You're part of some people's suspects because you barely posted anything after the game started.
Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]
- Thread starter KarlaKGB
- Start date
You're part of some people's suspects because you barely posted anything after the game started.
bluegoat14
INACTIVE
Thank you. If you felt that I wasn't really adding anything, I really am trying to be a more active part of the town. I usually keep my eye out for posting things that will be productive.
Here are the posts made by our two suspects: Beary, and Waffles, all made with spoilers and quotes. All of these posts are from Day 1 and beyond. Note: I will not include extremely useless posts, but I will include regular useless posts. I may miss some posts. Use these spoilers to decide who you want to vote for. The spoilers are really long, especially Beary's.
I'm not really sure, because of the incident and my shots (._.), I am still catching up.
BellBringer and Tom make me suspicious. I'm not accusing them, just have a feeling...>_>
Good luck to everyone in the lynching, because I have to go to bed soon and may not see the final verdict.
- - - Post Merge - - -
THANK YOU FOR ACKNOWLEDGING THAT I AM A GIRL...
Seriously though, bear in my username doesn't mean I'm a guy
Neither does the fact that I love Minecraft.
Horus has posted a might 5 TIMES!!!!
- - - Post Merge - - -
Mighty *
I'm reading through the first mafia, and it was much more relaxed and humorous, and seemed more enjoyable
Ain't nobody got time for that
I guess we are very lucky that Mary got lynched I never seen her posting/voting.
I compiled their posts into spoilers so people having a hard time choosing who to vote for can look here.
Superpenguin
Penguins! <3
If Waffles can manage to defend herself and convince me of her innocence, then I'd have no issue with voting for lynn. I've been debating between the two.
The problem I have with Beary509 is that she role-claimed to me two different times, through PM with two different Town roles. I'm trying to figure out why. She PM'd me first saying she was Townie. Was it a newbie mistake, in thinking Townie was the same thing as Town (technically it is, but Townie is it's own role itself)? She is definitly a newbie though. Which is why I don't want to waste a lynch on her.
With iTookYourWaffles it's really hard for me to enter a vote. Although I am still leaning towards her. The arguments facing her are so strong but I am trying to keep in mind the "What if she was framed" argument, posted by FireNinja1 and myself. Also MyLeIsCake made some good points about iTookYourWaffles:
Right now I am thinking about a potential option number 3. I am not confident enough that iTookYourWaffles is Town to be able to pardon her lynch (if it happens) and I still definitely will not pardon Beary509's lynch if it comes to it.
With iTookYourWaffles it's really hard for me to enter a vote. Although I am still leaning towards her. The arguments facing her are so strong but I am trying to keep in mind the "What if she was framed" argument, posted by FireNinja1 and myself. Also MyLeIsCake made some good points about iTookYourWaffles:
Right now I am thinking about a potential option number 3. I am not confident enough that iTookYourWaffles is Town to be able to pardon her lynch (if it happens) and I still definitely will not pardon Beary509's lynch if it comes to it.
This. This is my reasoning. I want to see Waffles defend herself. If she doesn't, I'll vote for her. If she does, I'll vote for Lynn. I'm not worrying about Beary since she's just a horrible, inexperienced Townie. If she keeps slipping up though, I doubt she'll be alive for long.
This is so discouraging!
Everyone thinks I'm mafia! I'm trying my best to fit in, but this is just not working ;-;
I still understand this game, but I've made an image of myself that nobody can change.
I'm not a newbie anymore, but everyone is convinced I am. I have to solid evidence supporting my claim that I am not mafia, but, of course, nobody cares about little miss newbies 'uncontributing spam'. I'm trying to make the game more enjoyable, and I even up making it worse.
I may as well just bury myself.
BUT.
-Waffles has made close to zero contributions as well.
- He was quick to point fingers.
- He keeps bringing up Dolby, which may be a sign of pride from killing her.
Thank you. I'm not going to post any more until the lynching.
I may as well say goodbye, and,
I TOLD YA SO.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also-
- This is my first time playing
- I got town and townie confused
- I'm a bit socially awkward in general.
Everyone thinks I'm mafia! I'm trying my best to fit in, but this is just not working ;-;
I still understand this game, but I've made an image of myself that nobody can change.
I'm not a newbie anymore, but everyone is convinced I am. I have to solid evidence supporting my claim that I am not mafia, but, of course, nobody cares about little miss newbies 'uncontributing spam'. I'm trying to make the game more enjoyable, and I even up making it worse.
I may as well just bury myself.
BUT.
-Waffles has made close to zero contributions as well.
- He was quick to point fingers.
- He keeps bringing up Dolby, which may be a sign of pride from killing her.
Thank you. I'm not going to post any more until the lynching.
I may as well say goodbye, and,
I TOLD YA SO.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also-
- This is my first time playing
- I got town and townie confused
- I'm a bit socially awkward in general.
Superpenguin
Penguins! <3
I have a bit of the problem with the whole If they're mafia, why doesn't the mafia come in and defend them? theory. Because, really, now the mafia can use VD's post as a cover-up for trying to draw votes away from beary and/or Waffles. Several players have all ready referred to it agreeing that the mafia would've come in and tried to protect the suspects.
The mafia isn't going to come in and come right out and say things like "Come on, you guys really think Waffles is suspicious? Look at what so-so is doing, put attention on them!" No, they're going to go about it sneakily, and VD just gave them the perfect post to use. Now they can go about pulling votes away by agreeing with VD's logic and saying "Come on guys, there's no members in here trying to protect Waffles or Beary, they're obviously not mafia".
- - - Post Merge - - -
This was the post I was referring to, but I guess I ended up pulling in elements from Cake's post too...so I qoted both and highlighted the points.
- - - Post Merge - - -
VD, Cake, and now Kayla are indirectly standing up for these people. Make of that as you will, but this doesn't make me suspect either three of them as mafia.
Beary: Your evidence could end up as a game-changing piece of information. Guess we'll never know. You will likely get put on the banlist for giving up. You should give the evidence while you can. It probably won't get considered spam and you even might redeem yourself. Of course, I won't stop you from giving up.
Superpenguin
Penguins! <3
You know your role; you know your innocence.
I've given up on there being people believing in my innocence.
Didn't you say you weren't going to post anymore?
Kayla does, and I'm sure more people do. There will be even more people if you give clear evidence of your innocence. See, what you just did may have just caused more suspicion. You shifted attention from yourself to Waffles, which isn't a good idea. Instead of suspecting others, defend yourself.
i wont vote for beary because eh yeah she just made a lot of mistakes and shes probably young
for waffles, i feel like if she was mafia and killed laurina it would be way too obvious. i feel like mafia is trying to shift blame onto her. yeah it was weird she randomly switched the topic to dolby, but that might be because shes a newbie. i really dont wanna vote for either of them though. but im probably very wrong ,
ill shut up now
for waffles, i feel like if she was mafia and killed laurina it would be way too obvious. i feel like mafia is trying to shift blame onto her. yeah it was weird she randomly switched the topic to dolby, but that might be because shes a newbie. i really dont wanna vote for either of them though. but im probably very wrong ,
ill shut up now
Has anybody read my post?
I gave evidence.
If you need more, fine.
- I didn't understand that a townie and a town were different, that is why Kayla said I was two things. I corrected my mistake.
-I am new at this game.
-I am trying very hard to be a valuable poster.
That is all I can think of right now.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh speaking of useles non contributing posts?
I gave evidence.
If you need more, fine.
- I didn't understand that a townie and a town were different, that is why Kayla said I was two things. I corrected my mistake.
-I am new at this game.
-I am trying very hard to be a valuable poster.
That is all I can think of right now.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh speaking of useles non contributing posts?
Remember that this is only a game and it shouldn't be taken too seriously, I'm sure that everyone has at least contributed something good.
It's only Day Two and not a lot of people have good evidence right now so don't think that the accusations are rock solid.
Personally I do plan on submitting a vote for one of the two. Like I said I am leaning towards iTookYourWaffles. I just have a hard time submitting it due to the arguments made in her defence. It's not so much defending her rather having the Town thinking about what IF they are both innocent town players. I understand most lynches will be huge "hits or misses" in terms of whether we hit a mafia player or not. That is why I feel like with every vote, we should think over the arguments for and against the two people up for lynching.
Like I said Superpenguin, Lynn105 is still on my suspicion list too but I feel like this will mostly come down to Beary509 versus iTookYourWaffles. Which is why if we are making a decision between those two, we need to pick the more suspicious of the two by laying out all our arguments for and against them.
Like I said Superpenguin, Lynn105 is still on my suspicion list too but I feel like this will mostly come down to Beary509 versus iTookYourWaffles. Which is why if we are making a decision between those two, we need to pick the more suspicious of the two by laying out all our arguments for and against them.
Kayla: I made a post with spoilers including Beary's and Waffle's posts. If you don't want to read it, then I guess I can do something. I'm going to try and write in the mindset of people who think XXX is innocent/scum.
Beary's Innocence Argument: She is a new player and slips up often. I guess this means she's still getting used to this game, which is a bad reason to vote for someone.
Beary's Scum Argument: She shifted attention from her to Waffles, which is suspicious. We saw what happened with Dolby.
Waffle's Innocence Argument: Waffles is most likely getting framed by the Mafia. Once suspicion laid down in Waffles, the Mafia shot Laurina to cause chaos.
Waffle's Scum Argument: Waffles could have shot Laurina for either: a) The Mafia just wanted to shoot a good player ; b) The Mafia was afraid of Waffles getting caught.
Remember, this is written in the mind set of people who think XXX is innocent/scum.
Beary's Innocence Argument: She is a new player and slips up often. I guess this means she's still getting used to this game, which is a bad reason to vote for someone.
Beary's Scum Argument: She shifted attention from her to Waffles, which is suspicious. We saw what happened with Dolby.
Waffle's Innocence Argument: Waffles is most likely getting framed by the Mafia. Once suspicion laid down in Waffles, the Mafia shot Laurina to cause chaos.
Waffle's Scum Argument: Waffles could have shot Laurina for either: a) The Mafia just wanted to shoot a good player ; b) The Mafia was afraid of Waffles getting caught.
Remember, this is written in the mind set of people who think XXX is innocent/scum.
cannedcommunism
idk man
It looks like Beary's in a lot of trouble, however, I think she's just a townie who's just getting used to things. Waffles looks like she's going as well, but the reasons for which have been blurred.
