Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[Midoriya]

Now that Waffles is a suspect I'm starting to think Beary is just a new player. It would be kind of wasteful to support lynching Beary, so I'm changing my vote to Waffles. I would like to hear a defense from both of them though.

 

[iLoveYou]

Actually did anyone think about how the Mafia could have potentially framed iTookYourWaffles? They are reading the thread too and could have watched Laurina try to make a move against iTookYourWaffles. Being Night One, they probably needed to pick hits that would have an effect on other specific remaining players, who are tied to the targets. Laurina was the only one to call out iTookYourWaffles. Easy affiliation on iTookYourWaffles if LaurinaMN died.

What if VillageDweller is right? What if they are both innocent players on the Town team?

 

[oath2order]

Actually did anyone think about how the Mafia could have potentially framed iTookYourWaffles? They are reading the thread too and could have watched Laurina try to make a move against iTookYourWaffles. Being Night One, they probably needed to pick hits that would have an effect on other specific remaining players, who are tied to the targets. Laurina was the only one to call out iTookYourWaffles. Easy affiliation on iTookYourWaffles if LaurinaMN died.

What if VillageDweller is right? What if they are both innocent players on the Town team?

But then who are you suggesting we lynch?

 

[Superpenguin]

Actually did anyone think about how the Mafia could have potentially framed iTookYourWaffles? They are reading the thread too and could have watched Laurina try to make a move against iTookYourWaffles. Being Night One, they probably needed to pick hits that would have an effect on other specific remaining players, who are tied to the targets. Laurina was the only one to call out iTookYourWaffles. Easy affiliation on iTookYourWaffles if LaurinaMN died.

What if VillageDweller is right? What if they are both innocent players on the Town team?

FireNinja mentioned this. It all comes down to the reason Laruina died. The mafia might not have even killed Laurina for her case against Waffles, but just wanted to use their 3rd KP on someone, and she fit the bill.

But then who are you suggesting we lynch?

What about lynn? Seriously, you guys keep ignoring anything that is said about her! Why do you keep brushing it off?

 

[oath2order]

Remind me what was said about Lynn.

 

[BlueLeaf]

Remind me what was said about Lynn.

Her last post was her beating around the bush. She seems to be hiding things from us.

 

[iLoveYou]

But then who are you suggesting we lynch?

That's the problem. I am currently on the fence between iTookYourWaffles and Beary509. I am trying to think of every possible scenario for these two players (both against them or for them) in terms of whether they could be Mafia players or not. Unfortunately I don't have any names to substitue them with. Although Hikari did fall silent after accusing Horus, and after the whole town took on Beary509 + iTookYourWaffles.

I mentioned Riley too, before. Although now I see Riley posting. I am willing to wait for Hikari too (due to timezones & etc.).

 

[Superpenguin]

Remind me what was said about Lynn.

Only two things, cause people are ignoring it. :/

I still have suspicions toward Lynn and River. More so toward Lynn, though, since River has stated she was busy with school, but now that she is off for a little while, apparently she'll be more active, so we should give her some time to see how all that plays out.

I noticed no change in lynn's activity last game as opposed to this game. She was active in the mafia chat last game, so she does know what she is doing, and she views this thread often, so it can't always just be a "Quick Catch-up Read". I'm not saying I am going to vote for lynn or that we should even lynch her. This is just my suspicion.

Wow this thread exploded really fast. I have a couple of pages to catch up on, but it seems like there are already 4 specific names up in the air.

If the town is in need of me to use my incarceration ability on anyone, please do speak up. I'm already somewhat considering it, although I won't be making this decision by myself this early in the game. I only get 3 times to incarcerate players, & not more than once per individual player. So that's something to think about too.

Lynn105:

Today you posted the following (one post only too):

I'm not sure if this will help anyone, but I'm kinda suspicious of people who talked A LOT in the last game, but have decreased and said minimal things in this one...

Is there anyone in particular that stands out to you? That was literally the only post you made today & it was closer to the time when the deathly post by KarlaKGB was supposed to be made. =P I'd like to hear about who you are referring to when you say you are kinda suspicious of people. I assume you have them in mind? Who are they though? We can call them out & talk to them hopefully.

 

[iLoveYou]

Lynn105 is still on my list as well, SuperPenguin. It's just people like Hikari, Beary509 & iTookYourWaffles are on my mind right now.

- - - Post Merge - - -

The last two names mostly because they are up for lynching right now.

 

[FireNinja1]

I'm keeping my vote on Waffles for now, mainly because I don't want to withdraw it, forget to vote, and be modkilled. It's likely I will switch to someone else, because Waffles seems innocent, and it just seems like a trap made by the mafia.

 

[Elijo]

I personally voted for Beary because she isn't a good player. I know she's new but I really don't see any use having a terrible newbie trying to persuade our town.

(Sorry for my inactiveness by the way. I'll try to be more active.)

 

[Hikari]

Lynn105 is still on my list as well, SuperPenguin. It's just people like Hikari, Beary509 & iTookYourWaffles are on my mind right now.

- - - Post Merge - - -

The last two names mostly because they are up for lynching right now.

Oh, hello, Kayla. I'll go ahead and tell you what I think about Beary and Waffles.

Beary: Seems like a dumb town member too me, like Justin said in a earlier post. We should probably look for a better candidate.

Waffles: The fact that she's contributed little help towards the town is very suspicious in my opinion because we just lost three town members, and she doesn't bother helping the town find out who did it. Also, she's been trying to put the blame on other people, which makes it seem like she has something to hide. (Since she's take the spotlight off the the self.)

 

[oath2order]

Yeah, sorry, Penguin, but I don't think I could vote for Lynn. It's a little suspicious, but I'm not entirely convinced.

That being said, I've been reading posts, and yes, Beary does seem like just a dumb townie. There's been enough posts here and I'm convinced enough to lean towards Waffles.

 

[Hikari]

I'm going to vote for ITookYourWaffles due to the fact that she's contributed little help towards the town is very suspicious in my opinion because we just lost three town members, and she doesn't bother helping the town find out who did it. Also, she's been trying to put the blame on other people, which makes it seem like she has something to hide. (Since she's take the spotlight off the the self.)

(Re-posted my reason from earlier.)

 

[bluegoat14]

It looks like the main targets of the lynch are iTookYourWaffles and Beary. Beary is a new player, but their sporadic posting is unusual for someone who is just a townie. iTookYourWaffles did take heat from Laurina, and now she's dead which is definitely significant. On the other hand, iTookYourWaffles hasn't posted any defense yet.

 

[FireNinja1]

It looks like the main targets of the lynch are iTookYourWaffles and Beary. Beary is a new player, but their sporadic posting is unusual for someone who is just a townie. iTookYourWaffles did take heat from Laurina, and now she's dead which is definitely significant. On the other hand, iTookYourWaffles hasn't posted any defense yet.

Uhm...not sure if you're mafia or just new. Those statements have already been concluded awhile ago.

 

[bluegoat14]

Uhm...not sure if you're mafia or just new. Those statements have already been concluded awhile ago.

I am new player; just voicing my opinion. Similar speculations have been posted more than once in the past, so I didn't think that was a problem.

 

[FireNinja1]

I am new player; just voicing my opinion. Similar speculations have been posted more than once in the past, so I didn't think that was a problem.

Well, when we put speculations, we added our own opinions as to the situation.

 

[MyLifeIsCake]

Everyone seems to going with waffles, though I'm going with VD, I don't think they are Mafia b/c no one has really stood up for them. Yes, Laurina did end up dead after accusing waffles. But like Fireninja said, the mafia likes to cause trouble on day 2. It is unlikley that the Mafia would just stand there and let their members be lynched. Waffles also hasn't said anything about this and I would at least hope that the mafia would be smart enough to tell their fellow member to stand up for theirself. I still have to say lynn05 (sorry if I typed that wrong, I'm on mobile) remains suspicious in my book because they haven't posted much, and I know well they were viewing this thread after Gandalf, Laurina, and Kippla were killed. As I said before, its one thing if you're busy, but if you are active, online and viewing the thread, I don't see why you don't even attempt to post unless you're afraid of slip ups.

 

[3DSfan134]

Who will end up being lynched?