Mafia TBT Mafia II: Mafia Strike Back [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[Prof Gallows]

Continuing SuperPenguin's post;

Waffles was also defending Hikari and attempting to drive the votes away from her. Beary was on my list of suspects the previous day as well. But right now I'm 50/50 on those two. If anyone has any insight on Waffles, I'd appreciate hearing it.

 

[Superpenguin]

*slipup not spotlight

 

[Midoriya]

Well, to me the lynch choice is pretty clear. . .beary.

I mean seriously, do we even need to look too far into her post record before we find evidence? Here we see her being very defensive of voting hikari for lynch who we all know is mafia.









Here we see hikari(mafia) defending beary on day one by constantly agreeing with everyone on their suspicions against beary. This entire quote was just a rehashing of ideas. Then when beary was once again te target of suspicion day two, hikari threw Horus out in the spotlight to save beary and backed off Horus suspicion after Waffles became the main target.




And let's not forget beary's random change in her behavior of posting from going from poor posts to well though out posts almost instantly as if someone told her what to do.

And who could forget the time she was overly enforcing the fact that the mafia may have attempted to frame her when no one even called it out.



I am typing on my phone, so this took me like twenty minutes to draft out. I apologize for any mistakes. :/

- - - Post Merge - - -





I agree with fire ninja. The sooner a person is accused, the longer try can remain in the spotlight thus the greater chance of a spotlight. Don't chicken out and accuse someone a few hours before the lynch.

Based on this I think it's necessary that we lynch Beary now. It's not that often that someone goes from newbie to making better posts in such a short time span. She has stayed safe due to changing, but that could also mean she's mafia. I find it hard to believe she improved her posts on her own, and doubt that a blue/green gave her tips/advice. If we are to lynch anyone right now this is the path to take. Right now we're just using trial and error, but that's all we can do with no leads. And since I revealed I was a townie pages ago I'll go ahead and vote for Beary.

 

[iLoveYou]

Well from here we can look at the people remaining quiet as a start. Too many people are remaining quiet and that obviously doesn't help Town .. seeing as we are at a dead end. I've already seen one player pop into this thread just to read (I assume - I mean what else would they be doing) and then leave.

At the moment though I'm concerned with what happened in this thread over the past few days + nights. I want to see if there is a pattern between the kills the Mafia are making (besides the fact that they were mostly important roles :l). I want to see if there are any friendship links between those who got murdered and those potentially making the kills amongst the remaining Town members.

 

[Horus]

and I have nothing to go off of. There are the people I suspect that I haven't mentioned but I'm going to wait until everyone has had enough time to post before saying names. The more I have to go off of, the better.

Yeah same here. I don't really want to accuse more after 3DSfan lol.

Now that I've said that, let me accuse people.

So here's our list of the living;

Prof Gallows [suspected Kayla/iLoveYou but she brought forth evidence of Hikari and pushed her lynch so...?]
iLoveYou [Don't really suspect much after Hikari tbh]
MyLifeIsCake
SuperPenguin
BlueLeaf
BellBringerGreen
Lauren
beary509
FireNinja1
ITookYourWaffles
Kuma
Farobi
Horus
Trundle
Justin
bluegoat14
pallycake
tsundere
FoxWolf64
Riley

Italics = Don't post much or where the hell are they
Bold = Bandwagoner or easily influenced
Underline = Should be dead/lynched but was diverted for a different bandwagon
The rest are people I just don't have an opinion about, haven't seen them really accuse anyone or do much..? [Excluding Justin, Gallows, and iLoveYou of course, they've posted some opinions, I just don't know about them lol]

 

[iLoveYou]

Oh shoot, this thread blew up quickly while I was typing my post.

Beary509:

I would like to provide my insight with the information I do know based on her.

She PM'd me saying she was a Townie. When I brought up the fact that there were green, blue and red roles she switched her answer to a blue role (Veteran). She also claims that she didn't know the difference between the Townie role & Town in general (Townie is a role all by itself). Her posts obviously do not support her case. She's been trying to defend Hikari as well, and felt sorry for voting him out:

##VOTE: Hikari

I'm sorry Hikari :c

When has Beary509 ever expressed remorse on a vote? She was so happy to bandwagon on the other votes, all except on this one?

I still think she is a newbie player, playing poorly. If the Town feels it is necessary to get rid of her, then we can go ahead and do it. We seriously have no other leads right now. :l


I honestly don't know what to think of iTookYourWaffles. I did find it suspicious that she was subtly steering the Town away from lynching Hikari, no doubt. I just don't know what to make of it yet.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Horus

Italics = Don't post much or where the hell are they

LOL YOU'RE SO CUTE. I was thinking the same thing about you actually.

P.S: Sorry if this post is spam. :L

 

[bluegoat14]

On a side note, I am here I just don't post often. It is my style to post when I think I have an important point or an opinion, besides that a lot that needs to be said has been already. Anyways; I am done hearing the all the excuses from Beary509, I think it is time for her to be lynched. Super Penguin put it well, and in addition it needs to be said how unnecessary many her posts are, often distracting the group from any of the real issues which seems like a Mafia move to me. I don't know too much about the current evidence about Waffles besides what I have read recently from Gallows, but if anyone has anything go ahead.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Wow this thread just got bigger, not trying to sound redundant.

 

[FireNinja1]

I try my best to be here. I have an education to complete, which is worth more than any mafia game.

Back on track, beary does sort of seem to be mafia. But remember the ACE incident last time. A thought-to-be red was a blue. I'm going with ITYW, because I think it's a bit safer than voting for beary. Mafia will try to blend in better than the technique beary is using, rather, rehash ideas and misdirect people in the form of accusations.

 

[Superpenguin]

I try my best to be here. I have an education to complete, which is worth more than any mafia game.

Back on track, beary does sort of seem to be mafia. But remember the ACE incident last time. A thought-to-be red was a blue. I'm going with ITYW, because I think it's a bit safer than voting for beary. Mafia will try to blend in better than the technique beary is using, rather, rehash ideas and misdirect people in the form of accusations.

Seriously, the whole ACE scenario from last game is irrelevant at this point of the game. Going by your logic we could apply that same scenario to Hikari's lynch. You want to know what was different between Hikari's and now potentially beary's lynch from that of ACE's? THERE IS EVIDENCE THIS TIME!

Stop referring back to ACE. That was a day one lynch with no evidence and no defense argument on ACE's part.

 

[radical6]

i cant beleive tom actually DIED LMAO THANKS FOR WHOEVER IN MAFIA ANSWERED MY PRAYERS <3333
and why the heck did oath die????????? what ???????????/ was it a lucky shot?????????/

idk i do find it weird beary was trying to defend hikari on day 1 and hikari tried defending her. def suspicious. dunno why anyone in the mafia chat would actually let her do something like that when it was very obvious that hikari was gonna die??? i think its okay for her to improve, maybe she thought for a bit before posting. or read some games. idk. it wasnt a big change imo but who knows

 

[EpicGamer12]

Hey guys, speaking from behind my prison bars here.
I don't want to say too much because I'm in jail BUT I do want to point my small opinion out.
Check this out and look through: http://www.belltreeforums.com/showt...-Strike-Back&p=1996165&viewfull=1#post1996165
What is Hikari trying to do here as a mafia member? Was beary509 agreeing as a result of not being a very good player or was she trying to put more attention on Horus? Who else was currently being accused that the mafia may want to have drawn attention away from? I'm not going to give any leads myself, but read closely through this post, TheCreeperHugz's posts, and some of Hikari's other posts. Who is she defending, who is agreeing, and why?

 

[Superpenguin]

Wow, just woke up to find 3 town dead, including one blue role.
This really isn't going too well, though I'm not sure what happened to the last KP.

As for my thoughts on Beary, I think she is probably a townie and is just quite bad at this game due to being new. Though there is a chance she is mafia, and I may vote for her, depending on how others act.
Even if she is a townie, the spam posts aren't really helping us...

Hugz is shown trying to convince us beary is town.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Hugz is shown trying to convince us beary is town.

Exactly! A great point. Hikari and Hugz have both repeatedly tried to defend beary in this game. Also, beary has improved significantly from the beginning of the game. beary has also agreed with things that Hikari and Hugz have said in the game, many times.

 

[Beary]

Im just saying...
They are trying to set me up.
I am not mafia. If I am one, Karla must have made a mistake o____O
I would roleclaim...but I know that that is a bad idea. People might get the wrong idea.
I have no idea why Hikari and Hugz were defending me. Tbh, I was just happy that somebody was on my side.
I am a new player, and that is why I agree. I dont want to seem to stiff or too agreeable...
I am new to this game. I was blundering around in the beginning and not taking things seriously. When I relized that this game was serious, I changed my playing style.
The only mafia players that I have talked to outside of this game by PM or visitor messages are-
iLoveYou
ITookYourWaffles

This is all the evidence supporting my innocence...
I was hesitent to lynching Hikari because I was afraid that we would lynch another townie. Luckily though, we hit mafia. Again, the other votes were LESS SERIOUS.

Thank you for reading. Go ahead and lynch me. If Im your last choice, you are in a deep hole, my friends.

 

[Superpenguin]

Im just saying...
They are trying to set me up.
I am not mafia. If I am one, Karla must have made a mistake o____O
I would roleclaim...but I know that that is a bad idea. People might get the wrong idea.
I have no idea why Hikari and Hugz were defending me. Tbh, I was just happy that somebody was on my side.
I am a new player, and that is why I agree. I dont want to seem to stiff or too agreeable...
I am new to this game. I was blundering around in the beginning and not taking things seriously. When I relized that this game was serious, I changed my playing style.
The only mafia players that I have talked to outside of this game by PM or visitor messages are-
iLoveYou
ITookYourWaffles

This is all the evidence supporting my innocence...
I was hesitent to lynching Hikari because I was afraid that we would lynch another townie. Luckily though, we hit mafia. Again, the other votes were LESS SERIOUS.

Thank you for reading. Go ahead and lynch me. If Im your last choice, you are in a deep hole, my friends.

You all ready role claimed ...

Well, I'm not a mafia...
I'm a TOWNIE.
And if I was a mafia, I wouldn't have been shocked at all by Dolbys role. And it surprised me!

And then apparently, according to Kayla, you then role claimed Veteran. You are way too inconsistent.
And really, stop using the fact that you're a new player as a crutch. It isn't a defense argument and surely doesn't make you seem any more or less innocent.

I don't see how talking to Kayla and Waffles outside of the game helps prove your innocence. You also only said through pm or vm, leaving out communication through mafia chat.

- - - Post Merge - - -

You were literally spoonfed who to lynch yesterday! We were all told by Kayla that Hikari came up mafia goon when inspected. THEN HIKARI MADE THAT MAJOR SLIP UP! There was no way you had a large enough doubt in your mind to be hesitant in voting Hikari.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I forgot to add that Hikari was inspected by a reliable source. My guess would be Lynn inspected her night 1 and then pmed Kayla the information after her death causing her 3-day ban.

 

[Beary]

You all ready role claimed ...




And then apparently, according to Kayla, you then role claimed Veteran. You are way too inconsistent.
And really, stop using the fact that you're a new player as a crutch. It isn't a defense argument and surely doesn't make you seem any more or less innocent.

I don't see how talking to Kayla and Waffles outside of the game helps prove your innocence. You also only said through pm or vm, leaving out communication through mafia chat.

- - - Post Merge - - -

You were literally spoonfed who to lynch yesterday! We were all told by Kayla that Hikari came up mafia goon when inspected. THEN HIKARI MADE THAT MAJOR SLIP UP! There was no way you had a large enough doubt in your mind to be hesitant in voting Hikari.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I forgot to add that Hikari was inspected by a reliable source. My guess would be Lynn inspected her night 1 and then pmed Kayla the information after her death causing her 3-day ban.

How was I supposed to know there was a mafia chat?!
I roleclaimed townie before because I thought that people on the town side were called townies, wether or not they were green or blue.

I am a veteran.
Go ahead. Lose another blue player.
I cant stop you, apparently. You are WAY to focused on me, yknow.
There are mafia out there.
I AM NO MAFIA.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, I didnt know that Kayla said that o-0
I saw she post as I skimmed that she found mafia goon on somebody, but I didnt see who, so I dismissed it and thought she didnt say.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also,it was not a 3 day ban. It was a THREE GAME BAN.

 

[Superpenguin]

How was I supposed to know there was a mafia chat?!
I roleclaimed townie before because I thought that people on the town side were called townies, wether or not they were green or blue.

I am a veteran.
Go ahead. Lose another blue player.
I cant stop you, apparently. You are WAY to focused on me, yknow.
There are mafia out there.
I AM NO MAFIA.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, I didnt know that Kayla said that o-0
I saw she post as I skimmed that she found mafia goon on somebody, but I didnt see who, so I dismissed it and thought she didnt say.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also,it was not a 3 day ban. It was a THREE GAME BAN.

Thanks for correcting me. Seems as though I mistyped.

You are obviously uneducated in how to play this game. In the time between signing up and waiting for the game to start, you should've looked over the other game and skimmed trough some stuff. You should've known about the mafia chat that way.

The fact that you claim you missed Kayla's post shows how little attention you are paying in this game and that you ate not trying to read every post. Everyone was basically talking about it anyway, so how you missed all of that is a wonder to me.

- - - Post Merge - - -

But you are right, Kayla never did say that Hikari was the one who turned up mafia goon in THAT post, but an hour later and the only person she pt attention on constantly referring back to that post was Hikari. It was obvious Hikari was the one who was found out to be mafia goon.

But why would you be so hesitant still in voting Hikari after his major slip up in role claiming Miller?

 

[radical6]

How was I supposed to know there was a mafia chat?!
I roleclaimed townie before because I thought that people on the town side were called townies, wether or not they were green or blue.

I am a veteran.
Go ahead. Lose another blue player.
I cant stop you, apparently. You are WAY to focused on me, yknow.
There are mafia out there.
I AM NO MAFIA.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, I didnt know that Kayla said that o-0
I saw she post as I skimmed that she found mafia goon on somebody, but I didnt see who, so I dismissed it and thought she didnt say.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also,it was not a 3 day ban. It was a THREE GAME BAN.

veterans cant do THAT much. they just have another life. i dont see why in the world you would roleclaim as one if you were truly apart of the town. thats a terrible move. im pretty sure it says in the first post somewhere its not advised to roleclaim blue..

where do you think mafia talk lol

kayla says something really important and you skip it. really. are you serious. you didnt see who so you dismissed it.what. why would you not look back. i dont understand you.

 

[Beary]

veterans cant do THAT much. they just have another life. i dont see why in the world you would roleclaim as one if you were truly apart of the town. thats a terrible move. im pretty sure it says in the first post somewhere its not advised to roleclaim blue..

where do you think mafia talk lol

kayla says something really important and you skip it. really. are you serious. you didnt see who so you dismissed it.what. why would you not look back. i dont understand you.

Do you enjoy being rude and ruining my self esteem?
I want to keep playing. You are making me rethink that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I WILL REPEAT.
I DID NOT TAKE THEGAME SERIOUSLY BACK THEN.
I DO NOW.

 

[radical6]

Do you enjoy being rude and ruining my self esteem?
I want to keep playing. You are making me rethink that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I WILL REPEAT.
I DID NOT TAKE THEGAME SERIOUSLY BACK THEN.
I DO NOW.

this is a game. thats just how i act with people. how the heck am i ruining your self esteem. i was more mean in the observers chat heh
i dont see why you would say you skipped over kaylas post? i dont get it. she said something important and you skipped it..