You have a good point, but in the long run, it won't be helpful anyway. If the Detective says Mayor is a mafia goon, they would have to kill the bodyguards. Unless the real detective finds the framer and the sheriff incarcerates them, this is a lot to sacrifice.
Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]
- Thread starter KarlaKGB
- Start date
You have a good point, but in the long run, it won't be helpful anyway. If the Detective says Mayor is a mafia goon, they would have to kill the bodyguards. Unless the real detective finds the framer and the sheriff incarcerates them, this is a lot to sacrifice.
TheCreeperHugz
Boop
Just got home from school, not sure who to vote for as mayor...
holy **** it takes a long time to read up on all thr posts
I think I'm leaning towards Justin, since last game (yes I know we shouldn't go completely with game one, but theres not much else to go on) he was really good at pointing out the mafia members, as was AndyB. Though i wouldn't mind seeing some posts from all e candidated justifying why we should vote for them.
holy **** it takes a long time to read up on all thr posts
I think I'm leaning towards Justin, since last game (yes I know we shouldn't go completely with game one, but theres not much else to go on) he was really good at pointing out the mafia members, as was AndyB. Though i wouldn't mind seeing some posts from all e candidated justifying why we should vote for them.
Yeah, either way though the detectives have a lot of work cut out for them. I just hope our detectives are ready for these road blocks.
And let's not forget the poor Miller role, as we don't know who that is. So you could be green as grass and return Mafia either because someone framed you or you're just unlucky.
I was going to throw my hat into the ring, but it's starting to look pretty crowded and I think I'd be comfortable sitting back letting things play out.
TheCreeperHugz
Boop
This made me facepalm, Jubs is Justin....
Superpenguin
Penguins! <3
I always wanted to vote for you, Kayla, and this post is really putting me over the edge. *-*
You seem completely clean, and you definitely are not holding back posting in this thread just like Observer Chat. I'd assume you'd be much less talkative if you were mafia. So, yeah, I will probably just go ahead and cast my vote for you now, or wait a bit longer, not sure yet.
Yes, good point, the framer(s) will probably target the mayor/sheriff Night 1. I would advise the detective(s) to rolecheck when they think they will find the truthful answer, or just rolecheck twice in a row, as detectives are not limited! : D
oath2order
#Porygon2024
I think I've made up my mind on who I'm voting for. BlueLeaf, you have my vote. I would like to see someone new to the game have the role, and from what I can see, you are the most invested new player thus far. You seem like a reasonable person, you seem clear-headed.
I would vote for AndyB, but throughout last game, I'd been torn between thinking he was mafia or not. It's really hard to tell. I mean no offense, and I'm most certainly not accusing you of anything, it's just this weird vibe I get from you. I mean, with your post telling us to be careful who to elect, my first thought is that you're a townie, making sure that we vote the right way. But then, I feel like you're doing some sort of reverse psychology to get us to vote for you. In addition, I always felt like you know more than you should have for being a townie, but that's just my personal feelings. I'm not voting you for lynch anytime soon, but because it's hard to tell, I won't be voting for you for mayor.
Thus far, it seems like Justin is winning the vote. I would be okay with that. Justin, you know the right person to accuse. You were right about River last game, and you did an excellent job of defending yourself. That being said, I would be perfectly fine if you won, but as I said before, I would like a new player, someone with a clean slate and no judgments on their mind.
I would vote for AndyB, but throughout last game, I'd been torn between thinking he was mafia or not. It's really hard to tell. I mean no offense, and I'm most certainly not accusing you of anything, it's just this weird vibe I get from you. I mean, with your post telling us to be careful who to elect, my first thought is that you're a townie, making sure that we vote the right way. But then, I feel like you're doing some sort of reverse psychology to get us to vote for you. In addition, I always felt like you know more than you should have for being a townie, but that's just my personal feelings. I'm not voting you for lynch anytime soon, but because it's hard to tell, I won't be voting for you for mayor.
Thus far, it seems like Justin is winning the vote. I would be okay with that. Justin, you know the right person to accuse. You were right about River last game, and you did an excellent job of defending yourself. That being said, I would be perfectly fine if you won, but as I said before, I would like a new player, someone with a clean slate and no judgments on their mind.
Thank you! I know I'll probably lose, but if a new player becomes the mayor/sheriff, I'll be fine with it. Again, thanks!
kittenrobotarmy
JOLLY COOPERATION
My apologies for being late, school ran a bit long...
I think all of you are suspicious... No one knows who's a Mafia Goon and who's a Townie. We should plan...
I think all of you are suspicious... No one knows who's a Mafia Goon and who's a Townie. We should plan...
I agree, BlueLeaf was a past observer so he mostly knows the tips everyone said in the chat. He also has less judgement of the past game so he probably won't make hasty judgements based on the previous game.
So I also think a new player should have mayor/sheriff.
So I also think a new player should have mayor/sheriff.
Superpenguin
Penguins! <3
Remember guys, sheriff is the runner-up in the election. So all you people out there running solely for Sheriff, you'll have to make sure you stay out of first, but stay in second. I think it'd just be easier to run for Mayor and you wouldn't feel disappointed if you lost by one or two votes, because you wanted Sheriff more.
kittenrobotarmy
JOLLY COOPERATION
That depends. Which players were in the last game and who's new? Who has good judgement and can make good decisions? Does the mayor/sheriff understand everything? We need to think about that. I agree with Green, a new player should have the chance to be the mayor/sheriff.
Superpenguin
Penguins! <3
That's what we are doing. We are currently choosing who should be Mayor. It'll be to your benefit to read the eariler psots if you have yet to do so.
kittenrobotarmy
JOLLY COOPERATION
Thank you, I shall do that. As for voting, the Mayor should be able to have good judgement and make good decisions. I'll look at the pages, then decide.
At this point I might not vote for Justin .. that bandwagon happened within seconds you guys. No one has YET to explain why they immediately voted Justin and it's making me hesitate so much. He was seriously my number one choice though (go back to my long posts). :l
Oh by the way, there's another new vote for Justin.
Oh by the way, there's another new vote for Justin.
Are you sure? You jumped on the bandwagon so early, are you sure you read all the posts?
kittenrobotarmy
JOLLY COOPERATION
Yes... Justin seems suspicious to me, and since he was in the last game, I can see how he does. That's really my personal opinion. However, if I do find another person, I will change my vote.
