Beary509 definitely claimed Veteran (she pointed out to me in PM that she had two night lives). I guess this is confirmed information by now though. So we're taking a chance on this lynch guys. It sucks to be back at this point: with no leads. This means this lynch will be a huge "hit or miss" as opposed to "definite scum les go guise".
If it comes down to it, my vote is going to go in for Beary509 because: now the tables are flipped where the evidence is seemingly strong towards Beary509 as opposed to iTookYourWaffles (like it was earlier in the game).
Honestly, I think this lynch will benefit town regardless. If she is not a Mafia member then I'm sure the Mafia are wanting her in the game as a distraction for us - solve problem by lynching. If she is a Mafia member then yay at us for striking down another red through lynching.
Everytime the thread explodes on Beary509, the Mafia get an opportunity to hide in the shadows and lurk. So we can just end this by removing her from the game, I guess. That way the other players need to start posting more instead of watching us take down Beary509 constantly.
I can't believe it's come back down to this lynch, haha.
Beary509 versus iTookYourWaffles, AGAIN.
Maybe it's a sign that this really needs to happen ( just kidding LOL ). I'm tired. :L
I'm not sure whether to laugh hysterically or to get mad at Beary. She says she's a veteran. Like Kayla said, Beary's distracting us from our goal. A veteran is the weakest blue role you can have. If she's Mafia and we lynch her, good. If she isn't Mafia and she's a veteran, I won't really care since veterans are townies with two lives. If she isn't Mafia, then the Mafia probably shot her, noticing she didn't die and realized she was a veteran. Then they just stopped since they didn't want to waste hits. This is the most likely scenario, if Beary is telling the truth. If there's a detective who role-checked Beary, PLEASE speak up to Kayla through PM. Like people have been saying, Hikari and Creeper have been defending Beary, both of these two being Mafia. Obviously, these two would be stupid to defend Beary out of kindness, so I'll most likely vote for Beary.
Tsundere was simply talking about veterans and their suggested play style. While people have different game styles, it's best to think one up that will help your role meanwhile.
I was veteran last game. She is correct; it's best to play as a green Townie. You'll practically be one when you lose a night life (besides night lives). She wasn't bring rude at all.
I know you think this is a fun game, but don't take anything seriously. It's just a game, and you will improve once you play more game. It's up to you to decide whether or not to take the game seriously or personally. The latter isn't the way to go.
well i think its ok if you already lost your life because then youre just a townie
but i dont really believe shes mafia meh. too many mistakes. she didn't really improve suddenly ? it just seems like she sat down and took the game more seriously. but whatever
you know taking oaths comment i think its fairly obvious who hes hinting at?? umm?? and i know some blues who did trust said so person and ended up dead. theres no way mafia struck lucky. i didnt believe in gallows at first, but now im kinda rethinking it. i mean, oath trusted kayla and hes dead. VD im pretty sure trusted kayla and hes dead. (sorry vd ): )) idk if thunder told kayla ?? lynn didnt but died anyway. i dunno why.
so far, only goons have been killed. theyre the most useless mafia members, so it makes sense to sacrifice them right? yeah it brings down your KP, but once you have most of the medics killed does it really matter? the town has your trust after you killed 2 of your own. you can play them right into your hands.
im sorry if i sound dumb. im bad. im sorry. ill shut up im just saying useless things
i think its a waste to lynch beary??? ?? yeah she messed up with the veteran stuff but im guessing its because shes young and she didn;t understand the game then. i did think it was weird that 2 mafia members defended beary, but why would they do something so obvious? im sure they knew this would happen. i think beary is innocent anyway. for now.
you know taking oaths comment i think its fairly obvious who hes hinting at?? umm?? and i know some blues who did trust said so person and ended up dead. theres no way mafia struck lucky. i didnt believe in gallows at first, but now im kinda rethinking it. i mean, oath trusted kayla and hes dead. VD im pretty sure trusted kayla and hes dead. (sorry vd ): )) idk if thunder told kayla ?? lynn didnt but died anyway. i dunno why.
so far, only goons have been killed. theyre the most useless mafia members, so it makes sense to sacrifice them right? yeah it brings down your KP, but once you have most of the medics killed does it really matter? the town has your trust after you killed 2 of your own. you can play them right into your hands.
im sorry if i sound dumb. im bad. im sorry. ill shut up im just saying useless things
i think its a waste to lynch beary??? ?? yeah she messed up with the veteran stuff but im guessing its because shes young and she didn;t understand the game then. i did think it was weird that 2 mafia members defended beary, but why would they do something so obvious? im sure they knew this would happen. i think beary is innocent anyway. for now.
Oath2Order did tell me, but he told me a while back. From that day onwards he has chosen to tell other people (I know this because more people have PM'd me saying they know what Oath2Order is and they now know my role too). I can't be responsible for those who he decides to trust, apart from the ones that are actually trusted and confirmed Town. The blue roles I know personally are still alive and doing well in this game.
VillageDweller and I were the ones who showed each other our Mod PMs and that is why KarlaKGB gave out the warnings and asked for everyone who cheated to own up to it. We got caught, along with others who shared their Mod PMs. That is the only reason I know his role & he knows mine.
Thunder, Lynn105, Gandalf and River have never revealed themselves to me. So those blue roles dying are a question mark in my head too. They can confirm this even after the game ends.
Mary actually got modkilled, so I had no hand in her death. TheCreeperHugz was found by our Vigilante themselves, first. We had a hand in discussing TheCreeperHugz together though and from there that person sent in their shot. Hikari was found through inspection because he kept slipping up in past posts (Trundle has been calling him out from the start - we took action by inspecting him). I can't be responsible for which Mafia members we actually take down (as in which roles). I am just hoping to strike red each time.
We actually have a small lead on who the GodFather might be because 3 people are claiming to be the exact same role. :l The role they are claiming is un-important one, so why would there be 3 of them in this game? There should be 1 - 2 of them in this game and not any more.
Like I said, I am inclined to believing Beary509 is a newbie player and "Veteran" as she claimed to me in PM. I'm just saying, if it comes down her versus iTookYourWaffles, I'm going to put my vote in for her. Mafia wants a distraction in the game and unfortunately she keeps distracting Town. Literally every day we are taking Beary509 down, so if the Town feels it's about time then I am with it.
Beary I am still waiting for you to explain your voting record......................
Anyway, Prof Gallows, your theory on Kayla is intriguing. If you're up for it, do you think you could make some sort of a grand post explaining why you're so sure it's Kayla?
Beary I am still waiting for you to explain your voting record......................
Anyway, Prof Gallows, your theory on Kayla is intriguing. If you're up for it, do you think you could make some sort of a grand post explaining why you're so sure it's Kayla?
Sorry guys, not been active, keeping up with posts and posting is hard when you have assignments to hand in! I've just read through everything! Waffles and Beary again? Something is telling us one is supposed to go!
I recall Lynn (the detective) voting for waffles, could this mean she checked waffles?
I voted for beary first time around because of how terribly they were playing but now im split, i think waffles just because lynn must have checked them!
But luckily enough, it just so happens that I too know who the remaining blue roles are. So I'll talk to the vigilante and see what they have to say. You're still way up on my suspicion list though.
I don't want to throw Prof Gallows under the bus here because he & I have been working on the Godfather lead that we have. After this post was made though, Oath2Order had decided to reveal himself to Prof Gallows. I know because it has been confirmed already by Prof Gallows. Other than that, I don't know who else Oath2Order spoke to though. But this is to show that I was not the only one Oath2Order trusted. He chose to tell his role to others, and we're puzzled as to who else knew beyond us.
My voting pattern?
What do you mean?
You know, causing such a fuss about me is only making the distraction bigger -.-
Its only a distraction if you make it one.
- - - Post Merge - - -
This is beginning just to be,
'You suck, get out of the way '
See how they're both stating that Beary is innocent (more subtly in TCH's case)? That shows me that beary could possibly be Mafiaso as well. Hikari's post catches my eye because he tries to push blame on 3dsfan (confirmed townie) instead. Also they're both using the "she's new" argument to their advantage.
Just something to check on. She could be a townie for all I know since she doesnt know about the mafia chat, but if i had to vote for someone right now it's probably gonna be her. (dont take this personally please! )
Tip for Justin and/or Kayla: If it's coming too split between Waffles and Beary, perhaps do a double lynch? You should consult with people before doing this however, as this is a risky move.
My thoughts on Beary: I don't think a new player is an excuse to any situation. SP is a new player, and he isn't exactly, "bad." Whether we make the distraction or not, we need to get rid of it, as it's blocking our hits to Mafia. A veteran isn't much to lose.
My thoughts on Waffles: This argument is a little stronger, if not weaker than Beary's. Lynn was a detective, and she probably checked Waffles, like Lauren said. Then, to avoid Waffles getting caught, they killed Lynn to keep her quiet.
My vote will probably stick with Beary in the meantime. We have a day and a few to hear everyone's suspicions, opinions, arguments, and defense. We need people talking more, especially the inactives. Kuma, after looking the number of posts, has the least posts and is still alive. Pally is second to last.
I personally don't feel comfortable doing a Double Lynch, just because this lynch is already so hard. There isn't enough good evidence or arguments for either candidates up for lynch right now. It's up to the Mayor though. I can only pardon lynches (so they do not die by the hands of Town).
Also iTookYourWaffles was never inspected. Right now I'm leaning more towards Beary509 and Prof Gallows knows why. We're waiting to see if any other evidence will pop up today before we place our votes though.
The reason why the Vigilante and Bodyguards are alive is because only I know who they are (Justin knows bodyguards though). They have only trusted me and like that I have been able to work with them and keep them safe. Honestly, If I were Mafia, I would never let the Vigilante shoot a Mafia member. After that we were able to bring down the Mafia KP and put them in that corner. The Vigilante gave me names we discussed them all, to bring down TheCreeperHugz. Why would I go through the effort of speaking with the Vigilante to shoot down TheCreeperHugz in the first place?
Again Thunder, Lynn105, River, Gandalf have never revealed themselves to me. You can even ask them after this game ends. I really have no idea who they told, but they obviously told someone in the Mafia to get themselves killed right away. :l
VillageDweller, I only know because we shared our Mod PM Roles together. That is why KarlaKGB gave everyone the warning to say if they cheated. We got caught.
Guys please be careful. At this point Mafia must be desperate to get me out & they are trying to frame me so that I can leave the game easier. They can't kill me at night right now (because 2x Bodyguards) so they need to find an easy way out.
A lot of our blues died because they were open about their roles.
I'd heard from multiple sources about Thunder, River, Lynn, and VillageDweller. The only blue I didn't know of was Oath, until it was too late of course. Word spreads around fast. Even telling one person is putting yourself at risk.
I agree that this day is a difficult decision because I seriously cannot tell if Beary is telling the truth or not. The whole "new player" thing could just be a huge act. My biggest concern with this is that Beary isn't trying to blame anyone else. They aren't trying to put anyone else into the spotlight. That is what confuses me about them.
We need people talking more, especially the inactives. Kuma, after looking the number of posts, has the least posts and is still alive. Pally is second to last.
I'll try to post more but life keeps distracting me from this game. Since it's the weekend, almost nothing should be distracting me from this game. I also sometimes forget about the game as well.
