Tom
If anything, this lynch should be Tom vs BlueLeaf; and I'm confident that BlueLeaf is the real doctor. He came forward to Waffles as the other Doctor, and then Waffles forwarded the message to me. I introduced myself to BlueLeaf, we discussed stuff that I'll not announce just yet, and I realized that we share the same suspicions. I tried to bring other people who I believe is town in our discussion through PMs, though some seem hesitant or even suspicious of contacting them, so I just leave them be for now.
People are hesitant after lynching Waffles to lynch another blue, let's be honest. They lynch me and a I flip blue, then you guys are screwed. We lynch Blue Leaf and he flips blue, you guys are screwed. Me and Blue Leaf are both lynched at some point AND we both return blue, you guys are screwed.
Now about Tom. I trust BlueLeaf, but that doesn't doesn't automatically mean I distrust Tom. I have seen and analyzed numerous things in the thread that convinced me that he's scum. Here are some.
?
Simultaneous vote on me today alongside Prof Gallows
Honestly I wasn't surprised that you guys voted for me as it seemed that I am an easy person to convince the town to lynch. Though not giving a reason
in the thread on why you voted for me? If anyone is getting cocky, it's both of you. Don't underestimate the rest of the town. We also need to clear the "Who's the real Doctor?" Case as soon as possible, and I am convinced that BlueLeaf is the real one. If Tom is somehow the real doctor, then tomorrow's lynch will be up to the rest of you guys. I'm sure he's not the real Doctor though
Ignoring you calling out Prof Gallows here, we placed votes on you for the same reason we tried Day 4. Saw no real reason to explain as we figured you guys were smart enough to pick up on that. Sure I'm pretty damn hesitant with my vote now if you're absolutely telling the truth, but do we have any better candidates? We could lynch a lurker and gamble red, but at this point in the game it'll just hurt us. Lynching off strong ones hurt us.
?
Leading Gandalf's lynch - Going Deeper
I have seen Gandalf visit the thread often at the day you brought up a case against him. What i found odd is that he defended himself when iLoveYou accused him of being a Godfather yet he has never defended himself during the day he got lynched by Tom, it's like he wanted to get lynched in order to achieve something. No one objected his lynch as well. He was also the Mafia Goon, the least useful role of the Mafia. I can see why Tom would intend to do this: 1) to gain trust and 2) to lead them to suspect Waffles, BBG, and I.
And what about the chance that Gandalf knew I'd rally against him regardless? He spend a long time arguing with iLoveYou and when she died that ultimately sealed his fate. Told him I was going to push his lynch regardless unless he came up with 100% genuine mafioso. Question: How does Gandalf immediately lead you, Waffles and BBG? When Waffles was getting lynched, I provided absolutely nothing but the final vote because others were asking me to. I wasn't 100% convinced Waffles was scum, wasn't 100% convinced Waffles was a doctor either.
Also, you still haven't died last night. But roleblocked instead? Really?
I'm sure Leaf is thinking the same. The way I figure it, Mafia has two roleblockers and the godfather left. Doctors at this point are absolutely useless. They block us, kill some townies and just laugh as we argue amongst ourselves about which doctor is real when they know the real answer. The way I had it figured, Leaf and I were to die if we were innocent. Yet here we are, someone must think keeping us alive to create a distraction helps.
?
Waffles lynch
You were hesitant on lynching someone who claimed Doctor to you, makes sense. But why didn't you want to defend her? You probably knew her role via PM (and the thread too, as she gave many unintentional hints) but didn't want to defend her. Now, here's a post you made that I find interesting:
Defend Waffles with what exactly? At the time I still believed it was just me and Blue Leaf who were doctors. Waffles had pretty much contributed squat so getting town to ease off would have been difficult, especially with the others so sure she was scum. Push to hard and it works against you, no gentle push as there was no fluff to give.
So BlueLeaf and Waffles claimed to have been roleblocked. Who exactly was the person you absolutely knew was roleblocked? If it was Waffles, then why didn't you defend her while she was the lynch candidate? If it was BlueLeaf, then why are you suspecting him as scum now? This post is enough to convince me that Tom is scum.
Blue Leaf naturally. He and I worked with Kayla and I had hoped to work with him some more before he backed away and accused me of being Godfather. :/ I suspected him after the Waffles lynch, as she returned blue. I didn't think he was scum before hand as my roleblock I chalked up to Gandalf relaying some information back to his scum team. But Night 2 when Leaf "protected" me, I was roleblocked and Kayla died. So he's either telling the truth or he's a Mafioso Roleblocker.
?
beary509
This is extremely subtle, but it's still in the lines of defending a scum mate:
How exactly is this any different from any one of you? >:/ Game II you guys lynched Beary for being a nuisance. Game III the mafia kept her around as a distraction before killing her night 3. Are any of us exactly sure what Beary does? Let's be honest, she'd probably still be here if Kayla or Tina hadn't shot her. I think you're grasping at straws with this point.
?
SuperPenguin
His death N1 pretty much shows how much of a threat he was to the Mafia. Scum obviously wanted him gone, and guess who also publicly announced his disapproval of SP being Mayor?
Yeah, I disapproved with his tactics. I'd hoped that he'd 180% with his campaign and then come back approaching it another way. I really had no intention of going forth with his lynch, even told him as much in the IRC later on. It'd be like that Scared Straight show.
I had to type this all in a phone, late at night, so expect some grammar mistakes etc. I hope I wake up finding the rest of the town making the right choice. Good night.
