Daniel (CMD)
And these people are on my slightly leaning on town list:
Ness
Trojan
Trundle
I?ll post the people I have my suspicion on after the Night post so I can confirm some things first. The rest of the players either falls under that or can?t read yet.
Also, does anyone else find the timing of Dolby?s post a bit odd? Like it?s a coincidence?
He posted just right when people are talking about him getting lynched/modkilled.
I was reading Tom?s Kingmaker game and I noticed in that game, Dolby seems to stay under the radar while everyone else are pointing fingers at each other. If he does have internet problems then I?m sorry to hear that, but it?d be kind of sad of us for knowning his playstyle on that game and letting him stay under the radar again.
If any players who?ve played on that game can give their thoughts on this I?d be very appreciated.
Ashtot
While I admittedly didn?t look at all of his posts yet, the ones I see while I was looking at exchanges between players makes me think he?s town. Only played 1 game with him where he?s scum and only read 1 game where he?s town, but so far he?s contributing a lot more than when he?s mafia, and I?m finding myself either agreeing or seeing where his logic comes from most of the time, so I?m inclined to believe he?s town for now
Daniel (CMD)
While I did read him as scum very hard on the previous game (he turned out to be town) I?m trying to be less biased this time and so far, all of his posts seem consistent to what he?s thinking/saying, and he plays similarly to when he?s town. Though it could just be that he?s better this time compared to when he first became scum. None of his posts didn?t strike me as odd yet, so I?m leaning on town right now.
And these people are on my slightly leaning on town list:
Ness
Never read the game where he plays as mafia so I have no idea his scum playstyle is, but I did notice he is less aggressive this time, which he acknowledged. I think he?d stay aggressive as scum to make himself look consistent, but so far his playstyle is a toned down version of him in Reindeer mafia. I also noticed he?s doing another silly test and being quick to think someone is town this time too (as he did read me and Dolby as town there)
Trojan
I noticed he?s trying to be more serious in this game. The playstyle change is a bit alarming but I think it?d be unfair to see him as scum based on that. Honestly I?m happy he?s just not spouting one liners so I?d like to see him more in this game.
Trundle
Him defending Ashtot was a liiiittle bit odd, but so far like Ashtot and CMD he?s contributing and staying consistent so I?m leaning on town for him.
I?ll post the people I have my suspicion on after the Night post so I can confirm some things first. The rest of the players either falls under that or can?t read yet.
Also, does anyone else find the timing of Dolby?s post a bit odd? Like it?s a coincidence?
http://www.belltreeforums.com/showt...-of-Thrones-A-Crown-for-a-King-DAY-ONE/page85
He posted just right when people are talking about him getting lynched/modkilled.
I was reading Tom?s Kingmaker game and I noticed in that game, Dolby seems to stay under the radar while everyone else are pointing fingers at each other. If he does have internet problems then I?m sorry to hear that, but it?d be kind of sad of us for knowning his playstyle on that game and letting him stay under the radar again.
If any players who?ve played on that game can give their thoughts on this I?d be very appreciated.
Lol we made lengthy posts at the same time, but thanks for posting this.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Ok, I don't like ayaya's reads list.
Heh! I noticed. I'll read your post now.
Also, I haven't been as active as much as I want to because my sister's wedding is coming up in a week (14 Feb, on Valentine's!) and I've been helping my family around for that
Forgot the wedding is close when I signed in for the game... Will most likely be MIA on 12-14 Feb AEST because of this. I can still pay attention to the thread and dedicate at least 2-3 hours per day to this game, but I'd probably be late to most discussions and post around this time/early morning EST.
If you think I'm suspicious from my inactivity then that's perfectly fine, I'd be suspicious of myself too. Just wanted to let you guys know why.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
And are you going to tell us why you don't like Ayaya's list
The reasoning behind her nulling me and Trojan I can understand and Towning Ashtot, but for making Trundle a null and making Daniel a town read are weird. Seriously, Trundle should be on the top of the town list. I can't understand why Enderwiggin or Karla aren't in the towns list either.
The fact that she's scum reading Dolby for telling us he can't post because or irl issues is scummy as well. She didn't share us any of her Scum reads either.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Ebwop.
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
I mean ness, the same can be said about you too. You don't post anything useful and when you were set to be lynched you were switching from being okay with being lynched and
wanting another candidate lynched because they suddenly became suspicious of you. Easy candidate to want to kill to save your skin.
Honestly, I think you're town because you role claimed, but saying you're suspicious of me for the same stuff you did is stupid.
wanting another candidate lynched because they suddenly became suspicious of you. Easy candidate to want to kill to save your skin.
Honestly, I think you're town because you role claimed, but saying you're suspicious of me for the same stuff you did is stupid.
Its hypocritical of me to be talking about you seeing 2 people as an easy lynch, but its not just that. You haven't been contributing much to the pot either. Llama's claimed townie, so I wanted to have M3ow lynched because she was the 3rd option.
I only started to want a Llama's lynch when the day started ending because we didn't have much to go off of. I never shared a scum read on Llama's until the day was ending because of what I said just now, but you went after her for bland reasons. Thats my thought process to you being scum.
Why are you trying to dictate my reads Ness? You have reasons for your read, I have mine. As for Ender and Karla, those players fall under "can't read yet", and I did say I was waiting until Night post (or Day 3 post, just noticed that error) so I can confirm my suspicion first.
And I didn't scum read Dolby either. Just pointing out that his post timing is coincident with when Town is considering to lynch/modkill him. I thought it was a bit odd which is why I asked for players from Tom's Kingmaker game their thoughts.
