Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[VillageDweller]

I've decide that i'm gonna vote for beary. She has tried to shift attention away from her multiple times (and failed most of the time) and hasn't come up with any good, solid reasons for some of her accusations of the people she's tried to shift the attention to. I get the feeling the mafia keeps telling her different ways to try to shift attention away from her and she had executed them badly. As other people have mentioned, she seems to have instantly changed her style quite a bit. I know she's mentioned about people asking her to improve and then her getting annoyed because when she tried, she got accused of being mafia, but still, the almost-instant change is weird.

Also I guess you have been contributing but you mixed in some contentless posts in there:

I really hope he's mafia. If he's not, we will have lost another blue/townie.
Losing a townie would be better though, because they don't do much, and blue roles have exclusive perks that are useful to the town.

Im a bit irritated about how people were scolding my on my noobishness, and then when I make a conscious effort to improve, everyone thinks I am the mafia?
Honestly...

Im so sorry, I get everyones gender confused Dx
Ignore my confusion.

I made a mistake. Just reread recent posts, Pally is doing a good job.
Sorry pally xD
And tsundere, I have contributed plenty. Try rereading.

Also in that last one, beary just tried to be like "I've contributed, go look for yourself." instead of providing the evidence that you have contributed yourself. Maybe if you had actually looked yourself, you wouldn't have accused pally blindly and then have to find out you were wrong. Should've taken your own advice, in hindsight.

 

[EpicGamer12]

....where


i don't like that everyone is jumping on the next train. hikari's horus post seemed like an attempt to push horus into the spotlight but he failed.
im pretty sure some of you promised to not jump on the bandwagon but look at what you're doing.

What do you mean? I'm definitely not. And yeah, a lot of them did say that, but after Justin says something everyone goes berserk voting for that person. Nothing against Justin, but he is really what causes bandwagons the majority of the time.
Also, if you're referring to me jumping on a bandwagon by the Hikari post, you're mistaken. I was the first to bring up Hikari way back when I also rehashed Superpenguin's thoughts on iTookYourWaffles.

 

[Beary]

I've decide that i'm gonna vote for beary. She has tried to shift attention away from her multiple times (and failed most of the time) and hasn't come up with any good, solid reasons for some of her accusations of the people she's tried to shift the attention to. I get the feeling the mafia keeps telling her different ways to try to shift attention away from her and she had executed them badly. As other people have mentioned, she seems to have instantly changed her style quite a bit. I know she's mentioned about people asking her to improve and then her getting annoyed because when she tried, she got accused of being mafia, but still, the almost-instant change is weird.

Also I guess you have been contributing but you mixed in some contentless posts in there:




Also in that last one, beary just tried to be like "I've contributed, go look for yourself." instead of providing the evidence that you have contributed yourself. Maybe if you had actually looked yourself, you wouldn't have accused pally blindly and then have to find out you were wrong. Should've taken your own advice, in hindsight.

Believe me, if I was mafia, I would be dead by now.
And people can look for themselves. If they are too lazy tobgo back a bit, they cant dedicate time to this game.

Nobody is telling me what to do. If they did, I would get mad. Im independant.
Im improving because im TRYING. If you dont want me to get better, fine.

 

[radical6]

What do you mean? I'm definitely not. And yeah, a lot of them did say that, but after Justin says something everyone goes berserk voting for that person. Nothing against Justin, but he is really what causes bandwagons the majority of the time.
Also, if you're referring to me jumping on a bandwagon by the Hikari post, you're mistaken. I was the first to bring up Hikari way back when I also rehashed Superpenguin's thoughts on iTookYourWaffles.

oh no i dont mean you! im hinting towards someone else. mostly someone who said they wouldn't start bandwagons when running for mayor but turns out to jump on every single one.

 

[VillageDweller]

Believe me, if I was mafia, I would be dead by now.
And people can look for themselves. If they are too lazy tobgo back a bit, they cant dedicate time to this game.

Nobody is telling me what to do. If they did, I would get mad. Im independant.
Im improving because im TRYING. If you dont want me to get better, fine.

why do you think you would be dead by now if you were mafia? mafia would've seen your (no offence bby xo) bad posts as an easy way to get any attention off of potential mafia players onto you, and could lynch you easily and not lose anything (if you assume that you are on town side) and while i agree about the dedicating time thing, it is also of a case you should be able to defend yourself, not have the people you're trying to defend yourself against research your own defence for you. if you want to live, you should do it on your own.

it's just a bit weird how you improved so well in such a short space of time. one could assume that other members of the mafia could be hinting you how to play better. not to mention since you want to improve so well, sometimes it would've been better to see how people would tell you how to play in order to improve yourself, which could easily just be what happened. i'm not saying it's bad you improved, i'm saying it's weird how you improved that well in such a short time.

 

[BungoTheElf]

You seem to be forgetting someone
beary509- Non-useful posts and gives bad reasons for lynching

You still never gave an answer on why you voted for me even though Pally mentioned it earlier
"She was a mafia last game May not have changed Or improved :3"- To me this really doesn't explain anything
Also what's up with Thunder? All he said was "(Gah, hate to make a vote like this, but)" You guys never really explained why you voted for me.. The time they voted for me they never even talked about me in the thread (Did they ever? Maybe Thunder)- In fact I feel like you're trying to avoid the reason why you voted for me..

 

[EpicGamer12]

You seem to be forgetting someone
beary509- Non-useful posts and gives bad reasons for lynching

You still never gave an answer on why you voted for me even though Pally mentioned it earlier
"She was a mafia last game May not have changed Or improved :3"- To me this really doesn't explain anything
Also what's up with Thunder? All he said was "(Gah, hate to make a vote like this, but)" You guys never really explained why you voted for me.. The time they voted for me they never even talked about me in the thread (Did they ever? Maybe Thunder)- In fact I feel like you're trying to avoid the reason why you voted for me..

The main reason you have been voted for was because of your major lurking, lack of posting, and hiding of details when asked questions, I believe.

 

[TheCreeperHugz]

Holy crap, I've got a lot to catch up on...

 

[radical6]

Holy crap, I've got a lot to catch up on...

have fun

anyway i think i gotta go with hikari. trundle's points against him make sense. his horus post seemed like a poor attempt at trying to shift someone into the spotlight. hes changing his votes every time someone accuses someone else too. also he didnt really put up a good fight in the irc when trundle called him out. doubt my vote will matter.

 

[bluegoat14]

why do you think you would be dead by now if you were mafia? mafia would've seen your (no offence bby xo) bad posts as an easy way to get any attention off of potential mafia players onto you, and could lynch you easily and not lose anything (if you assume that you are on town side) and while i agree about the dedicating time thing, it is also of a case you should be able to defend yourself, not have the people you're trying to defend yourself against research your own defence for you. if you want to live, you should do it on your own.

it's just a bit weird how you improved so well in such a short space of time. one could assume that other members of the mafia could be hinting you how to play better. not to mention since you want to improve so well, sometimes it would've been better to see how people would tell you how to play in order to improve yourself, which could easily just be what happened. i'm not saying it's bad you improved, i'm saying it's weird how you improved that well in such a short time.

After reading through the evidence and arguments, I think it would be in the town's best interest to lynch Beary. I know it's been said before, but I have seen that she often hasn't contributed relevant posts, and now has improved her posts to a degree. Additionally, I suspect her because her posts are often randomly accusatory and her posts often are irrelevant and it shows she could very well be anxious about something. It's not because she is a new player; (not to sound too redundant) it is because of her behavior.

 

[Princess]

Beary instead of answering my question and giving an explanation for your vote you've criticized how often and useful my posts are.

 

[3DSfan134]

I really need to start posting here more often.

 

[Princess]

3DS everyone is waiting for you to defend yourself.

 

[radical6]

I really need to start posting here more often.

gee, if you posted more then you would know that you're on the chopping block

 

[TheCreeperHugz]

Right, finally caught up.
I think I'll be voting for beary, because I find her sudden improvement quite suspicious. I think this, which was mentioned a while ago:

again, they probably hit someone who was protected by a medic/veteran.

i wont vote for beary...yet. tbh shes just a newbie. i feel like if she was mafia, someone in the mafia chat wouldve at least scolded her and helped her out.[/] i would like to see how she responds to all this, but ill make my mind up tomorrow when i wake up i guess.

Is what has actually happened.
Despite this improvement, she still tends to post quite a lot of spam posts that don't really help. So this is why I'm going to vote for her.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Whoops screwed up trying to bold a bit of the quote...

 

[cannedcommunism]

Im so sorry, I get everyones gender confused Dx
Ignore my confusion.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Let us remember, these are the people we have left. Its only day 2, so weeding out a mafia is NOT going to be easy.

We have-

Justin- Pointing fingers and starting a bandwagon
3DS- Lying about sickness
Waffle- Hardly posting at all
Horus- Also hardly posting at all
Lynn- Hardly posting
River-
Gallows-
Kayla-
Cake-
Andy-
Superpenguin-
BlueLeaf-
BBG-
Thunder-
Lauren-
beary509-
Hikari-
FireNinja1-
Kuma-
Farobi-
Trundle-
Bluegoat- hasnt posted often
Pally- unsubstational posts that are not useful
TsunDere-
Oath2order-
Creeper-
VD-
Riley-
Tom-

And that is a lot of people. And how many mafia?
6. Out of 30.
We have 1/5 chance if we pick random.

You forgot me.

 

[Hikari]

I still don't understand why Trundle is going after me for. Many other people have made bad accusations, but it seems like I'm the only getting some votes because of it. And I did thnk Horus was suspsious when I accused him, since he was very inactive, but he proved to me that I was wrong. Also, I accused him because I was trying to help the town realize he wasn't really contributing, which made me start suspecting him in the first place. Anyways, think what you want to think, but I don't think you should waste your vote on someone who was trying to help the town, but rather someone who hasn't been helping the town at all.

 

[BellGreen]

You forgot me.

You were one of the people to consult beary about contentless posts so maybe you should start thinking about that. Ask yourself if your post helps town efforts and see if you say yes or no.
----
I also find it strange about how beary509 improved in a short span. Someone probably gave her tips or, assuming she is mafia, had the mafia consult her. All of a sudden her spam is getting smaller and smaller each time while before it was quite big.
There are bigger fish to fry though and beary509, told many times, is just a newer player who still needs to get the hang of this game. She's improving and we should see if it starts degrading as well.

 

[cannedcommunism]

You were one of the people to consult beary about contentless posts so maybe you should start thinking about that. Ask yourself if your post helps town efforts and see if you say yes or no.
----
I also find it strange about how beary509 improved in a short span. Someone probably gave her tips or, assuming she is mafia, had the mafia consult her. All of a sudden her spam is getting smaller and smaller each time while before it was quite big.
There are bigger fish to fry though and beary509, told many times, is just a newer player who still needs to get the hang of this game. She's improving and we should see if it starts degrading as well.

You're overreacting. That was one post, it's not like I do that every 3 seconds.
------------------------------------------
Anyway, 3DSfan hasn't even picked up on a visitor message, what's up with that? He needs to explain himself or he's gonna kick the bucket before he knows it.

 

[unravel]

Anyway, 3DSfan hasn't even picked up on a visitor message, what's up with that? He needs to explain himself or he's gonna kick the bucket before he knows it.

I think because he doesn't want to screw up. He needs to explain about the voting thread